Resources
A stone is thrown vertically upward with an initial speed of from a bridge deck located above a river. Student A defines Coordinate System A with origin at the bridge deck and the -direction pointing vertically upward. Student B defines Coordinate System B with origin at the river surface and the -direction pointing vertically downward. Taking and neglecting air resistance: (a) state the acceleration of the stone and initial velocity in System A, and find the stone's position when it strikes the water, (b) state the acceleration and initial velocity in System B, and find the stone's position when it strikes the water, and (c) calculate the total flight time until the stone enters the river.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , , ; (b) , , ; (c)
Steps
Vector Signs and Coordinate Systems in Kinematics
In one-dimensional motion, vector quantities—such as position , velocity , and acceleration —are assigned positive or negative signs depending solely on whether they point in the chosen positive coordinate direction:
- If a vector points in the same direction as the positive axis, its value is positive.
- If it points in the opposite direction, its value is negative.
Physical quantities like the flight time and the physical distance traveled are independent of the chosen coordinate system.
Analysis in Coordinate System A
In System A, the origin is at the bridge deck, and the upward direction is defined as positive ():
- Initial Velocity (): The stone is projected vertically upward, which aligns with the positive direction:
- Acceleration (): Gravity acts vertically downward, opposite to :
- Position at Water Impact (): The river surface lies below the bridge origin:
Analysis in Coordinate System B
In System B, the downward direction is defined as positive (), with the release position measured toward the river:
- Initial Velocity (): The stone is thrown upward, opposite to the downward positive axis:
- Acceleration (): Gravity acts vertically downward, directly along the positive axis:
- Position at Water Impact (): Moving downward from the release level to the water corresponds to a displacement along the positive axis:
Calculating the Total Flight Time ()
The flight time can be determined using the kinematic equation for vertical position:
Using System A (with , , , and ):
Rearranging into standard quadratic form:
Alternatively, separating the trajectory into two phases:
- Upward phase to the highest point: The maximum height attained above the bridge is:
- Downward phase from the peak to the river: The total height above the river is approximately . The free-fall time from rest from the peak is:
Adding both phases gives the total flight time:
Typical errors
01 The student treats speed as always positive regardless of the chosen coordinate axis, giving a positive initial velocity in System B.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
, ,
- Step 2
, ,
Correct, , (or if measuring displacement from release)
In System B, the positive direction points vertically downward. Since the stone is thrown vertically upward, its initial velocity points opposite to , so it must be signed negative: .
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly established the signs for acceleration, initial velocity, and final position in Coordinate System A.
You set up and solved the kinematic quadratic equation accurately to find the flight time.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote as a positive scalar speed instead of assigning it a negative sign along the downward axis.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating given speed values as intrinsically positive numbers rather than projecting the velocity vector onto the defined coordinate axis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Vector Projection onto Coordinate Axes
In 1D kinematics, any vector pointing opposite to the designated positive direction must be assigned a negative algebraic sign.
Always draw an arrow for the vector's physical direction alongside the positive axis arrow; if they point in opposite directions, insert a minus sign.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the positive direction in System B: points vertically downward.
Identify the physical direction of the initial launch: the stone is projected vertically upward.
Because upward is opposite to downward, assign a negative sign to the initial velocity component: .
,
02 The student treats the water surface as having position -40.0 m in System B, confusing the two origins.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
, ,
- Step 2
,
- Step 3Correct
In System B, the positive axis points downward toward the river. Because the river is located in the positive direction from the release level, its coordinate is .
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly established the signs for acceleration, initial velocity, and position in System A.
You correctly reversed the signs of and in System B to reflect downward as positive.
You correctly formulated and solved the quadratic kinematic equation to find the total flight time.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou originally wrote for , but crossed it out and replaced it with , likely reverting to the common intuition that downward must be negative.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating intuitive everyday directions with the user-defined positive axis direction: once downward is defined as positive, positions located downward from the release origin take positive coordinate values.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Coordinate Sign Rule
The sign of a 1D vector or coordinate depends solely on whether it points along () or against () the defined positive axis, never on intuitive directions like up or down.
Check each coordinate against your chosen positive arrow: if the target point lies in the direction of the arrow, assign it a positive value.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationNote that the bridge origin is and the -axis points downward toward the river.
Because the water surface lies in the direction, its coordinate is .
(a) , , ; (b) , , ; (c) (or )
03 The student confuses the sign of the displacement in System A by taking the final position as +40.0 m instead of -40.0 m.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
, ,
Correct, ,
You correctly identified that gravity points downward () and the upward launch is positive (). However, because the origin is at the bridge deck and points vertically upward, the river surface lies in the negative direction, so the final position must be .
- Step 2
, ,
- Step 3Correct
You solved the quadratic equation correctly based on your equation, but because you entered instead of , the equation asked when the stone would reach above the bridge (which is impossible since its peak height is only ). Using the correct position yields a positive discriminant and the correct flight time .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the signs of acceleration and initial velocity in both coordinate systems.
You correctly recalled and applied the kinematic position equation .
You executed the algebraic rearrangement and quadratic discriminant calculation accurately.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the distance to the river as a positive coordinate instead of checking whether the river lies above or below the chosen origin.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing scalar distance with signed coordinate position. When an axis points upward and the origin is at the release point, any point located below the release level must have a negative coordinate.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Establish the Axis and Origin
Position is a signed coordinate: points along the positive axis are positive, and points on the opposite side of the origin are negative.
Before writing numbers into kinematic equations, sketch the axis, mark , and check whether your target location is on the positive or negative side of .
- Sanity-Check Negative Discriminants
A projectile launched upward above a cliff or bridge must always strike the ground below eventually.
If your kinematic quadratic yields a negative discriminant (no real roots), immediately re-verify the sign of your displacement or position term.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubstitute , , and into : .
Rearrange into standard quadratic form: .
Compute the discriminant: .
Take the positive root: .
Lock it in
How do you determine the algebraic sign of a 1D vector (like velocity or acceleration)?
Compare the vector's physical direction to the chosen positive axis: positive if in the same direction, negative if opposite.
Similar question
A dart is fired vertically downward at from a ceiling. If a student chooses an upward coordinate axis ( upward), state the initial velocity and acceleration .
Answer
and . Both downward motion and gravity point opposite to the upward -axis.
An elevator moves downward at and decelerates to a stop with an acceleration magnitude of . With downward defined as positive (), state and .
Answer
and . The velocity is in the downward direction (), while deceleration means acceleration points upward (opposite to velocity), making it negative.
A ball is dropped from rest from a balloon at . Coordinate system 1 defines upward with origin at the ground. Coordinate system 2 defines downward with origin at the balloon. Write the position equation for each system (taking ).
Answer
System 1: (starts at , accelerates downward). System 2: (starts at , accelerates in the positive downward direction).