Resources

In a scattering experiment, an alpha particle (qα=+2eq_\alpha = +2e, mα=6.64×10−27 kgm_\alpha = 6.64 \times 10^{-27}\text{ kg}) is fired head-on toward a stationary 82208Pb^{208}_{82}\text{Pb} nucleus from a large distance with an initial kinetic energy of Ki=14.0 MeVK_i = 14.0\text{ MeV}. Treating the lead nucleus as a point charge during approach: (a) find the distance of closest approach dmind_{\text{min}} in femtometers (fm\text{fm}), and (b) compare this distance to the sum of their nuclear radii Rtotal=RPb+RαR_{\text{total}} = R_{\text{Pb}} + R_\alpha, where R(A)=(1.20 fm)A1/3R(A) = (1.20\text{ fm})A^{1/3} (Aα=4A_\alpha = 4, APb=208A_{\text{Pb}} = 208), to determine whether the alpha particle touches the nuclear surface where the strong nuclear force takes over.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) dmin=16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm}; (b) Rtotal=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = 9.02\text{ fm}; since dmin>Rtotald_{\text{min}} > R_{\text{total}}, the alpha particle turns around before touching the nuclear surface.

Steps

Part (a): Finding the Distance of Closest Approach (dmind_{\text{min}})

  1. Principle of Conservation of Mechanical Energy: Because the lead nucleus is assumed stationary and only the conservative electrostatic force acts on the alpha particle, the total mechanical energy is conserved: Ei=EfE_i = E_f
  2. Setting up the Energy Equation:

    • Initially, at a very large distance (r→∞r \to \infty), the electric potential energy is negligible, so the total energy is purely kinetic: Ei=Ki=14.0 MeVE_i = K_i = 14.0\text{ MeV}
    • At the distance of closest approach (r=dminr = d_{\text{min}}) in a head-on collision, the alpha particle momentarily comes to rest (Kf=0K_f = 0). All initial kinetic energy is converted into electrostatic potential energy: Ef=Ue=14πε0qαqPbdminE_f = U_e = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} \frac{q_\alpha q_{\text{Pb}}}{d_{\text{min}}}
  3. Substituting Charges and Constants: The charges are qα=+2eq_\alpha = +2e and qPb=+82eq_{\text{Pb}} = +82e. Thus: Ki=ke(2e)(82e)dmin=164 kee2dminK_i = \frac{k_e (2e)(82e)}{d_{\text{min}}} = \frac{164 \, k_e e^2}{d_{\text{min}}} Using the standard nuclear physics constant kee2=e24πε0≈1.440 MeV⋅fmk_e e^2 = \frac{e^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} \approx 1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}: dmin=164⋅(1.440 MeV⋅fm)14.0 MeV=236.16 MeV⋅fm14.0 MeV≈16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = \frac{164 \cdot (1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm})}{14.0\text{ MeV}} = \frac{236.16\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{14.0\text{ MeV}} \approx 16.9\text{ fm}

Part (b): Nuclear Radii and Surface Contact

  1. Calculating the Nuclear Radii: The radius of a nucleus with mass number AA is modeled by: R(A)=(1.20 fm)A1/3R(A) = (1.20\text{ fm}) A^{1/3}

    • For the alpha particle (Aα=4A_\alpha = 4): Rα=(1.20 fm)(4)1/3≈(1.20 fm)(1.587)≈1.90 fmR_\alpha = (1.20\text{ fm})(4)^{1/3} \approx (1.20\text{ fm})(1.587) \approx 1.90\text{ fm}
    • For the lead nucleus (APb=208A_{\text{Pb}} = 208): RPb=(1.20 fm)(208)1/3≈(1.20 fm)(5.925)≈7.11 fmR_{\text{Pb}} = (1.20\text{ fm})(208)^{1/3} \approx (1.20\text{ fm})(5.925) \approx 7.11\text{ fm}
  2. Sum of Nuclear Radii: For the two nuclear surfaces to touch, the center-to-center distance must equal the sum of their radii: Rtotal=Rα+RPb=1.90 fm+7.11 fm=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = R_\alpha + R_{\text{Pb}} = 1.90\text{ fm} + 7.11\text{ fm} = 9.02\text{ fm}
  3. Comparison and Conclusion: Comparing the two distances: dmin=16.9 fm>Rtotal=9.02 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm} > R_{\text{total}} = 9.02\text{ fm} Since the distance of closest approach is significantly greater than RtotalR_{\text{total}}, the repulsive Coulomb barrier halts and reverses the alpha particle before it can make contact with the lead nucleus. Therefore, the alpha particle turns around purely due to electrostatic repulsion, and the short-range strong nuclear force does not come into play.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the atomic number Z with the mass number A for lead, using 208 instead of 82 for the charge of the nucleus in the potential energy calculation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Ki=k⋅qα⋅qPbdminK_i = \frac{k \cdot q_{\alpha} \cdot q_{\text{Pb}}}{d_{\text{min}}}

  2. Step 2

    qα=2e,  qPb=208eq_{\alpha} = 2e, \; q_{\text{Pb}} = 208e

    Correct

    qα=+2e,  qPb=+82eq_{\alpha} = +2e, \; q_{\text{Pb}} = +82e

    You used the mass number A=208A = 208 as the charge of the lead nucleus instead of its atomic number Z=82Z = 82. Nuclear charge is determined solely by the number of protons (q=Zeq = Ze).

  3. Step 3

    dmin=(8.99×109⋅2⋅208⋅(1.60×10−19)2)14.0×106⋅1.60×10−19⟹dmin=4.28×10−14 m=42.8 fmd_{\text{min}} = \frac{(8.99 \times 10^9 \cdot 2 \cdot 208 \cdot (1.60 \times 10^{-19})^2)}{14.0 \times 10^6 \cdot 1.60 \times 10^{-19}} \Longrightarrow d_{\text{min}} = 4.28 \times 10^{-14}\text{ m} = 42.8\text{ fm}

    Correct

    dmin=8.99×109⋅2⋅82⋅(1.60×10−19)214.0×106⋅1.60×10−19≈16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = \frac{8.99 \times 10^9 \cdot 2 \cdot 82 \cdot (1.60 \times 10^{-19})^2}{14.0 \times 10^6 \cdot 1.60 \times 10^{-19}} \approx 16.9\text{ fm}

    Your algebraic rearrangement and unit conversions were performed correctly, but the resulting numerical value was scaled up by a factor of 20882\frac{208}{82} due to the charge substitution error.

  4. Step 4

    Rα=1.20⋅41/3=1.90 fm⟹RPb=1.20⋅2081/3=7.11 fm⟹Rtotal=1.90+7.11=9.01 fmR_{\alpha} = 1.20 \cdot 4^{1/3} = 1.90\text{ fm} \Longrightarrow R_{\text{Pb}} = 1.20 \cdot 208^{1/3} = 7.11\text{ fm} \Longrightarrow R_{\text{total}} = 1.90 + 7.11 = 9.01\text{ fm}

  5. Step 5

    dmin=42.8 fm>9.01 fm, so it does not touch the surfaced_{\text{min}} = 42.8\text{ fm} > 9.01\text{ fm}\text{, so it does not touch the surface}

    Correct

    dmin=16.9 fm>9.02 fm, so it does not touch the surfaced_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm} > 9.02\text{ fm}\text{, so it does not touch the surface}

    Your comparison logic is sound, but it relied on the incorrect value of dmind_{\text{min}} calculated in Part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated initial kinetic energy to electrostatic potential energy to set up the turning point equation.

You correctly applied the formula R=R0A1/3R = R_0 A^{1/3} using the mass numbers of both nuclei.

You accurately converted kinetic energy from MeV\text{MeV} to joules and distance from meters to femtometers.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Atomic Number $Z$ with Mass Number $A$

You substituted qPb=208eq_{\text{Pb}} = 208e instead of qPb=82eq_{\text{Pb}} = 82e into Coulomb's law.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused mass number AA (total nucleons: protons + neutrons) with atomic number ZZ (number of protons). Neutrons are electrically neutral, so only the ZZ protons contribute to the nuclear charge q=+Zeq = +Ze.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclear Charge vs. Nuclear Mass
  • In nuclear notation ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X}, the positive charge is q=+Zeq = +Ze (protons only), whereas A=Z+NA = Z + N is the total nucleon count used for mass and radius scaling.

  • Before evaluating Coulomb potential energy, always check the lower index ZZ for charge and reserve the upper index AA for mass or radius.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the charge of the 82208Pb^{208}_{82}\text{Pb} nucleus as qPb=+82eq_{\text{Pb}} = +82e.

  2. Substitute Z=82Z = 82 into the energy conservation equation: dmin=ke(2e)(82e)Kid_{\text{min}} = \frac{k_e (2e)(82e)}{K_i}.

  3. Evaluate dmin=164⋅1.440 MeV⋅fm14.0 MeV≈16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = \frac{164 \cdot 1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{14.0\text{ MeV}} \approx 16.9\text{ fm}.

  4. Compare with Rtotal=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = 9.02\text{ fm}: since 16.9 fm>9.02 fm16.9\text{ fm} > 9.02\text{ fm}, the alpha particle turns around before contact.

Final answer

(a) dmin=16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm}; (b) Rtotal=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = 9.02\text{ fm}; since dmin>Rtotald_{\text{min}} > R_{\text{total}}, the alpha particle turns around before touching the nuclear surface.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review isotope notation ZAX^{A}_{Z}\text{X} to reinforce that ZZ governs electric interactions and AA governs inertial mass and nuclear volume.

  • Practice calculating Coulomb barrier energies for various target nuclei to build automatic habit in selecting ZZ for charge.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to account for the alpha particle having a charge of +2e and uses q_alpha = 1e in the Coulomb potential energy expression.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ki=k(1e)(82e)dmin  ⟹  dmin=82⋅1.44 MeV⋅fm14.0 MeV=8.43 fmK_i = \frac{k(1e)(82e)}{d_{\text{min}}} \implies d_{\text{min}} = \frac{82 \cdot 1.44\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{14.0\text{ MeV}} = 8.43\text{ fm}

    Correct

    Ki=k(2e)(82e)dmin  ⟹  dmin=164⋅1.44 MeV⋅fm14.0 MeV≈16.9 fmK_i = \frac{k(2e)(82e)}{d_{\text{min}}} \implies d_{\text{min}} = \frac{164 \cdot 1.44\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{14.0\text{ MeV}} \approx 16.9\text{ fm}

    You correctly applied conservation of energy, but an alpha particle is a helium nucleus with atomic number Z=2Z = 2, so its charge is qα=+2eq_\alpha = +2e, not +1e+1e.

  2. Step 2

    Rα=1.20⋅41/3=1.90 fm  ⟹  RPb=1.20⋅2081/3=7.11 fm  ⟹  Rtotal=1.90+7.11=9.01 fmR_{\alpha} = 1.20 \cdot 4^{1/3} = 1.90\text{ fm} \implies R_{\text{Pb}} = 1.20 \cdot 208^{1/3} = 7.11\text{ fm} \implies R_{\text{total}} = 1.90 + 7.11 = 9.01\text{ fm}

  3. Step 3

    dmin=8.43 fm<9.01 fmd_{\text{min}} = 8.43\text{ fm} < 9.01\text{ fm}, so it touches the nuclear surface

    Correct

    dmin=16.9 fm>9.02 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm} > 9.02\text{ fm}, so the alpha particle does not touch the nuclear surface

    Your comparison followed logically from your calculated value of dmind_{\text{min}}, but because dmind_{\text{min}} was underestimated by a factor of 2, your final conclusion was reversed.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated initial kinetic energy to electrostatic potential energy at the turning point.

You used the convenient conversion factor kee2≈1.44 MeV⋅fmk_e e^2 \approx 1.44\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm} cleanly.

You accurately computed the radii of both nuclei using R(A)=R0A1/3R(A) = R_0 A^{1/3}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect particle charge

You substituted 1e1e instead of 2e2e for the charge of the alpha particle.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an alpha particle's charge with that of a proton or singly charged ion (+1e+1e). An alpha particle is a helium-4 nucleus (24He^4_2\text{He}), containing 2 protons, so qα=+2eq_\alpha = +2e.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Alpha particle charge definition
  • An alpha particle is a bare helium nucleus (24He2+^4_2\text{He}^{2+}) consisting of 2 protons and 2 neutrons, giving it an electric charge of qα=+2eq_\alpha = +2e.

  • Whenever an alpha particle appears in Coulomb repulsion or electric field problems, immediately write down q=+2eq = +2e before setting up formulas.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute qα=+2eq_\alpha = +2e into the potential energy expression: Ki=ke(2e)(82e)dmin=164 kee2dminK_i = \frac{k_e (2e)(82e)}{d_{\text{min}}} = \frac{164 \, k_e e^2}{d_{\text{min}}}.

  2. Solve for dmind_{\text{min}} using kee2≈1.440 MeV⋅fmk_e e^2 \approx 1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}: dmin=164⋅1.440 MeV⋅fm14.0 MeV≈16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = \frac{164 \cdot 1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{14.0\text{ MeV}} \approx 16.9\text{ fm}.

  3. Compare dmind_{\text{min}} with the combined nuclear radii: 16.9 fm>9.02 fm16.9\text{ fm} > 9.02\text{ fm}.

Final answer

(a) dmin=16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm}; (b) Rtotal=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = 9.02\text{ fm}; because dmin>Rtotald_{\text{min}} > R_{\text{total}}, the alpha particle turns around before touching the nuclear surface.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check the charge q=Zeq = Ze of common radiation particles (proton: +1e+1e, alpha: +2e+2e, deuteron: +1e+1e).

  • Practice Rutherford scattering energy conservation problems to build automaticity with qα=+2eq_\alpha = +2e.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student compares the closest approach distance only to the radius of the lead nucleus instead of the sum of both nuclear radii.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Ki=k⋅(2e)(82e)dmin  ⟹  dmin=164⋅1.4414.0  ⟹  dmin=16.87 fmK_i = k \cdot \frac{(2e)(82e)}{d_{\text{min}}} \implies d_{\text{min}} = \frac{164 \cdot 1.44}{14.0} \implies d_{\text{min}} = 16.87\text{ fm}

  2. Step 2

    RPb=1.20⋅(208)1/3=7.11 fmR_{\text{Pb}} = 1.20 \cdot (208)^{1/3} = 7.11\text{ fm}

  3. Step 3

    Rtotal=7.11 fmR_{\text{total}} = 7.11\text{ fm}

    Correct

    Rtotal=RPb+Rα=7.11 fm+(1.20 fm)(4)1/3=7.11 fm+1.90 fm=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = R_{\text{Pb}} + R_\alpha = 7.11\text{ fm} + (1.20\text{ fm})(4)^{1/3} = 7.11\text{ fm} + 1.90\text{ fm} = 9.02\text{ fm}

    You treated the alpha particle as a point with zero radius instead of including its nuclear radius Rα=(1.20 fm)(4)1/3≈1.90 fmR_\alpha = (1.20\text{ fm})(4)^{1/3} \approx 1.90\text{ fm}.

  4. Step 4

    dmin=16.87 fm>7.11 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.87\text{ fm} > 7.11\text{ fm}, so it does not touch the nuclear surface

    Correct

    dmin=16.9 fm>9.02 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm} > 9.02\text{ fm}, so the alpha particle turns around before touching the nuclear surface.

    Your qualitative conclusion is correct, but your comparison used an incomplete threshold distance because it omitted RαR_\alpha.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used conservation of energy to determine the distance of closest approach.

You used the nuclear radius scaling formula R(A)=r0A1/3R(A) = r_0 A^{1/3} accurately for the lead nucleus.

You correctly understood that touching occurs when the center-to-center separation falls below the sum of the radii.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neglecting projectile nuclear radius in contact condition

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the alpha particle as a point particle when calculating the contact threshold, forgetting that both colliding nuclei have finite spatial extents given by R(A)=r0A1/3R(A) = r_0 A^{1/3}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Nuclear Contact Criterion
  • For two spherical nuclei of radii R1R_1 and R2R_2 to touch, their center-to-center separation dd must satisfy d≤R1+R2d \le R_1 + R_2.

  • Always compute the radius of both the target and the projectile nucleus whenever the projectile is a composite nucleus (like an alpha particle) rather than a fundamental point lepton (like an electron).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the radius of the alpha particle (Aα=4A_\alpha = 4): Rα=(1.20 fm)(4)1/3≈1.90 fmR_\alpha = (1.20\text{ fm})(4)^{1/3} \approx 1.90\text{ fm}.

  2. Find the total center-to-center touching distance: Rtotal=RPb+Rα=7.11 fm+1.90 fm=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = R_{\text{Pb}} + R_\alpha = 7.11\text{ fm} + 1.90\text{ fm} = 9.02\text{ fm}.

  3. Compare dmind_{\text{min}} with RtotalR_{\text{total}}: since 16.9 fm>9.02 fm16.9\text{ fm} > 9.02\text{ fm}, the alpha particle turns around before touching the lead nucleus.

Final answer

(a) dmin=16.9 fmd_{\text{min}} = 16.9\text{ fm}; (b) Rtotal=9.02 fmR_{\text{total}} = 9.02\text{ fm}; since dmin>Rtotald_{\text{min}} > R_{\text{total}}, the alpha particle turns around before touching the nuclear surface.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the geometric contact condition for two extended spheres: contact occurs when the center-to-center distance equals R1+R2R_1 + R_2.

  • Practice identifying whether incoming particles (e.g., protons, deuterons, alpha particles) must be treated as extended nuclear targets.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An alpha particle (q=+2eq = +2e) is directed head-on toward a stationary gold nucleus (79197Au^{197}_{79}\text{Au}) with kinetic energy Ki=7.70 MeVK_i = 7.70\text{ MeV}. Calculate the distance of closest approach dmind_{\text{min}} in femtometers. (Take kee2≈1.440 MeV⋅fmk_e e^2 \approx 1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}.)

Answer

dmin=ke(2e)(79e)Ki=158⋅1.440 MeV⋅fm7.70 MeV≈29.5 fmd_{\text{min}} = \frac{k_e (2e)(79e)}{K_i} = \frac{158 \cdot 1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{7.70\text{ MeV}} \approx 29.5\text{ fm}.

02

A proton (q=+eq = +e) is accelerated toward a stationary cobalt nucleus (2759Co^{59}_{27}\text{Co}). (a) Express the distance of closest approach dmind_{\text{min}} in terms of initial kinetic energy KiK_i. (b) What minimum kinetic energy KiK_i (in MeV\text{MeV}) is needed for the proton to reach the nuclear surface, given RCo=(1.20 fm)(59)1/3≈4.67 fmR_{\text{Co}} = (1.20\text{ fm})(59)^{1/3} \approx 4.67\text{ fm} (treat the proton as a point charge)?

Answer

(a) dmin=ke(e)(27e)Ki=27kee2Kid_{\text{min}} = \frac{k_e (e)(27e)}{K_i} = \frac{27 k_e e^2}{K_i}. (b) Setting dmin=RCo=4.67 fmd_{\text{min}} = R_{\text{Co}} = 4.67\text{ fm}: Kmin=27⋅1.440 MeV⋅fm4.67 fm≈8.33 MeVK_{\text{min}} = \frac{27 \cdot 1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{4.67\text{ fm}} \approx 8.33\text{ MeV}.

03

In a nuclear fusion experiment, a deuteron (12H^{2}_{1}\text{H}) and a triton (13H^{3}_{1}\text{H}) collide head-on with equal kinetic energies KK in their center-of-mass frame. Modeling their radii as R(A)=(1.20 fm)A1/3R(A) = (1.20\text{ fm})A^{1/3}, find the minimum total kinetic energy 2K2K (in keV\text{keV}) required for their surfaces to touch.

Answer
  1. Charges: each has Z=1Z = 1, so q1=q2=+eq_1 = q_2 = +e.
  2. Touching distance: Rtotal=Rd+Rt=1.20 fm(21/3+31/3)≈1.20(1.260+1.442)≈3.24 fmR_{\text{total}} = R_d + R_t = 1.20\text{ fm}(2^{1/3} + 3^{1/3}) \approx 1.20(1.260 + 1.442) \approx 3.24\text{ fm}.
  3. Energy required: Etotal=kee2Rtotal=1.440 MeV⋅fm3.24 fm≈0.444 MeV=444 keVE_{\text{total}} = \frac{k_e e^2}{R_{\text{total}}} = \frac{1.440\text{ MeV}\cdot\text{fm}}{3.24\text{ fm}} \approx 0.444\text{ MeV} = 444\text{ keV}.
Loading workspace…