Resources

An insulated copper block of mass m1=0.450 kgm_1 = 0.450\text{ kg} initially at temperature T1=368.15 KT_1 = 368.15\text{ K} (95.0∘C95.0^\circ\text{C}) is dropped into a thermally insulated container holding m2=0.800 kgm_2 = 0.800\text{ kg} of liquid water at T2=288.15 KT_2 = 288.15\text{ K} (15.0∘C15.0^\circ\text{C}). The specific heat capacity of copper is c1=386 J/(kg⋅K)c_1 = 386\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}) and that of water is c2=4186 J/(kg⋅K)c_2 = 4186\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}). Assuming no heat is exchanged with the container walls or the external environment, calculate: (a) the final thermal equilibrium temperature TfT_f of the mixture in Kelvin, and (b) the total entropy change ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}} of this irreversible thermal equilibration process in J/K\text{J}/\text{K}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Tf=292.11 KT_f = 292.11\text{ K}; (b) ΔSuniverse=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Final Equilibrium Temperature

When the hot copper block is placed into the colder water inside a thermally insulated system, no heat is exchanged with the surroundings: Qlost, copper+Qgained, water=0Q_{\text{lost, copper}} + Q_{\text{gained, water}} = 0

Equivalently, the heat released by the cooling copper equals the heat absorbed by the warming water: m1c1(T1−Tf)=m2c2(Tf−T2)m_1 c_1 (T_1 - T_f) = m_2 c_2 (T_f - T_2)

  1. Calculate the heat capacities of each component:

    • Copper: C1=m1c1=0.450 kg⋅386 J/(kg⋅K)=173.7 J/KC_1 = m_1 c_1 = 0.450\text{ kg} \cdot 386\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}) = 173.7\text{ J}/\text{K}
    • Water: C2=m2c2=0.800 kg⋅4186 J/(kg⋅K)=3348.8 J/KC_2 = m_2 c_2 = 0.800\text{ kg} \cdot 4186\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}) = 3348.8\text{ J}/\text{K}
  2. Solve for the equilibrium temperature TfT_f: Tf=m1c1T1+m2c2T2m1c1+m2c2T_f = \frac{m_1 c_1 T_1 + m_2 c_2 T_2}{m_1 c_1 + m_2 c_2}

    Substitute the initial absolute temperatures (T1=368.15 KT_1 = 368.15\text{ K} and T2=288.15 KT_2 = 288.15\text{ K}): Tf=(173.7 J/K)(368.15 K)+(3348.8 J/K)(288.15 K)173.7 J/K+3348.8 J/KT_f = \frac{(173.7\text{ J}/\text{K})(368.15\text{ K}) + (3348.8\text{ J}/\text{K})(288.15\text{ K})}{173.7\text{ J}/\text{K} + 3348.8\text{ J}/\text{K}} Tf=63947.7 J+964956.7 J3522.5 J/K=1028904.4 J3522.5 J/K≈292.11 KT_f = \frac{63947.7\text{ J} + 964956.7\text{ J}}{3522.5\text{ J}/\text{K}} = \frac{1028904.4\text{ J}}{3522.5\text{ J}/\text{K}} \approx 292.11\text{ K}

    (Note: This corresponds to approximately 18.96∘C18.96^\circ\text{C}.)


Part (b): Calculating the Total Entropy Change

Because thermal equilibration occurs via irreversible heat transfer across a finite temperature difference, the total entropy change of the isolated universe is the sum of the entropy changes of the copper and the water: ΔSuniverse=ΔScopper+ΔSwater\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{copper}} + \Delta S_{\text{water}}

For a substance of constant specific heat capacity cc changing temperature from TiT_i to TfT_f, the entropy change is: ΔS=∫TiTfmc dTT=mcln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = \int_{T_i}^{T_f} \frac{m c\, dT}{T} = m c \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right)

  1. Entropy change of the copper block (ΔScopper\Delta S_{\text{copper}}): ΔS1=m1c1ln⁡(TfT1)=173.7ln⁡(292.11368.15)\Delta S_1 = m_1 c_1 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_1}\right) = 173.7 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{368.15}\right) ΔS1=173.7⋅ln⁡(0.79345)=173.7⋅(−0.23136)≈−40.19 J/K\Delta S_1 = 173.7 \cdot \ln(0.79345) = 173.7 \cdot (-0.23136) \approx -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K} The copper loses heat, so its entropy decreases.
  2. Entropy change of the water (ΔSwater\Delta S_{\text{water}}): ΔS2=m2c2ln⁡(TfT2)=3348.8ln⁡(292.11288.15)\Delta S_2 = m_2 c_2 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_2}\right) = 3348.8 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{288.15}\right) ΔS2=3348.8⋅ln⁡(1.01374)=3348.8⋅(+0.01365)≈+46.22 J/K\Delta S_2 = 3348.8 \cdot \ln(1.01374) = 3348.8 \cdot (+0.01365) \approx +46.22\text{ J}/\text{K} The water gains heat at a lower temperature, so its entropy increases.
  3. Total entropy change (ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}}): ΔSuniverse=ΔS1+ΔS2=−40.19 J/K+46.22 J/K=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_1 + \Delta S_2 = -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K} + 46.22\text{ J}/\text{K} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}

Key Takeaway & Pitfall

  • Second Law of Thermodynamics: Heat flows spontaneously from a higher temperature to a lower temperature. Because heat is transferred into the cooler body at a lower temperature T2T_2 than that from which it left (T1T_1), the positive entropy change of the colder body exceeds the magnitude of the negative entropy change of the hotter body: ∣ΔSwater∣>∣ΔScopper∣|\Delta S_{\text{water}}| > |\Delta S_{\text{copper}}|.
  • Common Pitfall: Never use Celsius temperatures in the logarithmic entropy formula or write ΔS=Q/T\Delta S = Q/T with a single constant temperature. The temperatures must always be in Kelvin (T>0T > 0), and because temperature varies continuously during heat exchange, integration yields the logarithmic ratio ln⁡(Tf/Ti)\ln(T_f/T_i).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates entropy change using ΔS = Q / T with an initial or final temperature instead of integrating dQ / T as temperature varies.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    m1c1(T1−Tf)=m2c2(Tf−T2)  ⟹  173.7(368.15−Tf)=3348.8(Tf−288.15)  ⟹  Tf=292.10 Km_1 c_1 (T_1 - T_f) = m_2 c_2 (T_f - T_2) \implies 173.7(368.15 - T_f) = 3348.8(T_f - 288.15) \implies T_f = 292.10\text{ K}

  2. Step 2

    Qlost=13209.9 J  ⟹  ΔScopper=−13209.9 J368.15 K=−35.88 J/K,ΔSwater=13209.9 J288.15 K=45.84 J/KQ_{\text{lost}} = 13209.9\text{ J} \implies \Delta S_{\text{copper}} = -\frac{13209.9\text{ J}}{368.15\text{ K}} = -35.88\text{ J}/\text{K}, \quad \Delta S_{\text{water}} = \frac{13209.9\text{ J}}{288.15\text{ K}} = 45.84\text{ J}/\text{K}

    Correct

    ΔScopper=m1c1ln⁡(TfT1)=173.7ln⁡(292.11368.15)≈−40.19 J/K,ΔSwater=m2c2ln⁡(TfT2)=3348.8ln⁡(292.11288.15)≈+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{copper}} = m_1 c_1 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_1}\right) = 173.7 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{368.15}\right) \approx -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K}, \quad \Delta S_{\text{water}} = m_2 c_2 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_2}\right) = 3348.8 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{288.15}\right) \approx +46.22\text{ J}/\text{K}

    The formula ΔS=QT\Delta S = \frac{Q}{T} applies only to isothermal processes where temperature is constant (such as phase changes or ideal thermal reservoirs). Because the temperature of both the copper block and the water varies continuously during thermal equilibration, you must integrate dS=mc dTTdS = \frac{mc\,dT}{T} to obtain ΔS=mcln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = mc\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right).

  3. Step 3

    ΔSuniverse=−35.88+45.84=9.96 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -35.88 + 45.84 = 9.96\text{ J}/\text{K}

    Correct

    ΔSuniverse=ΔScopper+ΔSwater=−40.19 J/K+46.22 J/K=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{copper}} + \Delta S_{\text{water}} = -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K} + 46.22\text{ J}/\text{K} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}

    Your method of summing the two entropy changes was logically sound, but the final numerical value was affected by using the constant-temperature approximation in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the heat balance equation m1c1(T1−Tf)=m2c2(Tf−T2)m_1 c_1 (T_1 - T_f) = m_2 c_2 (T_f - T_2) to find the final equilibrium temperature.

You correctly recognized that the total entropy change of the universe equals the sum of the entropy changes of the copper block and the water.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Isothermal formula used for varying temperature

You evaluated ΔS\Delta S using the initial temperature in the denominator instead of accounting for continuous temperature variation.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an isothermal heat transfer process (where ΔS=QT\Delta S = \frac{Q}{T} holds because TT is constant) with a thermal equilibration process where the temperature of a finite body changes continuously as heat is transferred.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Constant $T$ vs. Varying $T$
  • For an isothermal process or ideal reservoir at constant temperature TT, ΔS=QT\Delta S = \frac{Q}{T}. For a substance with heat capacity C=mcC = mc undergoing a temperature change from TiT_i to TfT_f, ΔS=∫TiTfmc dTT=mcln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = \int_{T_i}^{T_f} \frac{mc\,dT}{T} = mc\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right).

  • Check whether the system changes temperature during heat exchange. If TT changes, always use the logarithmic integration formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the entropy change of the cooling copper: ΔS1=m1c1ln⁡(TfT1)=(0.450)(386)ln⁡(292.11368.15)=173.7(−0.23136)≈−40.19 J/K\Delta S_1 = m_1 c_1 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_1}\right) = (0.450)(386)\ln\left(\frac{292.11}{368.15}\right) = 173.7(-0.23136) \approx -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K}.

  2. Calculate the entropy change of the warming water: ΔS2=m2c2ln⁡(TfT2)=(0.800)(4186)ln⁡(292.11288.15)=3348.8(0.01365)≈+46.22 J/K\Delta S_2 = m_2 c_2 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_2}\right) = (0.800)(4186)\ln\left(\frac{292.11}{288.15}\right) = 3348.8(0.01365) \approx +46.22\text{ J}/\text{K}.

  3. Sum the entropy changes: ΔSuniverse=−40.19 J/K+46.22 J/K=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K} + 46.22\text{ J}/\text{K} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}.

Final answer

(a) Tf=292.11 KT_f = 292.11\text{ K}; (b) ΔSuniverse=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the thermodynamic definition of entropy change, noting why dS=dQrevTdS = \frac{dQ_{\text{rev}}}{T} requires integration when temperature changes.

  • Practice identifying whether a thermal system acts as an infinite heat reservoir (fixed TT) or a finite thermal mass (varying TT).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misapplies the temperature ratio in the logarithmic entropy formula by using temperatures in Celsius instead of absolute temperatures in Kelvin.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    m1⋅c1⋅(T1−Tf)=m2⋅c2⋅(Tf−T2)  ⟹  173.7⋅(368.15−Tf)=3348.8⋅(Tf−288.15)  ⟹  Tf=292.10 Km_1 \cdot c_1 \cdot (T_1 - T_f) = m_2 \cdot c_2 \cdot (T_f - T_2) \implies 173.7 \cdot (368.15 - T_f) = 3348.8 \cdot (T_f - 288.15) \implies T_f = 292.10\text{ K}

  2. Step 2

    T1c=95.0∘C,Tfc=18.95∘C  ⟹  ΔScopper=m1⋅c1⋅ln⁡(TfcT1c)=173.7⋅ln⁡(18.9595.0)=−279.79 J/KT_{1c} = 95.0^\circ\text{C}, \quad T_{fc} = 18.95^\circ\text{C} \implies \Delta S_{\text{copper}} = m_1 \cdot c_1 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{T_{fc}}{T_{1c}}\right) = 173.7 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{18.95}{95.0}\right) = -279.79\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔScopper=m1c1ln⁡(TfT1)=173.7⋅ln⁡(292.11368.15)≈−40.19 J/K\Delta S_{\text{copper}} = m_1 c_1 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_1}\right) = 173.7 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{368.15}\right) \approx -40.19\text{ J/K}

    Thermodynamic entropy is defined via dS=δQrevTdS = \frac{\delta Q_{\text{rev}}}{T}, where TT must be an absolute thermodynamic temperature in Kelvin. Taking the ratio of temperatures in degrees Celsius 18.9595.0\frac{18.95}{95.0} yields an incorrect ratio because the Celsius scale has an arbitrary non-zero zero point.

  3. Step 3

    T2c=15.0∘C,Tfc=18.95∘C  ⟹  ΔSwater=m2⋅c2⋅ln⁡(TfcT2c)=3348.8⋅ln⁡(18.9515.0)=781.18 J/KT_{2c} = 15.0^\circ\text{C}, \quad T_{fc} = 18.95^\circ\text{C} \implies \Delta S_{\text{water}} = m_2 \cdot c_2 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{T_{fc}}{T_{2c}}\right) = 3348.8 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{18.95}{15.0}\right) = 781.18\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSwater=m2c2ln⁡(TfT2)=3348.8⋅ln⁡(292.11288.15)≈+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{water}} = m_2 c_2 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_2}\right) = 3348.8 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{288.15}\right) \approx +46.22\text{ J/K}

    You repeated the same error here by using Celsius temperatures in the logarithmic ratio instead of Kelvin values (292.11 K292.11\text{ K} and 288.15 K288.15\text{ K}).

  4. Step 4

    ΔSuniverse=−279.79+781.18=501.39 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -279.79 + 781.18 = 501.39\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSuniverse=ΔScopper+ΔSwater=−40.19+46.22=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_{\text{copper}} + \Delta S_{\text{water}} = -40.19 + 46.22 = +6.03\text{ J/K}

    Your addition method is conceptually sound, but the final sum is incorrect because it uses the erroneous component values from the previous steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly established the thermal energy balance equation between the two substances.

You accurately solved for the final equilibrium temperature in Kelvin.

You recognized that total entropy change is the sum of the entropy changes of the two components.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Celsius Used in Absolute Temperature Ratio

You deliberately converted your correct Kelvin temperature into Celsius before substituting it into ΔS=mcln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S = m c \ln(T_f / T_i).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing temperature differences (ΔT\Delta T) with temperature ratios (Tf/TiT_f / T_i). While a change of 1∘C1^\circ\text{C} equals a change of 1 K1\text{ K} when subtracting, ratios and logarithmic arguments are not invariant under scale shifts and require absolute temperatures in Kelvin.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Absolute Temperature Requirement
  • Thermodynamic formulas involving absolute temperature TT or temperature ratios TfTi\frac{T_f}{T_i} strictly require temperatures in Kelvin.

  • Always keep temperatures in Kelvin when evaluating ln⁡(TfTi)\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right), QT\frac{Q}{T}, or ideal gas laws.

Difference vs. Ratio Invariance
  • ΔT=Tf−Ti\Delta T = T_f - T_i is identical in Celsius and Kelvin, but TfTi\frac{T_f}{T_i} is never equal in Celsius and Kelvin.

  • Only substitute Celsius directly when an expression contains solely a raw linear difference ΔT=T2−T1\Delta T = T_2 - T_1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the entropy change of copper using Kelvin: ΔScopper=(173.7 J/K)⋅ln⁡(292.11 K368.15 K)=173.7⋅(−0.23136)≈−40.19 J/K\Delta S_{\text{copper}} = (173.7\text{ J/K}) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{292.11\text{ K}}{368.15\text{ K}}\right) = 173.7 \cdot (-0.23136) \approx -40.19\text{ J/K}.

  2. Evaluate the entropy change of water using Kelvin: ΔSwater=(3348.8 J/K)⋅ln⁡(292.11 K288.15 K)=3348.8⋅(+0.01365)≈+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{water}} = (3348.8\text{ J/K}) \cdot \ln\left(\frac{292.11\text{ K}}{288.15\text{ K}}\right) = 3348.8 \cdot (+0.01365) \approx +46.22\text{ J/K}.

  3. Sum the component entropy changes: ΔSuniverse=−40.19 J/K+46.22 J/K=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -40.19\text{ J/K} + 46.22\text{ J/K} = +6.03\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

(a) Tf=292.11 KT_f = 292.11\text{ K}; (b) ΔSuniverse=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +6.03\text{ J/K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the thermodynamic definition dS=dQrevTdS = \frac{dQ_{\text{rev}}}{T} to understand why absolute temperature is required.

  • Practice identifying whether a formula depends on a temperature difference ΔT\Delta T or an absolute ratio Tf/TiT_f/T_i before substituting values.

  • Work through problems involving irreversible heat exchange between unequal thermal reservoirs.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses a simple arithmetic mean of the initial temperatures rather than weighting by heat capacities.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Tf=T1+T22=368.15+288.152=328.15 KT_f = \frac{T_1 + T_2}{2} = \frac{368.15 + 288.15}{2} = 328.15\text{ K}

    Correct

    m1c1(Tf−T1)+m2c2(Tf−T2)=0  ⟹  Tf=m1c1T1+m2c2T2m1c1+m2c2≈292.11 Km_1 c_1 (T_f - T_1) + m_2 c_2 (T_f - T_2) = 0 \implies T_f = \frac{m_1 c_1 T_1 + m_2 c_2 T_2}{m_1 c_1 + m_2 c_2} \approx 292.11\text{ K}

    You calculated TfT_f as the simple unweighted mean of T1T_1 and T2T_2. Because the total heat capacity of the water (C2=m2c2≈3348.8 J/KC_2 = m_2 c_2 \approx 3348.8\text{ J}/\text{K}) is nearly twenty times that of the copper (C1=m1c1≈173.7 J/KC_1 = m_1 c_1 \approx 173.7\text{ J}/\text{K}), the equilibrium temperature must be determined by heat conservation, Qlost+Qgained=0Q_{\text{lost}} + Q_{\text{gained}} = 0, which pulls TfT_f much closer to the initial water temperature.

  2. Step 2

    ΔScopper=m1⋅c1⋅ln⁡(TfT1)=0.450⋅386⋅ln⁡(328.15368.15)=173.7⋅ln⁡(0.89135)=−19.98 J/K\Delta S_{\text{copper}} = m_1 \cdot c_1 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_1}\right) = 0.450 \cdot 386 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{328.15}{368.15}\right) = 173.7 \cdot \ln(0.89135) = -19.98\text{ J}/\text{K}

    Correct

    ΔS1=m1c1ln⁡(TfT1)=173.7ln⁡(292.11368.15)≈−40.19 J/K\Delta S_1 = m_1 c_1 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_1}\right) = 173.7 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{368.15}\right) \approx -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K}

    You selected the correct thermodynamic relation for the entropy change of a cooling substance with constant heat capacity, and your arithmetic was accurate for your value of TfT_f. However, this result is numerically affected by the incorrect value of TfT_f from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    ΔSwater=m2⋅c2⋅ln⁡(TfT2)=0.800⋅4186⋅ln⁡(328.15288.15)=3348.8⋅ln⁡(1.13882)=435.37 J/K\Delta S_{\text{water}} = m_2 \cdot c_2 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_2}\right) = 0.800 \cdot 4186 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{328.15}{288.15}\right) = 3348.8 \cdot \ln(1.13882) = 435.37\text{ J}/\text{K}

    Correct

    ΔS2=m2c2ln⁡(TfT2)=3348.8ln⁡(292.11288.15)≈+46.22 J/K\Delta S_2 = m_2 c_2 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_2}\right) = 3348.8 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{288.15}\right) \approx +46.22\text{ J}/\text{K}

    Your formula and calculation method for the entropy change of the warming water were completely correct, but the numerical answer is carried over from the incorrect TfT_f from Step 1.

  4. Step 4

    ΔSuniverse=−19.98+435.37=415.39 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -19.98 + 435.37 = 415.39\text{ J}/\text{K}

    Correct

    ΔSuniverse=ΔS1+ΔS2=−40.19 J/K+46.22 J/K=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = \Delta S_1 + \Delta S_2 = -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K} + 46.22\text{ J}/\text{K} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}

    You correctly added the individual entropy changes to determine the total entropy change of the universe, but the value is incorrect due to the propagated error from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the integral form ΔS=mcln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S = m c \ln(T_f / T_i) to account for continuous temperature changes during heat exchange.

You correctly identified absolute temperatures in Kelvin for evaluating the entropy ratios.

You recognized that the total entropy change of an isolated system is the algebraic sum of the entropy changes of its components.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unweighted temperature average instead of calorimetric energy balance

You treated the final temperature as the simple midpoint (T1+T2)/2(T_1 + T_2)/2 instead of weighting the temperatures by heat capacities.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the first law of thermodynamics (Qnet=0Q_{\text{net}} = 0) in thermal mixing, assuming that thermal equilibrium corresponds to the geometric or arithmetic midpoint of temperatures rather than a heat-capacity-weighted average.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Thermal Equilibrium via First Law
  • For an insulated system, total heat exchanged is zero: ∑Q=∑mici(Tf−Ti)=0\sum Q = \sum m_i c_i (T_f - T_i) = 0.

  • Always compute the heat capacities Ci=miciC_i = m_i c_i first and solve Tf=∑CiTi∑CiT_f = \frac{\sum C_i T_i}{\sum C_i}.

Reality Check on Equilibrium Temperature
  • A body with a much larger heat capacity (C=mcC = mc) resists temperature changes more strongly.

  • Check whether TfT_f lies much closer to the initial temperature of the object with the larger heat capacity.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the total heat capacities of each substance: C1=m1c1=(0.450 kg)(386 J/(kg⋅K))=173.7 J/KC_1 = m_1 c_1 = (0.450\text{ kg})(386\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K})) = 173.7\text{ J}/\text{K} and C2=m2c2=(0.800 kg)(4186 J/(kg⋅K))=3348.8 J/KC_2 = m_2 c_2 = (0.800\text{ kg})(4186\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K})) = 3348.8\text{ J}/\text{K}.

  2. Apply energy conservation Q1+Q2=0Q_1 + Q_2 = 0: C1(Tf−T1)+C2(Tf−T2)=0  ⟹  Tf=C1T1+C2T2C1+C2=(173.7)(368.15)+(3348.8)(288.15)173.7+3348.8=1028904.43522.5≈292.11 KC_1(T_f - T_1) + C_2(T_f - T_2) = 0 \implies T_f = \frac{C_1 T_1 + C_2 T_2}{C_1 + C_2} = \frac{(173.7)(368.15) + (3348.8)(288.15)}{173.7 + 3348.8} = \frac{1028904.4}{3522.5} \approx 292.11\text{ K}.

  3. Recalculate copper entropy change: ΔS1=173.7ln⁡(292.11368.15)=173.7⋅(−0.23136)≈−40.19 J/K\Delta S_1 = 173.7 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{368.15}\right) = 173.7 \cdot (-0.23136) \approx -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K}.

  4. Recalculate water entropy change: ΔS2=3348.8ln⁡(292.11288.15)=3348.8⋅(+0.01365)≈+46.22 J/K\Delta S_2 = 3348.8 \ln\left(\frac{292.11}{288.15}\right) = 3348.8 \cdot (+0.01365) \approx +46.22\text{ J}/\text{K}.

  5. Find total entropy change: ΔSuniverse=−40.19 J/K+46.22 J/K=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -40.19\text{ J}/\text{K} + 46.22\text{ J}/\text{K} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}.

Final answer

(a) Tf=292.11 KT_f = 292.11\text{ K}; (b) ΔSuniverse=+6.03 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = +6.03\text{ J}/\text{K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the energy balance m1c1(T1−Tf)=m2c2(Tf−T2)m_1 c_1 (T_1 - T_f) = m_2 c_2 (T_f - T_2) before solving for TfT_f in any calorimetry problem.

  • Perform a quick mental sanity check: because water has a much higher specific heat capacity and mass, the final temperature should rise only a few degrees above the initial water temperature (288.15 K288.15\text{ K}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.200 kg0.200\text{ kg} piece of iron with specific heat capacity c=450 J/(kg⋅K)c = 450\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}) cools from 373.15 K373.15\text{ K} to 293.15 K293.15\text{ K}. Calculate its change in entropy ΔS\Delta S.

Answer

ΔS=mcln⁡(TfTi)=(0.200)(450)ln⁡(293.15373.15)=90.0⋅(−0.2413)≈−21.7 J/K\Delta S = mc\ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) = (0.200)(450)\ln\left(\frac{293.15}{373.15}\right) = 90.0 \cdot (-0.2413) \approx -21.7\text{ J}/\text{K}.

02

An ideal heat reservoir at a constant temperature of 400 K400\text{ K} transfers 4800 J4800\text{ J} of heat to a second reservoir at a constant temperature of 300 K300\text{ K}. Calculate the total entropy change of the universe ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}}.

Answer

Since both reservoirs maintain constant temperatures: ΔShot=−QTH=−4800400=−12.0 J/K\Delta S_{\text{hot}} = -\frac{Q}{T_H} = -\frac{4800}{400} = -12.0\text{ J}/\text{K} ΔScold=+QTC=+4800300=+16.0 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = +\frac{Q}{T_C} = +\frac{4800}{300} = +16.0\text{ J}/\text{K} ΔSuniverse=−12.0+16.0=+4.0 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -12.0 + 16.0 = +4.0\text{ J}/\text{K}.

03

A 0.500 kg0.500\text{ kg} block of aluminum (c=900 J/(kg⋅K)c = 900\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K})) at 400 K400\text{ K} is dropped into an enormous lake whose temperature remains constant at 290 K290\text{ K}. Calculate: (a) the heat transferred from the aluminum to the lake, (b) the entropy change of the aluminum, (c) the entropy change of the lake, and (d) ΔSuniverse\Delta S_{\text{universe}}.

Answer

(a) Q=mc(Ti−Tf)=(0.500)(900)(400−290)=49500 JQ = mc(T_i - T_f) = (0.500)(900)(400 - 290) = 49500\text{ J}. (b) Aluminum cools with varying TT: ΔSAl=mcln⁡(Tf/Ti)=450ln⁡(290/400)=450(−0.3216)≈−144.7 J/K\Delta S_{\text{Al}} = mc\ln(T_f/T_i) = 450\ln(290/400) = 450(-0.3216) \approx -144.7\text{ J}/\text{K}. (c) Lake is a constant-temperature reservoir: ΔSlake=+QTlake=+49500290≈+170.7 J/K\Delta S_{\text{lake}} = +\frac{Q}{T_{\text{lake}}} = +\frac{49500}{290} \approx +170.7\text{ J}/\text{K}. (d) ΔSuniverse=−144.7+170.7=+26.0 J/K\Delta S_{\text{universe}} = -144.7 + 170.7 = +26.0\text{ J}/\text{K}.

Loading workspace…