Resources
Consider a book of mass resting motionless on a rigid horizontal tabletop. Let . (a) Calculate the magnitude of the gravitational force exerted by the Earth on the book, , and the normal force exerted by the table on the book, . (b) Many students argue: 'Since , the normal force is the Newton's third law reaction to gravity.' Refute this argument rigorously using Newton's second and third laws by: (1) explaining why and are equal in magnitude in this specific static state, (2) providing a scenario where , and (3) identifying the exact Newton's third law reaction partner to each of the two forces.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , ; (b) (1) holds purely as a consequence of Newton's second law for a static equilibrium state (), not Newton's third law. (2) In an accelerating reference frame (such as an elevator accelerating upward at ), . (3) The reaction partner to the Earth's gravitational pull on the book is an upward gravitational pull of exerted by the book on the center of the Earth; the reaction partner to the upward normal force of the table on the book is a downward normal force of exerted by the book on the table.
Steps
Why in this specific case
Part (a): Calculating the Magnitudes of and
- Calculate the gravitational force (): The magnitude of the gravitational force exerted by the Earth on the book depends on the book's mass and the acceleration due to gravity :
- Calculate the normal force (): Since the book is at rest on a horizontal surface, its vertical acceleration is zero (). Setting the upward direction as positive, apply Newton's second law along the vertical axis:
Part (b): Refuting the Common Misconception
The relation (or ) is a consequence of Newton's second law applied to a single object in equilibrium, not Newton's third law: Both forces act on the same body (the book). Newton's third law pairs, by definition, must act on two different interacting objects.
A Scenario where
If and were a third-law action-reaction pair, they would always be equal in magnitude and opposite in direction regardless of motion.
However, place the book inside an elevator that accelerates upward with acceleration : Because during vertical acceleration, the two forces cannot be an action-reaction pair.
Identifying the True Newton's Third Law Reaction Partners
Newton's third law states that when object exerts a force on object , object exerts an equal and opposite force on object of the exact same physical type:
- Reaction to (Earth pulls book downward): An upward gravitational force exerted by the book on the Earth, centered at the Earth's center of mass, with a magnitude of .
- Reaction to (Table pushes book upward): A downward normal contact force exerted by the book on the table's surface, with a magnitude of .
Typical errors
01 The student conflates equilibrium of forces on a single object with Newton's third law action-reaction pairs, concluding that N and F_g are an action-reaction pair because they cancel out.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
and are equal because Newton's third law requires every action force to have an equal and opposite reaction force on the same object.
Correctbecause the book is in equilibrium: by Newton's second law. Both forces act on the same object (the book), so they cannot be a third-law pair.
Newton's third law action-reaction pairs always act on two different interacting objects ( on and on ), never on the same object. The forces balance here because the net acceleration of the book is zero.
- Step 3
If the book is moving at constant velocity on a horizontal table, still equals , so never differs from .
CorrectIn an elevator accelerating upward with vertical acceleration , .
You described another zero-acceleration case rather than providing a scenario where the magnitudes differ. Whenever there is a vertical acceleration or an extra vertical applied force, the normal force does not equal .
- Step 4
The reaction to is , and the reaction to is .
CorrectThe third-law reaction to (Earth pulling book downward) is an upward gravitational pull of exerted by the book on the Earth. The reaction to (table pushing book upward) is a downward contact force of exerted by the book on the table.
An action-reaction pair must involve swapping the agent and the recipient, and must be of the exact same physical type (gravity pairs with gravity; contact normal force pairs with contact normal force).
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the magnitude of the gravitational force using .
You correctly recognized that the normal force has the same magnitude as gravity when the book is resting motionless on a horizontal surface.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that two equal and opposite forces acting on the same object constitute an action-reaction pair under Newton's third law, whereas action-reaction pairs must act on two distinct objects and share the same physical nature.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Two Objects vs. One Object
Newton's third law pairs always act on two distinct objects ( on and on ). Equilibrium forces () act on a single object.
Identify the object feeling each force. If both forces act on the same body, they cannot be a third-law pair.
- Same Physical Type
An action-reaction partner must have the exact same physical mechanism (gravitational with gravitational, contact normal with contact normal).
Swap agent and object to find the true partner: 'table pushes book' pairs with 'book pushes table'.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState that comes from Newton's second law applied to the book: .
Show that in an accelerating elevator () or on an incline ().
Identify the third-law partner of Earth's gravitational pull on the book as the book's upward gravitational pull on the Earth, and the partner of the table's upward normal force on the book as the book's downward normal force on the table.
(a) , ; (b) (1) is due to Newton's second law for static equilibrium on one body (), not Newton's third law. (2) Inside an elevator accelerating upward at , . (3) The reaction to is the book pulling upward on the Earth with ; the reaction to is the book pushing downward on the table with .
02 The student misidentifies the reaction partner of gravity as the table pushing on the book rather than the book exerting a gravitational pull on the Earth.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
\sum F = N - F_g = ma = 0 a = 0, N = F_g.
- Step 3
P, N = F_g + P, g.
- Step 4
N F_g
Correct: g:
You correctly identified the reaction to the normal force as the book pushing down on the table. However, the reaction partner to the Earth's gravitational pull on the book is an upward gravitational pull exerted by the book on the Earth, not the table's support.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the numerical values of both forces using the mass and gravitational acceleration.
You clearly applied Newton's second law to demonstrate that equilibrium accounts for the equality of magnitudes.
You devised a completely valid physical counterexample where .
You correctly identified the third-law partner of the normal force as the book pushing down on the table.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the support force that counteracts gravity on the book as its reaction partner, confusing force balancing on a single body with an action-reaction pair across two interacting bodies.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Rule of Interacting Bodies
If object A exerts a force of type X on object B, then object B exerts an equal and opposite force of type X on object A.
Always swap the agent and the receiver while keeping the physical nature of the force identical (e.g., gravity pairs with gravity, contact normal force pairs with contact normal force).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the interaction for gravity: the Earth pulls downward on the book via gravity.
Swap the agent and recipient: the book pulls upward on the Earth via gravity.
Confirm that both forces are of the exact same physical type (gravitational attraction) and have equal magnitude ().
The reaction partner to is the downward normal contact force of the book on the table (). The reaction partner to is an upward gravitational pull of the book on the Earth ().
Lock it in
Can two forces that act on the same object ever form a Newton's third law action-reaction pair?
No. Action-reaction pairs always act on two different interacting bodies ( acts on , and acts on ).
Similar question
A block is placed on a horizontal floor inside an elevator that is accelerating upward at . Take . Calculate the magnitude of the normal force acting on the block, and state whether .
Answer
, so . By Newton's second law, .
A magnet rests on an iron refrigerator door, held motionless by magnetic attraction, contact normal force, friction, and gravity. Name the recipient, agent, and exact reaction partner for the magnetic pull exerted by the door on the magnet.
Answer
Recipient: the magnet. Agent: the door. Reaction partner: an equal and opposite magnetic pull exerted by the magnet on the door (agent: magnet, recipient: door).
A person of mass stands on a bathroom scale on a flat floor. Four forces are present: (Earth pulls person down), (scale pushes person up), (person pushes scale down), and (person pulls Earth up). Group these four forces into (a) pairs that cancel in Newton's second law for the person, and (b) true Newton's third law action-reaction pairs.
Answer
(a) Equilibrium pair for the person: and (both act on the person, so ). (b) Third-law pairs: (gravitational interaction between Earth and person) and (contact normal interaction between scale and person).