Resources

Consider the heat transfer of an infinitesimal quantity of heat dQdQ from a source at THT_H to a body at temperature TC=TH−ΔTT_C = T_H - \Delta T, where the temperature differential is ΔT>0\Delta T > 0. (a) Write the exact algebraic expression for the entropy generation dSunivd S_{\text{univ}} in terms of dQdQ, THT_H, and ΔT\Delta T. (b) Evaluate the Taylor series limit of dSunivd S_{\text{univ}} as the driving thermal difference approaches zero (ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0). (c) For TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K} and Q=100 JQ = 100\text{ J}, compute ΔSuniv\Delta S_{\text{univ}} when ΔT=50 K\Delta T = 50\text{ K}, ΔT=1 K\Delta T = 1\text{ K}, and ΔT=0.01 K\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K}, and explain how this asymptotic behavior defines the transition from irreversible to quasi-static reversible heat transfer.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) dSuniv=dQ(1TH−ΔT−1TH)=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\left(\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} - \frac{1}{T_H}\right) = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}; (b) As ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0, dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2→0d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \to 0, confirming that reversibility is an ideal asymptotic limit of vanishing driving gradient; (c) For ΔT=50 K\Delta T = 50\text{ K}: ΔSuniv=+0.0667 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = +0.0667\text{ J}/\text{K}; for ΔT=1 K\Delta T = 1\text{ K}: ΔSuniv=+0.00111 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = +0.00111\text{ J}/\text{K}; for ΔT=0.01 K\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K}: ΔSuniv=+1.11×10−5 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = +1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J}/\text{K}.

Steps

Part (a): Exact Algebraic Expression for dSunivd S_{\text{univ}}

By the second law of thermodynamics, the entropy change of the universe during a thermal interaction is the sum of the entropy changes of the two interacting bodies: dSuniv=dSH+dSCd S_{\text{univ}} = d S_H + d S_C

During the transfer of heat dQ>0dQ > 0 from the hot reservoir at THT_H to the colder reservoir at TC=TH−ΔTT_C = T_H - \Delta T:

  • The hot reservoir loses heat: dSH=−dQTHd S_H = -\dfrac{dQ}{T_H}
  • The cold reservoir gains heat: dSC=+dQTC=+dQTH−ΔTd S_C = +\dfrac{dQ}{T_C} = +\dfrac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T}

Combining these contributions gives: dSuniv=dQ(1TH−ΔT−1TH)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\left(\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} - \frac{1}{T_H}\right)

Finding a common denominator yields the exact expression: dSuniv=dQTH−(TH−ΔT)TH(TH−ΔT)=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\frac{T_H - (T_H - \Delta T)}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)} = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}

Since dQ>0dQ > 0, TH>0T_H > 0, and ΔT>0\Delta T > 0, we have dSuniv>0d S_{\text{univ}} > 0, consistent with the irreversibility of spontaneous heat conduction across a finite temperature gap.


Part (b): Taylor Series Expansion as ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0

Factoring out THT_H from the denominator of the cold reservoir's term: 1TH−ΔT=1TH(1−ΔTTH)−1\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} = \frac{1}{T_H}\left(1 - \frac{\Delta T}{T_H}\right)^{-1}

Using the geometric series/Taylor expansion (1−x)−1=1+x+O(x2)(1 - x)^{-1} = 1 + x + \mathcal{O}(x^2) for x=ΔTTH≪1x = \frac{\Delta T}{T_H} \ll 1: 1TH−ΔT=1TH+ΔTTH2+O((ΔT)2)\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} = \frac{1}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} + \mathcal{O}\left((\Delta T)^2\right)

Substituting this back into dSunivd S_{\text{univ}}: dSuniv=dQ[(1TH+ΔTTH2+O((ΔT)2))−1TH]=dQΔTTH2+O((ΔT)2)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\left[\left(\frac{1}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} + \mathcal{O}\left((\Delta T)^2\right)\right) - \frac{1}{T_H}\right] = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} + \mathcal{O}\left((\Delta T)^2\right)

To leading order: dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}

As the temperature difference vanishes (ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0): lim⁡ΔT→0dSuniv=0\lim_{\Delta T \to 0} d S_{\text{univ}} = 0

This shows that entropy generation is directly proportional to the driving thermal gradient ΔT\Delta T. A truly reversible process is an idealized limit where heat transfer occurs across an infinitesimal temperature difference (ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0), leaving the entropy of the universe unchanged.


Part (c): Numerical Calculations and Conceptual Interpretation

Using the exact formula ΔSuniv=QΔTTH(TH−ΔT)\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = Q\dfrac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)} with Q=100 JQ = 100\text{ J} and TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K}:

  1. For ΔT=50 K\Delta T = 50\text{ K} (TC=250 KT_C = 250\text{ K}): ΔSuniv=10050300⋅250=500075000=115≈+0.0667 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = 100\frac{50}{300 \cdot 250} = \frac{5000}{75000} = \frac{1}{15} \approx +0.0667\text{ J/K}
  2. For ΔT=1 K\Delta T = 1\text{ K} (TC=299 KT_C = 299\text{ K}): ΔSuniv=1001300⋅299=10089700≈+0.00111 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = 100\frac{1}{300 \cdot 299} = \frac{100}{89700} \approx +0.00111\text{ J/K}
  3. For ΔT=0.01 K\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K} (TC=299.99 KT_C = 299.99\text{ K}): ΔSuniv=1000.01300⋅299.99=189997≈+1.11×10−5 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = 100\frac{0.01}{300 \cdot 299.99} = \frac{1}{89997} \approx +1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K}

Physical Interpretation: As ΔT\Delta T decreases from 50 K50\text{ K} to 0.01 K0.01\text{ K}, the entropy generation drops by nearly four orders of magnitude.

  • When ΔT\Delta T is large, heat flow is strongly irreversible, creating a substantial increase in universal entropy.
  • When ΔT\Delta T is made progressively smaller, the state change proceeds quasi-statically through a continuous sequence of near-equilibrium states.
  • In the theoretical limit ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0, the transfer becomes reversible (ΔSuniv→0\Delta S_{\text{univ}} \to 0), demonstrating that reversible heat transfer is the zero-gradient asymptotic limit of irreversible heat transfer.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student reverses the sign of entropy changes by subtracting the heat absorbed from the heat released, resulting in negative universe entropy generation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dSuniv=dSsource−dSbody  ⟹  dSuniv=dQTH−dQTH−ΔT  ⟹  dSuniv=−dQ⋅ΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = d S_{\text{source}} - d S_{\text{body}} \implies d S_{\text{univ}} = \frac{dQ}{T_H} - \frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T} \implies d S_{\text{univ}} = \frac{-dQ \cdot \Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}

    Correct

    dSuniv=dSsource+dSbody=−dQTH+dQTH−ΔT=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = d S_{\text{source}} + d S_{\text{body}} = -\frac{dQ}{T_H} + \frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T} = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}

    Total entropy change of the universe is the sum of the entropy changes, dSuniv=dSsource+dSbodyd S_{\text{univ}} = d S_{\text{source}} + d S_{\text{body}}. Since the hot source loses heat, its entropy change is dSsource=−dQTHd S_{\text{source}} = -\frac{dQ}{T_H}, while the colder body gains heat, so dSbody=+dQTH−ΔTd S_{\text{body}} = +\frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T}. Reversing these signs makes the net entropy generation negative.

  2. Step 2

    dSuniv≈−dQ⋅ΔTTH2  ⟹  As ΔT→0,dSuniv→0 from below (negative)d S_{\text{univ}} \approx \frac{-dQ \cdot \Delta T}{T_H^2} \implies \text{As } \Delta T \to 0, d S_{\text{univ}} \to 0 \text{ from below (negative)}

    Correct

    dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2  ⟹  lim⁡ΔT→0dSuniv=0d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \implies \lim_{\Delta T \to 0} d S_{\text{univ}} = 0

    Your first-order Taylor expansion technique is algebraically sound, but the negative sign propagated from the error in Part (a).

  3. Step 3

    ΔT=50 K  ⟹  ΔSuniv≈−0.0667 J/K\Delta T = 50\text{ K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx -0.0667\text{ J/K}; ΔT=1 K  ⟹  ΔSuniv≈−0.00111 J/K\Delta T = 1\text{ K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx -0.00111\text{ J/K}; ΔT=0.01 K  ⟹  ΔSuniv≈−1.11×10−5 J/K\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx -1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔT=50 K  ⟹  ΔSuniv≈+0.0667 J/K\Delta T = 50\text{ K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx +0.0667\text{ J/K}; ΔT=1 K  ⟹  ΔSuniv≈+0.00111 J/K\Delta T = 1\text{ K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx +0.00111\text{ J/K}; ΔT=0.01 K  ⟹  ΔSuniv≈+1.11×10−5 J/K\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx +1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K}

    Your numerical arithmetic and observation that ΔSuniv→0\Delta S_{\text{univ}} \to 0 as ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0 are correct, but the values should be positive because spontaneous heat transfer always generates entropy.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You combined the thermal fractions over a common denominator accurately.

You correctly applied a first-order Taylor expansion for 1TH−ΔT\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} as ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0.

You computed the correct numerical magnitudes for all three values of ΔT\Delta T.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Heat Transfer Sign Convention in Entropy Balance

You set dSuniv=dSsource−dSbodyd S_{\text{univ}} = d S_{\text{source}} - d S_{\text{body}} rather than summing the individual entropy changes with their proper thermodynamic heat signs.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the sign convention of heat transfer (dQ<0dQ < 0 for heat leaving a reservoir, dQ>0dQ > 0 for heat entering a reservoir) and treating the total entropy change as a subtraction of states rather than an extensive sum (dStotal=∑dSid S_{\text{total}} = \sum d S_i).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Extensive Summation of Entropy
  • For an isolated universe consisting of interacting subsystems, the total entropy change is always the sum: dSuniv=∑idSid S_{\text{univ}} = \sum_i d S_i.

  • Always write dSuniv=dS1+dS2+…d S_{\text{univ}} = d S_1 + d S_2 + \dots before substituting thermodynamic relations.

Thermodynamic Heat Sign Convention
  • Entropy change for a reservoir at temperature TT exchanging heat dQdQ is dS=dQTd S = \frac{dQ}{T}, where dQ>0dQ > 0 if heat enters and dQ<0dQ < 0 if heat leaves.

  • Check that the colder reservoir absorbs heat (dSC>0d S_C > 0) and the hotter reservoir loses heat (dSH<0d S_H < 0), ensuring dSuniv>0d S_{\text{univ}} > 0 for spontaneous heat conduction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the universal entropy balance as a sum: dSuniv=dSsource+dSbodyd S_{\text{univ}} = d S_{\text{source}} + d S_{\text{body}}.

  2. Substitute heat lost by the source and heat gained by the body: dSuniv=−dQTH+dQTH−ΔT=dQ(1TH−ΔT−1TH)d S_{\text{univ}} = -\frac{dQ}{T_H} + \frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T} = dQ\left(\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} - \frac{1}{T_H}\right).

  3. Combine fractions: dSuniv=dQTH−(TH−ΔT)TH(TH−ΔT)=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\frac{T_H - (T_H - \Delta T)}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)} = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}.

  4. Expand to first order in ΔT\Delta T: dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}.

  5. Evaluate at Q=100 JQ = 100\text{ J} and TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K} to obtain positive entropy generation values: +0.0667 J/K+0.0667\text{ J/K}, +0.00111 J/K+0.00111\text{ J/K}, and +1.11×10−5 J/K+1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

(a) dSuniv=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}; (b) dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2→0d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \to 0 as ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0; (c) ΔSuniv=+0.0667 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = +0.0667\text{ J/K} (50 K50\text{ K}), +0.00111 J/K+0.00111\text{ J/K} (1 K1\text{ K}), and +1.11×10−5 J/K+1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K} (0.01 K0.01\text{ K}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice setting up entropy balances for multi-reservoir heat transfers using the explicit sum form ΔSuniv=∑QiTi\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = \sum \frac{Q_i}{T_i}.

  • Perform a sanity check on spontaneous thermal interactions: heat flowing naturally from hot to cold must always yield ΔSuniv>0\Delta S_{\text{univ}} > 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets that the source loses heat and adds both terms positively, concluding that entropy increases symmetrically from both reservoirs.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dSuniv=dQTC+dQTH  ⟹  dSuniv=dQTH−ΔT+dQTH  ⟹  dSuniv=dQ(2TH−ΔT)TH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = \frac{dQ}{T_C} + \frac{dQ}{T_H} \implies d S_{\text{univ}} = \frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T} + \frac{dQ}{T_H} \implies d S_{\text{univ}} = \frac{dQ(2T_H - \Delta T)}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}

    Correct

    dSuniv=dSC+dSH=dQTH−ΔT−dQTH=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = d S_C + d S_H = \frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T} - \frac{dQ}{T_H} = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}

    Heat dQdQ leaves the hot reservoir, which means the reservoir loses entropy: dSH=−dQTHd S_H = -\frac{dQ}{T_H}. Because you added both terms with positive signs, the entropy changes did not oppose each other.

  2. Step 2

    1TH−ΔT≈1TH(1+ΔTTH)  ⟹  dSuniv≈dQ(2TH+ΔTTH2)  ⟹  As ΔT→0, dSuniv→2dQTH\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} \approx \frac{1}{T_H}\left(1 + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H}\right) \implies d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\left(\frac{2}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}\right) \implies \text{As } \Delta T \to 0,\, d S_{\text{univ}} \to \frac{2dQ}{T_H}

    Correct

    dSuniv≈dQ[(1TH+ΔTTH2)−1TH]=dQΔTTH2  ⟹  lim⁡ΔT→0dSuniv=0d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\left[\left(\frac{1}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}\right) - \frac{1}{T_H}\right] = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \implies \lim_{\Delta T \to 0} d S_{\text{univ}} = 0

    You expanded the denominator using a Taylor series correctly, but substituting your sum from Step 1 caused the leading 1TH\frac{1}{T_H} terms to add up to 2TH\frac{2}{T_H} instead of canceling out.

  3. Step 3

    ΔT=50 K:ΔSuniv≈0.733 J/K\Delta T = 50\text{ K}: \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx 0.733\text{ J/K}; ΔT=1 K:ΔSuniv≈0.668 J/K\Delta T = 1\text{ K}: \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx 0.668\text{ J/K}; ΔT=0.01 K:ΔSuniv≈0.667 J/K  ⟹  As ΔT→0, ΔSuniv→2QTH=0.667 J/K rather than zero.\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K}: \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx 0.667\text{ J/K} \implies \text{As } \Delta T \to 0,\, \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \to \frac{2Q}{T_H} = 0.667\text{ J/K} \text{ rather than zero.}

    Correct

    ΔT=50 K:ΔSuniv≈+0.0667 J/K\Delta T = 50\text{ K}: \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx +0.0667\text{ J/K}; ΔT=1 K:ΔSuniv≈+0.00111 J/K\Delta T = 1\text{ K}: \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx +0.00111\text{ J/K}; ΔT=0.01 K:ΔSuniv≈+1.11×10−5 J/K  ⟹  lim⁡ΔT→0ΔSuniv=0\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K}: \Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx +1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K} \implies \lim_{\Delta T \to 0} \Delta S_{\text{univ}} = 0

    Your numerical calculations accurately followed your derived formula, but because of the initial sign error, your result approached a non-zero constant (0.667 J/K0.667\text{ J/K}) instead of vanishing asymptotically to demonstrate reversibility.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the first-order binomial series expansion for 1TH−ΔT\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T}.

You accurately carried out common-denominator algebraic simplification and arithmetic calculations.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Heat Sign Convention in Entropy Changes

Adding heat transfer terms with positive signs for both reservoirs instead of subtracting entropy from the donor body.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated heat transfer dQdQ as a positive scalar quantity for both subsystems rather than enforcing the thermodynamic sign convention where heat leaving a system carries a negative sign (dQsource=−dQdQ_{\text{source}} = -dQ).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Thermodynamic Sign Convention for Heat
  • dS=δQrevTd S = \frac{\delta Q_{\text{rev}}}{T}; δQ>0\delta Q > 0 when absorbed, and δQ<0\delta Q < 0 when rejected.

  • Always assign opposite signs to interacting reservoirs: dSdonor=−dQTdonord S_{\text{donor}} = -\frac{dQ}{T_{\text{donor}}} and dSreceiver=+dQTreceiverd S_{\text{receiver}} = +\frac{dQ}{T_{\text{receiver}}}.

Reversible Limit Consistency Check
  • When two bodies exchange heat across a vanishing temperature difference (ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0), the interaction becomes quasi-static and reversible, requiring dSuniv→0d S_{\text{univ}} \to 0.

  • Check whether your leading order term vanishes when ΔT=0\Delta T = 0. If dSunivd S_{\text{univ}} remains non-zero, check for missing negative signs.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Assign correct thermodynamic signs: dSuniv=dSC+dSH=+dQTH−ΔT−dQTHd S_{\text{univ}} = d S_C + d S_H = +\frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T} - \frac{dQ}{T_H}.

  2. Find a common denominator: dSuniv=dQTH−(TH−ΔT)TH(TH−ΔT)=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\frac{T_H - (T_H - \Delta T)}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)} = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}.

  3. Apply the Taylor approximation 1TH−ΔT≈1TH+ΔTTH2\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} \approx \frac{1}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}, yielding dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2→0d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \to 0 as ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0.

  4. Compute values for Q=100 JQ = 100\text{ J} and TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K}: ΔS50 K=10050300(250)=115≈+0.0667 J/K\Delta S_{50\text{ K}} = 100\frac{50}{300(250)} = \frac{1}{15} \approx +0.0667\text{ J/K}; ΔS1 K=1001300(299)≈+0.00111 J/K\Delta S_{1\text{ K}} = 100\frac{1}{300(299)} \approx +0.00111\text{ J/K}; ΔS0.01 K=1000.01300(299.99)≈+1.11×10−5 J/K\Delta S_{0.01\text{ K}} = 100\frac{0.01}{300(299.99)} \approx +1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

(a) dSuniv=dQΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}; (b) As ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0, dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2→0d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \to 0; (c) ΔS50 K=+0.0667 J/K\Delta S_{50\text{ K}} = +0.0667\text{ J/K}, ΔS1 K=+0.00111 J/K\Delta S_{1\text{ K}} = +0.00111\text{ J/K}, ΔS0.01 K=+1.11×10−5 J/K\Delta S_{0.01\text{ K}} = +1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the Clausius definition of entropy and practice writing signed expressions for donor and recipient systems.

  • Solve problems where heat flows through an intermediate thermal resistance and verify that entropy generation scales with temperature difference squared.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student truncates the Taylor series too early by setting 1/(T_H - ΔT) equal to 1/T_H, causing the leading first-order dependence on ΔT to be missed entirely.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    dSuniv=dQTH−ΔT−dQTH  ⟹  dSuniv=dQ⋅ΔTTH(TH−ΔT)d S_{\text{univ}} = \frac{dQ}{T_H - \Delta T} - \frac{dQ}{T_H} \implies d S_{\text{univ}} = \frac{dQ \cdot \Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)}

  2. Step 2

    1TH−ΔT≈1TH  ⟹  dSuniv≈dQTH−dQTH=0  ⟹  \frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} \approx \frac{1}{T_H} \implies d S_{\text{univ}} \approx \frac{dQ}{T_H} - \frac{dQ}{T_H} = 0 \implies "The Taylor series limit is identically 0 without any dependence on ΔT\Delta T."

    Correct

    1TH−ΔT=1TH(1−ΔTTH)−1≈1TH+ΔTTH2  ⟹  dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} = \frac{1}{T_H}\left(1 - \frac{\Delta T}{T_H}\right)^{-1} \approx \frac{1}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \implies d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}

    You approximated 1TH−ΔT\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} by its zeroth-order constant 1TH\frac{1}{T_H}. When the zeroth-order terms cancel out, you must retain the first non-zero order term in the Taylor expansion to capture the asymptotic rate at which dSuniv→0d S_{\text{univ}} \to 0.

  3. Step 3

    "For all small ΔT\Delta T: ΔSuniv≈0 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx 0\text{ J/K}. At ΔT=50 K\Delta T = 50\text{ K}, ΔT=1 K\Delta T = 1\text{ K}, and ΔT=0.01 K\Delta T = 0.01\text{ K}, ΔSuniv≈0 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx 0\text{ J/K}. The heat transfer is considered reversible at any temperature difference because the zeroth-order terms cancel out."

    Correct

    ΔSuniv(50 K)=10050300(250)≈+0.0667 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}}(50\text{ K}) = 100\frac{50}{300(250)} \approx +0.0667\text{ J/K}; ΔSuniv(1 K)=1001300(299)≈+0.00111 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}}(1\text{ K}) = 100\frac{1}{300(299)} \approx +0.00111\text{ J/K}; ΔSuniv(0.01 K)=1000.01300(299.99)≈+1.11×10−5 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}}(0.01\text{ K}) = 100\frac{0.01}{300(299.99)} \approx +1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K}. Heat transfer across any finite ΔT>0\Delta T > 0 is strictly irreversible (Sgen>0S_{\text{gen}} > 0) and only approaches reversible behavior in the limit ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0.

    Because you assumed the entropy generation vanished identically for any small ΔT\Delta T, you did not calculate the non-zero numerical values from your part (a) formula and reached the incorrect physical conclusion that heat transfer across finite temperature gaps is reversible.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the two thermodynamic reservoirs and set up the individual entropy differentials with their proper signs.

You successfully found the common denominator to obtain the exact expression for dSunivd S_{\text{univ}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Premature Taylor series truncation

You stopped expanding 1TH−ΔT\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} at the zeroth-order term 1TH\frac{1}{T_H}, causing the leading linear dependence to cancel completely.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Whenever a physical difference f(x)−f(0)f(x) - f(0) is evaluated for small xx, the zeroth-order terms identically cancel; finding the asymptotic scaling behavior requires expanding to the first non-vanishing term, which is the linear term in the Taylor expansion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
First Non-Vanishing Order Rule
  • When expanding a difference A−BA - B where A≈BA \approx B at zeroth order, always expand to at least O(Δx)\mathcal{O}(\Delta x) so that the dominant behavior is not lost to zero.

  • Write (1−x)−1=1+x+x2+…(1 - x)^{-1} = 1 + x + x^2 + \dots and substitute x=ΔTTHx = \frac{\Delta T}{T_H} to keep the linear term.

Thermodynamic Reversibility Condition
  • Heat transfer across any non-zero temperature gap (ΔT>0\Delta T > 0) is irreversible and produces positive entropy generation (Sgen>0S_{\text{gen}} > 0). Reversibility occurs strictly when ΔT→0\Delta T \to 0.

  • Always evaluate numerical values using the exact algebraic formula derived in part (a) rather than equating small numbers to zero prematurely.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Factor THT_H out of the cold reservoir term: 1TH−ΔT=1TH(1−ΔTTH)−1\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} = \frac{1}{T_H}\left(1 - \frac{\Delta T}{T_H}\right)^{-1}.

  2. Apply the binomial Taylor expansion (1−x)−1=1+x+O(x2)(1 - x)^{-1} = 1 + x + \mathcal{O}(x^2) for x=ΔTTH≪1x = \frac{\Delta T}{T_H} \ll 1: 1TH−ΔT=1TH+ΔTTH2+O((ΔT)2)\frac{1}{T_H - \Delta T} = \frac{1}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} + \mathcal{O}\left((\Delta T)^2\right).

  3. Subtract the hot reservoir term: dSuniv=dQ[(1TH+ΔTTH2)−1TH]=dQΔTTH2d S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\left[\left(\frac{1}{T_H} + \frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}\right) - \frac{1}{T_H}\right] = dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2}.

  4. Evaluate ΔSuniv=QΔTTH(TH−ΔT)\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = Q\frac{\Delta T}{T_H(T_H - \Delta T)} with Q=100 JQ = 100\text{ J} and TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K} for ΔT=50 K\Delta T = 50\text{ K}, 1 K1\text{ K}, and 0.01 K0.01\text{ K}.

Final answer

(b) dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2→0d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} \to 0; (c) ΔSuniv=+0.0667 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = +0.0667\text{ J/K} for 50 K50\text{ K}, +0.00111 J/K+0.00111\text{ J/K} for 1 K1\text{ K}, and +1.11×10−5 J/K+1.11 \times 10^{-5}\text{ J/K} for 0.01 K0.01\text{ K}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice expanding rational functions of the form (T±ΔT)−1(T \pm \Delta T)^{-1} to first order using (1±x)−1≈1∓x(1 \pm x)^{-1} \approx 1 \mp x.

  • Check whether your leading approximation equals zero; if it does, always include the next higher-order term in the Taylor expansion.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A thermal reservoir at 400 K400\text{ K} transfers 200 J200\text{ J} of heat directly to a colder reservoir at 300 K300\text{ K}. Calculate the entropy change of each reservoir and the total entropy generated in the universe.

Answer

ΔShot=−200 J400 K=−0.5 J/K\Delta S_{\text{hot}} = -\frac{200\text{ J}}{400\text{ K}} = -0.5\text{ J/K}; ΔScold=+200 J300 K=+0.667 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = +\frac{200\text{ J}}{300\text{ K}} = +0.667\text{ J/K}; ΔSuniv=ΔShot+ΔScold=+0.167 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = \Delta S_{\text{hot}} + \Delta S_{\text{cold}} = +0.167\text{ J/K}.

02

A system receives 50 J50\text{ J} of heat from a source at TH=500 KT_H = 500\text{ K} across a small temperature drop ΔT=2 K\Delta T = 2\text{ K}. Use the first-order approximation dSuniv≈dQΔTTH2d S_{\text{univ}} \approx dQ\frac{\Delta T}{T_H^2} to estimate the entropy generated, and compare it with the exact value.

Answer

Approximation: ΔSuniv≈5025002=100250000=4.00×10−4 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} \approx 50\frac{2}{500^2} = \frac{100}{250000} = 4.00 \times 10^{-4}\text{ J/K}. Exact: ΔSuniv=50(1498−1500)=100249000≈4.016×10−4 J/K\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = 50\left(\frac{1}{498} - \frac{1}{500}\right) = \frac{100}{249000} \approx 4.016 \times 10^{-4}\text{ J/K}. The approximation matches within 0.4%0.4\%.

03

An engineer claims that transferring dQdQ from a colder body at TCT_C to a hotter body at THT_H generates entropy ΔSuniv=dQ(1TH−1TC)>0\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\left(\frac{1}{T_H} - \frac{1}{T_C}\right) > 0. Identify the physical and mathematical error in this claim.

Answer

If heat leaves TCT_C and enters THT_H, then ΔScold=−dQTC\Delta S_{\text{cold}} = -\frac{dQ}{T_C} and ΔShot=+dQTH\Delta S_{\text{hot}} = +\frac{dQ}{T_H}, so ΔSuniv=dQ(1TH−1TC)\Delta S_{\text{univ}} = dQ\left(\frac{1}{T_H} - \frac{1}{T_C}\right). However, since TH>TCT_H > T_C, 1TH<1TC\frac{1}{T_H} < \frac{1}{T_C}, making ΔSuniv<0\Delta S_{\text{univ}} < 0. This violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics; heat cannot flow spontaneously from cold to hot without external work.

Loading workspace…