Resources
A charged dust grain carrying net charge with mass is launched with an initial velocity into a region with a uniform electric field and a uniform magnetic field . (a) Using the Lorentz force law , verify that the SI units of and are identical and both reduce to Newtons (). (b) Calculate the total instantaneous acceleration vector of the grain, specifying both its Cartesian components and its net direction in the -plane.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) and ; (b) , pointing along the negative -direction (direction angle ).
Steps
Electric Force Component ()
Part (a): Dimensional Verification of the Lorentz Force Terms
The Lorentz force acting on a particle with charge moving with velocity in an electric field and magnetic field is: To verify that both terms have identical SI units of Newtons ():
- Electric Force Term ():
- The SI unit of charge is Coulombs ().
- The SI unit of electric field is Newtons per Coulomb ().
- Magnetic Force Term ():
- The SI unit of velocity is meters per second ().
- The SI unit of magnetic field is the Tesla (), defined from the magnetic force equation or as:
- Substituting the base and derived units: Both terms evaluate directly to Newtons (), confirming dimensional homogeneity.
Part (b): Calculation of Instantaneous Acceleration
Magnetic Force Component ()
The magnitude of the magnetic interaction is:
Combining the component forces acting in the -direction:
Instantaneous Acceleration Vector ()
Using Newton's second law, , and applying the mass of the grain converted to standard SI mass units ():
Direction in the -Plane
The acceleration vector has no - or -component (, ) and a strictly negative -component (). Therefore:
- The acceleration vector points directly along the negative -direction ().
- Measured counterclockwise from the positive -axis, the direction angle is:
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the cross product unit vector relation i × k = -j with +j, resulting in an erroneous total electric-plus-magnetic field factor and an incorrect acceleration magnitude.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Unit of : Unit of :
- Step 2
= (4.00 10^3,) (0.250,) = +1.00 10^3,\hat{j}$$\text{ N/C} + = 6.00 10^2, + 1.00 10^3, = 1.60 10^3,\hat{j}$$\text{ N/C}
Correct= (4.00 10^3,) (0.250,) = -(1.00 10^3,) + = 6.00 10^2, - 1.00 10^3, = -(4.00 10^2,)
In a standard right-handed Cartesian coordinate system, the unit vector cross product satisfies , not . Because of this sign swap, you added the magnetic term to the electric field instead of subtracting it.
- Step 3
= (-3.20 10^{-16})(1.60 10^3,) = -5.12 10^{-13},\hat{j}$$\text{ N} = = = -0.213,\hat{j}$$\text{ m/s}^2 y
Correct= (-3.20 10^{-16})(-(4.00 10^2,)) = +(1.28 10^{-13},) = = +(5.33 10^{-2},)^2 +
You correctly applied Newton's second law and handled the negative charge multiplication consistently, but the final value and direction are affected by the earlier cross product sign error.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou performed complete and rigorous dimensional verification of the Tesla and electric field units in part (a).
You correctly combined the electric and magnetic forces using the factorized Lorentz force law .
You properly accounted for the particle's negative sign when calculating net force from the effective field.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou evaluated as instead of .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing cyclic order in the cross product of Cartesian unit vectors. Following cyclic order yields positive products (e.g., ), whereas going against the cycle reverses the sign ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Cyclic Order Rule for Unit Vectors
In a right-handed basis: , , and . Reversing order negates the result.
Draw a small clock face with clockwise. Clockwise products are positive; counter-clockwise products get an explicit negative sign.
- Right-Hand Rule Check
Point the index finger of your right hand along () and middle finger along ().
Your outstretched thumb points along (). Verify this direction before multiplying by charge .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationEvaluate the vector cross product: .
Compute the effective field: .
Determine the Lorentz force: .
Calculate instantaneous acceleration: .
, pointing along the positive -direction (direction angle )
02 The student forgets to apply the negative sign of the net charge q when computing the force from the electric plus magnetic field, inverting the direction of the final acceleration vector.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
qE: / = q(v B): (/) = ,; (/) =
- Step 2
= (4.00 10^3,) (0.250,) = -1.00 10^3,\hat{j}$$\text{ N/C} + = 6.00 10^2, - 1.00 10^3, = -4.00 10^2,\hat{j}$$\text{ N/C}
- Step 3
= q( + ) = (3.20 10^{-16})(-4.00 10^2,) = -1.28 10^{-13},$\hat{j}
Correct= q( + ) = (-3.20 10^{-16})(-4.00 10^2,\hat{j}$$\text{ N/C}) = +(1.28 10^{-13},)$\text{ N}$$
You omitted the negative sign of the charge . Because the combined field vector is negative, multiplying by a negative charge yields a positive force vector.
- Step 4
= = = -5.33 10^{-2},\hat{j}$$\text{ m}/^2-y$\text{ direction}$$
Correct= = = +(5.33 10^{-2},)/^2+y
Your division by mass and direction interpretation were carried out correctly, but the resulting sign and direction are reversed due to the dropped negative sign in Step 3.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly expressed magnetic field units in base mechanical units to verify dimensional consistency.
You correctly evaluated the vector cross product .
You correctly summed the electric and velocity-magnetic cross product terms.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou dropped the negative sign when substituting into .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating charge as an unsigned scalar magnitude rather than a signed physical quantity in vector equations reverses the resulting vector direction whenever the charge is negative.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Substitute Signed Charge
In vector force laws like and , always preserve the algebraic sign of .
Write with explicit parentheses so that negative signs distribute properly across vector components.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubstitute and : .
Divide by mass : .
Identify net orientation: The acceleration points strictly along the positive -axis (, or direction angle ).
(a) Dimensional verification shown; (b) , pointing along the positive -direction (direction angle ).
03 The student equates Tesla directly to N/(C · m) by forgetting the time factor in the definition of ampere, concluding that the unit is N/s rather than N.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You treated the Tesla as instead of . Since electric current is charge per unit time (), the Tesla is equivalent to , which cancels the seconds from velocity to leave Newtons.
- Step 3
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly verified the units of the electric force term .
You evaluated the cross product and its vector direction correctly.
You properly handled the negative charge sign when calculating the net Lorentz force vector.
You correctly divided the net force by the given mass to obtain the acceleration vector.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted Coulombs directly in place of Amperes in the definition of the Tesla.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the magnetic field unit (Tesla) as force per unit charge per meter rather than force per unit current per meter (), omitting the factor of seconds from .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define Magnetic Field from Force Relations
From or , , so .
Whenever decomposing a Tesla, recall that current has units of , giving .
- Check Dimensional Homogeneity of Added Terms
In the Lorentz force , both terms must have identical units of force ().
If your dimensional check yields for a force term, immediately inspect where a factor of time was lost.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationExpress the Tesla using the magnetic force equation : .
Substitute into the magnetic force term: .
Cancel identical units: Coulombs (), meters (), and seconds () cancel out, leaving exactly .
Lock it in
What is the cross product in a right-handed Cartesian coordinate system?
. Moving against cyclic order () introduces a negative sign.
Similar question
A particle with charge moves with velocity in a magnetic field . Calculate the magnetic force vector .
Answer
. Key step: , then .
An electron () has velocity in a region with and . Find the net Lorentz force vector .
Answer
. Key steps: . Effective field . Force .
A dust particle carrying with mass moves with velocity into fields and . Determine its instantaneous acceleration vector .
Answer
. Key steps: . Effective field . Net force . Acceleration .