Resources

An organ pipe of physical length L=0.850 mL = 0.850\text{ m} is open at one end and closed at the other. When driven by an acoustic transducer at a speed of sound of v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s}, it resonates in its third harmonic mode (the second resonant mode above fundamental). Determine the exact locations of all displacement nodes measured along the central axis of the pipe starting from the closed end at x=0x = 0, and find the fundamental frequency f1f_1 of this pipe.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Displacement nodes at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=0.567 mx = 0.567\text{ m}; Fundamental frequency: f1=100 Hzf_1 = 100\text{ Hz}

Steps

01

Fundamental Frequency of a Pipe Closed at One End

For an organ pipe of length LL that is closed at one end and open at the other, the boundary conditions require:

  • A displacement node (zero air displacement) at the closed end (x=0x = 0).
  • A displacement antinode (maximum air displacement) at the open end (x=Lx = L).

The longest possible standing wave (the fundamental mode, n=1n = 1) spans one-quarter of a wavelength inside the pipe: L=λ14  ⟹  λ1=4LL = \frac{\lambda_1}{4} \implies \lambda_1 = 4L

Using the wave speed relationship v=fλv = f \lambda, the fundamental frequency f1f_1 is: f1=vλ1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{\lambda_1} = \frac{v}{4L}

Substitute the given values v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s} and L=0.850 mL = 0.850\text{ m}: f1=340 m/s4⋅0.850 m=3403.40=100 Hzf_1 = \frac{340\text{ m/s}}{4 \cdot 0.850\text{ m}} = \frac{340}{3.40} = 100\text{ Hz}


02

Properties of the Third Harmonic Mode

For a pipe closed at one end, only odd harmonics exist (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots). The third harmonic corresponds to n=3n = 3.

The wavelength λ3\lambda_3 for this mode is given by: L=3λ34  ⟹  λ3=4L3L = \frac{3\lambda_3}{4} \implies \lambda_3 = \frac{4L}{3}

Substituting L=0.850 mL = 0.850\text{ m}: λ3=4⋅0.850 m3=3.403 m≈1.133 m\lambda_3 = \frac{4 \cdot 0.850\text{ m}}{3} = \frac{3.40}{3}\text{ m} \approx 1.133\text{ m}


03

Locating the Displacement Nodes

The displacement standing wave function along the central axis of the pipe can be written as: s(x,t)=Asin⁡(kx)cos⁡(ωt)s(x, t) = A \sin(kx) \cos(\omega t)

where the wave number is: k=2πλ3=2π4L3=3π2Lk = \frac{2\pi}{\lambda_3} = \frac{2\pi}{\frac{4L}{3}} = \frac{3\pi}{2L}

Displacement nodes occur where the spatial amplitude is zero: sin⁡(kx)=0  ⟹  kx=mπ(m=0,1,2,… )\sin(kx) = 0 \implies kx = m\pi \quad (m = 0, 1, 2, \dots)

Solving for xx: x=mπk=m⋅λ32=m(2L3)x = \frac{m\pi}{k} = m \cdot \frac{\lambda_3}{2} = m \left(\frac{2L}{3}\right)

Now, determine all values of xx lying within the physical pipe length 0≤x≤L=0.850 m0 \le x \le L = 0.850\text{ m}:

  • For m=0m = 0: x0=0 mx_0 = 0\text{ m}
  • For m=1m = 1: x1=2(0.850 m)3=1.7003 m≈0.567 mx_1 = \frac{2(0.850\text{ m})}{3} = \frac{1.700}{3}\text{ m} \approx 0.567\text{ m}
  • For m=2m = 2: x2=4(0.850 m)3≈1.133 m>L(outside the pipe)x_2 = \frac{4(0.850\text{ m})}{3} \approx 1.133\text{ m} > L \quad (\text{outside the pipe})

(Pitfall note: Be careful not to confuse displacement nodes with pressure nodes. A displacement node corresponds to a pressure antinode, and displacement antinodes occur at odd quarter-wavelength multiples, such as the open end at x=Lx = L.)

Thus, the displacement nodes inside the pipe are located at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=0.567 mx = 0.567\text{ m}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats the pipe as open at both ends (or closed at both ends) using λ_n = 2L/n, resulting in incorrect node locations and fundamental frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    For third harmonic, L=3(λ2)  ⟹  λ=2L3=2(0.850)3=0.567 mL = 3\left(\frac{\lambda}{2}\right) \implies \lambda = \frac{2L}{3} = \frac{2(0.850)}{3} = 0.567\text{ m}

    Correct

    L=3λ34  ⟹  λ3=4L3=4(0.850 m)3≈1.133 mL = \frac{3\lambda_3}{4} \implies \lambda_3 = \frac{4L}{3} = \frac{4(0.850\text{ m})}{3} \approx 1.133\text{ m}

    A pipe closed at one end and open at the other requires a displacement node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end. The resonant lengths must be odd multiples of quarter wavelengths: L=nλ4L = \frac{n\lambda}{4} with n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots, so for the third harmonic (n=3n = 3), L=3λ4L = \frac{3\lambda}{4}.

  2. Step 2

    Nodes occur at intervals of λ/2\lambda/2 starting from x=0  ⟹  x=0 m,  0.283 m,  0.567 mx=0 \implies x = 0\text{ m},\; 0.283\text{ m},\; 0.567\text{ m}

    Correct

    x=m(λ32)=m(2L3)  ⟹  x=0 m,  0.567 mx = m\left(\frac{\lambda_3}{2}\right) = m\left(\frac{2L}{3}\right) \implies x = 0\text{ m},\; 0.567\text{ m}

    Your reasoning that displacement nodes are separated by λ2\frac{\lambda}{2} starting from the closed end is conceptually sound, but using the incorrect wavelength λ=0.567 m\lambda = 0.567\text{ m} produced an extra node at 0.283 m0.283\text{ m}. With λ3≈1.133 m\lambda_3 \approx 1.133\text{ m}, the nodes within the pipe are at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=λ32≈0.567 mx = \frac{\lambda_3}{2} \approx 0.567\text{ m}.

  3. Step 3

    f_1 = v2L\frac{v}{2L}   ⟹  \implies f_1 = 3402×0.850\frac{340}{2 \times 0.850} = 200 Hz\text{ Hz}$

    Correct

    f_1 = v4L\frac{v}{4L} = 340 m/s4(0.850 m)\frac{340\text{ m/s}}{4(0.850\text{ m})} = 100 Hz\text{ Hz}$

    Because the pipe has one open end and one closed end, the fundamental standing wave spans one quarter of a wavelength (L=λ14L = \frac{\lambda_1}{4}), which makes the fundamental frequency f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} rather than v2L\frac{v}{2L}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that the closed end at x=0x = 0 is a displacement node.

You correctly identified that consecutive displacement nodes are separated by half a wavelength (λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}).

You carried out all numerical divisions and substitutions accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Boundary Condition Misidentification

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the half-wave harmonic model λn=2Ln\lambda_n = \frac{2L}{n} and f1=v2Lf_1 = \frac{v}{2L} valid for symmetric pipes (open-open or closed-closed), overlooking the quarter-wave condition L=nλ4L = \frac{n\lambda}{4} (with n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots) required for an open-closed pipe.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Pipe Boundary Types
  • An open end forms a displacement antinode; a closed end forms a displacement node.

  • Always sketch the boundary ends before writing equations: closed-closed or open-open pipes have L=nλ2L = \frac{n\lambda}{2}, whereas closed-open pipes have L=nλ4L = \frac{n\lambda}{4} for odd integers nn.

Fundamental Frequency Relation
  • For a pipe closed at one end of length LL, λ1=4L  ⟹  f1=v4L\lambda_1 = 4L \implies f_1 = \frac{v}{4L}.

  • Check whether the factor in the denominator should be 2L2L (symmetric boundaries) or 4L4L (mixed boundaries).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the open-closed boundary condition for the third harmonic: L=3λ34L = \frac{3\lambda_3}{4}.

  2. Solve for the wavelength: λ3=4L3=4(0.850 m)3=1.133 m\lambda_3 = \frac{4L}{3} = \frac{4(0.850\text{ m})}{3} = 1.133\text{ m}.

  3. Place displacement nodes at intervals of λ32=0.567 m\frac{\lambda_3}{2} = 0.567\text{ m} starting from x=0x = 0, giving x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=0.567 mx = 0.567\text{ m} inside the pipe of length 0.850 m0.850\text{ m}.

  4. Compute the fundamental frequency using the quarter-wave condition: f1=v4L=340 m/s4(0.850 m)=100 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{340\text{ m/s}}{4(0.850\text{ m})} = 100\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

Displacement nodes at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=0.567 mx = 0.567\text{ m}; Fundamental frequency: f1=100 Hzf_1 = 100\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the boundary condition differences between open-open, closed-closed, and open-closed resonant tubes.

  • Practice drawing displacement standing wave envelopes to visually confirm the number of quarter-wavelength segments fitting into length LL.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misinterprets the third harmonic as the mode with n = 5 because the problem notes it is the second resonant mode above the fundamental, using n = 5 instead of n = 3.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Second resonant mode above fundamental has n=5  ⟹  L=5λ4  ⟹  λ=4L5=4(0.850)5=0.680 mn = 5 \implies L = \frac{5\lambda}{4} \implies \lambda = \frac{4L}{5} = \frac{4(0.850)}{5} = 0.680\text{ m}

    Correct

    The third harmonic corresponds to n=3n = 3: L=3λ34  ⟹  λ3=4L3=4(0.850 m)3≈1.133 mL = \frac{3\lambda_3}{4} \implies \lambda_3 = \frac{4L}{3} = \frac{4(0.850\text{ m})}{3} \approx 1.133\text{ m}

    In an organ pipe closed at one end and open at the other, only odd harmonics exist. The harmonic number is the multiplier of the fundamental frequency: the fundamental is n=1n = 1, the first overtone is the third harmonic (n=3n = 3), and the second overtone is the fifth harmonic (n=5n = 5). Because the problem specifies the third harmonic, you should use n=3n = 3 rather than n=5n = 5.

  2. Step 2

    Nodes are at x=0,λ/2,λx = 0, \lambda/2, \lambda: x=0 m,0.340 m,0.680 mx = 0\text{ m}, 0.340\text{ m}, 0.680\text{ m}

    Correct

    x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=λ32=1.133 m2≈0.567 mx = \frac{\lambda_3}{2} = \frac{1.133\text{ m}}{2} \approx 0.567\text{ m}

    Your method of finding displacement nodes at integer multiples of half-wavelengths starting from the closed end was logically sound, but the values are shifted because they were calculated using the wavelength for n=5n = 5 instead of n=3n = 3.

  3. Step 3

    f1=v4L  ⟹  f1=3404×0.850=100 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} \implies f_1 = \frac{340}{4 \times 0.850} = 100\text{ Hz}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the boundary conditions that give f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} for a pipe closed at one end.

You accurately calculated the fundamental frequency to be 100 Hz100\text{ Hz}.

You correctly knew that displacement nodes are separated by half-wavelength increments starting from the closed end at x=0x = 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Harmonic number vs. overtone confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the harmonic number nn with the overtone count. In asymmetric pipes (closed at one end, open at the other), only odd harmonics exist (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots). The third harmonic specifically corresponds to n=3n = 3 (the first overtone), whereas n=5n = 5 is the fifth harmonic (the second overtone).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Harmonic Number vs. Overtone Index
  • For a pipe closed at one end, the mm-th overtone has harmonic number n=2m+1n = 2m + 1. The kk-th harmonic always has n=kn = k.

  • Always let the harmonic name set the value of nn: the third harmonic means n=3n = 3, giving f3=3f1f_3 = 3f_1 and λ3=4L3\lambda_3 = \frac{4L}{3}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set n=3n = 3 for the third harmonic: L=3λ34  ⟹  λ3=4(0.850 m)3=3.403 m≈1.133 mL = \frac{3\lambda_3}{4} \implies \lambda_3 = \frac{4(0.850\text{ m})}{3} = \frac{3.40}{3}\text{ m} \approx 1.133\text{ m}.

  2. Displacement nodes occur at intervals of λ32=1.703 m≈0.567 m\frac{\lambda_3}{2} = \frac{1.70}{3}\text{ m} \approx 0.567\text{ m}, beginning at the closed boundary x=0 mx = 0\text{ m}.

  3. List all nodes within the pipe length 0≤x≤0.850 m0 \le x \le 0.850\text{ m}: x0=0 mx_0 = 0\text{ m} and x1≈0.567 mx_1 \approx 0.567\text{ m}.

Final answer

Displacement nodes at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=0.567 mx = 0.567\text{ m}; Fundamental frequency: f1=100 Hzf_1 = 100\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between harmonic number nn (fn=nf1f_n = n f_1) and overtone index for systems that only support odd harmonics.

  • Practice drawing displacement standing wave diagrams for pipes closed at one end to quickly verify node counts.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student locates pressure nodes (displacement antinodes) instead of displacement nodes, placing the first node at an antinode position rather than at the closed end.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ=4L3=4(0.850)3=1.133 m\lambda = \frac{4L}{3} = \frac{4(0.850)}{3} = 1.133\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    Nodes occur at \text{Nodes occur at } λ4\frac{\lambda}{4}, 3λ4\frac{3\lambda}{4}  from closed end\text{ from closed end}   ⟹  \implies x = 1.1334\frac{1.133}{4} = 0.283 m\text{ m}  and \text{ and } x = 3(1.133)4\frac{3(1.133)}{4} = 0.850 m\text{ m}

    Correct

    x = 0 m\text{ m}  and \text{ and } x = λ32\frac{\lambda_3}{2} = 2L3\frac{2L}{3} ≈\approx 0.567 m\text{ m}

    At a closed end, air molecules cannot move, which forces a displacement node at x=0x = 0. Subsequent displacement nodes occur at half-wavelength increments (x=0x = 0 and x=λ2=0.567 mx = \frac{\lambda}{2} = 0.567\text{ m}). The locations λ4\frac{\lambda}{4} and 3λ4\frac{3\lambda}{4} are displacement antinodes (or pressure nodes).

  3. Step 3

    f_1 = v4L\frac{v}{4L} = 3404×0.850\frac{340}{4 \times 0.850} = 100 Hz\text{ Hz}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the quarter-wave relationship to find the wavelength of the third harmonic.

You calculated the fundamental frequency accurately using the wave speed and pipe length.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Node/Antinode Confusion

You identified the positions of displacement antinodes instead of displacement nodes.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You mixed up displacement boundary conditions with pressure boundary conditions. A rigid boundary (the closed end) prevents air motion, creating a displacement node at x=0x = 0, while the open end allows maximum motion, creating a displacement antinode at x=Lx = L.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Closed vs. Open End Boundary Conditions
  • For displacement waves, a closed boundary is always a node (s=0s = 0), and an open boundary is always an antinode (s=maxs = \text{max}).

  • Always begin displacement node spacing from x=0x = 0 when measuring from a closed end.

Spacing Between Consecutive Nodes
  • Adjacent nodes of the same quantity (displacement to displacement) are separated by λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}, never λ4\frac{\lambda}{4}.

  • Add integer multiples of λ2\frac{\lambda}{2} to the initial node location at x=0x = 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the first displacement node at the closed end: x0=0 mx_0 = 0\text{ m}.

  2. Find the next node by adding half a wavelength: x1=0+λ32=1.133 m2≈0.567 mx_1 = 0 + \frac{\lambda_3}{2} = \frac{1.133\text{ m}}{2} \approx 0.567\text{ m}.

  3. Check the next node: x2=0.567 m+0.567 m=1.133 m>Lx_2 = 0.567\text{ m} + 0.567\text{ m} = 1.133\text{ m} > L, which lies outside the pipe.

Final answer

Displacement nodes at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} and x=0.567 mx = 0.567\text{ m}; Fundamental frequency: f1=100 Hzf_1 = 100\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the standing wave envelope inside the pipe before calculating positions to visually confirm where nodes and antinodes lie.

  • Label whether a question asks for displacement or pressure nodes, remembering they are spatial complements separated by λ4\frac{\lambda}{4}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cylindrical tube of length L=1.20 mL = 1.20\text{ m} is closed at one end and open at the other. If the speed of sound is v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s}, calculate its fundamental frequency f1f_1 and the frequency of its next resonant mode (the third harmonic).

Answer

f1=70.8 Hzf_1 = 70.8\text{ Hz} and f3=212.5 Hzf_3 = 212.5\text{ Hz}. Key steps: f1=v4L=3404(1.20)=70.83 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{340}{4(1.20)} = 70.83\text{ Hz}; since only odd harmonics exist, the next mode is n=3n=3, so f3=3f1=3(70.83 Hz)=212.5 Hzf_3 = 3 f_1 = 3(70.83\text{ Hz}) = 212.5\text{ Hz}.

02

An organ pipe closed at one end has length L=0.750 mL = 0.750\text{ m}. It vibrates in its fifth harmonic mode (n=5n = 5). Find the wavelength λ5\lambda_5 and list the positions of all displacement antinodes measured from the closed end at x=0x = 0.

Answer

λ5=0.600 m\lambda_5 = 0.600\text{ m}; antinodes at x=0.150 mx = 0.150\text{ m}, 0.450 m0.450\text{ m}, and 0.750 m0.750\text{ m}. Key steps: L=5λ54  ⟹  λ5=4(0.750)5=0.600 mL = \frac{5\lambda_5}{4} \implies \lambda_5 = \frac{4(0.750)}{5} = 0.600\text{ m}. Displacement antinodes occur at odd quarter-wavelengths from the closed end: x=(2m+1)λ54=(2m+1)(0.150 m)x = (2m+1)\frac{\lambda_5}{4} = (2m+1)(0.150\text{ m}) for m=0,1,2m = 0, 1, 2.

03

A pipe of unknown length is driven into resonance. When both ends are open, its fundamental frequency is 300 Hz300\text{ Hz}. If one end is now tightly capped while the other remains open, what are the new fundamental frequency and the frequency of the first overtone (second resonant mode)?

Answer

New f1=150 Hzf_1 = 150\text{ Hz} and first overtone f3=450 Hzf_3 = 450\text{ Hz}. Key steps: For open-open, fopen=v2L=300 Hzf_{\text{open}} = \frac{v}{2L} = 300\text{ Hz}. Capping one end gives f1=v4L=12fopen=150 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{1}{2} f_{\text{open}} = 150\text{ Hz}. The first overtone for an open-closed tube is the third harmonic: f3=3f1=3(150 Hz)=450 Hzf_3 = 3 f_1 = 3(150\text{ Hz}) = 450\text{ Hz}.

Loading workspace…