Resources
Two infinitely long parallel wires are parallel to the -axis. Wire A is fixed at and carries current in the -direction. Wire B is fixed at , where , and carries current in the -direction. (a) Locate the exact coordinate along the -axis where a magnetic neutral point (a topological boundary where magnetic field lines cannot cross and ) occurs. (b) Explain why no neutral point exists in the interior interval , and determine the net field magnitude at the midpoint .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) (i.e., at ); (b) In the interior , both wires generate magnetic fields pointing in the same direction (), preventing destructive cancellation; at the origin , in the direction.
Steps
Part (a): Locating the Magnetic Neutral Point
-
Identify the Field Directions in Each Region Along the -Axis
- Wire A is located at carrying current in the -direction.
- Wire B is located at carrying current in the -direction.
- For a neutral point () to exist along the line connecting the wires, the magnetic field vectors produced by the two wires must point in opposite directions:
- For : Any point is closer to Wire A than to Wire B. Since , the field from Wire A dominates everywhere in this region, so the fields cannot cancel.
- For : The fields point in the same direction (as shown in Part (b)), preventing cancellation.
- For : The point is farther from the stronger wire () and closer to the weaker wire (). Here, the fields point in opposite directions ( from Wire A and from Wire B), allowing destructive cancellation.
-
Set Up the Distance Relations Let be the coordinate of the neutral point, with :
- Distance from Wire A:
- Distance from Wire B:
-
Determine the Neutral Point Coordinate Equating the source field strengths yields the distance scaling relation:
Substitute the given currents and :
Cross-multiply and solve for :
With :
Therefore, the neutral point is at the coordinate .
Part (b): Analysis of the Interior Interval and Field at the Midpoint
-
Why No Neutral Point Exists for
- By the right-hand rule, the current in the -direction creates a magnetic field circulating such that everywhere along the segment between the wires (to the right of Wire A), points in the direction.
- The current in the -direction creates an oppositely circulating magnetic field such that everywhere to the left of Wire B, also points in the direction.
- Because both contributions are parallel () and point in the direction throughout , they reinforce each other constructively: Hence, no neutral point can exist in the interior interval.
-
Net Magnetic Field at the Midpoint At the origin, the distance to each wire is . Using the magnetic field formula for an infinitely long straight wire, :
- Field due to Wire A:
- Field due to Wire B:
- Net field magnitude and direction:
In vector form, the net magnetic field is:
Typical errors
01 The student assumes the neutral point lies between the two wires by incorrectly treating antiparallel currents as producing opposing fields in the interior region.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
, Set :
Correctfor
You assumed the neutral point lies in the interior interval . However, between two opposite (antiparallel) currents, both magnetic field vectors point in the same direction and reinforce each other. Opposing fields only occur outside the wires, and because , the fields can only balance where the point is farther from Wire A and closer to Wire B, which requires .
- Step 2
Between the wires, the fields point in opposite directions, so they cancel at .
CorrectIn , the field from Wire A () and the field from Wire B () both point in the same direction along the -axis, preventing destructive cancellation.
You concluded that the fields oppose each other between the wires. Using the right-hand rule, pointing your thumb along for Wire A gives a field pointing along (or ) to its right, and pointing your thumb along for Wire B gives a field circulating in the same direction to its left. Because both contributions are parallel, anywhere between the wires.
- Step 3Correct
Because both magnetic field vectors point in the same direction at the midpoint, their magnitudes add constructively rather than subtract.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled and applied the formula for the magnetic field of an infinitely long straight wire, .
You solved the algebraic linear equation accurately based on your initial setup.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the field geometry of parallel currents with that of antiparallel currents. Parallel currents produce opposing magnetic fields between them, whereas antiparallel currents produce fields that point in the same direction between them and oppose each other only in the exterior regions.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Right-Hand Rule for Antiparallel Wires
Point your right thumb along the current direction; your curled fingers show the circular magnetic field lines. For antiparallel currents, both sets of field lines point in the same direction in the space between the wires.
Always sketch the circular field vectors and explicitly at candidate test points before writing down distance equations.
- Locating Neutral Points
A neutral point requires , which means the fields must be equal in magnitude and opposite in direction. Cancellation requires being closer to the weaker current and farther from the stronger current in a region where the vectors point in opposite directions.
Check that your candidate region has opposing vectors, and place the neutral point on the side of the smaller current ( when ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the region where the vectors point in opposite directions: for antiparallel currents, this occurs for and .
Since , the neutral point must lie closer to Wire B, so .
Express the distances from each wire: and .
Set the magnitudes equal: .
Cross-multiply and solve: .
(a) ; (b) No neutral point exists for because both fields point in the same direction; at the origin, .
02 The student misidentifies the distances from the wires to an exterior point x > a as (x - a) and (x + a) inverted, or sets the distance from wire A as x instead of x + a.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
For , distance to wire B is and distance to wire A is ⟹ ⟹
CorrectFor , distance to Wire B is and distance to Wire A is ⟹
Wire A is positioned at the coordinate , not at the origin . Therefore, the geometric distance from Wire A to an exterior point on the positive axis is .
- Step 2Correct
Your algebraic steps were executed consistently, but the result was altered by the incorrect distance expression from Step 1.
- Step 3
Between the wires, wire A produces field in and wire B produces field in , so both point in and cannot cancel.
- Step 4
At , both fields add along :
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the neutral point must lie in the exterior region where the fields oppose each other.
You properly equated the magnitudes of the magnetic fields to set up the balance condition.
You clearly reasoned that fields pointing in the same direction cannot produce a neutral point in the interior region.
You correctly calculated the net magnetic field magnitude at the midpoint.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the position of Wire A as the origin instead of when writing its distance to the field point.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing a point's spatial coordinate with the physical geometric distance from a source not located at the origin.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distance from Coordinate
For a source located at coordinate , the distance to any point along the axis is .
Always write down explicitly before substituting into field formulas.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationExpress the distance from Wire A at to point as .
Equate the magnetic field magnitudes: .
Simplify the ratio using and : .
Solve for : (Wait, solving gives , but let's recheck: , cross-multiplied gives , which yields ; note that if , , so , ).
(or if using square-root scaling)
03 The student forgets the factor of 2π in the denominator of the magnetic field formula of a long wire, treating the field as μ₀I / r.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You correctly determined that the fields from the two wires point in opposite directions when . However, the formula for the magnetic field of an infinitely long straight wire has in the denominator from Ampère's law, not just .
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Because you wrote instead of , your result is larger than the true value by a factor of . Dividing your result by yields the correct field magnitude of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the magnetic fields oppose each other outside the wires () and reinforce each other between the wires ().
You accurately solved the linear distance relation to find the coordinate of the neutral point.
You correctly recognized that the net field at the midpoint is the sum of the individual field magnitudes.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote the magnetic field of a long straight wire as rather than , omitting the cylindrical circumference factor .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the magnetic field formula of an infinitely long straight wire (, derived from Ampère's law around a circular path of length ) with expressions that lack , or treating simply as .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ampère's Law Derivation Check
For an infinitely long wire, .
Always recall that the circular loop around the wire has circumference , which must appear in the denominator.
- Numerical Constant Shortcut
Since , the fraction .
Use directly in calculations to avoid forgetting the factor of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the correct field superposition at : .
Substitute the given values and :
Lock it in
Do two parallel wires carrying currents in opposite directions (antiparallel) produce opposing or reinforcing magnetic fields between them?
They produce reinforcing magnetic fields pointing in the same direction; field cancellation can only happen in the exterior regions.
Similar question
Two parallel wires separated by carry currents (along ) at and (along ) at . Find the coordinate along the -axis where the net magnetic field is zero.
Answer
. Since the currents are antiparallel and , the neutral point lies in . Setting gives from the origin? Re-evaluating: measured from the origin (or to the right of wire 2).
Two parallel wires carry equal currents in opposite directions and are separated by . Can a point with exist anywhere at a finite distance from the wires? Explain briefly.
Answer
No. Between the wires, both fields point in the same direction and reinforce. Outside the wires, the fields point in opposite directions, but any finite point is strictly closer to one wire than the other; since , the field of the nearer wire always has a strictly greater magnitude, preventing cancellation.
Wire 1 carries current along at . Wire 2 carries current along at . (a) Locate the neutral point on the -axis. (b) Calculate the net field vector at the midpoint .
Answer
(a) . For , . (b) (or pointing along depending on axis orientation), since both fields reinforce: .