Resources
A glass lens with refractive index is coated with a uniform thin film of magnesium fluoride (, refractive index ) to minimize reflections for normal-incidence green light with vacuum wavelength . The lens is surrounded by air (). (a) Explicitly identify the phase change upon reflection at the air-film boundary and at the film-glass boundary, and state whether the effective net phase difference between the two reflections is or . (b) Calculate the minimum non-zero physical thickness of the coating required for destructive interference in reflection. (c) If this exact same coated lens is subsequently immersed in a specialized optical immersion oil of refractive index , determine whether reflection of the light is now constructively or destructively reinforced at normal incidence.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) phase shift at both interfaces, yielding a net reflective phase difference of ; (b) ; (c) Constructively reinforced (bright reflection)
Steps
Part (a): Phase Changes upon Reflection
When light in a medium of refractive index reflects off an interface with a medium of refractive index :
- If (reflection off an optically denser medium), the reflected wave undergoes a phase inversion of (equivalent to a path shift of ).
- If (reflection off an optically less dense medium), there is no phase change ().
- Air-to-film interface:
Light travels from air () to the magnesium fluoride film (). Since , the phase shift upon reflection is: - Film-to-glass interface:
Light travels within the film () and reflects off the glass substrate (). Since , the phase shift upon reflection is: - Net reflective phase difference:
Because both rays undergo identical phase shifts of , the net phase difference arising solely from reflection is:
Part (b): Minimum Film Thickness for Destructive Interference
For normal incidence, the optical path difference between the wave reflected from the front surface and the wave reflected from the back surface is:
Since the net reflection phase shift is , destructive interference occurs when the round-trip path difference corresponds to an odd half-integral number of wavelengths in vacuum:
To find the minimum non-zero thickness , select the smallest mode integer :
Substitute the given values:
Part (c): Coated Lens Immersed in Immersion Oil ()
Now, the surrounding medium is optical oil ():
- Oil-to-film interface:
Light travels from oil () to the film (). Since , reflection occurs from a medium of lower refractive index, resulting in: - Film-to-glass interface:
Light reflects at the boundary between the film () and the glass (). Since , the phase shift remains: - Net reflective phase difference:
- Total phase difference:
The round-trip path through the coating still introduces a phase shift of: Combining the path-length phase difference with the reflection phase difference gives:
An overall phase difference of (or an integer multiple of ) satisfies the condition for constructive interference. Therefore, the reflection of light is now constructively reinforced (bright reflection).
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that the wavelength inside the film is reduced by the refractive index of the film and incorrectly uses the vacuum wavelength in the path condition.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Air-film: increases ( to ), phase change = Film-glass: increases ( to ), phase change = Net reflection phase difference =
- Step 2Correct
You omitted the refractive index of the film in the optical path condition. Light travels inside the film where the wavelength is compressed to , making the optical path difference .
- Step 3
In oil: , phase change at first surface = Second surface: , phase change = Reflection phase difference is , so condition flips to constructive interference
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the boundary phase shifts using the relative values of refractive indices.
You correctly concluded that identical phase shifts at both interfaces produce a net reflective phase difference of zero.
You correctly reasoned that changing the ambient medium alters the reflection shift at the first boundary and flips the overall interference condition.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou used the geometric round-trip distance with the vacuum wavelength instead of the optical path difference (or equivalently, using the reduced wavelength inside the medium).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Optical Path vs. Geometric Path
The optical path difference (OPD) through a medium of thickness and refractive index at normal incidence is .
Always multiply the physical round-trip thickness by the refractive index of the thin-film layer when equating to wavelength conditions in terms of .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the destructive interference condition using the optical path difference: .
Isolate physical thickness: .
Substitute the given numbers: .
t_{\min} 99.6_
02 The student misapplies the destructive interference condition by assuming path length 2 n_f t must equal a full wavelength rather than a half-wavelength.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Air to film: phase shift = ⟹ Film to glass: phase shift = ⟹ Net phase difference from reflection =
- Step 2Correct
Because the net phase shift from reflection is , destructive interference requires the round-trip optical path difference to contribute an odd half-integral wavelength shift . For the minimum non-zero thickness (), , not .
- Step 3
In oil, giving phase shift, and giving phase shift ⟹ With reflection phase difference and path difference , total phase difference is ⟹ The reflection is destructively reinforced
Correctand (constructive interference)
Your phase-shift analysis for the oil interface is correct. However, because the actual coating thickness yields an optical path difference of (a path phase difference of ), the total phase difference is , which produces constructive interference.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly evaluated reflection phase shifts using the relative refractive indices at each boundary.
You properly recognized that identical phase shifts at both interfaces yield a net reflection phase difference of zero.
You accurately tracked the change in phase shift when replacing air with a higher-index immersion oil.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the conditions for constructive and destructive interference when reflection phase shifts cancel out. When the net reflection phase difference is , waves start in phase, so destructive interference requires an extra half-cycle optical path difference (), while a full-wavelength path difference () causes constructive interference.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Net Reflection Phase Shift Audit
If , the waves are naturally in phase upon reflection.
Set for destructive interference and for constructive interference.
- Minimum Non-Zero Thickness for Anti-Reflection
In standard anti-reflection coatings (), both reflections flip by .
The minimum anti-reflective thickness is always a quarter-wavelength in the film: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the destructive interference condition with zero net reflection shift: .
Solve for .
In immersion oil (), the front reflection has shift while the back reflection has shift, giving .
Add the path phase difference: .
Compute total phase difference: .
(a) at both interfaces, net reflection difference ; (b) ; (c) Constructively reinforced
03 The student assumes that immersion oil having a higher refractive index than air causes no change to boundary phase shifts, concluding the interference remains destructive.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Air to film reflection: phase change is ⟹ Film to glass reflection: phase change is ⟹ Effective net phase difference =
- Step 2
- Step 3
The coating thickness is manufactured to cause destructive interference for light ⟹ Immersing the system does not alter the designed destructive nature of the antireflective coating ⟹ The reflection remains destructively reinforced
CorrectOil-to-film: ; Film-to-glass: . Net boundary shift: . Path shift: . Total phase difference: , resulting in constructive interference.
You treated the antireflective property as an intrinsic property of the film rather than re-evaluating the boundary conditions. Because , the top reflection undergoes no phase shift (), changing the total phase difference to and causing constructive reinforcement.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the phase change at both optical boundaries when the surrounding medium was air.
You set up the correct condition for destructive interference in a thin film with matching boundary phase shifts.
You carried out the numerical calculation for the minimum film thickness with high precision.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that thin-film interference behavior is fixed by the film's manufacture rather than determined by the refractive index ratios across every interface, missing that changing the ambient medium can invert the reflection phase shift.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Boundary Phase Shift Rule
A reflection undergoes a phase shift of only when reflecting off an interface with an optically denser medium (). If , the phase shift is .
Always compare the refractive index of the incident medium directly with that of the transmitting medium at each interface before determining the interference condition.
- Total Phase Difference Accounting
The total phase difference between the two reflections is , where .
Recompute both and whenever the surrounding medium, film thickness, or wavelength changes.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompare the refractive index of the oil with that of the film: . Because the incident medium is denser, reflection at this front surface produces a phase shift of .
Compare the film with the glass substrate: . Because light reflects off a denser medium, this back surface reflection produces a phase shift of .
Find the net reflective phase difference: .
Evaluate the round-trip path phase shift using the thickness from part (b): .
Add the path phase difference and the reflection phase difference: .
Because the total phase difference is an integer multiple of , the two reflected waves interfere constructively.
Constructively reinforced (bright reflection)
Lock it in
What is the optical path difference (OPD) for light reflecting at normal incidence from the front and back surfaces of a film of thickness and refractive index ?
. The refractive index accounts for the slower wave speed and shorter wavelength inside the film.
Similar question
A soap film () in air () is illuminated by light with at normal incidence. What is the minimum non-zero thickness of the film that produces constructive interference in reflection?
Answer
. At the front surface, increases (), yielding a shift. At the back surface, decreases (), yielding a shift. The net reflection phase shift is . For constructive interference, the round-trip optical path must supply an additional shift: .
A silicon solar cell () is coated with a thin layer of silicon monoxide (, ) to minimize reflection for . Determine the minimum coating thickness required for destructive interference.
Answer
. Since , both reflections undergo a phase change, giving a net reflective phase difference of . Destructive interference requires , so .
An antireflective coating () on glass () is optimized for normal-incidence light of wavelength in air (). If the system is placed in a liquid with , find the total phase difference between the two reflected rays and state the resulting interference type.
Answer
(Constructive interference). In the liquid, , so the top surface reflection has . The bottom surface has , so . The net reflection shift is . The round-trip path phase shift is . Thus, , causing constructive interference.