Resources

During a calibration experiment in an environmental hydraulics laboratory, an open-ended vertical tube with an internal cross-sectional area of A=4.20×10−4 m2A = 4.20 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^2 is immersed vertically into a large open reservoir of freshwater (ρw=1.00×103 kg/m3\rho_{\text{w}} = 1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3). A student slowly pipettes V=1.50×10−4 m3V = 1.50 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^3 of an immiscible indicator oil (ρoil=7.80×102 kg/m3\rho_{\text{oil}} = 7.80 \times 10^2\text{ kg/m}^3) into the tube until the oil forms a distinct upper layer resting on top of the water column within the tube. The system reaches static equilibrium open to atmospheric pressure P0=1.013×105 PaP_0 = 1.013 \times 10^5\text{ Pa}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, calculate: (a) the vertical height of the oil column hoilh_{\text{oil}}, and (b) the vertical distance Δy\Delta y by which the top surface of the oil sits above the undisturbed freshwater surface of the outer reservoir.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) hoil=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = 0.357\text{ m}; (b) Δy=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.0785\text{ m}

Steps

Part (a): Vertical Height of the Oil Column

The open vertical tube has a uniform cross-sectional area AA. The oil column forms a cylinder of volume VV and height hoilh_{\text{oil}} inside the tube:

V=A⋅hoilV = A \cdot h_{\text{oil}}

Rearranging to solve for the height hoilh_{\text{oil}}:

hoil=VAh_{\text{oil}} = \frac{V}{A}

Substitute the given values:

hoil=1.50×10−4 m34.20×10−4 m2=514 m≈0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.50 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^3}{4.20 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^2} = \frac{5}{14}\text{ m} \approx 0.357\text{ m}


Part (b): Height Difference Above the Reservoir Surface

  1. Establish a Horizontal Reference Level (Datum): Within a continuous, static body of fluid of uniform density, pressure depends only on depth. The lowest point of the oil column inside the tube marks the oil-water boundary. At this horizontal plane (depth dd below the outer water surface), the pressure inside the tube must equal the hydrostatic pressure at the same depth in the reservoir.
  2. Express Pressure at the Oil-Water Interface:

    • From inside the tube: The top of the oil column is open to atmospheric pressure P0P_0. The pressure at the bottom of the oil column is: Pinterface=P0+ρoilghoilP_{\text{interface}} = P_0 + \rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}}
    • From the outer reservoir: The free surface of the freshwater reservoir is also open to atmospheric pressure P0P_0. At depth dd below the water surface: P(d)=P0+ρwgdP(d) = P_0 + \rho_{\text{w}} g d
  3. Equate the Pressures at the Interface: P0+ρoilghoil=P0+ρwgdP_0 + \rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = P_0 + \rho_{\text{w}} g d

    Subtracting P0P_0 and dividing by gg: ρoilhoil=ρwd  ⟹  d=ρoilρwhoil\rho_{\text{oil}} h_{\text{oil}} = \rho_{\text{w}} d \implies d = \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} h_{\text{oil}}

  4. Relate Depth dd to the Offset Δy\Delta y: The total height of the oil column spans from the oil-water interface up to the top oil surface. Therefore, the distance Δy\Delta y that the top surface extends above the reservoir surface is: Δy=hoil−d\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d

    Substitute d=ρoilρwhoild = \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} h_{\text{oil}}: Δy=hoil(1−ρoilρw)\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} \left(1 - \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}}\right)

  5. Calculate Δy\Delta y: Δy=(0.357 m)(1−7.80×102 kg/m31.00×103 kg/m3)\Delta y = (0.357\text{ m})\left(1 - \frac{7.80 \times 10^2\text{ kg/m}^3}{1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3}\right) Δy=0.357 m×(1−0.780)=0.357 m×0.220=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.357\text{ m} \times (1 - 0.780) = 0.357\text{ m} \times 0.220 = 0.0785\text{ m}

Pitfall to avoid: Do not assume the oil displaces an equal height of water. Because oil is less dense than water (ρoil<ρw\rho_{\text{oil}} < \rho_{\text{w}}), a column of oil exerts less downward pressure than an equal height of water. Consequently, the top of the oil column must sit higher than the surrounding water level to achieve equilibrium.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the depth of the submerged oil-water interface instead of the height of the oil surface above the water reservoir.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    hoil=VA  ⟹  hoil=1.50×10−4 m34.20×10−4 m2=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = \frac{V}{A} \implies h_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.50 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^3}{4.20 \times 10^{-4}\text{ m}^2} = 0.357\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    P0+ρoil⋅g⋅hoil=P0+ρw⋅g⋅Δy  ⟹  Δy=ρoilρw⋅hoilP_0 + \rho_{\text{oil}} \cdot g \cdot h_{\text{oil}} = P_0 + \rho_{\text{w}} \cdot g \cdot \Delta y \implies \Delta y = \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} \cdot h_{\text{oil}}

    Correct

    P0+ρoilghoil=P0+ρwgd  ⟹  d=ρoilρwhoilP_0 + \rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = P_0 + \rho_{\text{w}} g d \implies d = \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} h_{\text{oil}}, then Δy=hoil−d=hoil(1−ρoilρw)\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d = h_{\text{oil}}\left(1 - \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}}\right)

    The pressure balance at the oil-water interface yields the depth dd of the interface below the reservoir's water surface, not the height Δy\Delta y above it. Geometrically, the oil column of height hoilh_{\text{oil}} consists of the submerged depth dd plus the protrusion height Δy\Delta y, meaning Δy=hoil−d\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d.

  3. Step 3

    Δy=(7801000)⋅0.357 m=0.278 m\Delta y = \left(\frac{780}{1000}\right) \cdot 0.357\text{ m} = 0.278\text{ m}

    Correct

    Δy=0.357 m×(1−7801000)=0.357 m×0.220=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.357\text{ m} \times \left(1 - \frac{780}{1000}\right) = 0.357\text{ m} \times 0.220 = 0.0785\text{ m}

    Because this numerical step directly evaluates the formula from Step 2, it calculates the submerged depth d=0.278 md = 0.278\text{ m} rather than the vertical protrusion Δy\Delta y.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the cylindrical volume formula to find the height of the oil column.

You correctly identified that the hydrostatic pressure at the oil-water interface inside the tube matches the hydrostatic pressure in the surrounding water reservoir at that same depth.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Submerged Depth with Elevation Offset

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You equated the total hydrostatic pressure of the oil column directly to an equivalent depth of water and assigned that value to Δy\Delta y. You missed the geometric relationship that the oil column's total height is divided into two segments: the submerged depth dd below the reservoir surface and the elevation Δy\Delta y above the reservoir surface (hoil=d+Δyh_{\text{oil}} = d + \Delta y).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Geometric Decomposition
  • When a floating or perched column of fluid spans across a reference level, its total height equals the portion below the reference level plus the portion above it: h=dbelow+Δyaboveh = d_{\text{below}} + \Delta y_{\text{above}}.

  • Always draw a clear vertical reference line at the outer liquid surface and label both the depth below (dd) and the height above (Δy\Delta y) before setting up pressure equations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Define dd as the depth of the oil-water interface below the undisturbed reservoir surface: P0+ρoilghoil=P0+ρwgd  ⟹  d=ρoilρwhoilP_0 + \rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = P_0 + \rho_{\text{w}} g d \implies d = \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} h_{\text{oil}}.

  2. Express the elevation difference Δy\Delta y using the geometry of the tube: Δy=hoil−d=hoil(1−ρoilρw)\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d = h_{\text{oil}}\left(1 - \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}}\right).

  3. Substitute hoil=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = 0.357\text{ m} and the densities: Δy=0.357 m×(1−780 kg/m31000 kg/m3)=0.357 m×0.220=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.357\text{ m} \times \left(1 - \frac{780\text{ kg/m}^3}{1000\text{ kg/m}^3}\right) = 0.357\text{ m} \times 0.220 = 0.0785\text{ m}.

Final answer

(a) hoil=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = 0.357\text{ m}; (b) Δy=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.0785\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the water datum line across the open tube to visually distinguish between the submerged depth dd and the protrusion Δy\Delta y.

  • Practice solving hydrostatic U-tube and manometer problems by explicitly labeling every height relative to a horizontal reference line before doing algebra.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the density ratio when balancing the hydrostatic pressures between the oil and water columns.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    hoil=VA  ⟹  hoil=1.50×10−44.20×10−4=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = \frac{V}{A} \implies h_{\text{oil}} = \frac{1.50 \times 10^{-4}}{4.20 \times 10^{-4}} = 0.357\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    d=(ρwρoil)⋅hoil  ⟹  d=(1000780)⋅0.357 m=0.458 md = \left(\frac{\rho_{\text{w}}}{\rho_{\text{oil}}}\right) \cdot h_{\text{oil}} \implies d = \left(\frac{1000}{780}\right) \cdot 0.357\text{ m} = 0.458\text{ m}

    Correct

    P0+ρoilghoil=P0+ρwgd  ⟹  d=(ρoilρw)hoil=(7801000)(0.357 m)≈0.278 mP_0 + \rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = P_0 + \rho_{\text{w}} g d \implies d = \left(\frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}}\right) h_{\text{oil}} = \left(\frac{780}{1000}\right)(0.357\text{ m}) \approx 0.278\text{ m}

    You inverted the density ratio when solving for the submerged depth dd. Balancing hydrostatic pressure at the oil-water interface requires ρoilghoil=ρwgd\rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = \rho_{\text{w}} g d, which gives d=ρoilρwhoild = \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} h_{\text{oil}}.

  3. Step 3

    Δy=d−hoil=0.458 m−0.357 m=0.101 m\Delta y = d - h_{\text{oil}} = 0.458\text{ m} - 0.357\text{ m} = 0.101\text{ m}

    Correct

    Δy=hoil−d=0.357 m−0.278 m=0.0785 m\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d = 0.357\text{ m} - 0.278\text{ m} = 0.0785\text{ m}

    Because your calculated depth dd was larger than hoilh_{\text{oil}}, you subtracted hoilh_{\text{oil}} from dd. The oil column extends from depth dd up to the top surface, so the height above the reservoir is Δy=hoil−d\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the geometric relationship between volume, cross-sectional area, and column height.

You recognized that hydrostatic pressure equilibrium relates the oil column to a corresponding water depth.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted density ratio in hydrostatic balance

Inverting the fraction ρoilρw\frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} as ρwρoil\frac{\rho_{\text{w}}}{\rho_{\text{oil}}} when solving for the balancing depth of water.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Rearranging the pressure balance equation ρoilhoil=ρwd\rho_{\text{oil}} h_{\text{oil}} = \rho_{\text{w}} d incorrectly without checking whether the less dense fluid requires a shorter or taller column of water to balance it.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Pressure Balance at Equal Levels
  • In static equilibrium, points at the same elevation in a continuous fluid share equal pressure: P0+ρ1gh1=P0+ρ2gh2P_0 + \rho_1 g h_1 = P_0 + \rho_2 g h_2.

  • Write out the full hydrostatic pressure equation at the interface before isolating any single variable.

Physical Sanity Check on Densities
  • A less dense fluid column exerts less pressure per unit height, so it balances a shorter column of denser fluid (hdense<hlighth_{\text{dense}} < h_{\text{light}}).

  • Check that d<hoild < h_{\text{oil}} because ρoil<ρw\rho_{\text{oil}} < \rho_{\text{w}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the hydrostatic pressures at the oil-water interface: ρoilghoil=ρwgd\rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = \rho_{\text{w}} g d.

  2. Solve for the interface depth dd: d=(ρoilρw)hoil=(780 kg/m31000 kg/m3)(0.357 m)=0.278 md = \left(\frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}}\right) h_{\text{oil}} = \left(\frac{780\text{ kg/m}^3}{1000\text{ kg/m}^3}\right)(0.357\text{ m}) = 0.278\text{ m}.

  3. Calculate the height difference: Δy=hoil−d=0.357 m−0.278 m=0.0785 m\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d = 0.357\text{ m} - 0.278\text{ m} = 0.0785\text{ m}.

Final answer

(a) hoil=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = 0.357\text{ m}; (b) Δy=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.0785\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write down the full pressure balance equation P1=P2P_1 = P_2 before rearranging algebraic terms.

  • Perform a quick physical plausibility check: verify whether the denser fluid should have a smaller height than the lighter fluid.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student equates the height above the reservoir to the oil column height minus the water density displaced without multiplying by the column height properly, simply computing Δy = h_oil · (ρ_oil / ρ_w).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    hoil=VA=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = \frac{V}{A} = 0.357\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    Δy=hoil⋅ρoilρw  ⟹  Δy=0.357 m⋅(7801000)=0.278 m\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} \cdot \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} \implies \Delta y = 0.357\text{ m} \cdot \left(\frac{780}{1000}\right) = 0.278\text{ m}

    Correct

    Δy=hoil−d=hoil(1−ρoilρw)=0.357 m×(1−0.780)=0.0785 m\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d = h_{\text{oil}}\left(1 - \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}}\right) = 0.357\text{ m} \times (1 - 0.780) = 0.0785\text{ m}

    The quantity hoil⋅ρoilρwh_{\text{oil}} \cdot \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} gives the depth dd of the oil-water interface below the reservoir surface, because ρoilghoil=ρwgd\rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = \rho_{\text{w}} g d. The height extending above the reservoir surface is the remainder of the oil column, Δy=hoil−d\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total height of the oil column using the volume and cross-sectional area.

You correctly applied hydrostatic pressure balance at the oil-water interface to find the equivalent water depth.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Geometry / Reference Level Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the submerged depth of the interface below the reservoir level (d=hoilρoilρwd = h_{\text{oil}} \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}}) with the height of the oil column protruding above the reservoir level (Δy=hoil−d\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Sketch the Interface and Datum
  • At the horizontal datum level of the oil-water boundary, pressure inside the tube equals pressure outside: ρoilghoil=ρwgd\rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} = \rho_{\text{w}} g d.

  • Always draw a diagram showing how the total oil column height hoilh_{\text{oil}} is split into the submerged portion dd below the reservoir surface and the exposed portion Δy\Delta y above it, giving hoil=d+Δyh_{\text{oil}} = d + \Delta y.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that the balance of pressures at the lower interface gives the submerged depth: d=hoilρoilρw=0.357 m×0.780=0.278 md = h_{\text{oil}} \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} = 0.357\text{ m} \times 0.780 = 0.278\text{ m}.

  2. Express the height protruding above the reservoir surface as the geometric difference: Δy=hoil−d\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}} - d.

  3. Subtract the submerged depth from the total oil height: Δy=0.357 m−0.278 m=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.357\text{ m} - 0.278\text{ m} = 0.0785\text{ m}.

Final answer

(a) hoil=0.357 mh_{\text{oil}} = 0.357\text{ m}; (b) Δy=0.0785 m\Delta y = 0.0785\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch fluid column problems with a clear datum line at the lowest interface before writing algebraic expressions.

  • Verify limiting cases: if ρoil=ρw\rho_{\text{oil}} = \rho_{\text{w}}, the oil column would not stick out at all (Δy=0\Delta y = 0), which confirms Δy∝(1−ρoil/ρw)\Delta y \propto (1 - \rho_{\text{oil}}/\rho_{\text{w}}) rather than ρoil/ρw\rho_{\text{oil}}/\rho_{\text{w}}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A vertical glass tube open at both ends is placed in a large container of water (ρ=1000 kg/m3\rho = 1000\text{ kg/m}^3). Kerosene (ρk=820 kg/m3\rho_{\text{k}} = 820\text{ kg/m}^3) is poured into the tube until it forms a column of height h=0.500 mh = 0.500\text{ m}. Calculate the vertical distance between the top of the kerosene column and the water surface outside the tube.

Answer

Δy=0.090 m\Delta y = 0.090\text{ m}. Key steps: Submerged depth of the interface is d=ρkρwh=8201000×0.500=0.410 md = \frac{\rho_{\text{k}}}{\rho_{\text{w}}} h = \frac{820}{1000} \times 0.500 = 0.410\text{ m}. Height above water level is Δy=h−d=0.500−0.410=0.090 m\Delta y = h - d = 0.500 - 0.410 = 0.090\text{ m}.

02

In a vertical open tube immersed in saltwater (ρsw=1025 kg/m3\rho_{\text{sw}} = 1025\text{ kg/m}^3), a column of olive oil (ρoil=920 kg/m3\rho_{\text{oil}} = 920\text{ kg/m}^3) is added. If the top surface of the olive oil sits exactly Δy=3.15 cm\Delta y = 3.15\text{ cm} above the surrounding saltwater surface, find the total height of the olive oil column hoilh_{\text{oil}}.

Answer

hoil=30.8 cmh_{\text{oil}} = 30.8\text{ cm} (or 0.308 m0.308\text{ m}). Key steps: Δy=hoil(1−ρoilρsw)  ⟹  hoil=Δy1−920/1025=3.15 cm0.1024≈30.8 cm\Delta y = h_{\text{oil}}\left(1 - \frac{\rho_{\text{oil}}}{\rho_{\text{sw}}}\right) \implies h_{\text{oil}} = \frac{\Delta y}{1 - 920/1025} = \frac{3.15\text{ cm}}{0.1024} \approx 30.8\text{ cm}.

03

A U-tube of uniform cross-section contains mercury (ρm=13600 kg/m3\rho_{\text{m}} = 13600\text{ kg/m}^3). In the left arm, a 20.0 cm20.0\text{ cm} column of water (ρw=1000 kg/m3\rho_{\text{w}} = 1000\text{ kg/m}^3) is poured. In the right arm, an unknown oil of column height 25.0 cm25.0\text{ cm} is poured until the mercury levels in both arms are at the exact same horizontal height. Determine: (a) the density of the unknown oil, and (b) the vertical difference between the free surface of the oil and the free surface of the water.

Answer

(a) ρoil=800 kg/m3\rho_{\text{oil}} = 800\text{ kg/m}^3; (b) Δh=5.0 cm\Delta h = 5.0\text{ cm}. Key steps: (a) Since mercury levels are equal, pressure at the mercury interface in both arms is equal: ρwghw=ρoilghoil  ⟹  ρoil=1000×20.025.0=800 kg/m3\rho_{\text{w}} g h_{\text{w}} = \rho_{\text{oil}} g h_{\text{oil}} \implies \rho_{\text{oil}} = 1000 \times \frac{20.0}{25.0} = 800\text{ kg/m}^3. (b) Since both columns start from the same bottom level, the difference between their top surfaces is simply Δh=hoil−hw=25.0 cm−20.0 cm=5.0 cm\Delta h = h_{\text{oil}} - h_{\text{w}} = 25.0\text{ cm} - 20.0\text{ cm} = 5.0\text{ cm}.

Loading workspace…