Resources

A student claims that since a pipe open at both ends supports all integer harmonics (fn=nv2Lf_n = n \frac{v}{2L}) while a pipe closed at one end supports only odd harmonics (fm=mv4Lf_m = m \frac{v}{4L}, m=1,3,5,…m = 1, 3, 5, \dots), closing one end of an open pipe must always lower the frequencies of its existing resonance spectrum. Consider a pipe of length L=0.680 mL = 0.680\text{ m} initially open at both ends with speed of sound v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s}. One end is then capped, converting it into a closed-open pipe of the exact same length. Determine the original fundamental frequency f1,openf_{1,\text{open}}, the new fundamental frequency f1,closedf_{1,\text{closed}}, and find the lowest resonant frequency of the closed pipe that is strictly greater than the original fundamental frequency f1,openf_{1,\text{open}}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Original open fundamental: f1,open=250 Hzf_{1,\text{open}} = 250\text{ Hz}; New closed fundamental: f1,closed=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 125\text{ Hz}; Lowest closed resonance strictly above f1,openf_{1,\text{open}}: f3,closed=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz}

Steps

01

Fundamental Frequency of the Open-Open Pipe

For a pipe open at both ends, displacement antinodes form at each boundary. The resonant frequencies are given by:

fn,open=nv2L,n=1,2,3,…f_{n,\text{open}} = n \frac{v}{2L}, \quad n = 1, 2, 3, \dots

Substitute n=1n = 1, v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s}, and L=0.680 mL = 0.680\text{ m}:

f1,open=340 m/s2(0.680 m)=3401.36 Hz=250 Hzf_{1,\text{open}} = \frac{340\text{ m/s}}{2(0.680\text{ m})} = \frac{340}{1.36}\text{ Hz} = 250\text{ Hz}


02

Fundamental Frequency of the Capped (Closed-Open) Pipe

When one end is capped, a displacement node forms at the closed end, while an antinode remains at the open end. The quarter-wavelength condition applies, and only odd harmonics can form:

fm,closed=mv4L,m=1,3,5,…f_{m,\text{closed}} = m \frac{v}{4L}, \quad m = 1, 3, 5, \dots

For the fundamental mode (m=1m = 1):

f1,closed=340 m/s4(0.680 m)=3402.72 Hz=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = \frac{340\text{ m/s}}{4(0.680\text{ m})} = \frac{340}{2.72}\text{ Hz} = 125\text{ Hz}

Closing one end halves the fundamental frequency because the required fundamental wavelength doubles from λ=2L\lambda = 2L to λ=4L\lambda = 4L.


03

Lowest Closed Resonance Strictly Above f1,openf_{1,\text{open}}

The resonant frequencies of the closed-open pipe are odd integer multiples of its fundamental frequency (125 Hz125\text{ Hz}):

  • First harmonic (m=1m = 1): f1,closed=1⋅125 Hz=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 1 \cdot 125\text{ Hz} = 125\text{ Hz}
  • Third harmonic (m=3m = 3): f3,closed=3⋅125 Hz=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 3 \cdot 125\text{ Hz} = 375\text{ Hz}
  • Fifth harmonic (m=5m = 5): f5,closed=5⋅125 Hz=625 Hzf_{5,\text{closed}} = 5 \cdot 125\text{ Hz} = 625\text{ Hz}

We require the smallest closed-pipe resonant frequency such that fm,closed>250 Hzf_{m,\text{closed}} > 250\text{ Hz}:

f3,closed=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz}

Common Pitfall: While capping the tube halves the fundamental frequency, it does not mean every resonance shifts downward relative to the old spectrum. Instead, it reconfigures the standing wave nodes and antinodes, introducing new resonant frequencies (such as 375 Hz375\text{ Hz}) that lie between the original open harmonics (250 Hz250\text{ Hz} and 500 Hz500\text{ Hz}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats all integer harmonics as present in the closed-at-one-end pipe instead of only odd harmonics, calculating the next harmonic as m = 2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f1 open=340/(2∗0.680)=250 Hzf_{1\text{ open}} = 340 / (2 * 0.680) = 250\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    f1 closed=340/(4∗0.680)=125 Hzf_{1\text{ closed}} = 340 / (4 * 0.680) = 125\text{ Hz}

  3. Step 3

    f2 closed=2∗125=250 Hz  ⟹  f3 closed=3∗125=375 Hzf_{2\text{ closed}} = 2 * 125 = 250\text{ Hz} \implies f_{3\text{ closed}} = 3 * 125 = 375\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fm,closed=m⋅f1,closed for m=1,3,5,⋯  ⟹  f3,closed=3(125 Hz)=375 Hzf_{m,\text{closed}} = m \cdot f_{1,\text{closed}} \text{ for } m = 1, 3, 5, \dots \implies f_{3,\text{closed}} = 3(125\text{ Hz}) = 375\text{ Hz}

    A pipe closed at one end and open at the other supports only odd harmonics because the boundary conditions require a displacement node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end. Therefore, m=2m = 2 (250 Hz250\text{ Hz}) does not exist in this tube.

  4. Step 4

    f2=250 Hz is not strictly greater than 250 Hz, so the next frequency is 250 Hzf_2 = 250\text{ Hz} \text{ is not strictly greater than } 250\text{ Hz, so the next frequency is } 250\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f3,closed=375 Hz>250 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz} > 250\text{ Hz}

    Because m=2m = 2 does not exist in a closed-open pipe, the lowest resonant frequency strictly greater than 250 Hz250\text{ Hz} is the third harmonic, f3,closed=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the fundamental frequency of the open-open pipe as 250 Hz250\text{ Hz}.

You accurately determined that capping one end halves the fundamental frequency to 125 Hz125\text{ Hz}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Harmonic series selection for closed-open boundary conditions

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that a pipe closed at one end supports all integer harmonics (m=1,2,3,…m = 1, 2, 3, \dots) instead of recognizing that the asymmetric boundary conditions (node at closed end, antinode at open end) restrict the allowable standing waves to odd quarter-wavelengths (m=1,3,5,…m = 1, 3, 5, \dots).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Boundary Conditions
  • Open ends create displacement antinodes; closed ends create displacement nodes.

  • Ensure the standing wave mode fits an odd number of quarter-wavelengths (L=mλ4L = m\frac{\lambda}{4} with m=1,3,5,…m = 1, 3, 5, \dots).

List Only Allowed Harmonics
  • For a closed-open pipe, fm=mf1f_m = m f_1 only for m∈{1,3,5,… }m \in \{1, 3, 5, \dots\}.

  • Never compute even multiples such as 2f12 f_1 or 4f14 f_1 for a pipe closed at one end.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the allowed harmonic series for a closed-open pipe: fm=m⋅125 Hzf_m = m \cdot 125\text{ Hz} for m=1,3,5,…m = 1, 3, 5, \dots.

  2. Calculate the allowable resonant frequencies: f1=125 Hzf_1 = 125\text{ Hz}, f3=375 Hzf_3 = 375\text{ Hz}, f5=625 Hzf_5 = 625\text{ Hz}.

  3. Compare the frequencies to f1,open=250 Hzf_{1,\text{open}} = 250\text{ Hz}. The lowest resonant frequency strictly greater than 250 Hz250\text{ Hz} is f3=375 Hzf_3 = 375\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

f1,open=250 Hzf_{1,\text{open}} = 250\text{ Hz}, f1,closed=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 125\text{ Hz}, lowest closed resonance strictly above f1,openf_{1,\text{open}} is f3,closed=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the standing wave patterns for closed-open air columns to visualize why even quarter-wavelengths cannot meet the boundary conditions.

  • Practice identifying whether a resonant system allows all integer harmonics (n=1,2,3,…n = 1, 2, 3, \dots) or only odd harmonics (m=1,3,5,…m = 1, 3, 5, \dots).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the harmonic number m with the sequential mode index n and evaluates the third mode using m = 5 instead of m = 3.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f1 open=3402⋅0.680=250 Hzf_{1\text{ open}} = \frac{340}{2 \cdot 0.680} = 250\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    f1 closed=3404⋅0.680=125 Hzf_{1\text{ closed}} = \frac{340}{4 \cdot 0.680} = 125\text{ Hz}

  3. Step 3

    fm=m⋅125 Hz for m=1,3,5,⋯  ⟹  m=3 giving 375 Hz and m=5 giving 625 Hzf_m = m \cdot 125\text{ Hz} \text{ for } m = 1, 3, 5, \dots \implies m = 3 \text{ giving } 375\text{ Hz and } m = 5 \text{ giving } 625\text{ Hz}

  4. Step 4

    Lowest resonant frequency strictly greater than 250 Hz250\text{ Hz} is 625 Hz625\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    Lowest resonant frequency strictly greater than 250 Hz250\text{ Hz} is f3,closed=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz}

    Because 375 Hz>250 Hz375\text{ Hz} > 250\text{ Hz}, 375 Hz375\text{ Hz} is already strictly greater than f1,openf_{1,\text{open}} and is smaller than 625 Hz625\text{ Hz}, making it the lowest resonant frequency that satisfies the condition.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You used the correct boundary conditions and formulas for both the open-open pipe and the closed-open pipe.

You correctly calculated the odd harmonics of the closed-open pipe.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Harmonic selection error

You found that the m=3m=3 harmonic is 375 Hz375\text{ Hz}, which is already strictly greater than 250 Hz250\text{ Hz}, but you skipped it and chose the m=5m=5 harmonic (625 Hz625\text{ Hz}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked that the first overtone (m=3m=3, 375 Hz375\text{ Hz}) already surpasses the original open fundamental of 250 Hz250\text{ Hz}, leading to selecting the next higher harmonic instead.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Compare calculated spectrum values directly to the threshold
  • List the closed-pipe spectrum in ascending order: 125 Hz,375 Hz,625 Hz,…125\text{ Hz}, 375\text{ Hz}, 625\text{ Hz}, \dots and pick the very first value that satisfies f>250 Hzf > 250\text{ Hz}.

  • Check 125 Hz>250 Hz125\text{ Hz} > 250\text{ Hz} (False); check 375 Hz>250 Hz375\text{ Hz} > 250\text{ Hz} (True). Therefore, 375 Hz375\text{ Hz} is the smallest.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate m=1m=1: f1,closed=125 Hz≤250 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 125\text{ Hz} \le 250\text{ Hz}.

  2. Evaluate m=3m=3: f3,closed=375 Hz>250 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz} > 250\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

f3,closed=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the resonant frequencies in an ordered list when finding a threshold frequency.

  • Compare each candidate frequency directly against the target boundary before moving to higher modes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses the open-pipe harmonic spacing v / (2L) instead of v / (4L) for the fundamental frequency of the closed pipe.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f1,open=340/(2∗0.680)=250 Hzf_{1,\text{open}} = 340 / (2 * 0.680) = 250\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    f1,closed=340/(2∗0.680)=250 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 340 / (2 * 0.680) = 250\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f1,closed=v4L=340 m/s4(0.680 m)=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{340\text{ m/s}}{4(0.680\text{ m})} = 125\text{ Hz}

    A pipe closed at one end requires a displacement node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, which corresponds to a fundamental wavelength of λ1=4L\lambda_1 = 4L. Therefore, the denominator must be 4L4L, yielding f1,closed=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 125\text{ Hz} rather than 250 Hz250\text{ Hz}.

  3. Step 3

    fm=m∗250 Hz with odd m=1,3,5,⋯  ⟹  f3=3∗250=750 Hz  ⟹  The lowest frequency strictly greater than 250 Hz is 750 Hzf_m = m * 250\text{ Hz} \text{ with odd } m = 1, 3, 5, \dots \implies f_3 = 3 * 250 = 750\text{ Hz} \implies \text{The lowest frequency strictly greater than } 250\text{ Hz is } 750\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fm,closed=m(125 Hz)  ⟹  f3,closed=3(125 Hz)=375 Hz>250 Hzf_{m,\text{closed}} = m(125\text{ Hz}) \implies f_{3,\text{closed}} = 3(125\text{ Hz}) = 375\text{ Hz} > 250\text{ Hz}

    You correctly recognized that a closed-open pipe produces only odd harmonics (m=1,3,5,…m = 1, 3, 5, \dots). However, because you carried forward f1,closed=250 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 250\text{ Hz} instead of 125 Hz125\text{ Hz}, your third harmonic evaluated to 750 Hz750\text{ Hz} instead of the correct value of 375 Hz375\text{ Hz}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the fundamental frequency of the open-open pipe as 250 Hz250\text{ Hz}.

You correctly recalled that a pipe closed at one end only supports odd harmonic multiples (m=1,3,5,…m = 1, 3, 5, \dots).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Boundary Condition Formula Confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied the open-open boundary condition formula f1=v2Lf_1 = \frac{v}{2L} to the closed-open pipe instead of the quarter-wavelength relationship f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Boundary Conditions & Fundamental Wavelength
  • For a pipe of length LL: open-open has antinodes at both ends with λ1=2L\lambda_1 = 2L (f1=v2Lf_1 = \frac{v}{2L}); closed-open has a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end with λ1=4L\lambda_1 = 4L (f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L}).

  • Always verify whether the pipe has symmetric boundaries (both open or both closed, using 2L2L) or mixed boundaries (one open and one closed, using 4L4L) before setting up the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recalculate the fundamental frequency for the closed-open pipe: f1,closed=v4L=340 m/s4(0.680 m)=3402.72 Hz=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{340\text{ m/s}}{4(0.680\text{ m})} = \frac{340}{2.72}\text{ Hz} = 125\text{ Hz}.

  2. List the odd harmonic frequencies of the closed pipe: f1,closed=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 125\text{ Hz}, f3,closed=3×125 Hz=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 3 \times 125\text{ Hz} = 375\text{ Hz}, and f5,closed=5×125 Hz=625 Hzf_{5,\text{closed}} = 5 \times 125\text{ Hz} = 625\text{ Hz}.

  3. Compare each harmonic against f1,open=250 Hzf_{1,\text{open}} = 250\text{ Hz} to find the smallest value strictly greater than 250 Hz250\text{ Hz}, which is f3,closed=375 Hzf_{3,\text{closed}} = 375\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

f1,open=250 Hzf_{1,\text{open}} = 250\text{ Hz}, f1,closed=125 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 125\text{ Hz}, and the lowest closed resonance strictly above 250 Hz250\text{ Hz} is 375 Hz375\text{ Hz}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the standing wave pattern sketches for open-open versus closed-open tubes to visually anchor why a closed-open fundamental spans one quarter of a wavelength (L=λ4L = \frac{\lambda}{4}).

  • Practice identifying the factor of 2L2L versus 4L4L in problems involving organ pipes, resonance tubes, and acoustic cavities.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An organ pipe of length 0.850 m0.850\text{ m} is closed at one end and open at the other. Taking the speed of sound as 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, calculate its fundamental frequency and its third harmonic frequency.

Answer

f1=100 Hzf_1 = 100\text{ Hz} and f3=300 Hzf_3 = 300\text{ Hz}. Key steps: f1=v4L=3404(0.850)=100 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{340}{4(0.850)} = 100\text{ Hz}. Since only odd harmonics exist, the third harmonic is f3=3f1=300 Hzf_3 = 3 f_1 = 300\text{ Hz}.

02

A cylindrical pipe open at both ends resonates at a fundamental frequency of 300 Hz300\text{ Hz}. One end is now sealed. Find the frequency of the first resonant mode of the sealed pipe that is higher than 400 Hz400\text{ Hz}.

Answer

450 Hz450\text{ Hz}. Key steps: Sealing one end halves the fundamental frequency, so f1,closed=150 Hzf_{1,\text{closed}} = 150\text{ Hz}. The allowed frequencies are odd multiples: f1=150 Hzf_1 = 150\text{ Hz}, f3=3(150)=450 Hzf_3 = 3(150) = 450\text{ Hz}. The lowest resonance strictly above 400 Hz400\text{ Hz} is 450 Hz450\text{ Hz}.

03

A tuning fork with frequency 510 Hz510\text{ Hz} is held over a resonance tube filled with water, creating a column of air closed at the water surface and open at the top. The speed of sound is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}. Find the two shortest tube lengths L1L_1 and L2L_2 that produce resonance.

Answer

L1=0.167 mL_1 = 0.167\text{ m} (16.7 cm16.7\text{ cm}) and L2=0.500 mL_2 = 0.500\text{ m} (50.0 cm50.0\text{ cm}). Key steps: λ=vf=340510=23 m\lambda = \frac{v}{f} = \frac{340}{510} = \frac{2}{3}\text{ m}. Resonance occurs at odd quarter-wavelengths: L1=λ4=16 m≈0.167 mL_1 = \frac{\lambda}{4} = \frac{1}{6}\text{ m} \approx 0.167\text{ m}; L2=3λ4=36 m=0.500 mL_2 = \frac{3\lambda}{4} = \frac{3}{6}\text{ m} = 0.500\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…