Resources

An Atwood machine consists of two masses, m1=3.00 kgm_1 = 3.00\text{ kg} and m2=5.00 kgm_2 = 5.00\text{ kg}, connected by a light inextensible cord passing over a frictionless, massless pulley. Two students choose different coordinate representations: Student 1 uses separate 1D vertical axes with +y1+y_1 pointing downward for m1m_1 and +y2+y_2 pointing downward for m2m_2. Student 2 chooses a continuous 1D curvilinear coordinate system along the string, defining the positive direction ss as pointing clockwise (downward for m2m_2 and upward for m1m_1). Using g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2: (a) in Student 1's coordinate system, state the geometric constraint equation relating the accelerations a1ya_{1y} and a2ya_{2y}, and solve for the numerical acceleration a2ya_{2y}, (b) in Student 2's coordinate system, set up the single equation of motion for the system coordinate acceleration asa_s and calculate its numerical value, and (c) explain why assuming a1y=a2ya_{1y} = a_{2y} in Student 1's system produces an unphysical result.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Constraint: a1y+a2y=0a_{1y} + a_{2y} = 0 (or a1y=−a2ya_{1y} = -a_{2y}); a2y=2.45 m/s2a_{2y} = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2, (b) as=2.45 m/s2a_s = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2, (c) Setting a1y=a2ya_{1y} = a_{2y} with both positive-down implies the cord stretches or slackens; since the cord has fixed length y1+y2=constanty_1 + y_2 = \text{constant}, differentiating twice yields a1y=−a2ya_{1y} = -a_{2y}.

Steps

Part (a): Student 1's Coordinate System

  1. Derive the kinematic constraint:
    Let the vertical positions of m1m_1 and m2m_2 measured downward from the center of the pulley be y1y_1 and y2y_2. Because the cord has a fixed length LL and wraps around a pulley of radius RR, the geometric relationship is: y1+y2+πR=Ly_1 + y_2 + \pi R = L Differentiating twice with respect to time gives: d2y1dt2+d2y2dt2=0  ⟹  a1y+a2y=0ora1y=−a2y\frac{d^2 y_1}{dt^2} + \frac{d^2 y_2}{dt^2} = 0 \implies a_{1y} + a_{2y} = 0 \quad \text{or} \quad a_{1y} = -a_{2y}
  2. Apply Newton's second law to each mass:
    Both axes point downward, so gravity acts in the positive direction and cord tension TT acts in the negative (upward) direction: m1g−T=m1a1ym_1 g - T = m_1 a_{1y} m2g−T=m2a2ym_2 g - T = m_2 a_{2y}
  3. Solve for the acceleration a2ya_{2y}:
    Substitute a1y=−a2ya_{1y} = -a_{2y} into the first equation: m1g−T=−m1a2y  ⟹  T=m1g+m1a2ym_1 g - T = -m_1 a_{2y} \implies T = m_1 g + m_1 a_{2y} Substitute this expression for TT into the second equation: m2g−(m1g+m1a2y)=m2a2ym_2 g - (m_1 g + m_1 a_{2y}) = m_2 a_{2y} (m2−m1)g=(m1+m2)a2y(m_2 - m_1)g = (m_1 + m_2)a_{2y} a2y=m2−m1m1+m2ga_{2y} = \frac{m_2 - m_1}{m_1 + m_2} g Substitute the given values: a2y=5.00 kg−3.00 kg5.00 kg+3.00 kg⋅9.80 m/s2=2.008.00⋅9.80 m/s2=2.45 m/s2a_{2y} = \frac{5.00\text{ kg} - 3.00\text{ kg}}{5.00\text{ kg} + 3.00\text{ kg}} \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = \frac{2.00}{8.00} \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2

Part (b): Student 2's Coordinate System

  1. Set up the system equation of motion:
    In the continuous 1D coordinate ss directed clockwise, the motion of both blocks is parameterized by a single variable: moving along +s+s means m1m_1 moves upward and m2m_2 moves downward.

    • Gravity on m2m_2 pulls in the +s+s direction: +m2g+m_2 g
    • Gravity on m1m_1 pulls opposite the +s+s direction: −m1g-m_1 g
    • The tension TT acts internally to the two-mass system and cancels out.

    Applying Newton's second law along the coordinate ss: (m1+m2)as=m2g−m1g=(m2−m1)g(m_1 + m_2) a_s = m_2 g - m_1 g = (m_2 - m_1) g

  2. Calculate the numerical value of asa_s:
    as=m2−m1m1+m2g=5.00 kg−3.00 kg5.00 kg+3.00 kg⋅9.80 m/s2=2.45 m/s2a_s = \frac{m_2 - m_1}{m_1 + m_2} g = \frac{5.00\text{ kg} - 3.00\text{ kg}}{5.00\text{ kg} + 3.00\text{ kg}} \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2

Part (c): Physical Meaning and Pitfall of Setting a1y=a2ya_{1y} = a_{2y}

  • Setting a1y=a2y=aa_{1y} = a_{2y} = a implies that both blocks accelerate downward simultaneously.
  • If both masses move downward, the total length of the cord hanging below the pulley, y1+y2y_1 + y_2, would increase over time: d2dt2(y1+y2)=a1y+a2y=2a>0\frac{d^2}{dt^2}(y_1 + y_2) = a_{1y} + a_{2y} = 2a > 0
  • This requires the cord to stretch or break, violating the condition that the cord is inextensible. For an inextensible cord, any downward displacement of one mass must be matched by an equal upward displacement of the other, requiring a1y=−a2ya_{1y} = -a_{2y}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that downward is positive for both masses and mistakenly equates the acceleration magnitudes with the same sign, setting a1y = a2y.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    a1y=a2ya_{1y} = a_{2y}

    Correct

    a1y+a2y=0  ⟹  a1y=−a2ya_{1y} + a_{2y} = 0 \implies a_{1y} = -a_{2y}

    Because both coordinate axes +y1+y_1 and +y2+y_2 point downward from the pulley, the string length constraint is y1+y2+πR=Ly_1 + y_2 + \pi R = L. Differentiating twice with respect to time gives a1y+a2y=0a_{1y} + a_{2y} = 0, meaning a1y=−a2ya_{1y} = -a_{2y}, not +a2y+a_{2y}.

  2. Step 2

    m1g−T=m1a2y  ⟹  m2g−T=m2a2y  ⟹  (m2−m1)g=(m2−m1)a2y  ⟹  a2y=g=9.80 m/s2m_1 g - T = m_1 a_{2y} \implies m_2 g - T = m_2 a_{2y} \implies (m_2 - m_1)g = (m_2 - m_1)a_{2y} \implies a_{2y} = g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2

    Correct

    m1g−T=−m1a2y and m2g−T=m2a2y  ⟹  a2y=m2−m1m1+m2g=2.45 m/s2m_1 g - T = -m_1 a_{2y} \text{ and } m_2 g - T = m_2 a_{2y} \implies a_{2y} = \frac{m_2 - m_1}{m_1 + m_2}g = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2

    Your algebraic elimination of tension TT was executed correctly, but substituting the incorrect sign from Step 1 led to the unphysical result a2y=ga_{2y} = g.

  3. Step 3

    (m2−m1)g=(m1+m2)as  ⟹  as=5.00−3.005.00+3.00×9.80=2.45 m/s2(m_2 - m_1)g = (m_1 + m_2)a_s \implies a_s = \frac{5.00 - 3.00}{5.00 + 3.00} \times 9.80 = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2

  4. Step 4

    Assuming a1y=a2ya_{1y} = a_{2y} implies both masses accelerate downward together at free-fall acceleration gg, which would require the inextensible cord to stretch and become slack.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You set up and evaluated the 1D curvilinear equation of motion in Part (b) flawlessly.

You clearly explained the physical impossibility of both masses falling downward together in Part (c).

You applied Newton's second law with consistent gravitational and tension signs for both individual free-body diagrams in Part (a).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Constraint Sign Error in Independent Coordinate Systems

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You matched the acceleration magnitudes without projecting the physical displacement of each body onto its own chosen coordinate axis. When two axes both point downward, an upward motion of m1m_1 corresponds to a negative displacement rate (Δy1<0\Delta y_1 < 0) while m2m_2 moves in the positive direction (Δy2>0\Delta y_2 > 0), requiring a1y=−a2ya_{1y} = -a_{2y}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Kinematic Constraint from Fixed Length
  • Express the total string length in terms of position coordinates before relating accelerations.

  • Write y1+y2=constanty_1 + y_2 = \text{constant} and take the second time derivative y¨1+y¨2=0\ddot{y}_1 + \ddot{y}_2 = 0 to determine the exact sign relation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the geometric constraint: y1+y2+πR=Ly_1 + y_2 + \pi R = L.

  2. Differentiate twice: a1y+a2y=0  ⟹  a1y=−a2ya_{1y} + a_{2y} = 0 \implies a_{1y} = -a_{2y}.

  3. Substitute into m1m_1's equation: m1g−T=m1a1y=−m1a2y  ⟹  T=m1(g+a2y)m_1 g - T = m_1 a_{1y} = -m_1 a_{2y} \implies T = m_1(g + a_{2y}).

  4. Substitute into m2m_2's equation: m2g−m1(g+a2y)=m2a2y  ⟹  (m2−m1)g=(m1+m2)a2ym_2 g - m_1(g + a_{2y}) = m_2 a_{2y} \implies (m_2 - m_1)g = (m_1 + m_2)a_{2y}.

Final answer

a_{2y} = 5.00 kg−3.00 kg5.00 kg+3.00 kg\frac{5.00\text{ kg} - 3.00\text{ kg}}{5.00\text{ kg} + 3.00\text{ kg}}(9.80 m/s\text{ m/s}^2) = 2.45 m/s\text{ m/s}^2_

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the geometric position constraint L(y1,y2,… )=constantL(y_1, y_2, \dots) = \text{constant} before assigning acceleration signs.

  • Check whether your chosen positive directions point toward or away from the fixed pulley for each mass.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the opposing forces in the single-coordinate system and adds the gravitational forces instead of subtracting them.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    a1y=−a2y  ⟹  m1g−T=−m1a2y and m2g−T=m2a2y  ⟹  (m2−m1)g=(m1+m2)a2y  ⟹  a2y=5.00−3.005.00+3.00×9.80=2.45 m/s2a_{1y} = -a_{2y} \implies m_1 g - T = -m_1 a_{2y} \text{ and } m_2 g - T = m_2 a_{2y} \implies (m_2 - m_1)g = (m_1 + m_2)a_{2y} \implies a_{2y} = \frac{5.00 - 3.00}{5.00 + 3.00} \times 9.80 = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2

  2. Step 2

    (m1+m2)g=(m1+m2)as  ⟹  as=5.00+3.005.00+3.00×9.80=9.80 m/s2(m_1 + m_2)g = (m_1 + m_2)a_s \implies a_s = \frac{5.00 + 3.00}{5.00 + 3.00} \times 9.80 = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2

    Correct

    m2g−m1g=(m1+m2)as  ⟹  as=m2−m1m1+m2g=2.45 m/s2m_2 g - m_1 g = (m_1 + m_2)a_s \implies a_s = \frac{m_2 - m_1}{m_1 + m_2}g = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2

    Along the clockwise coordinate +s+s, gravity pulls m2m_2 in the positive direction (+m2g+m_2 g), but gravity on m1m_1 opposes the clockwise motion (−m1g-m_1 g). Because the two gravitational forces oppose each other along the string, the net external force along ss is (m2−m1)g(m_2 - m_1)g, not (m1+m2)g(m_1 + m_2)g.

  3. Step 3

    Setting a1y=a2ya_{1y} = a_{2y} requires both masses to accelerate downward simultaneously, which violates the condition that the string has a fixed length.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the relationship between a1ya_{1y} and a2ya_{2y} from the fixed length of the cord.

You correctly eliminated the tension TT to obtain the correct acceleration in part (a).

You provided a sound physical explanation in part (c) based on cord inextensibility.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Coordinate projection error in 1D curvilinear coordinates

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When using a single 1D coordinate ss traced along a string over a pulley, the positive direction curves over the pulley. A downward external force on one side points along +s+s, while a downward external force on the opposite side points along −s-s. You treated gravity on both masses as acting in the +s+s direction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Trace the positive sense along the cord
  • For a curvilinear coordinate ss directed clockwise, motion in +s+s means mass 1 moves upward and mass 2 moves downward.

  • Project every external force vector onto the local unit tangent t^s\hat{t}_s. If the force points opposite to the local +s+s direction, it must enter the net force sum with a negative sign.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the external force along the clockwise coordinate ss: gravity on m2m_2 acts downward (parallel to +s+s), contributing +m2g+m_2 g.

  2. Gravity on m1m_1 acts downward (opposite to +s+s, which goes upward for m1m_1), contributing −m1g-m_1 g.

  3. Sum the external forces along ss: ∑Fs=m2g−m1g=(m2−m1)g\sum F_s = m_2 g - m_1 g = (m_2 - m_1)g.

  4. Apply Newton's second law to the total mass: (m1+m2)as=(m2−m1)g(m_1 + m_2)a_s = (m_2 - m_1)g.

  5. Substitute numerical values: as=5.00 kg−3.00 kg5.00 kg+3.00 kg×9.80 m/s2=2.45 m/s2a_s = \frac{5.00\text{ kg} - 3.00\text{ kg}}{5.00\text{ kg} + 3.00\text{ kg}} \times 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2.

Final answer

as=2.45 m/s2a_s = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before writing ∑Fs\sum F_s, always draw the unit tangent arrow t^\hat{t} alongside each mass to verify whether downward is positive or negative for that specific mass.

  • Check your result against intuition: two hanging masses cannot both accelerate in free fall (g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2) because each partially balances the other.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cord over a fixed pulley connects mass mA=2.0 kgm_A = 2.0\text{ kg} and mass mB=6.0 kgm_B = 6.0\text{ kg}. Both coordinates yAy_A and yBy_B are measured downward from the pulley center. Write the constraint relation between aAya_{Ay} and aBya_{By}, and compute aBya_{By} using g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

Constraint: aAy+aBy=0  ⟹  aAy=−aBya_{Ay} + a_{By} = 0 \implies a_{Ay} = -a_{By}. Equations of motion: mAg−T=−mAaBym_A g - T = -m_A a_{By} and mBg−T=mBaBym_B g - T = m_B a_{By}. Subtracting gives (mB−mA)g=(mA+mB)aBy  ⟹  aBy=6.0−2.06.0+2.0(9.8)=4.9 m/s2(m_B - m_A)g = (m_A + m_B)a_{By} \implies a_{By} = \frac{6.0 - 2.0}{6.0 + 2.0}(9.8) = 4.9\text{ m/s}^2.

02

Block AA of mass 4.0 kg4.0\text{ kg} rests on a frictionless horizontal table and is attached to a cord that runs over a pulley at the table edge to hanging block BB of mass 1.0 kg1.0\text{ kg}. Define +x+x as rightward for block AA and +y+y as downward for block BB. (a) State the kinematic constraint between aAxa_{Ax} and aBya_{By}. (b) Calculate the acceleration of the system with g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

(a) Since cord length xA+yB=Lx_A + y_B = L, differentiating twice gives aAx+aBy=0a_{Ax} + a_{By} = 0 if positions are measured toward the corner, but measured from fixed origins along motion gives xA=yB  ⟹  aAx=aByx_A = y_B \implies a_{Ax} = a_{By}. (b) T=mAaT = m_A a and mBg−T=mBa  ⟹  a=mBgmA+mB=1.0×9.84.0+1.0=1.96 m/s2m_B g - T = m_B a \implies a = \frac{m_B g}{m_A + m_B} = \frac{1.0 \times 9.8}{4.0 + 1.0} = 1.96\text{ m/s}^2.

03

In a movable pulley system, mass m1m_1 hangs from a fixed cord looped through a movable pulley carrying mass m2m_2, with the other end anchored to the ceiling. If y1y_1 and y2y_2 are both measured downward from the ceiling, write the length constraint equation and find the relation between accelerations a1ya_{1y} and a2ya_{2y}.

Answer

The cord length consists of one strand to m1m_1 and two strands supporting the movable pulley: y1+2y2=constanty_1 + 2y_2 = \text{constant}. Differentiating twice with respect to time yields a1y+2a2y=0a_{1y} + 2a_{2y} = 0, or a1y=−2a2ya_{1y} = -2a_{2y}.

Loading workspace…