Resources

An ultra-massive interstellar probe of mass MM moves at initial velocity vi=+12.0 km/sv_i = +12.0\text{ km/s} along the +x+x-axis and collides head-on elastically with a microscopic stationary space dust particle of mass mm (v2i=0 km/sv_{2i} = 0\text{ km/s}), where m≪Mm \ll M. (a) Derive the asymptotic limit expression for the dust particle's final velocity v2fv_{2f} as the mass ratio mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0. (b) Using this asymptotic expression, evaluate the numerical value of v2fv_{2f} in km/s\text{km/s}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) v2f=2viv_{2f} = 2v_i; (b) v2f=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = +24.0\text{ km/s}

Steps

Part (a): Derivation of the Asymptotic Limit for v2fv_{2f}

In a one-dimensional elastic collision between two bodies of masses MM (probe) and mm (dust particle), both total linear momentum and total mechanical energy are conserved:

  1. Conservation of Linear Momentum: Mvi+mv2i=Mv1f+mv2fM v_i + m v_{2i} = M v_{1f} + m v_{2f}
  2. Elastic Collision Relation (Relative Speed): The relative velocity of separation equals the negative of the relative velocity of approach: v2f−v1f=−(v2i−vi)=vi−v2iv_{2f} - v_{1f} = -(v_{2i} - v_i) = v_i - v_{2i}

Solving this system of equations for the final velocity of the second mass (v2fv_{2f}) yields the standard elastic collision formula: v2f=2MM+mvi+m−MM+mv2iv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M + m}v_i + \frac{m - M}{M + m}v_{2i}

Given that the dust particle is initially stationary (v2i=0 km/sv_{2i} = 0\text{ km/s}), the expression simplifies to: v2f=2MM+mviv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M + m}v_i

To find the asymptotic limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0, divide the numerator and denominator by MM: v2f=21+mMviv_{2f} = \frac{2}{1 + \frac{m}{M}}v_i

Taking the limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0: lim⁡mM→0v2f=21+0vi=2vi\lim_{\frac{m}{M} \to 0} v_{2f} = \frac{2}{1 + 0}v_i = 2v_i

Thus, the asymptotic expression is: v2f=2viv_{2f} = 2v_i

(Intuitive check via reference frames: In the rest frame of the massive probe, the dust particle approaches at speed viv_i. Because M≫mM \gg m, the probe acts like a massive stationary wall, reflecting the particle elastically backward at speed viv_i relative to the probe. Transforming back to the lab frame, the dust particle's speed is vi+vi=2viv_i + v_i = 2v_i.)


Part (b): Numerical Evaluation

Substitute the given initial velocity of the probe, vi=+12.0 km/sv_i = +12.0\text{ km/s}, into the derived asymptotic formula: v2f=2(+12.0 km/s)=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = 2(+12.0\text{ km/s}) = +24.0\text{ km/s}

Common Pitfall: A common mistake is to assume the light particle merely matches the speed of the massive object (v2f=viv_{2f} = v_i). In an elastic collision, the particle does not stick to the probe; instead, it is reflected forward with respect to the probe's frame of reference, resulting in exactly twice the probe's speed.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the final velocity of the struck light particle with that of the massive projectile, mistakenly assuming the particle simply moves off at the incoming probe's velocity vᵢ.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    v2f=2MM+mviv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m}v_i

  2. Step 2

    As \text{As } mM\frac{m}{M} →\to 0, \text{, } m  is negligible so \text{ is negligible so } v_{2f} = MM\frac{M}{M}v_i = v_i_

    Correct

    \lim_{mM\frac{m}{M} →\to 0} v_{2f} = \lim_{mM\frac{m}{M} →\to 0} 21+mM\frac{2}{1 + \frac{m}{M}}v_i = 2v_i_

    When setting m→0m \to 0 in the denominator M+mM + m, the numerator remains 2M2M, yielding 2MMvi=2vi\frac{2M}{M}v_i = 2v_i. You dropped the factor of 22 from the numerator and wrote MMvi=vi\frac{M}{M}v_i = v_i instead.

  3. Step 3

    v2f=vi=+12.0 km/sv_{2f} = v_i = +12.0\text{ km/s}

    Correct

    v2f=2vi=2(+12.0 km/s)=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = 2v_i = 2(+12.0\text{ km/s}) = +24.0\text{ km/s}

    Your substitution is consistent with your incorrect asymptotic expression from Step 2, but the correct result requires multiplying by 22.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and wrote down the standard 1D elastic collision formula for the struck mass with v2i=0v_{2i} = 0.

You recognized that the condition m≪Mm \ll M means evaluating the asymptotic behavior as the mass ratio mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0.

You carried your derived expression consistently into Part (b) to calculate a numerical value.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic Limit Error in Collision Asymptotics

Dropping the coefficient 22 in the numerator when taking the limit of 2MM+m\frac{2M}{M+m} as m→0m \to 0.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You likely confused the final velocity of the struck microscopic particle (v2f→2viv_{2f} \to 2v_i) with that of the massive projectile (v1f=M−mM+mvi→viv_{1f} = \frac{M-m}{M+m}v_i \to v_i), or accidentally simplified the 2M2M in the numerator to MM when setting m≈0m \approx 0. In an elastic collision, an ultra-massive projectile acts as a moving wall that reflects the light particle at twice the incoming speed in the lab frame.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Numerator Preservation During Limits
  • When finding lim⁡m/M→02MM+m\lim_{m/M \to 0} \frac{2M}{M+m}, divide numerator and denominator by MM: 21+m/M\frac{2}{1 + m/M}.

  • Always factor out the dominant mass MM explicitly before taking the limit so coefficients in the numerator are never dropped.

Center-of-Mass / Moving-Wall Intuition
  • In the frame of an ultra-massive object moving at vv, a stationary particle approaches at −v-v and bounces back elastically at +v+v.

  • Transform back to the lab frame by adding the object's velocity: vfinal=vrel+v=v+v=2vv_{\text{final}} = v_{\text{rel}} + v = v + v = 2v.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide the numerator and denominator of v2f=2MM+mviv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m}v_i by MM: v2f=21+mMviv_{2f} = \frac{2}{1 + \frac{m}{M}}v_i

  2. Take the limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0: v2f=21+0vi=2viv_{2f} = \frac{2}{1 + 0}v_i = 2v_i

  3. Substitute vi=+12.0 km/sv_i = +12.0\text{ km/s} into the corrected formula: v2f=2(+12.0 km/s)=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = 2(+12.0\text{ km/s}) = +24.0\text{ km/s}

Final answer

(a) v2f=2viv_{2f} = 2v_i; (b) v2f=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = +24.0\text{ km/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review one-dimensional elastic collisions using relative velocity and moving reference frames to build intuition for the factor of 22.

  • Practice dividing through by the dominant variable when taking asymptotic limits of rational functions to avoid dropping leading coefficients.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misremembers the elastic collision formula by dropping the factor of 2 in the numerator for the stationary target's velocity, obtaining v₂f = [M / (M + m)] * vᵢ.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    v2f=MM+mviv_{2f} = \frac{M}{M+m} v_i

    Correct

    v2f=2MM+mviv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m} v_i

    In an elastic collision with a stationary target, conservation of momentum and mechanical energy yields a numerator factor of 2M2M rather than MM for the second body's final velocity.

  2. Step 2

    v2f=11+mMvi  ⟹  Taking limit mM→0:v2f=viv_{2f} = \frac{1}{1 + \frac{m}{M}} v_i \implies \text{Taking limit } \frac{m}{M} \to 0: v_{2f} = v_i

    Correct

    v2f=21+mMvi  ⟹  lim⁡mM→0v2f=2viv_{2f} = \frac{2}{1 + \frac{m}{M}} v_i \implies \lim_{\frac{m}{M} \to 0} v_{2f} = 2v_i

    Your algebraic technique of dividing through by MM and evaluating the limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0 was completely correct, but the missing factor of 22 carried over from the starting formula.

  3. Step 3

    v2f=+12.0 km/sv_{2f} = +12.0\text{ km/s}

    Correct

    v2f=2(+12.0 km/s)=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = 2(+12.0\text{ km/s}) = +24.0\text{ km/s}

    You correctly substituted your derived formula, but because the formula was missing the factor of 22, the resulting numerical velocity was half of the true value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized the need to express the velocity in terms of the mass ratio mM\frac{m}{M}.

You evaluated the asymptotic limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0 correctly based on your algebraic expression.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula recall error

You omitted the factor of 22 in the numerator of the elastic collision velocity formula for a stationary target.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the coefficient for a completely inelastic collision (where objects stick together and move at vf=MM+mviv_f = \frac{M}{M+m}v_i) with an elastic collision (where kinetic energy is conserved and the light particle rebounds forward at v2f=2MM+mviv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m}v_i).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Elastic vs. Inelastic Limit
  • In a completely inelastic collision with a stationary target, vf=MM+mvi→viv_f = \frac{M}{M+m}v_i \to v_i. In an elastic collision, relative speed of separation equals relative speed of approach, giving v2f=2MM+mvi→2viv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m}v_i \to 2v_i.

  • Check the collision type: if kinetic energy is conserved, the lighter target must rebound away faster than the projectile, reaching nearly 2vi2v_i in the lab frame.

Reference Frame Sanity Check
  • In the heavy projectile's rest frame, the projectile is like an immovable wall. The dust particle approaches at speed viv_i and bounces elastically backward at speed viv_i.

  • Transform back to the lab frame by adding the projectile's velocity: v2f=vi+vi=2viv_{2f} = v_i + v_i = 2v_i.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the general 1D elastic collision formula for mass mm initially at rest (v2i=0v_{2i} = 0): v2f=2MM+mviv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M + m}v_i.

  2. Divide the numerator and denominator by MM: v2f=21+mMviv_{2f} = \frac{2}{1 + \frac{m}{M}}v_i.

  3. Take the asymptotic limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0: lim⁡mM→0v2f=2vi\lim_{\frac{m}{M} \to 0} v_{2f} = 2v_i.

  4. Substitute vi=+12.0 km/sv_i = +12.0\text{ km/s} into the asymptotic limit: v2f=2(+12.0 km/s)=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = 2(+12.0\text{ km/s}) = +24.0\text{ km/s}.

Final answer

(a) v2f=2viv_{2f} = 2v_i; (b) v2f=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = +24.0\text{ km/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the elastic collision equations for a stationary target: v1f=m1−m2m1+m2v1iv_{1f} = \frac{m_1 - m_2}{m_1 + m_2}v_{1i} and v2f=2m1m1+m2v1iv_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}v_{1i}.

  • Practice using the moving reference frame shortcut to verify limiting collision cases intuitively without memorizing long formulas.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student models the head-on collision as completely inelastic rather than elastic, using conservation of momentum alone to conclude both masses stick together.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    M⋅vi=(M+m)⋅v2fM \cdot v_i = (M+m) \cdot v_{2f}

    Correct

    Mvi=Mv1f+mv2f and v2f−v1f=vi  ⟹  v2f=2MM+mviM v_i = M v_{1f} + m v_{2f} \text{ and } v_{2f} - v_{1f} = v_i \implies v_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m}v_i

    You assumed both objects stick together and share a single final velocity v2fv_{2f}, which describes a completely inelastic collision. Because the problem states that the collision is elastic, kinetic energy is conserved alongside momentum, meaning the relative speed of separation equals the relative speed of approach.

  2. Step 2

    v2f=MM+m⋅vi=11+m/M⋅vi  ⟹  As m/M→0, v2f=viv_{2f} = \frac{M}{M+m} \cdot v_i = \frac{1}{1 + m/M} \cdot v_i \implies \text{As } m/M \to 0,\, v_{2f} = v_i

    Correct

    lim⁡mM→0v2f=lim⁡mM→021+mMvi=2vi\lim_{\frac{m}{M} \to 0} v_{2f} = \lim_{\frac{m}{M} \to 0} \frac{2}{1 + \frac{m}{M}} v_i = 2v_i

    Your algebraic step dividing by MM and taking the limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0 was executed cleanly, but the missing factor of 22 from the elastic collision formula propagated into your final expression.

  3. Step 3

    v2f=+12.0 km/sv_{2f} = +12.0\text{ km/s}

    Correct

    v2f=2(+12.0 km/s)=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = 2(+12.0\text{ km/s}) = +24.0\text{ km/s}

    You substituted the initial velocity into your derived expression correctly, but because the formula was missing the factor of 22, your numerical result is half of the true value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that linear momentum is conserved during the collision.

You correctly rewrote the rational expression in terms of the mass ratio mM\frac{m}{M} before evaluating the asymptotic limit.

You properly substituted the given numerical value vi=+12.0 km/sv_i = +12.0\text{ km/s} into your derived expression.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inelastic collision formula used instead of elastic collision

You set up (M+m)v2f(M+m)v_{2f} as the final momentum, treating the two objects as sticking together rather than bouncing apart elastically.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the collision as completely inelastic by equating final velocities instead of using the relative velocity condition for elastic collisions, where v2f−v1f=−(v2i−v1i)v_{2f} - v_{1f} = -(v_{2i} - v_{1i}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check collision type and kinetic energy
  • Elastic collisions conserve both linear momentum and mechanical kinetic energy (vsep=vappv_{\text{sep}} = v_{\text{app}}); completely inelastic collisions stick together with a single shared final velocity.

  • Always check whether the problem specifies 'elastic' or 'inelastic' before writing the final momentum term.

Use reference frame intuition for massive-light collisions
  • In the rest frame of an ultra-massive object (M≫mM \gg m), an elastic collision acts like reflection off a moving wall: the light particle bounces back at its approach speed relative to the wall.

  • Relative to the probe, the dust particle approaches at −vi-v_i and rebounds at +vi+v_i. In the lab frame, its velocity is vi+vi=2viv_i + v_i = 2v_i.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply both conservation of momentum and the elastic relative-speed condition: v2f−v1f=vi−0=viv_{2f} - v_{1f} = v_i - 0 = v_i, which gives v1f=v2f−viv_{1f} = v_{2f} - v_i.

  2. Substitute v1fv_{1f} into the momentum equation: Mvi=M(v2f−vi)+mv2f  ⟹  2Mvi=(M+m)v2fM v_i = M(v_{2f} - v_i) + m v_{2f} \implies 2M v_i = (M+m) v_{2f}.

  3. Solve for v2fv_{2f}: v2f=2MM+mvi=21+mMviv_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m} v_i = \frac{2}{1 + \frac{m}{M}} v_i.

  4. Evaluate the limit as mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0: v2f=2viv_{2f} = 2v_i.

  5. Substitute vi=+12.0 km/sv_i = +12.0\text{ km/s}: v2f=2(+12.0 km/s)=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = 2(+12.0\text{ km/s}) = +24.0\text{ km/s}.

Final answer

(a) v2f=2viv_{2f} = 2v_i; (b) v2f=+24.0 km/sv_{2f} = +24.0\text{ km/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between elastic collisions (where kinetic energy is conserved and objects bounce) and completely inelastic collisions (where objects stick together).

  • Practice using the relative speed equation v2f−v1f=−(v2i−v1i)v_{2f} - v_{1f} = -(v_{2i} - v_{1i}) to quickly solve 1D elastic collision problems without squaring velocities.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A spacecraft of mass M=5000 kgM = 5000\text{ kg} traveling at +15.0 km/s+15.0\text{ km/s} collides elastically head-on with a stationary micrometeoroid of mass m=0.02 gm = 0.02\text{ g}. What are the approximate final velocities of (a) the spacecraft and (b) the micrometeoroid?

Answer

(a) v1f≈+15.0 km/sv_{1f} \approx +15.0\text{ km/s} (its velocity is virtually unchanged because M≫mM \gg m). (b) v2f≈2vi=2(+15.0 km/s)=+30.0 km/sv_{2f} \approx 2v_i = 2(+15.0\text{ km/s}) = +30.0\text{ km/s}.

02

A particle of mass mm moving at +10 m/s+10\text{ m/s} strikes an immovable stationary wall (M→∞M \to \infty) elastically head-on. Now consider the wall moving toward the particle at +4 m/s+4\text{ m/s}. What is the final velocity of the particle after the collision?

Answer

In the wall's frame, the particle approaches at 10−(−4)=14 m/s10 - (-4) = 14\text{ m/s} (or relative speed of approach is 14 m/s14\text{ m/s}). It rebounds at 14 m/s14\text{ m/s} relative to the wall in the direction of the wall's motion. Transforming back to the lab frame: vf=+4 m/s+14 m/s=+18 m/sv_f = +4\text{ m/s} + 14\text{ m/s} = +18\text{ m/s} (in the direction of the wall's motion).

03

A heavy object of mass MM moves at velocity v1v_1 and collides elastically head-on with a light particle of mass mm (m≪Mm \ll M) already moving at velocity v2v_2 in the same direction (v1>v2v_1 > v_2). Derive the asymptotic final velocity v2fv_{2f} of the light particle in terms of v1v_1 and v2v_2.

Answer

From the general elastic formula, v2f=2MM+mv1+m−MM+mv2v_{2f} = \frac{2M}{M+m}v_1 + \frac{m-M}{M+m}v_2. Dividing through by MM and letting mM→0\frac{m}{M} \to 0, we get v2f→2v1−v2v_{2f} \to 2v_1 - v_2. (Check: if v2=0v_2 = 0, v2f=2v1v_{2f} = 2v_1. If v2=v1v_2 = v_1, no collision occurs and v2f=v1v_{2f} = v_1.)

Loading workspace…