Resources

An illuminated object is placed along the principal axis of a thin converging lens of focal length f=+16.0 cmf = +16.0\text{ cm}. Consider the asymptotic behavior of the image distance did_i and lateral magnification mm: (a) Evaluate lim⁡do→∞di\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i and the corresponding limiting value of mm; (b) Determine the one-sided limit of image distance lim⁡do→f+di\lim_{d_o \to f^+} d_i as the object approaches the focal point from the left, and (c) determine the one-sided limit lim⁡do→f−di\lim_{d_o \to f^-} d_i as the object approaches the focal point from inside the focal length.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) lim⁡do→∞di=+16.0 cm\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i = +16.0\text{ cm} and lim⁡do→∞m=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} m = 0; (b) lim⁡do→16.0+di=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} d_i = +\infty; (c) lim⁡do→16.0−di=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} d_i = -\infty

Steps

Limit as do→∞d_o \to \infty

To analyze the asymptotic behavior of the image formed by a thin converging lens, we apply the thin lens equation and the definition of lateral magnification.

Governing Equations

For a thin lens with focal length ff: 1do+1di=1f\frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} Rearranging this formula to express the image distance did_i explicitly as a function of the object distance dod_o: di=fdodo−fd_i = \frac{f d_o}{d_o - f} The lateral magnification mm is given by: m=−dido=−fdo−fm = -\frac{d_i}{d_o} = -\frac{f}{d_o - f} Here, the focal length is f=+16.0 cmf = +16.0\text{ cm}.

Step-by-Step Derivation

Substitute f=16.0 cmf = 16.0\text{ cm} into the expressions and take the limit as the object distance approaches infinity: lim⁡do→∞di=lim⁡do→∞16.0dodo−16.0=lim⁡do→∞16.01−16.0do=16.01−0=+16.0 cm\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i = \lim_{d_o \to \infty} \frac{16.0 d_o}{d_o - 16.0} = \lim_{d_o \to \infty} \frac{16.0}{1 - \frac{16.0}{d_o}} = \frac{16.0}{1 - 0} = +16.0\text{ cm}

Similarly, for the lateral magnification: lim⁡do→∞m=lim⁡do→∞(−16.0do−16.0)=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} m = \lim_{d_o \to \infty} \left(-\frac{16.0}{d_o - 16.0}\right) = 0

Physical Interpretation: Light rays originating from an infinitely distant object arrive essentially parallel to the principal axis and converge at the focal point on the opposite side, producing an infinitesimally small (point-like) real image.


One-sided Limit as do→f+d_o \to f^+ (do→16.0+d_o \to 16.0^+)

When the object approaches the focal point from the outside (do>fd_o > f): do−16.0→0+d_o - 16.0 \to 0^+

Evaluating the limit: lim⁡do→16.0+di=lim⁡do→16.0+16.0⋅dodo−16.0=16.0⋅16.00+=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} d_i = \lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} \frac{16.0 \cdot d_o}{d_o - 16.0} = \frac{16.0 \cdot 16.0}{0^+} = +\infty

Physical Interpretation: As the object gets arbitrarily close to the front focal point from the outside, the refracted rays on the right side of the lens become nearly parallel, forming an infinitely enlarged real image infinitely far to the right (+∞+\infty).


One-sided Limit as do→f−d_o \to f^- (do→16.0−d_o \to 16.0^-)

When the object approaches the focal point from inside the focal length (do<fd_o < f): do−16.0→0−d_o - 16.0 \to 0^-

Evaluating the limit: lim⁡do→16.0−di=lim⁡do→16.0−16.0⋅dodo−16.0=16.0⋅16.00−=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} d_i = \lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} \frac{16.0 \cdot d_o}{d_o - 16.0} = \frac{16.0 \cdot 16.0}{0^-} = -\infty

Physical Interpretation: When the object is inside the focal point, the refracted rays diverge on the right side of the lens. Their backward projections meet on the same side as the object (virtual image, indicated by a negative image distance). As the object approaches the focal point from within, these virtual rays become parallel, placing the virtual image at −∞-\infty.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the direction of the one-sided limit and treats approaching f from inside the focal length as giving positive infinity instead of negative infinity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1di=1f−1do  ⟹  As do→∞, 1do→0, so di=f=+16.0 cm  ⟹  m=−dido=−16.0∞=0\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_o} \implies \text{As } d_o \to \infty,\, \frac{1}{d_o} \to 0,\, \text{so } d_i = f = +16.0\text{ cm} \implies m = -\frac{d_i}{d_o} = -\frac{16.0}{\infty} = 0

  2. Step 2

    di=f⋅dodo−f  ⟹  As do→f+, do−f→0+  ⟹  di→+∞d_i = \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f} \implies \text{As } d_o \to f^+,\, d_o - f \to 0^+ \implies d_i \to +\infty

  3. Step 3

    di=f⋅dodo−f  ⟹  As do approaches f, the denominator goes to 0  ⟹  di→+∞d_i = \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f} \implies \text{As } d_o \text{ approaches } f,\, \text{the denominator goes to } 0 \implies d_i \to +\infty

    Correct

    lim⁡do→16.0−di=lim⁡do→16.0−f⋅dodo−f=16.0⋅16.00−=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} d_i = \lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f} = \frac{16.0 \cdot 16.0}{0^-} = -\infty

    When approaching the focal length from inside (do<fd_o < f), the quantity do−fd_o - f is negative. Therefore, the denominator approaches 0−0^-, making the limit −∞-\infty rather than +∞+\infty.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly manipulated the thin lens equation into an explicit form for the image distance.

You evaluated the infinite-distance limits for both image distance and magnification accurately in part (a).

You correctly tracked the positive sign of the one-sided limit denominator in part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
One-sided limit sign error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You omitted the directional sign of the one-sided limit in part (c). When an object is placed inside the focal length (do<fd_o < f), the image formed is virtual, corresponding to di<0d_i < 0. Approaching ff from the left (do→f−d_o \to f^-) means do−f<0d_o - f < 0, giving a denominator of 0−0^- and yielding di→−∞d_i \to -\infty.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate the sign of approaching infinitesimals
  • If x→a−x \to a^-, then x<ax < a and x−a→0−x - a \to 0^-.

  • Always write down whether the denominator tends to 0+0^+ or 0−0^- before computing the final infinite limit.

Connect the mathematical sign to physical optics
  • For a single thin lens, di>0d_i > 0 denotes a real image (formed on the transmission side), whereas di<0d_i < 0 denotes a virtual image (formed on the incident side).

  • Check whether the object position creates real refracted rays or diverging rays whose projections form a virtual image.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Consider the left-hand limit where do→f−d_o \to f^- (do<16.0 cmd_o < 16.0\text{ cm}).

  2. Determine the sign of the denominator: since do<fd_o < f, do−f→0−d_o - f \to 0^-.

  3. Compute the ratio: lim⁡do→16.0−16.0⋅dodo−16.0=256.00−=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} \frac{16.0 \cdot d_o}{d_o - 16.0} = \frac{256.0}{0^-} = -\infty.

Final answer

(a) lim⁡do→∞di=+16.0 cm\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i = +16.0\text{ cm} and lim⁡do→∞m=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} m = 0; (b) lim⁡do→16.0+di=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} d_i = +\infty; (c) lim⁡do→16.0−di=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} d_i = -\infty

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying one-sided limit signs (0+0^+ vs 0−0^-) when rational functions have vertical asymptotes.

  • Review ray diagrams for an object located inside the focal point of a converging lens to visualize why the image is virtual (di<0d_i < 0).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly uses an addition formula d_i = f - d_o or confuses focal distance with image distance when taking limits.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1di=1f−1do=116.0−0  ⟹  di=+16.0 cm  ⟹  m=−dido→0\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_o} = \frac{1}{16.0} - 0 \implies d_i = +16.0\text{ cm} \implies m = -\frac{d_i}{d_o} \to 0

  2. Step 2

    1di=1f−1do  ⟹  As do→f+,1do→1f  ⟹  1di=1f−1f=0, so di=0\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_o} \implies \text{As } d_o \to f^+, \frac{1}{d_o} \to \frac{1}{f} \implies \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{f} = 0, \text{ so } d_i = 0

    Correct

    lim⁡do→16.0+di=lim⁡do→16.0+fdodo−f=16.0⋅16.00+=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} d_i = \lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} \frac{f d_o}{d_o - f} = \frac{16.0 \cdot 16.0}{0^+} = +\infty

    When 1di→0+\frac{1}{d_i} \to 0^+, taking the reciprocal means di→+∞d_i \to +\infty, not 00. Physically, rays from an object near the focal point emerge nearly parallel, forming an image at infinity.

  3. Step 3

    1di=1f−1do  ⟹  As do→f−,1di→0  ⟹  di=0\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_o} \implies \text{As } d_o \to f^-, \frac{1}{d_i} \to 0 \implies d_i = 0

    Correct

    lim⁡do→16.0−di=lim⁡do→16.0−fdodo−f=16.0⋅16.00−=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} d_i = \lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} \frac{f d_o}{d_o - f} = \frac{16.0 \cdot 16.0}{0^-} = -\infty

    When do<fd_o < f, do−f<0d_o - f < 0, so 1di=1f−1do→0−\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_o} \to 0^-. Taking the reciprocal gives di→−∞d_i \to -\infty (a virtual image infinitely far behind the lens), not 00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and rearranged the thin lens formula 1di=1f−1do\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_o}.

You evaluated the limit at infinity correctly for both image distance and magnification.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reciprocal Limit Inversion Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated 1di→0\frac{1}{d_i} \to 0 as implying di→0d_i \to 0 rather than taking the reciprocal lim⁡x→0±1x=±∞\lim_{x \to 0^\pm} \frac{1}{x} = \pm \infty.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reciprocal Limit Property
  • If lim⁡g(x)=0\lim g(x) = 0, then lim⁡1g(x)=±∞\lim \frac{1}{g(x)} = \pm \infty, not 00.

  • Always track the sign of the denominator when inverting: 10+=+∞\frac{1}{0^+} = +\infty and 10−=−∞\frac{1}{0^-} = -\infty.

Optical Behavior at the Focal Point
  • An object placed at the focal point produces parallel refracted rays that never converge at a finite distance.

  • Remember that as an object nears ff, the image distance must blow up to infinity (∣di∣→∞|d_i| \to \infty), not collapse to zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express did_i explicitly in terms of dod_o: di=fdodo−fd_i = \frac{f d_o}{d_o - f}.

  2. Evaluate the one-sided limit as do→16.0+d_o \to 16.0^+: since do−16.0→0+d_o - 16.0 \to 0^+, we have di→16.0×16.00+=+∞d_i \to \frac{16.0 \times 16.0}{0^+} = +\infty.

  3. Evaluate the one-sided limit as do→16.0−d_o \to 16.0^-: since do−16.0→0−d_o - 16.0 \to 0^-, we have di→16.0×16.00−=−∞d_i \to \frac{16.0 \times 16.0}{0^-} = -\infty.

Final answer

(a) lim⁡do→∞di=+16.0 cm,  lim⁡do→∞m=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i = +16.0\text{ cm},\; \lim_{d_o \to \infty} m = 0; (b) lim⁡do→16.0+di=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} d_i = +\infty; (c) lim⁡do→16.0−di=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} d_i = -\infty

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review one-sided limits involving division by zero: distinguish between approaching 0+0^+ and 0−0^-.

  • Practice sketching ray diagrams for an object just outside ff versus just inside ff to build physical intuition for ±∞\pm\infty.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the limit of magnification as d_o approaches infinity with 1 instead of 0.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    di=f⋅dodo−f  ⟹  As do→∞,  di=f=+16.0 cmd_i = \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f} \implies \text{As } d_o \to \infty,\; d_i = f = +16.0\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    m=−dido,  but at infinity m=−1m = -\frac{d_i}{d_o},\; \text{but at infinity } m = -1

    Correct

    lim⁡do→∞m=lim⁡do→∞(−dido)=−16.0 cm∞=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} m = \lim_{d_o \to \infty} \left(-\frac{d_i}{d_o}\right) = -\frac{16.0\text{ cm}}{\infty} = 0

    At infinity, the image distance did_i approaches a finite value (+16.0 cm+16.0\text{ cm}), not infinity. Dividing a finite number by an arbitrarily large dod_o yields 00, representing a point-like image.

  3. Step 3

    As do→f+,  do−f→0+  ⟹  di→+∞\text{As } d_o \to f^+,\; d_o - f \to 0^+ \implies d_i \to +\infty

  4. Step 4

    As do→f−,  do−f→0−  ⟹  di→−∞\text{As } d_o \to f^-,\; d_o - f \to 0^- \implies d_i \to -\infty

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the thin lens formula explicitly for image distance did_i.

You found the correct asymptotic image distance of +16.0 cm+16.0\text{ cm} for an infinitely distant object.

You carefully evaluated the signs of the one-sided limits around the focal point.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Magnification limit at infinity

You treated di/dod_i / d_o as a ratio of comparable quantities approaching infinity rather than dividing the finite focal length by an infinite object distance.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the asymptotic behaviors of did_i and dod_o: because parallel incoming rays focus into a point on the focal plane, the image size shrinks to zero, which means lim⁡do→∞m=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} m = 0.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate Numerator vs. Denominator Limits Separately
  • For lateral magnification m=−didom = -\frac{d_i}{d_o}, substitute the limiting value of each variable before concluding.

  • Check that lim⁡do→∞di=f\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i = f is finite. Since finite∞=0\frac{\text{finite}}{\infty} = 0, the limiting magnification must be 00.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the lateral magnification formula: m=−dido=−fdo−fm = -\frac{d_i}{d_o} = -\frac{f}{d_o - f}.

  2. Substitute f=16.0 cmf = 16.0\text{ cm} and take the limit: lim⁡do→∞(−16.0do−16.0)=−16.0∞=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} \left(-\frac{16.0}{d_o - 16.0}\right) = -\frac{16.0}{\infty} = 0.

Final answer

(a) lim⁡do→∞di=+16.0 cm\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i = +16.0\text{ cm} and lim⁡do→∞m=0\lim_{d_o \to \infty} m = 0; (b) lim⁡do→16.0+di=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^+} d_i = +\infty; (c) lim⁡do→16.0−di=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 16.0^-} d_i = -\infty

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice expressing mm directly in terms of dod_o and ff as m=−fdo−fm = -\frac{f}{d_o - f} to avoid treating did_i and dod_o as independent variables in limits.

  • Connect the mathematical limit m→0m \to 0 to the physical picture of distant stars forming point-like images at the focal point.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A thin converging lens has a focal length of f=+10.0 cmf = +10.0\text{ cm}. Calculate the one-sided limit of the lateral magnification lim⁡do→10.0−m\lim_{d_o \to 10.0^-} m.

Answer

Using m=−fdo−fm = -\frac{f}{d_o - f}, as do→10.0−d_o \to 10.0^-, the denominator satisfies do−10.0→0−d_o - 10.0 \to 0^-. Therefore, lim⁡do→10.0−m=−10.00−=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 10.0^-} m = -\frac{10.0}{0^-} = +\infty. The image is upright and infinitely magnified.

02

A diverging lens has a focal length of f=−20.0 cmf = -20.0\text{ cm}. Determine lim⁡do→0+di\lim_{d_o \to 0^+} d_i and lim⁡do→∞di\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i. Does this lens ever produce an infinite image distance for a real object?

Answer

From di=fdodo−f=−20dodo+20d_i = \frac{f d_o}{d_o - f} = \frac{-20 d_o}{d_o + 20}:

  1. lim⁡do→0+di=0 cm\lim_{d_o \to 0^+} d_i = 0\text{ cm}.
  2. lim⁡do→∞di=−20.0 cm\lim_{d_o \to \infty} d_i = -20.0\text{ cm}. Because do+20>0d_o + 20 > 0 for all real objects (do>0d_o > 0), the denominator never equals zero; hence did_i is never infinite for a real object.
03

A concave spherical mirror with focal length f=+15.0 cmf = +15.0\text{ cm} obeys the mirror equation 1do+1di=1f\frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f}. Describe the behavior and sign of the image distance did_i as a real object moves continuously from do=15.1 cmd_o = 15.1\text{ cm} to do=14.9 cmd_o = 14.9\text{ cm} through the focal point.

Answer

Using di=15dodo−15d_i = \frac{15 d_o}{d_o - 15}: At do=15.1 cmd_o = 15.1\text{ cm} (do>fd_o > f), di=15(15.1)+0.1=+2265 cmd_i = \frac{15(15.1)}{+0.1} = +2265\text{ cm} (a distant real image). As do→15+d_o \to 15^+, di→+∞d_i \to +\infty. As do→15−d_o \to 15^-, di→−∞d_i \to -\infty. At do=14.9 cmd_o = 14.9\text{ cm} (do<fd_o < f), di=15(14.9)−0.1=−2235 cmd_i = \frac{15(14.9)}{-0.1} = -2235\text{ cm} (a distant virtual image behind the mirror). The image flips discontinuously from +∞+\infty to −∞-\infty.

Loading workspace…