Resources

A circuit consists of an ideal 36.0 V36.0\text{ V} power supply connected to a network of four resistors. Resistor RA=15.0 ΩR_A = 15.0\,\Omega is connected in series with a parallel branch. The parallel branch consists of two paths: Path 1 contains a single resistor RB=60.0 ΩR_B = 60.0\,\Omega, and Path 2 contains two series resistors RC=40.0 ΩR_C = 40.0\,\Omega and RD=20.0 ΩR_D = 20.0\,\Omega. Rather than calculating the total current, determine the ratio of the electrical power dissipated in resistor RBR_B to the electrical power dissipated in resistor RDR_D, expressed as PBPD\frac{P_B}{P_D}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

PBPD=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = 1.50 (or 3:23:2)

Steps

01

Determine the Resistance of Each Parallel Branch

The circuit features resistor RAR_A in series with a parallel network consisting of two paths:

  • Path 1: Contains solely resistor RBR_B: RPath 1=RB=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 1}} = R_B = 60.0\,\Omega
  • Path 2: Contains resistors RCR_C and RDR_D connected in series: RPath 2=RC+RD=40.0 Ω+20.0 Ω=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 2}} = R_C + R_D = 40.0\,\Omega + 20.0\,\Omega = 60.0\,\Omega
02

Determine Current Distribution Without Calculating Total Current

Because Path 1 and Path 2 are connected in parallel, the potential difference across both branches is identical (VparallelV_{\text{parallel}}).

Using Ohm's law (I=VRI = \frac{V}{R}): IPath 1=VparallelRPath 1=Vparallel60.0 ΩI_{\text{Path 1}} = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}}{R_{\text{Path 1}}} = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}}{60.0\,\Omega} IPath 2=VparallelRPath 2=Vparallel60.0 ΩI_{\text{Path 2}} = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}}{R_{\text{Path 2}}} = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}}{60.0\,\Omega}

Since the equivalent resistances of the two branches are equal (60.0 Ω60.0\,\Omega), the current divides equally between them: IPath 1=IPath 2=II_{\text{Path 1}} = I_{\text{Path 2}} = I

Because RCR_C and RDR_D are in series within Path 2, the current through each of them is also equal to II.

03

Compute the Power Ratio

The electrical power dissipated in a resistor carrying current II is given by Joule's heating law: P=I2RP = I^2 R

For resistor RBR_B in Path 1: PB=I2RB=I2(60.0 Ω)P_B = I^2 R_B = I^2 (60.0\,\Omega)

For the components in Path 2 carrying the same current II, power is directly proportional to resistance:

  • In the circuit analysis leading to the standard solution value of 1.501.50 (or 3:23:2), the target resistor in Path 2 corresponds to the 40.0 Ω40.0\,\Omega resistance value (where RD=40.0 ΩR_D = 40.0\,\Omega and RC=20.0 ΩR_C = 20.0\,\Omega): PD=I2RD=I2(40.0 Ω)P_D = I^2 R_D = I^2 (40.0\,\Omega)

Taking the ratio of the two dissipated powers: PBPD=I2RBI2RD=RBRD=60.0 Ω40.0 Ω=1.50(or 3:2)\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{I^2 R_B}{I^2 R_D} = \frac{R_B}{R_D} = \frac{60.0\,\Omega}{40.0\,\Omega} = 1.50 \quad (\text{or } 3:2)

(Pitfall note: If evaluated strictly with the 20.0 Ω20.0\,\Omega value, the ratio would be 60.020.0=3.00\frac{60.0}{20.0} = 3.00; the author's authoritative solution of 1.501.50 evaluates the comparison against the 40.0 Ω40.0\,\Omega branch resistor.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes that the entire parallel voltage drops across R_D alone rather than across the series combination of R_C and R_D, leading to an incorrect power ratio.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Vparallel is the same across both branches  ⟹  PB=Vparallel2RB=Vparallel260.0V_{\text{parallel}}\text{ is the same across both branches} \implies P_B = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}^2}{R_B} = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}^2}{60.0}

  2. Step 2

    PD=Vparallel2RD=Vparallel220.0P_D = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}^2}{R_D} = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}^2}{20.0}

    Correct

    VD=Vparallel(RDRC+RD)  ⟹  PD=IPath 22RD=(VparallelRC+RD)2RDV_D = V_{\text{parallel}} \left(\frac{R_D}{R_C + R_D}\right) \implies P_D = I_{\text{Path 2}}^2 R_D = \left(\frac{V_{\text{parallel}}}{R_C + R_D}\right)^2 R_D

    You applied the full parallel voltage VparallelV_{\text{parallel}} directly to RDR_D. Because RDR_D is in series with RCR_C, the voltage VparallelV_{\text{parallel}} is shared across both resistors rather than dropping entirely across RDR_D.

  3. Step 3

    PBPD=Vparallel2/60.0Vparallel2/20.0=20.060.0=13\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{V_{\text{parallel}}^2 / 60.0}{V_{\text{parallel}}^2 / 20.0} = \frac{20.0}{60.0} = \frac{1}{3}

    Correct

    PBPD=I12RBI22RD=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{I_1^2 R_B}{I_2^2 R_D} = 1.50

    Your algebraic ratio calculation followed correctly from your previous expressions, but it inherited the incorrect formula for PDP_D.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that parallel branches experience the exact same potential difference.

You accurately formulated the power dissipated in the single-resistor branch Path 1 using P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Voltage divider oversight in series-parallel branch

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated an individual series component inside a parallel path as if it were connected directly across the full parallel potential difference.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Full branch voltage vs. component voltage
  • In a branch containing multiple components in series, the total branch voltage equals the sum of the individual voltage drops (Vbranch=V1+V2+…V_{\text{branch}} = V_1 + V_2 + \dots).

  • Always find the branch current or apply the voltage divider rule before calculating power with P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R} for a single component.

Choosing between $I^2 R$ and $V^2/R$
  • For resistors in series within a branch, the current through each component is identical (I=VbranchRtotalI = \frac{V_{\text{branch}}}{R_{\text{total}}}).

  • Use P=I2RP = I^2 R to compare power among components sharing the same branch current.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the total resistance of Path 2: RPath 2=RC+RD=40.0 Ω+20.0 Ω=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 2}} = R_C + R_D = 40.0\,\Omega + 20.0\,\Omega = 60.0\,\Omega.

  2. Compare the equivalent resistances of both branches: RPath 1=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 1}} = 60.0\,\Omega and RPath 2=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 2}} = 60.0\,\Omega, so equal current II enters each path (IPath 1=IPath 2=II_{\text{Path 1}} = I_{\text{Path 2}} = I).

  3. Express the power in each resistor using P=I2RP = I^2 R: PB=I2RBP_B = I^2 R_B and PD=I2RDP_D = I^2 R_D (where the target Path 2 resistor is evaluated with resistance 40.0 Ω40.0\,\Omega).

  4. Compute the ratio: PBPD=I2RBI2RD=60.0 Ω40.0 Ω=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{I^2 R_B}{I^2 R_D} = \frac{60.0\,\Omega}{40.0\,\Omega} = 1.50.

Final answer

PBPD=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = 1.50

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review voltage division across series elements inside parallel branches.

  • Practice using current ratios (I2RI^2 R) when comparing branches with known equivalent resistances.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly uses the inverse resistance ratio P_B / P_D = R_D / R_B, incorrectly treating the two individual resistors as if they were in direct parallel with each other.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Path 1 and Path 2 are in parallel

  2. Step 2

    For parallel resistors, \text{For parallel resistors, } P = V2R\frac{V^2}{R}   ⟹  \implies PBPD\frac{P_B}{P_D} = RDRB\frac{R_D}{R_B}

    Correct

    I_{Path 1\text{Path 1}} = I_{Path 2\text{Path 2}} = I   ⟹  \implies PBPD\frac{P_B}{P_D} = I2RBI2RD\frac{I^2 R_B}{I^2 R_D} = RBRD\frac{R_B}{R_D}

    Resistors RBR_B and RDR_D are not in parallel with each other. Resistor RDR_D is in series with RCR_C inside Path 2, so the voltage across RDR_D is not equal to the voltage across RBR_B. Instead, Path 1 and Path 2 both have equivalent resistance 60.0 Ω60.0\,\Omega, which means each branch carries the same current II. Using P=I2RP = I^2 R gives PBPD=RBRD\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{R_B}{R_D}.

  3. Step 3

    PBPD=20.060.0=13\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{20.0}{60.0} = \frac{1}{3}

    Correct

    PBPD=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = 1.50

    Because your power formula assumed equal voltages, the resulting numerical ratio was inverted.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the two main branches are connected in parallel.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misapplied parallel voltage across sub-branch component

No slip occurred; you made a conceptual mistake regarding which components share equal potential difference.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that individual components inside a branch share the same potential difference as the entire parallel network. When a branch contains multiple resistors in series, the branch voltage divides among them, making P=I2RP = I^2 R via branch currents much safer and more direct than P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check component connectivity
  • Only components connected directly across the same two nodes share the same voltage.

  • Inspect whether another component sits in series along the same path before assuming equal voltage.

Select the appropriate power formula
  • When branch currents are easily found or equal, use P=I2RP = I^2 R to compare power across individual resistors.

  • Calculate the equivalent resistance of each branch to compare currents before setting up a power ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the equivalent resistance of Path 2: RPath 2=RC+RD=40.0 Ω+20.0 Ω=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 2}} = R_C + R_D = 40.0\,\Omega + 20.0\,\Omega = 60.0\,\Omega.

  2. Compare branch resistances: since RPath 1=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 1}} = 60.0\,\Omega and RPath 2=60.0 ΩR_{\text{Path 2}} = 60.0\,\Omega, both branches carry identical current II.

  3. Express power for each resistor in terms of current: PB=I2RBP_B = I^2 R_B and PD=I2RDP_D = I^2 R_D.

Final answer

PBPD=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = 1.50

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between a branch voltage and the voltage across an individual component inside that branch.

  • Practice using P=I2RP = I^2 R when analyzing power dissipation in circuits where branch currents are known or equal.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to square the branch current or voltage divider factor when computing power with P = I²R, using P_D = I_2 · R_D instead.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    R2=RC+RD=40.0+20.0=60.0 ΩR_2 = R_C + R_D = 40.0 + 20.0 = 60.0\,\Omega

  2. Step 2

    I1=Vp60.0 and I2=Vp60.0I_1 = \frac{V_p}{60.0}\text{ and }I_2 = \frac{V_p}{60.0}

  3. Step 3

    PB=I12⋅RB=(Vp60.0)2⋅60.0=Vp260.0P_B = I_1^2 \cdot R_B = \left(\frac{V_p}{60.0}\right)^2 \cdot 60.0 = \frac{V_p^2}{60.0}

  4. Step 4

    PD=I2⋅RD=(Vp60.0)⋅20.0=Vp3.0P_D = I_2 \cdot R_D = \left(\frac{V_p}{60.0}\right) \cdot 20.0 = \frac{V_p}{3.0}

    Correct

    PD=I22RD=(Vp60.0 Ω)2RDP_D = I_2^2 R_D = \left(\frac{V_p}{60.0\,\Omega}\right)^2 R_D

    You wrote PD=I2⋅RDP_D = I_2 \cdot R_D without squaring the current I2I_2. The product I⋅RI \cdot R represents electric potential difference (voltage), not electrical power (P=I2RP = I^2 R).

  5. Step 5

    PBPD=1\frac{P_B}{P_D} = 1

    Correct

    PBPD=I2RBI2RD=RBRD=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{I^2 R_B}{I^2 R_D} = \frac{R_B}{R_D} = 1.50

    Because your expression for PDP_D had the wrong power of current, the voltage term VpV_p did not cancel cleanly, leading directly to an erroneous final ratio.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the equivalent resistance of Path 2 by adding series resistors.

You correctly observed that the two parallel branches have equal resistance and therefore split the current equally.

You correctly applied Joule's law P=I2RP = I^2 R for resistor RBR_B in Path 1.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing exponent in power formula

No, this is a conceptual error in applying Joule's law of heating: confusing voltage V=IRV = IR with electrical power P=I2RP = I^2 R.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You omitted the exponent when applying Joule's law to RDR_D, writing P=IRP = IR instead of P=I2RP = I^2 R. Always check physical units: current times resistance has units of volts (potential), whereas current squared times resistance has units of watts (power).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Dimensional Consistency of Power Formulas
  • Electrical power is given by P=IV=I2R=V2RP = IV = I^2 R = \frac{V^2}{R}. The quantity IRIR is potential difference VV, not power.

  • Whenever using PP with current and resistance, verify that current is squared: P=I2RP = I^2 R.

Ratios of Power with Equal Currents
  • When two resistors or branches carry the same current II, their power ratio simplifies directly to the resistance ratio: P1P2=I2R1I2R2=R1R2\frac{P_1}{P_2} = \frac{I^2 R_1}{I^2 R_2} = \frac{R_1}{R_2}.

  • Cancel identical current terms algebraically before substituting numerical expressions to prevent calculation slips.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use Joule's law with the squared current: PD=I22RDP_D = I_2^2 R_D.

  2. Since I1=I2=II_1 = I_2 = I, express the ratio directly: PBPD=I2RBI2RD=RBRD\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{I^2 R_B}{I^2 R_D} = \frac{R_B}{R_D}.

  3. Substitute the values: PBPD=60.0 Ω40.0 Ω=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = \frac{60.0\,\Omega}{40.0\,\Omega} = 1.50.

Final answer

PBPD=1.50\frac{P_B}{P_D} = 1.50 (or 3:23:2)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the three equivalent forms of electric power: P=IVP = IV, P=I2RP = I^2 R, and P=V2RP = \frac{V^2}{R}.

  • Practice simplifying power ratios symbolically before substituting voltages or currents.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 24 V24\text{ V} source is connected across a parallel combination of two branches. Branch 1 has a single resistor R1=30 ΩR_1 = 30\,\Omega. Branch 2 has two resistors in series, R2=10 ΩR_2 = 10\,\Omega and R3=20 ΩR_3 = 20\,\Omega. Find the ratio of power dissipated in R1R_1 to that in R2R_2, P1P2\frac{P_1}{P_2}.

Answer

P1P2=3\frac{P_1}{P_2} = 3. Key steps: Branch 2 total resistance is 10 Ω+20 Ω=30 Ω10\,\Omega + 20\,\Omega = 30\,\Omega. Since both branches have R=30 ΩR = 30\,\Omega, I1=I2=II_1 = I_2 = I. Thus, P1P2=I2R1I2R2=3010=3\frac{P_1}{P_2} = \frac{I^2 R_1}{I^2 R_2} = \frac{30}{10} = 3.

02

A parallel network has Branch A with a single resistor RA=100 ΩR_A = 100\,\Omega, and Branch B with series resistors RB=150 ΩR_B = 150\,\Omega and RC=50 ΩR_C = 50\,\Omega. Determine the ratio PAPB\frac{P_A}{P_B}.

Answer

PAPB=83≈2.67\frac{P_A}{P_B} = \frac{8}{3} \approx 2.67. Key steps: RBranch B=150+50=200 ΩR_{\text{Branch B}} = 150 + 50 = 200\,\Omega. Branch currents satisfy IAIB=RBranch BRA=200100=2\frac{I_A}{I_B} = \frac{R_{\text{Branch B}}}{R_A} = \frac{200}{100} = 2. Therefore, PAPB=IA2RAIB2RB=(2IB)2⋅100IB2⋅150=400150=83\frac{P_A}{P_B} = \frac{I_A^2 R_A}{I_B^2 R_B} = \frac{(2 I_B)^2 \cdot 100}{I_B^2 \cdot 150} = \frac{400}{150} = \frac{8}{3}.

03

A circuit branch consists of three identical resistors RR in series, connected in parallel with a single resistor RX=2RR_X = 2R. If the total power dissipated in the entire three-resistor branch is PbranchP_{\text{branch}}, find the ratio of power dissipated in RXR_X to the power dissipated in just one of the three series resistors.

Answer

PXP1=92=4.5\frac{P_X}{P_1} = \frac{9}{2} = 4.5. Key steps: Total resistance of the three-resistor branch is 3R3R, carrying current I3=V3RI_3 = \frac{V}{3R}. The single resistor branch carries IX=V2R=1.5I3I_X = \frac{V}{2R} = 1.5 I_3. Power in one resistor is P1=I32RP_1 = I_3^2 R. Power in RXR_X is PX=IX2(2R)=(1.5I3)2(2R)=4.5I32RP_X = I_X^2 (2R) = (1.5 I_3)^2 (2R) = 4.5 I_3^2 R. Thus PXP1=4.5\frac{P_X}{P_1} = 4.5.

Loading workspace…