Resources

A fixed line of charge of length L=0.500 mL = 0.500\text{ m} lies along the xx-axis from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L with a uniform linear charge density λ=+3.00 μC/m\lambda = +3.00\text{ }\mu\text{C/m} (total charge Q=λLQ = \lambda L). A point charge q0=+1.50 μCq_0 = +1.50\text{ }\mu\text{C} is located on the axis at x=d+Lx = d + L, where dd is the distance from the near end of the rod. (a) By integrating Coulomb's law for infinitesimal elements dqdq, write the exact expression for the electrostatic force F(d)F(d) on q0q_0. (b) Evaluate the force for d=0.100 md = 0.100\text{ m}. (c) Evaluate the asymptotic limit as d→∞d \to \infty by computing the ratio F(d)keQq0/d2\frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} to show convergence to the point-charge Coulomb law.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) F(d)=keq0Qd(d+L)F(d) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}; (b) F(0.100 m)=0.337 NF(0.100\text{ m}) = 0.337\text{ N}; (c) lim⁡d→∞F(d)keQq0/d2=lim⁡d→∞dd+L=1\lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = \lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{d}{d + L} = 1

Steps

Part (a): Deriving the Exact Expression for Force

  1. Set up the geometry and coordinate system: A line charge of length LL lies on the xx-axis spanning from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L. The point charge q0q_0 is located at position xp=L+dx_p = L + d.
  2. Define an infinitesimal charge element: Consider a segment of the rod of length dxdx located at an arbitrary position xx (0≤x≤L0 \le x \le L). The charge within this segment is: dq=λ dxdq = \lambda\, dx The distance rr from this charge element to the point charge q0q_0 is: r=(L+d)−xr = (L + d) - x
  3. Apply Coulomb's Law for the element: Since both λ>0\lambda > 0 and q0>0q_0 > 0, the force exerted by dqdq on q0q_0 is repulsive and acts along the positive xx-direction: dF=keq0dqr2=keq0λ dx(L+d−x)2dF = \frac{k_e q_0 dq}{r^2} = \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\, dx}{(L + d - x)^2}
  4. Integrate over the entire length of the rod: Summing the contributions from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L: F(d)=∫0Lkeq0λ dx(L+d−x)2F(d) = \int_0^L \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\, dx}{(L + d - x)^2} Using the substitution u=L+d−xu = L + d - x (so du=−dxdu = -dx):

    • At x=0x = 0, u=L+du = L + d
    • At x=Lx = L, u=du = d

    Substituting these limits and evaluating the integral: F(d)=∫L+dd−keq0λ duu2=keq0λ[1u]L+dd=keq0λ(1d−1L+d)F(d) = \int_{L+d}^d \frac{-k_e q_0 \lambda\, du}{u^2} = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[ \frac{1}{u} \right]_{L+d}^d = k_e q_0 \lambda \left( \frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{L + d} \right) Combining over a common denominator: 1d−1L+d=(L+d)−dd(d+L)=Ld(d+L)\frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{L + d} = \frac{(L + d) - d}{d(d + L)} = \frac{L}{d(d + L)} Since the total charge of the rod is Q=λLQ = \lambda L, the exact expression is: F(d)=keq0Qd(d+L)F(d) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}


Part (b): Evaluating the Force for d=0.100 md = 0.100\text{ m}

  1. Identify the given values:

    • Linear charge density: λ=3.00 μC/m=3.00×10−6 C/m\lambda = 3.00\text{ }\mu\text{C/m} = 3.00 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C/m}
    • Length of rod: L=0.500 mL = 0.500\text{ m}
    • Total charge: Q=λL=(3.00×10−6 C/m)(0.500 m)=1.50×10−6 CQ = \lambda L = (3.00 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C/m})(0.500\text{ m}) = 1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C}
    • Point charge: q0=1.50 μC=1.50×10−6 Cq_0 = 1.50\text{ }\mu\text{C} = 1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C}
    • Distance: d=0.100 md = 0.100\text{ m}
    • Coulomb constant: ke≈8.99×109 N⋅m2/C2k_e \approx 8.99 \times 10^9\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{C}^2
  2. Compute the force: d(d+L)=(0.100 m)(0.100 m+0.500 m)=0.100×0.600=0.0600 m2d(d + L) = (0.100\text{ m})(0.100\text{ m} + 0.500\text{ m}) = 0.100 \times 0.600 = 0.0600\text{ m}^2 F(0.100 m)=(8.99×109 N⋅m2/C2)(1.50×10−6 C)(1.50×10−6 C)0.0600 m2F(0.100\text{ m}) = \frac{(8.99 \times 10^9\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{C}^2)(1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C})(1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C})}{0.0600\text{ m}^2} F(0.100 m)=0.02023 N⋅m20.0600 m2≈0.337 NF(0.100\text{ m}) = \frac{0.02023\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2}{0.0600\text{ m}^2} \approx 0.337\text{ N}

Part (c): Asymptotic Limit as d→∞d \to \infty

  1. Form the ratio: Compare the exact force F(d)F(d) to the force expected if the rod's charge were concentrated as a point charge at a distance dd, Fpoint=keQq0d2F_{\text{point}} = \frac{k_e Q q_0}{d^2}: F(d)keQq0/d2=keq0Qd(d+L)keQq0d2=d2d(d+L)=dd+L\frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = \frac{\frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}}{\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d^2}} = \frac{d^2}{d(d + L)} = \frac{d}{d + L}
  2. Evaluate the limit: Divide the numerator and denominator by dd: lim⁡d→∞F(d)keQq0/d2=lim⁡d→∞dd+L=lim⁡d→∞11+Ld=11+0=1\lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = \lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{d}{d + L} = \lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{1}{1 + \frac{L}{d}} = \frac{1}{1 + 0} = 1 This confirms that at distances much larger than the rod's length (d≫Ld \gg L), the finite line of charge behaves electrostatically as an ordinary point charge QQ.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misidentifies the separation distance between charge element dq and q0 as d - x instead of d + L - x.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dq=λ dx  ⟹  r=d−x  ⟹  dF=keq0dq(d−x)2dq = \lambda\,dx \implies r = d - x \implies dF = \frac{k_e q_0 dq}{(d - x)^2}

    Correct

    dq=λ dx  ⟹  r=(L+d)−x  ⟹  dF=keq0λ dx(L+d−x)2dq = \lambda\,dx \implies r = (L + d) - x \implies dF = \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\,dx}{(L + d - x)^2}

    You set the position of q0q_0 to dd instead of its actual coordinate x=L+dx = L + d. Since the rod spans from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L and q0q_0 is placed a distance dd past the near end (x=Lx = L), the separation between a charge element at xx and the point charge is r=L+d−xr = L + d - x.

  2. Step 2

    F(d)=keq0λ∫0Ldx(d−x)2=keq0λ[1d−x]0L=keq0λ(1d−L−1d)=keQq0d(d−L)F(d) = k_e q_0 \lambda \int_0^L \frac{dx}{(d - x)^2} = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[\frac{1}{d - x}\right]_0^L = k_e q_0 \lambda \left(\frac{1}{d - L} - \frac{1}{d}\right) = \frac{k_e Q q_0}{d(d - L)}

    Correct

    F(d)=keq0λ∫0Ldx(L+d−x)2=keq0λ[1L+d−x]0L=keq0λ(1d−1L+d)=keQq0d(d+L)F(d) = k_e q_0 \lambda \int_0^L \frac{dx}{(L + d - x)^2} = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[\frac{1}{L + d - x}\right]_0^L = k_e q_0 \lambda \left(\frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{L + d}\right) = \frac{k_e Q q_0}{d(d + L)}

    You carried out the integration technique and common denominator algebra correctly, but this step inherits the incorrect separation distance r=d−xr = d - x from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Q=1.50×10−6 CQ = 1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C}, q0=1.50×10−6 C  ⟹  d−L=0.100−0.500=−0.400 m  ⟹  F(0.100)=(8.99×109)(1.50×10−6)(1.50×10−6)0.100×(−0.400)=−0.506 Nq_0 = 1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C} \implies d - L = 0.100 - 0.500 = -0.400\text{ m} \implies F(0.100) = \frac{(8.99 \times 10^9)(1.50 \times 10^{-6})(1.50 \times 10^{-6})}{0.100 \times (-0.400)} = -0.506\text{ N}

    Correct

    d(d+L)=0.100(0.100+0.500)=0.0600 m2  ⟹  F(0.100)=(8.99×109)(1.50×10−6)20.0600≈0.337 Nd(d + L) = 0.100(0.100 + 0.500) = 0.0600\text{ m}^2 \implies F(0.100) = \frac{(8.99 \times 10^9)(1.50 \times 10^{-6})^2}{0.0600} \approx 0.337\text{ N}

    You substituted your values properly, but because the denominator contained d−Ld - L instead of d+Ld + L, the distance product became negative, producing an impossible negative force magnitude for two like charges.

  4. Step 4

    F(d)keQq0/d2=keQq0d(d−L)keQq0d2=dd−L=11−L/d  ⟹  lim⁡d→∞11−L/d=1\frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = \frac{\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d(d - L)}}{\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d^2}} = \frac{d}{d - L} = \frac{1}{1 - L/d} \implies \lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{1}{1 - L/d} = 1

    Correct

    F(d)keQq0/d2=keQq0d(d+L)keQq0d2=dd+L=11+L/d  ⟹  lim⁡d→∞11+L/d=1\frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = \frac{\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d(d + L)}}{\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d^2}} = \frac{d}{d + L} = \frac{1}{1 + L/d} \implies \lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{1}{1 + L/d} = 1

    You evaluated the limit as d→∞d \to \infty with sound mathematical reasoning, but the algebraic ratio carried forward the erroneous factor d−Ld - L.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the infinitesimal charge element as dq=λ dxdq = \lambda\,dx.

You successfully integrated the inverse-square differential form using an appropriate antiderivative.

You correctly recognized that Q=λLQ = \lambda L to write the final algebraic form.

You properly analyzed the limit as d→∞d \to \infty by dividing numerator and denominator by dd.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Coordinate Setup Error in Separation Distance

You treated dd as the absolute xx-coordinate of q0q_0 rather than its distance from the near end of the rod at x=Lx = L.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing a relative distance offset with an absolute coordinate. The point charge q0q_0 is located at xp=L+dx_{p} = L + d, so the distance from any source element at coordinate xx to the point charge is r=xp−x=(L+d)−xr = x_{p} - x = (L + d) - x, which is always strictly positive (r≥d>0r \ge d > 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Always Write Coordinates Before Distances
  • For a source element at xsourcex_{\text{source}} and a target at xtargetx_{\text{target}}, the separation distance along the line is r=∣xtarget−xsource∣r = |x_{\text{target}} - x_{\text{source}}|.

  • Locate the source range (x∈[0,L]x \in [0, L]) and the target point (xp=L+dx_p = L + d), then construct r=(L+d)−xr = (L + d) - x before substituting into Coulomb's law.

Physical Reality Check on Distances
  • A geometric separation distance rr must remain strictly positive for all xx within the limits of integration.

  • Check the endpoints: at the near end x=Lx = L, rr must equal dd; at the far end x=0x = 0, rr must equal L+dL + d. Notice that r=d−xr = d - x gave d−L<0d - L < 0, which immediately signals an incorrect setup.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the target coordinate: xp=L+dx_p = L + d.

  2. Write the distance to an element at xx: r=xp−x=L+d−xr = x_p - x = L + d - x.

  3. Integrate dF=keq0λ dx(L+d−x)2dF = \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\,dx}{(L + d - x)^2} from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L: F(d)=keq0λ[1L+d−x]0L=keq0λ(1d−1L+d)=keq0Qd(d+L)F(d) = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[\frac{1}{L + d - x}\right]_0^L = k_e q_0 \lambda \left(\frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{L + d}\right) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}.

  4. Substitute d=0.100 md = 0.100\text{ m}, L=0.500 mL = 0.500\text{ m}, and Q=q0=1.50 μCQ = q_0 = 1.50\text{ }\mu\text{C} to find F(0.100)=0.337 NF(0.100) = 0.337\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) F(d)=keq0Qd(d+L)F(d) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}; (b) F(0.100 m)=0.337 NF(0.100\text{ m}) = 0.337\text{ N}; (c) lim⁡d→∞F(d)keQq0/d2=1\lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = 1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the xx-axis and label both boundary coordinates of the rod (00 and LL) and the exact coordinate of the test charge (L+dL + d).

  • Verify your distance expression at both integration bounds: x=0x = 0 and x=Lx = L must yield positive, physically sensible distances.

  • Practice setting up Coulomb integrals for configurations where charges are placed on opposite sides of the origin.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly treats the entire rod as a point charge concentrated at its center of mass before integration, bypassing the continuous integral of Coulomb's law.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    The center of the rod is at \text{The center of the rod is at } x = L2\frac{L}{2} = 0.250 m\text{ m}   ⟹  \implies r = d + L - L2\frac{L}{2} = d + L2\frac{L}{2}   ⟹  \implies F(d) = keQq0(d+L/2)2\frac{k_e Q q_0}{(d + L/2)^2}

    Correct

    dF = keq0dqr2\frac{k_e q_0 dq}{r^2} = keq0λ dx(L+d−x)2\frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\,dx}{(L + d - x)^2}   ⟹  \implies F(d) = \int_0^L keq0λ dx(L+d−x)2\frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\,dx}{(L + d - x)^2} = keq0Qd(d+L)\frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}

    You replaced the continuous line charge with a single point charge at its center of mass x=L/2x = L/2. Because electrostatic force scales as 1/r21/r^2, the average of 1/r21/r^2 over a rod does not equal 1/rcenter21/r_{\text{center}}^2. You must set up an infinitesimal element dq=λ dxdq = \lambda\,dx at position xx with distance r=L+d−xr = L + d - x and integrate from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L.

  2. Step 2

    Q = 1.50 ×\times 10^{-6} C\text{ C}, \quad q_0 = 1.50 ×\times 10^{-6} C\text{ C}, \quad r = 0.100 + 0.250 = 0.350 m\text{ m}   ⟹  \implies F(0.100) = (8.99×109)(1.50×10−6)(1.50×10−6)(0.350)2\frac{(8.99 \times 10^9)(1.50 \times 10^{-6})(1.50 \times 10^{-6})}{(0.350)^2} = 0.02022750.1225\frac{0.0202275}{0.1225} = 0.165 N\text{ N}

    Correct

    F(0.100) = (8.99×109)(1.50×10−6)(1.50×10−6)(0.100)(0.100+0.500)\frac{(8.99 \times 10^9)(1.50 \times 10^{-6})(1.50 \times 10^{-6})}{(0.100)(0.100 + 0.500)} = 0.020230.0600\frac{0.02023}{0.0600} ≈\approx 0.337 N\text{ N}

    Your arithmetic and substitution were carried out carefully, but the result is incorrect because it relies on the center-of-mass formula from part (a).

  3. Step 3

    F(d)keQq0/d2\frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = keQq0/(d+L/2)2keQq0/d2\frac{k_e Q q_0 / (d + L/2)^2}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = d2(d+L/2)2\frac{d^2}{(d + L/2)^2} = 1(1+L2d)2\frac{1}{(1 + \frac{L}{2d})^2}   ⟹  \implies $\lim_{d →\to ∞\infty}$ \frac{1}{(1 + \frac{L}{2d})^2} = 1_

    Correct

    F(d)keQq0/d2\frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = d2d(d+L)\frac{d^2}{d(d + L)} = dd+L\frac{d}{d + L} = 11+Ld\frac{1}{1 + \frac{L}{d}}   ⟹  \implies $\lim_{d →\to ∞\infty}$ \frac{1}{1 + \frac{L}{d}} = 1_

    You correctly set up and computed the asymptotic limit to show convergence to 1, but your ratio expression inherited the incorrect formula from part (a).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the total charge of the rod Q=λLQ = \lambda L.

You correctly determined the geometric distance from the center of the rod to the test charge.

You performed the numerical calculations and limit evaluation accurately for the formula you used.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Extended charge treated as point charge at center of mass

No, this was a conceptual error rather than an arithmetic slip.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that an extended continuous charge distribution can be treated as a point charge at its center of mass when computing electrostatic forces. Unlike uniform linear gravitational fields, the 1/r21/r^2 non-linearity in Coulomb's law means ∫dqr2≠Qrcm2\int \frac{dq}{r^2} \neq \frac{Q}{r_{\text{cm}}^2}, requiring direct integration over infinitesimal charge elements.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Validity of Center-of-Charge Simplification
  • Extended objects can only be replaced by a point charge at their center if Gauss's Law spherical symmetry applies (such as spherically symmetric shells/balls outside their radius). For rods, disks, or rings, you must integrate over dqdq.

  • Always represent continuous charge distributions by dq=λ dxdq = \lambda\,dx (or σ dA\sigma\,dA, ρ dV\rho\,dV) and integrate dF⃗=keq0dqr2r^d\vec{F} = \frac{k_e q_0 dq}{r^2}\hat{r}.

Distance from an Arbitrary Segment
  • For a rod extending from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L and a point charge at xp=L+dx_p = L + d, an element at position xx is at distance r=xp−x=L+d−xr = x_p - x = L + d - x.

  • Express rr in terms of the variable of integration xx before integrating.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the infinitesimal charge: dq=λ dx=QL dxdq = \lambda\,dx = \frac{Q}{L}\,dx at coordinate x∈[0,L]x \in [0, L].

  2. Find the distance from dqdq to the point charge at xp=L+dx_p = L + d: r=(L+d)−xr = (L + d) - x.

  3. Write the differential force on q0q_0: dF=keq0dqr2=keq0λ dx(L+d−x)2dF = \frac{k_e q_0 dq}{r^2} = \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\,dx}{(L + d - x)^2}.

  4. Integrate from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L: using u=L+d−xu = L + d - x (du=−dxdu = -dx), F(d)=keq0λ∫L+dd−duu2=keq0λ[1u]L+dd=keq0λ(1d−1L+d)F(d) = k_e q_0 \lambda \int_{L+d}^{d} \frac{-du}{u^2} = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[\frac{1}{u}\right]_{L+d}^d = k_e q_0 \lambda \left(\frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{L + d}\right).

  5. Simplify the algebraic difference: 1d−1L+d=Ld(d+L)\frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{L + d} = \frac{L}{d(d + L)}, and substitute Q=λLQ = \lambda L to obtain F(d)=keq0Qd(d+L)F(d) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}.

Final answer

(a) F(d)=keq0Qd(d+L)F(d) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}; (b) F(0.100 m)=0.337 NF(0.100\text{ m}) = 0.337\text{ N}; (c) lim⁡d→∞F(d)keQq0/d2=1\lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = 1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice setting up dqdq and the position-dependent distance r(x)r(x) for 1D charge distributions.

  • Verify whether an extended charge problem can be treated as a point charge by checking for spherical symmetry (only spherical shells and spheres allow this via Gauss's Law).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets the negative sign resulting from the chain rule when integrating 1/(d + L - x)², leading to an inverted difference and a negative force expression.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    dq=λdx  ⟹  r=d+L−x  ⟹  dF=keq0λdx(d+L−x)2dq = \lambda dx \implies r = d + L - x \implies dF = \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda dx}{(d + L - x)^2}

  2. Step 2

    ∫dx(d+L−x)2=−1d+L−x\int \frac{dx}{(d + L - x)^2} = -\frac{1}{d + L - x}

    Correct

    ∫dx(d+L−x)2=1d+L−x+C\int \frac{dx}{(d + L - x)^2} = \frac{1}{d + L - x} + C

    When applying the substitution u=d+L−xu = d + L - x, the differential is du=−dxdu = -dx, meaning dx=−dudx = -du. The integral becomes ∫−u−2 du=u−1+C=1d+L−x+C\int -u^{-2}\,du = u^{-1} + C = \frac{1}{d + L - x} + C. Forgetting this negative sign caused an extraneous minus sign in the antiderivative.

  3. Step 3

    F(d)=keq0λ[−1d+L−x]0L=keq0λ(1d+L−1d)=−keQq0d(d+L)F(d) = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[ -\frac{1}{d + L - x} \right]_0^L = k_e q_0 \lambda \left( \frac{1}{d + L} - \frac{1}{d} \right) = -\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d(d + L)}

    Correct

    F(d)=keq0λ[1d+L−x]0L=keq0λ(1d−1d+L)=keQq0d(d+L)F(d) = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[ \frac{1}{d + L - x} \right]_0^L = k_e q_0 \lambda \left( \frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{d + L} \right) = \frac{k_e Q q_0}{d(d + L)}

    You evaluated the limits and simplified the fraction correctly based on your antiderivative, but the result carried the sign error from the previous step.

  4. Step 4

    Q=1.50×10−6 C  ⟹  q0=1.50×10−6 C  ⟹  F(0.100)=−(8.99×109)(1.50×10−6)(1.50×10−6)(0.100×0.600)=−0.337 NQ = 1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C} \implies q_0 = 1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C} \implies F(0.100) = -\frac{(8.99 \times 10^9)(1.50 \times 10^{-6})(1.50 \times 10^{-6})}{(0.100 \times 0.600)} = -0.337\text{ N}

    Correct

    F(0.100)=(8.99×109 N⋅m2/C2)(1.50×10−6 C)2(0.100 m)(0.600 m)=0.337 NF(0.100) = \frac{(8.99 \times 10^9\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{C}^2)(1.50 \times 10^{-6}\text{ C})^2}{(0.100\text{ m})(0.600\text{ m})} = 0.337\text{ N}

    Your arithmetic and substitutions were accurate, but the force magnitude inherited the negative sign from Part (a).

  5. Step 5

    F(d)keQq0d2=−dd+L=−11+L/d  ⟹  lim⁡d→∞−11+L/d=−1\frac{F(d)}{\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d^2}} = -\frac{d}{d + L} = -\frac{1}{1 + L/d} \implies \lim_{d \to \infty} -\frac{1}{1 + L/d} = -1

    Correct

    lim⁡d→∞F(d)keQq0d2=lim⁡d→∞dd+L=1\lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{F(d)}{\frac{k_e Q q_0}{d^2}} = \lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{d}{d + L} = 1

    Your limit computation was mathematically sound based on your formula, but the resulting limit was −1-1 rather than +1+1 due to the earlier sign error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the differential charge element dq=λdxdq = \lambda dx and distance r=d+L−xr = d + L - x.

You correctly set up the differential Coulomb force dFdF.

You correctly evaluated limits, simplified rational expressions, and computed the asymptotic limit.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Integration by substitution sign omission

You omitted the negative sign from du=−dxdu = -dx when integrating with respect to xx.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When using uu-substitution with a linear expression having a negative coefficient like u=a−xu = a - x, the differential includes a factor of −1-1 (du=−dxdu = -dx). Missing this factor flips the sign of the antiderivative and leads to an unphysical negative electrostatic force between two positive charges.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Differential Relation in $u$-Substitution
  • If u=c−xu = c - x, then du=−dxdu = -dx, which means dx=−dudx = -du.

  • Always explicitly write out du=dudx dxdu = \frac{du}{dx}\,dx before replacing dxdx in the integral.

Physical Sanity Check on Force Signs
  • Like charges repel; the net electrostatic force along the outward radial axis must be positive.

  • Before moving to subsequent parts, verify that the computed force expression yields a positive value for positive charges.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use substitution with u=d+L−xu = d + L - x, so du=−dx  ⟹  dx=−dudu = -dx \implies dx = -du.

  2. Compute the antiderivative: ∫dx(d+L−x)2=∫−duu2=1u+C=1d+L−x+C\int \frac{dx}{(d + L - x)^2} = \int \frac{-du}{u^2} = \frac{1}{u} + C = \frac{1}{d + L - x} + C.

  3. Evaluate the definite integral across the rod from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L: F(d)=keq0λ[1d+L−x]0L=keq0λ(1d−1d+L)=keQq0d(d+L)F(d) = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[ \frac{1}{d + L - x} \right]_0^L = k_e q_0 \lambda \left( \frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{d + L} \right) = \frac{k_e Q q_0}{d(d + L)}.

  4. Substitute the numerical values for Part (b): F(0.100 m)=(8.99×109)(1.50×10−6)2(0.100)(0.600)=0.337 NF(0.100\text{ m}) = \frac{(8.99 \times 10^9)(1.50 \times 10^{-6})^2}{(0.100)(0.600)} = 0.337\text{ N}.

  5. Evaluate the asymptotic limit for Part (c): lim⁡d→∞dd+L=1\lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{d}{d + L} = 1.

Final answer

(a) F(d)=keq0Qd(d+L)F(d) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}; (b) F(0.100 m)=0.337 NF(0.100\text{ m}) = 0.337\text{ N}; (c) lim⁡d→∞F(d)keQq0/d2=1\lim_{d \to \infty} \frac{F(d)}{k_e Q q_0 / d^2} = 1

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice integrating functions of the form (a−x)−n(a - x)^{-n} while explicitly writing down du=−dxdu = -dx.

  • Perform a physical sign check on vector quantities such as force and field to confirm they match physical intuition (repulsion between like charges).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A thin rod with uniform linear charge density λ\lambda lies along the xx-axis from x=−ax = -a to x=+ax = +a. A point charge +q0+q_0 is located on the xx-axis at x=bx = b, where b>ab > a. Write the integral expression for the electric force on q0q_0 and evaluate it in terms of total charge Q=2aλQ = 2a\lambda.

Answer

F=keq0Qb2−a2F = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{b^2 - a^2}. Key steps: For x∈[−a,a]x \in [-a, a], separation is r=b−xr = b - x. F=∫−aakeq0λ dx(b−x)2=keq0λ[1b−x]−aa=keq0λ(1b−a−1b+a)=keq0(2aλ)b2−a2=keq0Qb2−a2F = \int_{-a}^a \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\,dx}{(b - x)^2} = k_e q_0 \lambda \left[\frac{1}{b - x}\right]_{-a}^a = k_e q_0 \lambda \left(\frac{1}{b - a} - \frac{1}{b + a}\right) = \frac{k_e q_0 (2a\lambda)}{b^2 - a^2} = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{b^2 - a^2}.

02

A uniformly charged rod of length LL with total charge Q>0Q > 0 lies along the yy-axis from y=0y = 0 to y=Ly = L. A point charge q0>0q_0 > 0 is placed at y=−dy = -d (where d>0d > 0). Determine the exact magnitude and direction of the electrostatic force exerted on q0q_0.

Answer

F=keq0Qd(d+L)F = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)} directed downward (−j^-\hat{j}). Key steps: The target charge is at yp=−dy_p = -d and elements are at y∈[0,L]y \in [0, L]. The distance is r=y−(−d)=y+dr = y - (-d) = y + d. The force element is directed in −j^-\hat{j}: dF=keq0λ dy(y+d)2dF = \frac{k_e q_0 \lambda\,dy}{(y + d)^2}. Integrating from 00 to LL gives keq0λ(1d−1d+L)=keq0Qd(d+L)k_e q_0 \lambda \left(\frac{1}{d} - \frac{1}{d + L}\right) = \frac{k_e q_0 Q}{d(d + L)}.

03

A non-uniform line of charge of length LL lies on the xx-axis from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L with linear charge density λ(x)=αx\lambda(x) = \alpha x. A point charge q0q_0 is placed at x=L+dx = L + d. Find the electrostatic force on q0q_0 as an explicit function of dd, LL, α\alpha, and kek_e.

Answer

F=keq0α[ln⁡(L+dd)−LL+d]F = k_e q_0 \alpha \left[\ln\left(\frac{L + d}{d}\right) - \frac{L}{L + d}\right]. Key steps: The separation distance is r=L+d−xr = L + d - x. Setting u=L+d−xu = L + d - x gives x=L+d−ux = L + d - u and dx=−dudx = -du. The integral becomes F=keq0α∫0Lx dx(L+d−x)2=keq0α∫dL+dL+d−uu2 du=keq0α[−(L+d)1u−ln⁡u]dL+d=keq0α[ln⁡(L+dd)−LL+d]F = k_e q_0 \alpha \int_0^L \frac{x\,dx}{(L + d - x)^2} = k_e q_0 \alpha \int_d^{L+d} \frac{L + d - u}{u^2}\,du = k_e q_0 \alpha \left[-(L + d)\frac{1}{u} - \ln u\right]_d^{L+d} = k_e q_0 \alpha \left[\ln\left(\frac{L + d}{d}\right) - \frac{L}{L + d}\right].

Loading workspace…