Resources
A warehouse operator compares two lifting methods for an identical load of weight raised through a vertical height : Method A uses a single movable pulley system with an Ideal Mechanical Advantage () of and a total cable friction of ; Method B adds two more pulleys to achieve an of , but the additional sheaves and bearings increase total friction to . A novice student assumes that because Method B reduces the required pulling effort force, it must also be more mechanically efficient. Evaluate this claim quantitatively by calculating the actual mechanical efficiency of System A and of System B.
Answer and steps
Final answer
, ; the student's assumption is incorrect because the additional friction and greater displacement of the effort cable significantly increase wasted non-conservative work, lowering efficiency.
Steps
Useful Work Output ()
The useful work output is the work required to raise the load against gravity, independent of the mechanism used:
Efficiency of System A ()
For a pulley system with an Ideal Mechanical Advantage (), the displacement of the effort cable is related to the load height by:
In the ideal (frictionless) case, the required pulling force is:
Accounting for the opposing frictional resistance , the actual input effort force is:
The total work input is:
The mechanical efficiency of System A is:
Efficiency of System B ()
For System B, with :
The ideal pulling force is:
With friction , the actual input effort force is:
The total work input is:
The mechanical efficiency of System B is:
Evaluating the Student's Claim
- Common Pitfall: Conflating mechanical advantage with mechanical efficiency. A higher reduces the required applied force (), making the object easier to pull by hand. However, efficiency measures the percentage of input energy converted into useful output work.
- Because System B requires pulling the rope over twice the distance ( vs. ), the non-conservative work done against friction increases dramatically:
- Thus, the student's assumption is incorrect: System B is significantly less efficient () than System A ().
Typical errors
01 The student subtracts the friction force from the ideal effort instead of adding it, assuming friction aids the pull rather than opposing it.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You subtracted the friction force from the ideal force. Because friction resists the pulling motion, the actual input effort must overcome both the ideal load share and friction: .
- Step 3Correct
Your formulas for work input and efficiency were applied properly, but your result was affected by the underestimated effort force, yielding an efficiency over , which violates conservation of energy.
- Step 4Correct
You repeated the subtraction of friction for System B. The actual effort needed is .
- Step 5Correct
Your calculation of input work and efficiency followed the correct structure, but the value propagated from the incorrect force.
- Step 6Correct
Because your calculated efficiencies were reversed due to the friction sign error, your conclusion about the operator's claim was also reversed.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the gravitational potential energy gained by the load correctly as .
You correctly used the ideal mechanical advantage to find the ideal effort force and the input cable displacement for both systems.
You set up the efficiency ratio as useful work output divided by work input.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated friction as an assisting force that reduces input effort rather than an opposing force that increases it.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating load-reducing mechanical advantage with frictional losses. In real machines, non-conservative forces such as friction dissipate energy as thermal energy, meaning the operator must perform extra work (), so the applied force must exceed the ideal force: .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Sanity Check Efficiency Bounds
For any passive machine, mechanical efficiency must satisfy () due to the first and second laws of thermodynamics.
Whenever you compute an efficiency greater than , immediately re-examine your input force and work input to verify whether friction was added or subtracted.
- Accounting for Friction in Machines
Friction always opposes the direction of cable motion, adding to the effort needed: .
Sum the ideal effort and the frictional resistance when determining the actual pulling force required.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompute the actual input force for System A: .
Calculate total work input for System A: .
Calculate actual efficiency for System A: .
Compute the actual input force for System B: .
Calculate total work input for System B: .
Calculate actual efficiency for System B: .
Compare efficiencies: , proving the student's claim is false.
, ; the claim is unsupported because System B is less efficient.
02 The student calculates efficiency as the ratio of load height to effort displacement, which is merely 1/IMA and neglects friction entirely.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You set efficiency equal to the ratio of load height to effort displacement , which is merely . Mechanical efficiency is the ratio of useful work output to total work input, , which requires accounting for the friction force .
- Step 3Correct
You repeated the same formula error for System B, omitting the actual input force and calculating instead of the actual energy efficiency.
- Step 4Correct
The claim is incorrect because ; pulling the rope through a greater distance with higher friction wastes more non-conservative work.
Your final qualitative conclusion is correct, but the values you used to justify it were derived from an incorrect definition of mechanical efficiency.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly related the load height and the ideal mechanical advantage to find the cable displacement for both systems.
You recognized that a higher mechanical advantage does not necessarily mean higher efficiency.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou used the kinematic ratio as efficiency instead of calculating work input and work output.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the geometric velocity ratio (or ) with mechanical efficiency . Efficiency always represents an energy ratio , which requires evaluating the actual input force needed to overcome both the ideal load and friction.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Mechanical Efficiency
Mechanical efficiency is strictly the ratio of useful work output to total work input: .
Always compute and in Joules (or find the actual effort force ) before calculating efficiency.
- Distinguishing IMA from Efficiency
is purely determined by geometry and has nothing to do with energy loss; an ideal machine with no friction has regardless of its .
Check your formula: if your efficiency expression contains only distances, you are calculating , not efficiency.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate useful work output: .
Find the actual input force for System A: .
Compute the work input for System A: .
Calculate .
Find the actual input force for System B: .
Compute the work input for System B: .
Calculate .
Evaluate the claim: since , the student's claim is quantitatively disproven.
, ; the claim is incorrect.
03 The student omits the displacement multiplier for work done against friction, adding friction force directly to useful work rather than multiplying it by effort displacement.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You added a force in newtons () directly to an energy quantity in joules (). To find work done against friction, multiply the frictional resistance by the effort displacement: , giving .
- Step 3Correct
Your efficiency formula is conceptually correct, but the result is inaccurate due to the understated input work from Step 2.
- Step 4Correct
You repeated the same dimensional error by omitting the displacement factor . The actual work done against friction is .
- Step 5Correct
This calculation correctly evaluates , but the value is affected by the incorrect input work in Step 4.
- Step 6Correct
The claim is incorrect because .
Your qualitative conclusion happens to agree with the correct answer, but your quantitative efficiencies were derived from dimensionally inconsistent input work expressions.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly computed the useful work output as .
You correctly applied the definition of mechanical efficiency as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated friction force as an amount of wasted energy, writing .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked that work is the product of force and displacement (), adding a force in newtons directly to work in joules and ignoring that higher IMA systems pull the cable over a proportionally longer distance.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dimensional Consistency Check
Every additive term in an energy equation must carry units of energy (Joules, ), never force (Newtons).
Always multiply non-conservative friction forces by the distance over which they act: .
- Effort Displacement via IMA
For an ideal pulley or simple machine, effort displacement is .
Calculate first whenever computing input work or energy dissipated by friction along the input line.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind input displacement for System A: .
Calculate actual input work for System A: .
Compute efficiency for System A: .
Find input displacement for System B: .
Calculate actual input work for System B: .
Compute efficiency for System B: .
, ; the novice's claim is incorrect because System B requires pulling cable through twice the distance, multiplying the energy lost to friction and lowering overall efficiency.
Lock it in
In a real simple machine with friction, is the actual input effort force greater than or less than the ideal effort force?
Greater than ideal effort (). Friction opposes motion, so extra applied force is required to overcome it.
Similar question
A ramp has an ideal mechanical advantage of . To slide a crate to the top, friction between the crate and ramp is . Find the actual pushing force required and the mechanical efficiency of the ramp.
Answer
, . Key steps: . With friction opposing motion, . Efficiency is .
A hydraulic lift with lifts a vehicle through a height of . Due to seal friction, the actual input force applied is . Calculate the friction force opposing the input piston and the mechanical efficiency of the lift.
Answer
, . Key steps: Ideal input force . Frictional resistance is . Efficiency is .
A winch system has . Raising an load by requires an actual effort of . (a) Determine the energy lost to friction. (b) If an engineer redesigns the gears to increase to but gear friction increases the required effort to , does the efficiency improve or worsen?
Answer
(a) ; (b) Efficiency worsens from to . Key steps: . Original: , , so , . Redesign: , , .