Resources

An engineering student constructs an asymmetrical dumbbell consisting of two small spherical weights joined by a thin carbon-fiber rod of length L=0.900 mL = 0.900\text{ m} with negligible mass. One sphere has a known mass m1=3.20 kgm_1 = 3.20\text{ kg} and is located at x1=0 mx_1 = 0\text{ m}. By balancing the system on a sharp knife-edge, the student determines that the center of mass is located precisely at xcm=0.540 mx_{\text{cm}} = 0.540\text{ m} along the rod. Determine the mass m2m_2 of the second sphere positioned at x2=0.900 mx_2 = 0.900\text{ m}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

m2=4.80 kgm_2 = 4.80\text{ kg}

Steps

Method 1: Center of Mass Definition

The center of mass xcmx_{\text{cm}} for a system of point masses along a straight line is defined by:

xcm=m1x1+m2x2m1+m2x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 x_1 + m_2 x_2}{m_1 + m_2}

Substitute the given values into the formula:

  • m1=3.20 kgm_1 = 3.20\text{ kg} at x1=0 mx_1 = 0\text{ m}
  • xcm=0.540 mx_{\text{cm}} = 0.540\text{ m}
  • x2=0.900 mx_2 = 0.900\text{ m}

0.540=(3.20)(0)+m2(0.900)3.20+m20.540 = \frac{(3.20)(0) + m_2(0.900)}{3.20 + m_2}

Simplify the numerator:

0.540=0.900m23.20+m20.540 = \frac{0.900 m_2}{3.20 + m_2}

Multiply both sides by (3.20+m2)(3.20 + m_2):

0.540(3.20+m2)=0.900m20.540(3.20 + m_2) = 0.900 m_2

1.728+0.540m2=0.900m21.728 + 0.540 m_2 = 0.900 m_2

Collect the terms involving m2m_2 on one side:

1.728=0.900m2−0.540m21.728 = 0.900 m_2 - 0.540 m_2

1.728=0.360m21.728 = 0.360 m_2

Solve for m2m_2:

m2=1.7280.360=4.80 kgm_2 = \frac{1.728}{0.360} = 4.80\text{ kg}


Alternative Method: Torque Balance (Principle of Moments)

When an object balances horizontally on a sharp pivot (knife-edge), the pivot is located at its center of gravity (which coincides with the center of mass in a uniform gravitational field). The net torque about the pivot must be zero:

∑τ=0  ⟹  m1gd1=m2gd2\sum \tau = 0 \implies m_1 g d_1 = m_2 g d_2

Dividing both sides by the gravitational acceleration gg:

m1d1=m2d2m_1 d_1 = m_2 d_2

  1. Determine the lever arm distances from the balance point (xcm=0.540 mx_{\text{cm}} = 0.540\text{ m}):

    • Distance to mass 11: d1=0.540 m−0 m=0.540 md_1 = 0.540\text{ m} - 0\text{ m} = 0.540\text{ m}
    • Distance to mass 22: d2=0.900 m−0.540 m=0.360 md_2 = 0.900\text{ m} - 0.540\text{ m} = 0.360\text{ m}
  2. Substitute the values:

    (3.20)(0.540)=m2(0.360)(3.20)(0.540) = m_2 (0.360)

    m2=3.20⋅0.5400.360=3.20⋅1.5=4.80 kgm_2 = \frac{3.20 \cdot 0.540}{0.360} = 3.20 \cdot 1.5 = 4.80\text{ kg}

Common Pitfall: Be careful when identifying lever arm distances in torque calculations. Using the total rod length L=0.900 mL = 0.900\text{ m} instead of the distance from the pivot (L−xcm=0.360 m)(L - x_{\text{cm}} = 0.360\text{ m}) for m2m_2 will result in an incorrect mass.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that the denominator of the center-of-mass formula includes the total mass (m_1 + m_2) and instead divides only by m_2 or treats the formula as x_cm = (m_1*x_1 + m_2*x_2)/m_1.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    xcm=m1∗x1+m2∗x2m1+m2x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 * x_1 + m_2 * x_2}{m_1 + m_2}

  2. Step 2

    m1∗(x2−xcm)=m2∗xcmm_1 * (x_2 - x_{\text{cm}}) = m_2 * x_{\text{cm}}

    Correct

    m1∗(xcm−x1)=m2∗(x2−xcm)m_1 * (x_{\text{cm}} - x_1) = m_2 * (x_2 - x_{\text{cm}}) or m1∗xcm=m2∗(x2−xcm)m_1 * x_{\text{cm}} = m_2 * (x_2 - x_{\text{cm}})

    You inverted the lever arm distances. Mass m1m_1 is at x1=0 mx_1 = 0\text{ m}, so its distance to the balance point is d1=xcm−0=xcmd_1 = x_{\text{cm}} - 0 = x_{\text{cm}}. Mass m2m_2 is at x2x_2, so its distance to the balance point is d2=x2−xcmd_2 = x_2 - x_{\text{cm}}. Multiplying cross-wise from xcm(m1+m2)=m2x2x_{\text{cm}}(m_1 + m_2) = m_2 x_2 gives m1xcm=m2(x2−xcm)m_1 x_{\text{cm}} = m_2(x_2 - x_{\text{cm}}).

  3. Step 3

    3.20∗(0.900−0.540)=m2∗0.540  ⟹  3.20∗0.360=0.540∗m2  ⟹  1.152=0.540∗m23.20 * (0.900 - 0.540) = m_2 * 0.540 \implies 3.20 * 0.360 = 0.540 * m_2 \implies 1.152 = 0.540 * m_2

    Correct

    3.20∗0.540=m2∗(0.900−0.540)  ⟹  1.728=0.360∗m23.20 * 0.540 = m_2 * (0.900 - 0.540) \implies 1.728 = 0.360 * m_2

    You substituted your numerical values and simplified consistently with your mismatched lever arm equation.

  4. Step 4

    m2=2.13 kgm_2 = 2.13\text{ kg}

    Correct

    m2=4.80 kgm_2 = 4.80\text{ kg}

    Your final calculation followed from the swapped lever arms. A physical sanity check shows that because xcm=0.540 mx_{\text{cm}} = 0.540\text{ m} is beyond the midpoint (0.450 m0.450\text{ m}), m2m_2 must be larger than m1=3.20 kgm_1 = 3.20\text{ kg}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly wrote down the standard formula for the center of mass of a two-body system.

You correctly evaluated the distance difference 0.900−0.540=0.360 m0.900 - 0.540 = 0.360\text{ m}.

You performed the algebraic isolation and division accurately based on your equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Swapped lever arm distances in balance equation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the remaining distance to the right end (x2−xcm)(x_2 - x_{\text{cm}}) with the left mass m1m_1, and the position coordinate xcmx_{\text{cm}} with the right mass m2m_2, reversing the inverse relationship between mass and lever arm in static equilibrium.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distance to Pivot
  • In torque balance ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0 about the center of mass, each mass is multiplied by its own distance to the center of mass: m1d1=m2d2m_1 d_1 = m_2 d_2, where d1=∣xcm−x1∣d_1 = |x_{\text{cm}} - x_1| and d2=∣x2−xcm∣d_2 = |x_2 - x_{\text{cm}}|.

  • Always sketch the line segment and label d1d_1 and d2d_2 from the pivot point xcmx_{\text{cm}} directly to each mass before writing the equation.

Physical Sanity Check
  • The center of mass is always located closer to the heavier mass.

  • Check whether xcmx_{\text{cm}} is past the midpoint: since 0.540 m>0.450 m0.540\text{ m} > 0.450\text{ m}, it is closer to m2m_2, meaning m2m_2 must exceed 3.20 kg3.20\text{ kg}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the torque balance about the center of mass: m1(xcm−x1)=m2(x2−xcm)m_1(x_{\text{cm}} - x_1) = m_2(x_2 - x_{\text{cm}})

  2. Substitute the given values: (3.20 kg)(0.540 m−0 m)=m2(0.900 m−0.540 m)(3.20\text{ kg})(0.540\text{ m} - 0\text{ m}) = m_2(0.900\text{ m} - 0.540\text{ m})

  3. Simplify both sides: (3.20)(0.540)=m2(0.360)  ⟹  1.728=0.360m2(3.20)(0.540) = m_2(0.360) \implies 1.728 = 0.360 m_2

  4. Solve for m2m_2: m2=1.7280.360=4.80 kgm_2 = \frac{1.728}{0.360} = 4.80\text{ kg}

Final answer

m2=4.80 kgm_2 = 4.80\text{ kg}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the principle of moments to ensure lever arms are measured from the pivot to the respective mass.

  • Practice estimating which mass is larger based solely on the location of the center of mass relative to the midpoint.

  • Solve balance problems by substituting directly into xcm=∑mixi∑mix_{\text{cm}} = \frac{\sum m_i x_i}{\sum m_i} before cross-multiplying to avoid algebraic misplacement.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student inverts the lever arms in the torque balance equation, multiplying each mass by the distance to the opposite end or assigning the wrong distance from the pivot.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    xcm=m1⋅x1+m2⋅x2L  ⟹  0.540=3.20⋅0+m2⋅0.9000.900x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 \cdot x_1 + m_2 \cdot x_2}{L} \implies 0.540 = \frac{3.20 \cdot 0 + m_2 \cdot 0.900}{0.900}

    Correct

    xcm=m1x1+m2x2m1+m2  ⟹  0.540=3.20(0)+m2(0.900)3.20+m2x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 x_1 + m_2 x_2}{m_1 + m_2} \implies 0.540 = \frac{3.20(0) + m_2(0.900)}{3.20 + m_2}

    The center of mass is a mass-weighted average of position, so the denominator must be the sum of the masses m1+m2m_1 + m_2, not the geometric length LL.

  2. Step 2

    0.540⋅0.900=0.900⋅m2  ⟹  0.486=0.900⋅m20.540 \cdot 0.900 = 0.900 \cdot m_2 \implies 0.486 = 0.900 \cdot m_2

    Correct

    0.540(3.20+m2)=0.900m2  ⟹  1.728+0.540m2=0.900m20.540(3.20 + m_2) = 0.900m_2 \implies 1.728 + 0.540m_2 = 0.900m_2

    You solved your linear equation correctly, but your calculation was carried out on an incorrect denominator.

  3. Step 3

    m2=0.540 kgm_2 = 0.540\text{ kg}

    Correct

    m2=4.80 kgm_2 = 4.80\text{ kg}

    Because the denominator used length rather than total mass, the resulting mass of the second sphere is incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the coordinates x1=0 mx_1 = 0\text{ m} and x2=0.900 mx_2 = 0.900\text{ m} along the rod.

You substituted the known numerical values into the numerator correctly.

You performed each algebraic step accurately according to your written equation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula Selection

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the center-of-mass weighting denominator (total mass ∑mi\sum m_i) with the spatial span or total length (LL). Notice that dividing the moment ∑mixi\sum m_i x_i (units of kg⋅m\text{kg}\cdot\text{m}) by length LL (units of m\text{m}) yields units of kg\text{kg}, whereas a center-of-mass coordinate must have units of meters.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Center of Mass Denominator Rule
  • The one-dimensional center of mass is defined as xcm=∑mixi∑mix_{\text{cm}} = \frac{\sum m_i x_i}{\sum m_i}. The denominator is always the total mass MtotalM_{\text{total}}, never the total length LL.

  • Before solving for an unknown mass, verify that the denominator is the sum of all masses so that the overall expression yields units of length.

Dimensional Consistency Check
  • The units on both sides of a physical equation must match: [xcm]=m[x_{\text{cm}}] = \text{m}.

  • Check that [mass][length][mass]=m\frac{[\text{mass}][\text{length}]}{[\text{mass}]} = \text{m}. If you place length in the denominator, you get [mass][length][length]=mass\frac{[\text{mass}][\text{length}]}{[\text{length}]} = \text{mass}, which signals a missing total mass term.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the correct center-of-mass formula: xcm=m1x1+m2x2m1+m2x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 x_1 + m_2 x_2}{m_1 + m_2}.

  2. Substitute the known values: 0.540=(3.20)(0)+m2(0.900)3.20+m2=0.900m23.20+m20.540 = \frac{(3.20)(0) + m_2(0.900)}{3.20 + m_2} = \frac{0.900m_2}{3.20 + m_2}.

  3. Clear the denominator: 0.540(3.20+m2)=0.900m2  ⟹  1.728+0.540m2=0.900m20.540(3.20 + m_2) = 0.900m_2 \implies 1.728 + 0.540m_2 = 0.900m_2.

  4. Collect terms in m2m_2: 0.360m2=1.728  ⟹  m2=1.7280.360=4.80 kg0.360m_2 = 1.728 \implies m_2 = \frac{1.728}{0.360} = 4.80\text{ kg}.

Final answer

m2=4.80 kgm_2 = 4.80\text{ kg}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of center of mass as a weighted average where masses serve as the weighting coefficients.

  • Perform a quick units check whenever you write a physical definition to ensure the dimensions balance.

  • Practice solving two-mass balance problems using both the center-of-mass equation and the torque-balance condition m1d1=m2d2m_1 d_1 = m_2 d_2.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies the distance of the second mass from the center of mass as the total length L instead of L - x_cm when balancing torques about the knife-edge.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    m1⋅xcm=m2⋅L  ⟹  3.20⋅0.540=m2⋅0.900m_1 \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = m_2 \cdot L \implies 3.20 \cdot 0.540 = m_2 \cdot 0.900

    Correct

    m1(xcm−x1)=m2(x2−xcm)  ⟹  3.20⋅0.540=m2⋅(0.900−0.540)m_1(x_{\text{cm}} - x_1) = m_2(x_2 - x_{\text{cm}}) \implies 3.20 \cdot 0.540 = m_2 \cdot (0.900 - 0.540)

    When balancing torques about the knife-edge at xcmx_{\text{cm}}, each lever arm must be measured relative to the pivot. Mass m2m_2 is located at x2=0.900 mx_2 = 0.900\text{ m}, so its distance from the pivot is 0.900 m−0.540 m=0.360 m0.900\text{ m} - 0.540\text{ m} = 0.360\text{ m}, not the full length 0.900 m0.900\text{ m}.

  2. Step 2

    1.728=0.900⋅m2  ⟹  m2=1.92 kg1.728 = 0.900 \cdot m_2 \implies m_2 = 1.92\text{ kg}

    Correct

    1.728=0.360⋅m2  ⟹  m2=4.80 kg1.728 = 0.360 \cdot m_2 \implies m_2 = 4.80\text{ kg}

    Your algebraic simplification and division were carried out correctly, but the result is incorrect due to the lever arm error in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the net torque about the balance point must equal zero.

You correctly identified that the distance from m1m_1 to the pivot is 0.540 m0.540\text{ m}.

You solved the linear equation accurately based on your setup.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Lever Arm in Torque Balance

You substituted the position coordinate x2=L=0.900 mx_2 = L = 0.900\text{ m} directly as the lever arm instead of subtracting the pivot coordinate xcm=0.540 mx_{\text{cm}} = 0.540\text{ m}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an absolute coordinate along a reference axis with a relative lever-arm distance measured from the pivot point.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Pivot and Distances
  • A lever arm did_i for torque about a pivot at xpx_p is always the relative distance di=∣xi−xp∣d_i = |x_i - x_p|, never the coordinate xix_i itself unless xp=0x_p = 0.

  • Always sketch the system, mark the pivot location, and explicitly write di=∣xi−xp∣d_i = |x_i - x_p| for every mass before setting up ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up torque balance about the knife-edge: m1(xcm−x1)=m2(x2−xcm)m_1(x_{\text{cm}} - x_1) = m_2(x_2 - x_{\text{cm}})

  2. Substitute the given values: 3.20⋅(0.540−0)=m2⋅(0.900−0.540)3.20 \cdot (0.540 - 0) = m_2 \cdot (0.900 - 0.540)

  3. 1.728=0.360⋅m21.728 = 0.360 \cdot m_2

  4. Divide by 0.3600.360: m2=1.7280.360=4.80 kgm_2 = \frac{1.728}{0.360} = 4.80\text{ kg}

Final answer

m2=4.80 kgm_2 = 4.80\text{ kg}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before substituting into a torque equation, always calculate and label each lever arm d=∣x−xpivot∣d = |x - x_{\text{pivot}}| separately on a sketch.

  • Alternatively, use the center of mass formula xcm=m1x1+m2x2m1+m2x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 x_1 + m_2 x_2}{m_1 + m_2}, where coordinates measured from the origin can be substituted directly.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A light rod of length 1.20 m1.20\text{ m} connects a 4.00 kg4.00\text{ kg} sphere at x1=0 mx_1 = 0\text{ m} and a sphere of mass MM at x2=1.20 mx_2 = 1.20\text{ m}. The system balances on a knife edge at xcm=0.400 mx_{\text{cm}} = 0.400\text{ m}. Calculate the mass MM.

Answer

M=2.00 kgM = 2.00\text{ kg}. The lever arm for the first mass is d1=0.400−0=0.400 md_1 = 0.400 - 0 = 0.400\text{ m}, and for the second mass is d2=1.20−0.400=0.800 md_2 = 1.20 - 0.400 = 0.800\text{ m}. Balancing torques: (4.00 kg)(0.400 m)=M(0.800 m)  ⟹  1.60=0.800M  ⟹  M=2.00 kg(4.00\text{ kg})(0.400\text{ m}) = M(0.800\text{ m}) \implies 1.60 = 0.800M \implies M = 2.00\text{ kg}.

02

Two point masses, m1=5.0 kgm_1 = 5.0\text{ kg} located at x1=1.0 mx_1 = 1.0\text{ m} and m2=15.0 kgm_2 = 15.0\text{ kg} located at x2=5.0 mx_2 = 5.0\text{ m}, rest on a horizontal axis. Find the coordinate xcmx_{\text{cm}} of the center of mass.

Answer

xcm=4.0 mx_{\text{cm}} = 4.0\text{ m}. Using xcm=m1x1+m2x2m1+m2=(5.0)(1.0)+(15.0)(5.0)5.0+15.0=5.0+75.020.0=80.020.0=4.0 mx_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1 x_1 + m_2 x_2}{m_1 + m_2} = \frac{(5.0)(1.0) + (15.0)(5.0)}{5.0 + 15.0} = \frac{5.0 + 75.0}{20.0} = \frac{80.0}{20.0} = 4.0\text{ m}.

03

An asymmetrical bar of total length L=2.00 mL = 2.00\text{ m} and negligible mass has masses mA=6.00 kgm_A = 6.00\text{ kg} at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m}, mB=2.00 kgm_B = 2.00\text{ kg} at x=0.80 mx = 0.80\text{ m}, and an unknown mass mCm_C at x=2.00 mx = 2.00\text{ m}. If the entire system balances at xcm=1.00 mx_{\text{cm}} = 1.00\text{ m}, find mCm_C.

Answer

mC=4.40 kgm_C = 4.40\text{ kg}. Using torque equilibrium about the pivot at xcm=1.00 mx_{\text{cm}} = 1.00\text{ m}: counterclockwise torque from mAm_A and mBm_B must equal clockwise torque from mCm_C. For mAm_A: dA=1.00−0=1.00 md_A = 1.00 - 0 = 1.00\text{ m}. For mBm_B: dB=1.00−0.80=0.20 md_B = 1.00 - 0.80 = 0.20\text{ m}. For mCm_C: dC=2.00−1.00=1.00 md_C = 2.00 - 1.00 = 1.00\text{ m}. Equating torques: (6.00)(1.00)+(2.00)(0.20)=mC(1.00)  ⟹  6.00+0.40=1.00mC  ⟹  mC=6.40−2.00=4.40 kg(6.00)(1.00) + (2.00)(0.20) = m_C(1.00) \implies 6.00 + 0.40 = 1.00 m_C \implies m_C = 6.40 - 2.00 = 4.40\text{ kg}.

Loading workspace…