Resources
A proposed geothermal power plant is evaluated for thermodynamic feasibility. Deep subterranean steam provides heat at , while a surface cooling pond provides an exhaust sink at . The plant specifications claim that the engine absorbs of thermal energy per cycle and outputs of net mechanical work while exhausting the remaining energy to the pond. (a) Determine the maximum theoretical work output allowed by the Second Law of Thermodynamics for this intake of . (b) Determine the maximum allowable efficiency and compare it with the claimed efficiency . (c) State whether the proposed plant satisfies the Second Law or violates the Carnot threshold boundary.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) () versus (); (c) The proposed plant exceeds the Carnot limit () and physically violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
Steps
Convert Reservoir Temperatures to the Kelvin Scale
The maximum thermodynamic efficiency of any heat engine operating between two thermal reservoirs depends strictly on their absolute temperatures. Convert the given temperatures to kelvins:
Common Pitfall: Never use temperatures in degrees Celsius when calculating Carnot efficiency. Ratios of temperatures are only physically meaningful on the absolute (Kelvin) scale.
Determine Maximum Efficiency and Claimed Efficiency
According to Carnot's theorem, no heat engine can be more efficient than a reversible Carnot engine operating between the same two temperatures:
Substitute the absolute temperatures:
Now calculate the engine's claimed thermal efficiency from the claimed work output and heat absorbed :
Comparing the two:
Calculate the Maximum Theoretical Work Output
Using the maximum theoretical efficiency, the maximum work output achievable from the input energy is:
Evaluate Thermodynamic Feasibility
Comparing the claimed work output with the physical upper bound:
Because the claimed work output and efficiency exceed the theoretical maximum set by the Carnot limit (), the proposed power plant would produce a net decrease in the entropy of an isolated system, which physically violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics. Therefore, the proposed plant is thermodynamically impossible.
Typical errors
01 The student calculates Carnot efficiency using temperatures in degrees Celsius instead of converting them to kelvins, yielding an impossibly high theoretical efficiency that falsely makes the plant appear compliant.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Thermodynamic temperature ratios require the absolute Kelvin scale. Substituting Celsius temperatures directly produced an artificially inflated theoretical efficiency of instead of .
- Step 2Correct
Your relationship between maximum work and Carnot efficiency is correct, but the computed value is distorted by using the incorrect efficiency from Step 1.
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
Your reasoning that an engine below the Carnot limit satisfies the Second Law is conceptually sound. However, because the actual Carnot limit is , the claimed efficiency of physically exceeds the maximum bound and violates the Second Law.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou selected the correct Carnot efficiency formula .
You correctly calculated the engine's claimed thermal efficiency as .
You correctly understood that comparing claimed efficiency to the Carnot limit determines whether a cycle is physically allowable.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted temperatures in degrees Celsius into a thermodynamic ratio instead of first converting them to the absolute Kelvin scale.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisForgetting that thermodynamic formulas involving temperature ratios or products (such as and ) are derived from statistical mechanics and absolute zero, meaning only absolute temperature (Kelvin) can be used.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Temperature Scale Rule
Whenever temperature enters a ratio in thermodynamics, you must convert to absolute temperature: .
Always convert Celsius to Kelvin before substituting values into .
- Carnot Feasibility Check
A real heat engine can never exceed the reversible Carnot efficiency: .
Check whether ; if , the proposal violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert temperatures to Kelvin: , .
Recalculate theoretical maximum efficiency: .
Recalculate maximum allowable work: .
Compare: (or ).
Conclude: The proposed plant exceeds the maximum possible theoretical efficiency and therefore violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
(a) ; (b) () versus (); (c) The proposed plant violates the Carnot threshold and the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
02 The student inverts the Carnot temperature ratio as T_H / T_C or confuses heat exhaust with work output, subtracting T_H / T_C or taking (T_H - T_C) / T_C, resulting in an erroneous efficiency expression.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Carnot efficiency is defined relative to the high-temperature heat input , giving . Dividing by confuses heat engine efficiency with the coefficient of performance (COP) of a refrigerator or heat pump.
- Step 3Correct
Your method of multiplying efficiency by heat input is correct, but this step carries forward the incorrect efficiency value from Step 2.
- Step 4
- Step 5
The plant satisfies the Second Law because is less than the calculated maximum efficiency.
CorrectBecause (or ), the proposed plant exceeds the Carnot limit and physically violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
Your comparison logic matches your calculated numbers, but because was overestimated, the resulting conclusion about the Second Law is reversed.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted both Celsius temperatures to the Kelvin scale before performing thermodynamic calculations.
You accurately defined and computed the claimed efficiency as the ratio of net work output to heat absorbed from the hot reservoir.
You recognized that comparing the claimed efficiency against the theoretical maximum efficiency determines whether the Second Law of Thermodynamics is satisfied.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou used the cold reservoir temperature in the denominator instead of the hot reservoir temperature . Thermal efficiency is always work output over heat input (), which corresponds to . Dividing by mistakenly applies the formula structure for the coefficient of performance (COP) of a refrigerator.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Heat Engine Efficiency Formula
For any heat engine, thermal efficiency is the fraction of heat supplied from the hot reservoir that is converted to work: . For a reversible Carnot cycle, this equals .
Always place the hot reservoir absolute temperature in the denominator when calculating heat engine efficiency.
- Sanity Check for Efficiency Limits
Carnot efficiency must always be strictly between and () whenever .
If you divide by , a high temperature ratio can yield values greater than (), which immediately signals that the wrong temperature is in the denominator.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecalculate maximum Carnot efficiency using in the denominator: .
Recalculate maximum theoretical work output: .
Compare the claimed parameters to the Carnot ceiling: and .
Conclude that the proposed plant violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
(a) ; (b) () vs (); (c) The proposed plant violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
03 The student evaluates the plant using only First Law energy conservation, verifying that energy is conserved without checking whether efficiency exceeds the Carnot limit.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
You checked only First Law energy conservation () instead of testing against the Carnot limit. Because (or ), the proposed engine would decrease the total entropy of an isolated system, which violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted both reservoir temperatures to the absolute Kelvin scale.
You correctly applied Carnot's theorem to find the maximum possible efficiency.
You accurately calculated the maximum theoretical work output and the claimed efficiency.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou verified that energy is conserved ( with exhaust heat remaining), but you treated that as proof that the Second Law is satisfied.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated First Law feasibility (energy conservation) with Second Law feasibility (entropy and the Carnot threshold). Energy conservation requires only with , but the Second Law strictly forbids any heat engine from exceeding the Carnot efficiency limit . Because , the proposal violates the Second Law.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- First Law vs. Second Law Feasibility
The First Law checks energy conservation (). The Second Law checks directional entropy increase, requiring .
Always compare to (or to ). If , the device violates the Second Law, even if energy is conserved.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationObserve that and , meaning .
Recall that Carnot's theorem, derived from the Second Law of Thermodynamics, establishes that no cyclic engine operating between two thermal reservoirs can have an efficiency exceeding .
Conclude that exceeding this threshold creates a net decrease in entropy ($ S_{} < 0$), so the engine is physically impossible._
The proposed plant exceeds the Carnot limit ( and ) and physically violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
Lock it in
Why must you always convert temperatures to Kelvin when using the Carnot efficiency formula ?
Carnot efficiency is defined using absolute thermodynamic temperatures where zero corresponds to absolute zero, not the arbitrary zero point of the Celsius scale.
Similar question
A proposed ocean thermal energy conversion (OTEC) plant operates between surface water at and deep ocean water at . Calculate the maximum theoretical thermal efficiency allowed by the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
Answer
Convert temperatures to Kelvin: , . Then or .
An inventor claims to have built an engine operating between and that absorbs of heat and delivers of mechanical work per cycle. Determine whether this claim is thermodynamically possible.
Answer
Convert to Kelvin: , . Carnot efficiency is (). Maximum work is . Because the claimed work () exceeds , the claim violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics and is impossible.
A combined-cycle power plant operates between a combustion chamber at and river coolant at . (a) Find its Carnot limit. (b) If real-world irreversibilities cause the actual plant to achieve exactly of its theoretical Carnot efficiency, calculate the heat input required to produce of electric output.
Answer
(a) , . (). (b) Actual efficiency is (). Heat input rate is (or ).