Resources

Consider a reversible Carnot refrigerator operating between a cold reservoir at temperature TCT_C and a warm ambient environment at fixed temperature TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K}. (a) Express the reversible coefficient of performance COPCarnot\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} purely as a function of the reservoir temperature difference ΔT=TH−TC\Delta T = T_H - T_C. (b) Evaluate COPCarnot\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} at TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K}, TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K}, and TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K} (liquid helium temperature). (c) Evaluate the asymptotic limit lim⁡TC→0∘KCOPCarnot\lim_{T_C \to 0^\circ\text{K}} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} and state the physical implication for the mechanical work required to extract a finite quantity of heat ∣QC∣|Q_C| as the reservoir approaches absolute zero.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) COPCarnot=TH−ΔTΔT=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}; (b) For TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K}, COP=9.00\text{COP} = 9.00; for TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K}, COP=2.00\text{COP} = 2.00; for TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K}, COP=0.0135\text{COP} = 0.0135; (c) lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = 0; an infinite amount of mechanical work (Win→∞W_{\text{in}} \to \infty) is required to remove heat as absolute zero is approached.

Steps

Part (a): Expressing COPCarnot\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} in Terms of ΔT\Delta T

The coefficient of performance of a refrigerator (COP\text{COP}) is defined as the ratio of the heat removed from the cold reservoir (QCQ_C) to the net work input (WinW_{\text{in}}):

COP=QCWin\text{COP} = \frac{Q_C}{W_{\text{in}}}

By the first law of thermodynamics for a cyclic process, Win=QH−QCW_{\text{in}} = Q_H - Q_C, where QHQ_H is the heat discharged to the hot reservoir. For a reversible (Carnot) cycle, the ratio of heat transfers equals the ratio of absolute temperatures:

QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}

Substituting this into the definition gives the standard Carnot coefficient of performance:

COPCarnot=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}

Given the temperature difference ΔT=TH−TC\Delta T = T_H - T_C, the cold reservoir temperature can be written as:

TC=TH−ΔTT_C = T_H - \Delta T

Substituting TCT_C and the denominator TH−TC=ΔTT_H - T_C = \Delta T into the equation:

COPCarnot=TH−ΔTΔT=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}


Part (b): Evaluating COPCarnot\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} at Specified Temperatures

With TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K}:

  1. For TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K} (household freezer range): ΔT=300 K−270 K=30 K\Delta T = 300\text{ K} - 270\text{ K} = 30\text{ K} COPCarnot=27030=9.00\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{270}{30} = 9.00
  2. For TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K} (dry ice range): ΔT=300 K−200 K=100 K\Delta T = 300\text{ K} - 200\text{ K} = 100\text{ K} COPCarnot=200100=2.00\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{200}{100} = 2.00
  3. For TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K} (liquid helium range): ΔT=300 K−4.00 K=296 K\Delta T = 300\text{ K} - 4.00\text{ K} = 296\text{ K} COPCarnot=4.00296≈0.0135\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{4.00}{296} \approx 0.0135

Common Pitfall: Always use absolute temperatures in kelvins (K\text{K}), never in degrees Celsius (∘C^\circ\text{C}), when computing thermodynamic ratios.


Part (c): Asymptotic Limit as TC→0 KT_C \to 0\text{ K} and Physical Implication

Taking the limit of COPCarnot\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} as TC→0 KT_C \to 0\text{ K} while holding THT_H constant:

lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=lim⁡TC→0(TCTH−TC)=0TH=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \lim_{T_C \to 0} \left(\frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}\right) = \frac{0}{T_H} = 0

From the fundamental definition of the coefficient of performance:

Win=QCCOPCarnotW_{\text{in}} = \frac{Q_C}{\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}}}

As TC→0T_C \to 0, COPCarnot→0\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} \to 0. Therefore, to extract any finite quantity of thermal energy QC>0Q_C > 0 from a body as it approaches absolute zero:

lim⁡TC→0Win=lim⁡TC→0QCCOPCarnot→∞\lim_{T_C \to 0} W_{\text{in}} = \lim_{T_C \to 0} \frac{Q_C}{\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}}} \to \infty

Physical Implication: An infinite amount of mechanical work is required to extract heat from a system at temperatures approaching absolute zero. This is a direct thermodynamic manifestation of the Third Law of Thermodynamics (the unattainability principle), stating that absolute zero cannot be reached in a finite number of thermodynamic operations.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the coefficient of performance of a refrigerator with that of a heat pump, using T_H / ΔT instead of T_C / ΔT.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    COPCarnot=THTH−TC  ⟹  ΔT=TH−TC  ⟹  COPCarnot=300ΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} \implies \Delta T = T_H - T_C \implies \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300}{\Delta T}

    Correct

    COPCarnot=TCTH−TC=TH−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T}

    You used the definition for a heat pump rather than a refrigerator. A refrigerator's objective is to extract heat QCQ_C from the cold reservoir, so its coefficient of performance is defined as COP=QCWin=TCTH−TC=TH−ΔTΔT\text{COP} = \frac{Q_C}{W_{\text{in}}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T}.

  2. Step 2

    For TC=270 K:ΔT=30 K,COPCarnot=30030=10  ⟹  For TC=200 K:ΔT=100 K,COPCarnot=300100=3  ⟹  For TC=4.00 K:ΔT=296 K,COPCarnot=300296≈1.01\text{For } T_C = 270\text{ K}: \Delta T = 30\text{ K}, \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300}{30} = 10 \implies \text{For } T_C = 200\text{ K}: \Delta T = 100\text{ K}, \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300}{100} = 3 \implies \text{For } T_C = 4.00\text{ K}: \Delta T = 296\text{ K}, \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300}{296} \approx 1.01

    Correct

    For TC=270 K:COP=27030=9.00  ⟹  For TC=200 K:COP=200100=2.00  ⟹  For TC=4.00 K:COP=4.00296≈0.0135\text{For } T_C = 270\text{ K}: \text{COP} = \frac{270}{30} = 9.00 \implies \text{For } T_C = 200\text{ K}: \text{COP} = \frac{200}{100} = 2.00 \implies \text{For } T_C = 4.00\text{ K}: \text{COP} = \frac{4.00}{296} \approx 0.0135

    Your arithmetic was accurate for the formula you used, but because of the initial formula mix-up, each value equals COPref+1\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} + 1.

  3. Step 3

    lim⁡TC→0 KCOPCarnot=300300=1  ⟹  Work W=∣QC∣COPCarnot=∣QC∣, so finite work is needed to remove heat at absolute zero.\lim_{T_C \to 0\text{ K}} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300}{300} = 1 \implies \text{Work } W = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}}} = |Q_C|\text{, so finite work is needed to remove heat at absolute zero.}

    Correct

    lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=lim⁡TC→0TCTH−TC=0  ⟹  Win=∣QC∣COPCarnot→∞, so infinite work is required.\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \lim_{T_C \to 0} \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = 0 \implies W_{\text{in}} = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}}} \to \infty\text{, so infinite work is required.}

    With the correct refrigerator formula, the numerator approaches 00 while the denominator approaches THT_H, giving lim⁡TC→0COP=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP} = 0. Consequently, extracting any finite amount of heat ∣QC∣|Q_C| near absolute zero requires an infinite amount of work (Win→∞W_{\text{in}} \to \infty), illustrating the Third Law of Thermodynamics.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the temperature differences ΔT=TH−TC\Delta T = T_H - T_C for all three test temperatures.

You correctly recognized that required work is related to heat and performance by W=∣QC∣COPW = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}}.

You carried out all algebraic and numerical substitutions carefully.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Heat pump vs. refrigerator COP confusion

You set the numerator of COP\text{COP} to THT_H instead of TCT_C.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the performance metric of a refrigerator with that of a heat pump. A refrigerator's desired benefit is removing heat from the cold reservoir (QCQ_C), giving COPref=QCW=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} = \frac{Q_C}{W} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}, whereas a heat pump's desired benefit is delivering heat to the warm space (QHQ_H), giving COPHP=QHW=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Desired Output
  • COP=What you wantWhat you pay for\text{COP} = \frac{\text{What you want}}{\text{What you pay for}}

  • For cooling/refrigeration, the desired output is QCQ_C, so the numerator is TCT_C. For heating/heat pumps, the desired output is QHQ_H, so the numerator is THT_H.

Sanity Check the Absolute Zero Limit
  • As TC→0 KT_C \to 0\text{ K}, cooling must become infinitely difficult: COPref→0\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} \to 0.

  • Check whether your expression approaches zero as TC→0T_C \to 0. If it approaches 11, you have likely used the heat pump formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the definition of refrigerator performance: COPCarnot=QCWin=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{Q_C}{W_{\text{in}}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}.

  2. Substitute TC=TH−ΔTT_C = T_H - \Delta T to express purely in terms of ΔT\Delta T: COPCarnot=TH−ΔTΔT=300−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T} = \frac{300 - \Delta T}{\Delta T}.

  3. Evaluate at TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K} (ΔT=30 K\Delta T = 30\text{ K}): COP=27030=9.00\text{COP} = \frac{270}{30} = 9.00.

  4. Evaluate at TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K} (ΔT=100 K\Delta T = 100\text{ K}): COP=200100=2.00\text{COP} = \frac{200}{100} = 2.00.

  5. Evaluate at TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K} (ΔT=296 K\Delta T = 296\text{ K}): COP=4.00296≈0.0135\text{COP} = \frac{4.00}{296} \approx 0.0135.

  6. Take the limit: lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=0TH=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{0}{T_H} = 0.

  7. Conclude the required work: Win=∣QC∣COP→∞W_{\text{in}} = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}} \to \infty, meaning infinite mechanical work is required to extract heat as absolute zero is approached.

Final answer

(a) COPCarnot=TH−ΔTΔT=TCΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T} = \frac{T_C}{\Delta T}; (b) 9.009.00, 2.002.00, and 0.01350.0135; (c) lim⁡TC→0COP=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP} = 0, requiring infinite work (Win→∞W_{\text{in}} \to \infty).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the energy flow diagrams for both heat engines and reverse cycles to anchor the difference between cooling effect (QCQ_C) and heating effect (QHQ_H).

  • Memorize the useful identity COPHP=COPref+1\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \text{COP}_{\text{ref}} + 1 to quickly verify your formulas.

  • Practice checking physical limits (TC→0 KT_C \to 0\text{ K} and TC→THT_C \to T_H) whenever deriving thermodynamic performance coefficients.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the coefficient of performance of a refrigerator with Carnot heat engine efficiency η = ΔT / T_H.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    COPCarnot=TH−TCTH  ⟹  COPCarnot=ΔT300\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_H} \implies \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{\Delta T}{300}

    Correct

    COPCarnot=TCTH−TC=TH−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T}

    You used the thermal efficiency formula for a heat engine η=WQH=TH−TCTH\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_H} instead of the coefficient of performance for a refrigerator, which is defined as COP=QCW=TCTH−TC\text{COP} = \frac{Q_C}{W} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}.

  2. Step 2

    For TC=270 K:ΔT=30 K,COPCarnot=0.1  ⟹  For TC=200 K:COPCarnot=100300=0.333  ⟹  For TC=4.00 K:COPCarnot=296300≈0.987\text{For } T_C = 270\text{ K}: \Delta T = 30\text{ K}, \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = 0.1 \implies \text{For } T_C = 200\text{ K}: \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{100}{300} = 0.333 \implies \text{For } T_C = 4.00\text{ K}: \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{296}{300} \approx 0.987

    Correct

    For TC=270 K:COP=27030=9.00;  For TC=200 K:COP=200100=2.00;  For TC=4.00 K:COP=4.00296≈0.0135\text{For } T_C = 270\text{ K}: \text{COP} = \frac{270}{30} = 9.00;\; \text{For } T_C = 200\text{ K}: \text{COP} = \frac{200}{100} = 2.00;\; \text{For } T_C = 4.00\text{ K}: \text{COP} = \frac{4.00}{296} \approx 0.0135

    Your arithmetic and substitutions followed consistently from your formula in Step 1, but the values are incorrect because of the initial formula error.

  3. Step 3

    lim⁡TC→0 KCOPCarnot=300300=1  ⟹  W=∣QC∣1=∣QC∣, which is finite.\lim_{T_C \to 0\text{ K}} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300}{300} = 1 \implies W = \frac{|Q_C|}{1} = |Q_C|\text{, which is finite.}

    Correct

    lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=lim⁡TC→0TCTH−TC=0  ⟹  W=∣QC∣COP→∞\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \lim_{T_C \to 0} \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = 0 \implies W = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}} \to \infty

    Because the true COP\text{COP} has TCT_C in the numerator, it approaches 00 as TC→0 KT_C \to 0\text{ K}. Consequently, extracting a finite amount of heat ∣QC∣|Q_C| requires infinite work (W→∞W \to \infty), consistent with the Third Law of Thermodynamics.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the temperature differences ΔT=TH−TC\Delta T = T_H - T_C for each cold-reservoir temperature.

You correctly related the mechanical work input to the heat removed and the coefficient of performance via W=∣QC∣COPW = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion between heat engine efficiency and refrigerator COP

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the performance metric of a heat engine (efficiency η=work outputheat input=WQH\eta = \frac{\text{work output}}{\text{heat input}} = \frac{W}{Q_H}) with that of a refrigerator (coefficient of performance COP=cooling benefitwork input=QCW\text{COP} = \frac{\text{cooling benefit}}{\text{work input}} = \frac{Q_C}{W}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the device objective
  • A heat engine turns heat into work ("benefit"=W"\text{benefit}" = W), while a refrigerator removes heat from a cold space ("benefit"=QC"\text{benefit}" = Q_C).

  • Always write the fundamental energy ratio desired outputrequired input\frac{\text{desired output}}{\text{required input}} before substituting temperatures.

Carnot temperature substitutions
  • For a reversible cycle, QHTH=QCTC\frac{Q_H}{T_H} = \frac{Q_C}{T_C}, so COPref=QCQH−QC=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} = \frac{Q_C}{Q_H - Q_C} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}.

  • Check that your refrigerator COP\text{COP} can exceed 11 when ΔT\Delta T is small, whereas heat engine efficiency η\eta can never exceed 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the Carnot refrigerator COP using absolute temperatures: COPCarnot=TCTH−TC=TH−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T}.

  2. Evaluate at TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K}: COP=270300−270=27030=9.00\text{COP} = \frac{270}{300 - 270} = \frac{270}{30} = 9.00.

  3. Evaluate at TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K}: COP=200300−200=200100=2.00\text{COP} = \frac{200}{300 - 200} = \frac{200}{100} = 2.00.

  4. Evaluate at TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K}: COP=4.00300−4.00=4.00296≈0.0135\text{COP} = \frac{4.00}{300 - 4.00} = \frac{4.00}{296} \approx 0.0135.

  5. Evaluate the limit as TC→0 KT_C \to 0\text{ K}: lim⁡TC→0COP=0TH=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP} = \frac{0}{T_H} = 0.

  6. Find the required work: W=QCCOP→∞W = \frac{Q_C}{\text{COP}} \to \infty, meaning infinite work is required.

Final answer

(a) COPCarnot=TH−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H - \Delta T}{\Delta T}; (b) 9.009.00, 2.002.00, and 0.01350.0135; (c) Limit is 00, requiring an infinite amount of work (W→∞W \to \infty).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental distinction between η=WQH\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H} (heat engine) and COP=QCW\text{COP} = \frac{Q_C}{W} (refrigerator).

  • Practice writing out the derivation of COPCarnot=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} directly from the First Law (W=QH−QCW = Q_H - Q_C) and reversibility (QH/QC=TH/TCQ_H/Q_C = T_H/T_C).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the definition of refrigerator COP as W / Q_C = ΔT / T_C instead of Q_C / W.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    COPCarnot=TH−TCTC  ⟹  TC=300−ΔT  ⟹  COPCarnot=ΔT300−ΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_C} \implies T_C = 300 - \Delta T \implies \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{\Delta T}{300 - \Delta T}

    Correct

    COPCarnot=TCTH−TC=300−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{300 - \Delta T}{\Delta T}

    You inverted the ratio for a refrigerator's coefficient of performance. The performance metric is 'what you get out' divided by 'what you put in', which is ∣QC∣Win=TCTH−TC\frac{|Q_C|}{W_{\text{in}}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}, not Win∣QC∣\frac{W_{\text{in}}}{|Q_C|}.

  2. Step 2

    For TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K}: ΔT=30 K,COPCarnot=30270=19≈0.111\Delta T = 30\text{ K}, \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{30}{270} = \frac{1}{9} \approx 0.111 ⟹ For TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K}: ΔT=100 K,COPCarnot=100200=0.5\Delta T = 100\text{ K}, \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{100}{200} = 0.5 ⟹ For TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K}: ΔT=296 K,COPCarnot=2964=74\Delta T = 296\text{ K}, \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{296}{4} = 74

    Correct

    For TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K}: COP=27030=9.00\text{COP} = \frac{270}{30} = 9.00; For TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K}: COP=200100=2.00\text{COP} = \frac{200}{100} = 2.00; For TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K}: COP=4.00296≈0.0135\text{COP} = \frac{4.00}{296} \approx 0.0135

    Your arithmetic substitutions follow your expression from part (a), but the values are reciprocals of the true Carnot COP values because they were evaluated using the inverted formula.

  3. Step 3

    lim⁡TC→0 K=3000=∞  ⟹  Work W=∣QC∣×COPCarnot→∞\lim_{T_C \to 0\text{ K}} = \frac{300}{0} = \infty \implies \text{Work } W = |Q_C| \times \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} \to \infty, so infinite work is required to extract heat.

    Correct

    lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=lim⁡TC→0TCTH−TC=0  ⟹  Win=∣QC∣COPCarnot→∞\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \lim_{T_C \to 0} \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = 0 \implies W_{\text{in}} = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}}} \to \infty

    You evaluated the limit of COP\text{COP} as ∞\infty because of the inverted formula, and you wrote W=∣QC∣×COPW = |Q_C| \times \text{COP} to relate work to COP. The true definition is Win=∣QC∣COPW_{\text{in}} = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}}, so as COP→0\text{COP} \to 0, Win→∞W_{\text{in}} \to \infty.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the reservoir temperatures using TC=TH−ΔT=300−ΔTT_C = T_H - \Delta T = 300 - \Delta T.

You accurately substituted your temperature difference values into each expression in part (b).

You correctly deduced the physical conclusion that infinite work is required to reach absolute zero.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted thermodynamic performance ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined the refrigerator coefficient of performance as the reciprocal ratio Win/QC=(TH−TC)/TCW_{\text{in}} / Q_C = (T_H - T_C)/T_C rather than desired cooling benefit over work cost, QC/Win=TC/(TH−TC)Q_C / W_{\text{in}} = T_C / (T_H - T_C).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Benefit over Cost Principle
  • Every coefficient of performance or efficiency is defined as Desired OutputRequired Input\frac{\text{Desired Output}}{\text{Required Input}}.

  • For a refrigerator, the desired output is heat removed from the cold space (QCQ_C) and the required input is work (WinW_{\text{in}}), so COP=QCWin=TCTH−TC\text{COP} = \frac{Q_C}{W_{\text{in}}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}.

Physical Reality Check at Extreme Temperatures
  • Refrigerating an object close to absolute zero becomes extremely inefficient, meaning COP→0\text{COP} \to 0, not ∞\infty.

  • Always verify that lower cold-reservoir temperatures yield smaller COP values, because moving heat against a larger temperature gap requires more work per joule removed.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from the fundamental definition: COPCarnot=QCWin=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{Q_C}{W_{\text{in}}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}.

  2. Substitute TH−TC=ΔTT_H - T_C = \Delta T and TC=TH−ΔT=300−ΔTT_C = T_H - \Delta T = 300 - \Delta T: COPCarnot=300−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300 - \Delta T}{\Delta T}.

  3. Re-evaluate part (b): for TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K}, COP=27030=9.00\text{COP} = \frac{270}{30} = 9.00; for TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K}, COP=200100=2.00\text{COP} = \frac{200}{100} = 2.00; for TC=4.00 KT_C = 4.00\text{ K}, COP=4.00296≈0.0135\text{COP} = \frac{4.00}{296} \approx 0.0135.

  4. Evaluate the limit: lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=0300=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{0}{300} = 0. Since Win=∣QC∣COPW_{\text{in}} = \frac{|Q_C|}{\text{COP}}, Win→∞W_{\text{in}} \to \infty as TC→0T_C \to 0.

Final answer

(a) COPCarnot=300−ΔTΔT\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{300 - \Delta T}{\Delta T}; (b) 9.009.00, 2.002.00, 0.01350.0135; (c) lim⁡TC→0COPCarnot=0\lim_{T_C \to 0} \text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = 0, requiring infinite work (Win→∞W_{\text{in}} \to \infty).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize thermodynamic performance ratios using 'Benefit / Cost': η=W/QH\eta = W/Q_H for engines, but COPref=QC/W\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} = Q_C/W for refrigerators.

  • Perform a sanity check on COP trends: cooling near room temperature should have a high COP (>1>1), while cooling near absolute zero must approach zero.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A Carnot refrigerator maintains an interior at −23∘C-23^\circ\text{C} in a room at 27∘C27^\circ\text{C}. Calculate its coefficient of performance.

Answer

First convert temperatures to kelvins: TC=273.15−23=250.15 K≈250 KT_C = 273.15 - 23 = 250.15\text{ K} \approx 250\text{ K} and TH=273.15+27=300.15 K≈300 KT_H = 273.15 + 27 = 300.15\text{ K} \approx 300\text{ K}. Then COP=TCTH−TC=250300−250=25050=5.00\text{COP} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{250}{300 - 250} = \frac{250}{50} = 5.00.

02

A cryogenic cooler is designed to remove heat at a rate of 2.0 W2.0\text{ W} from a superconducting sensor at TC=20 KT_C = 20\text{ K} and exhaust heat to ambient air at TH=300 KT_H = 300\text{ K}. Assuming Carnot efficiency, find the minimum electrical power input required.

Answer

The Carnot refrigerator COP\text{COP} is COP=TCTH−TC=20300−20=20280=114≈0.0714\text{COP} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{20}{300 - 20} = \frac{20}{280} = \frac{1}{14} \approx 0.0714. The minimum power required is Pin=Q˙CCOP=2.0 W×14=28 WP_{\text{in}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{\text{COP}} = 2.0\text{ W} \times 14 = 28\text{ W}.

03

A cyclic cooling system extracts heat ∣QC∣|Q_C| from a finite thermal reservoir of heat capacity CC (constant), cooling it from T0T_0 down to T1T_1, and rejects heat to an infinite environment at constant temperature THT_H. Show using the Carnot coefficient of performance that the total work required is W=C[THln⁡(T0T1)−(T0−T1)]W = C \left[ T_H \ln\left(\frac{T_0}{T_1}\right) - (T_0 - T_1) \right].

Answer

For an infinitesimal step, dQC=−C dTdQ_C = -C\,dT, and dW=dQCCOP=−C dT(TH−TT)=C(1−THT)dTdW = \frac{dQ_C}{\text{COP}} = -C\,dT \left(\frac{T_H - T}{T}\right) = C\left(1 - \frac{T_H}{T}\right)dT. Integrating from T0T_0 to T1T_1: W=∫T0T1C(1−THT)dT=C[(T1−T0)−THln⁡(T1T0)]=C[THln⁡(T0T1)−(T0−T1)]W = \int_{T_0}^{T_1} C\left(1 - \frac{T_H}{T}\right)dT = C\left[(T_1 - T_0) - T_H \ln\left(\frac{T_1}{T_0}\right)\right] = C\left[T_H \ln\left(\frac{T_0}{T_1}\right) - (T_0 - T_1)\right]. Notice as T1→0T_1 \to 0, W→∞W \to \infty.

Loading workspace…