Resources

A thin wire is bent into a semicircle of radius R=0.200 mR = 0.200\text{ m} in the xyxy-plane, lying in the upper half-plane y≥0y \ge 0 with endpoints at (−R,0)(-R, 0) and (+R,0)(+R, 0). The wire carries a steady current I=4.50 AI = 4.50\text{ A} flowing counterclockwise from (−R,0)(-R, 0) to (+R,0)(+R, 0). A uniform magnetic field B⃗=B0j^\vec{B} = B_0\hat{j} with B0=0.800 TB_0 = 0.800\text{ T} is applied along the positive yy-axis. By integrating the differential force dF⃗B=I(dl⃗×B⃗)d\vec{F}_B = I(d\vec{l} \times \vec{B}) along the curved path (or by evaluating the equivalent displacement vector L⃗eff\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} between the endpoints), determine the total magnetic force F⃗B\vec{F}_B acting on the semicircular wire.

Answer and steps

Final answer

F⃗B=(1.44k^) N\vec{F}_B = (1.44\hat{k})\text{ N} (Magnitude: 1.44 N1.44\text{ N} along the positive zz-axis)

Steps

Method 1: Using the Equivalent Displacement Vector

For any current-carrying conductor in a uniform magnetic field B⃗\vec{B}, the magnetic force dF⃗Bd\vec{F}_B on an infinitesimal segment dl⃗d\vec{l} is given by: dF⃗B=I(dl⃗×B⃗)d\vec{F}_B = I(d\vec{l} \times \vec{B})

Integrating over the entire wire from the starting point to the ending point: F⃗B=∫I(dl⃗×B⃗)=I(∫dl⃗)×B⃗=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = \int I(d\vec{l} \times \vec{B}) = I \left(\int d\vec{l}\right) \times \vec{B} = I (\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B})

where L⃗eff\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} is the net displacement vector from the current's entry point to its exit point:

  • Initial point: (−R,0,0)(-R, 0, 0)
  • Final point: (+R,0,0)(+R, 0, 0)

L⃗eff=(R−(−R))i^=2Ri^\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = (R - (-R))\hat{i} = 2R\hat{i}

Now, compute the cross product with B⃗=B0j^\vec{B} = B_0\hat{j}: F⃗B=I(2Ri^×B0j^)=2IRB0(i^×j^)=2IRB0k^\vec{F}_B = I (2R\hat{i} \times B_0\hat{j}) = 2IRB_0(\hat{i} \times \hat{j}) = 2IRB_0\hat{k}

Substitute the given numerical values:

  • I=4.50 AI = 4.50\text{ A}
  • R=0.200 mR = 0.200\text{ m}
  • B0=0.800 TB_0 = 0.800\text{ T}

F⃗B=2⋅(4.50 A)⋅(0.200 m)⋅(0.800 T)k^=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = 2 \cdot (4.50\text{ A}) \cdot (0.200\text{ m}) \cdot (0.800\text{ T})\hat{k} = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}


Method 2: Direct Integration along the Semicircle

To verify this result, we can parameterize the semicircular path in the xyxy-plane using the angle θ\theta measured from the positive xx-axis. Since the path lies in the upper half-plane (y≥0y \ge 0) and the current flows from (−R,0)(-R, 0) to (+R,0)(+R, 0), θ\theta decreases from π\pi to 00:

r⃗(θ)=Rcos⁡θi^+Rsin⁡θj^\vec{r}(\theta) = R\cos\theta\hat{i} + R\sin\theta\hat{j} dl⃗=dr⃗=(−Rsin⁡θi^+Rcos⁡θj^)dθd\vec{l} = d\vec{r} = (-R\sin\theta\hat{i} + R\cos\theta\hat{j})d\theta

Taking the cross product with B⃗=B0j^\vec{B} = B_0\hat{j}: dl⃗×B⃗=(−Rsin⁡θi^+Rcos⁡θj^)dθ×B0j^=−B0Rsin⁡θ dθ (i^×j^)=−B0Rsin⁡θ dθ k^d\vec{l} \times \vec{B} = (-R\sin\theta\hat{i} + R\cos\theta\hat{j})d\theta \times B_0\hat{j} = -B_0 R \sin\theta\, d\theta\, (\hat{i} \times \hat{j}) = -B_0 R \sin\theta\, d\theta\,\hat{k}

Integrate from θ=π\theta = \pi to θ=0\theta = 0: F⃗B=∫π0I(−B0Rsin⁡θ dθ k^)=−IB0Rk^∫π0sin⁡θ dθ\vec{F}_B = \int_{\pi}^{0} I (-B_0 R \sin\theta\, d\theta\,\hat{k}) = -I B_0 R \hat{k} \int_{\pi}^{0} \sin\theta\, d\theta

Evaluating the integral: ∫π0sin⁡θ dθ=[−cos⁡θ]π0=−(1−(−1))=−2\int_{\pi}^{0} \sin\theta\, d\theta = \left[-\cos\theta\right]_{\pi}^{0} = -(1 - (-1)) = -2

Multiplying by the leading factors: F⃗B=−IB0Rk^(−2)=2IRB0k^=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = -I B_0 R \hat{k} (-2) = 2 I R B_0 \hat{k} = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

Both approaches yield the total magnetic force: F⃗B=(1.44k^) N\vec{F}_B = (1.44\hat{k})\text{ N}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly uses the actual path length of the wire, πR, instead of the endpoint-to-endpoint displacement vector 2R when calculating the force in a uniform magnetic field.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Length of the wire is \text{Length of the wire is } L = π\pi R = π\pi(0.200) = 0.628 m\text{ m}

    Correct

    L⃗\vec{L}{eff\text{eff}} = \int dl⃗\vec{l} = r⃗\vec{r}{final\text{final}} - r⃗\vec{r}{initial\text{initial}} = (R - (-R))i^\hat{i} = 2Ri^\hat{i} = 0.400\hat{i}$$\text{ m}$$

    Because the magnetic field B⃗\vec{B} is uniform across space, it factors out of the path integral: F⃗B=∫I(dl⃗×B⃗)=I(∫dl⃗)×B⃗=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = \int I(d\vec{l} \times \vec{B}) = I\left(\int d\vec{l}\right) \times \vec{B} = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}). The relevant geometric quantity is the straight displacement vector between the endpoints (2R2R), not the scalar arc length (πR)(\pi R).

  2. Step 2

    F_B = I L B (i ×\times j)   ⟹  \implies F_B = (4.50)(0.628)(0.800) k = 2.26 k N\text{ N}

    Correct

    F⃗\vec{F}B = I(L⃗\vec{L}{eff\text{eff}} ×\times B⃗\vec{B}) = (4.50 A\text{ A})(0.400\hat{i}$$\text{ m} ×\times 0.800\hat{j}$$\text{ T}) = 1.44$\hat{k} N\text{ N}

    Your cross product direction i^×j^=k^\hat{i} \times \hat{j} = \hat{k} and numerical multiplication were executed properly, but the resulting magnitude of 2.26 N2.26\text{ N} is incorrect due to using L=0.628 mL = 0.628\text{ m} instead of Leff=0.400 mL_{\text{eff}} = 0.400\text{ m}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the net current direction points along the positive xx-axis from (−R,0)(-R, 0) to (+R,0)(+R, 0).

You correctly evaluated the cross product direction using i^×j^=k^\hat{i} \times \hat{j} = \hat{k}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Arc Length vs. Effective Displacement

Using the scalar curve length πR\pi R instead of the vector displacement Δr⃗=2Ri^\Delta \vec{r} = 2R\hat{i} between the endpoints.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the actual physical path length of a wire with its effective vector displacement when integrating differential forces in a uniform field. Since B⃗\vec{B} is constant, ∫(dl⃗×B⃗)=(∫dl⃗)×B⃗=L⃗eff×B⃗\int (d\vec{l} \times \vec{B}) = (\int d\vec{l}) \times \vec{B} = \vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Factoring Uniform Fields
  • If B⃗\vec{B} is uniform, F⃗B=I(∫dl⃗)×B⃗=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = I \left(\int d\vec{l}\right) \times \vec{B} = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}).

  • Always replace any arbitrarily shaped wire in a uniform field with a straight line segment connecting its starting point to its endpoint.

Straight Displacement vs. Contour Length
  • L⃗eff=r⃗end−r⃗start\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = \vec{r}_{\text{end}} - \vec{r}_{\text{start}}.

  • Check whether the problem asks for the force on a path in a uniform field; if so, compute coordinates of the two endpoints rather than integrating arc length.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the start point (−R,0,0)(-R, 0, 0) and end point (+R,0,0)(+R, 0, 0) of the current flow.

  2. Calculate the effective displacement vector: L⃗eff=(R−(−R))i^=2Ri^=2(0.200 m)i^=0.400i^ m\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = (R - (-R))\hat{i} = 2R\hat{i} = 2(0.200\text{ m})\hat{i} = 0.400\hat{i}\text{ m}.

  3. Compute the total magnetic force: F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)=(4.50 A)(0.400i^ m×0.800j^ T)=2(4.50)(0.200)(0.800)k^ N\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}) = (4.50\text{ A})(0.400\hat{i}\text{ m} \times 0.800\hat{j}\text{ T}) = 2(4.50)(0.200)(0.800)\hat{k}\text{ N}.

Final answer

F⃗B=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the vector integration step showing why ∫dl⃗=L⃗eff\int d\vec{l} = \vec{L}_{\text{eff}} whenever B⃗\vec{B} is spatially uniform.

  • Practice finding L⃗eff\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} for other wire shapes (e.g., zig-zag, quarter-circle, closed loop) in uniform fields.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student reverses the order of the cross product as B × L_eff or incorrectly computes i × j = -k, leading to the opposite force direction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    L⃗eff=2Ri^=2(0.200)i^=0.400i^ m\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = 2R\hat{i} = 2(0.200)\hat{i} = 0.400\hat{i}\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    F⃗B=I(B⃗×L⃗eff)=(4.50)(0.800j^×0.400i^)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{B} \times \vec{L}_{\text{eff}}) = (4.50)(0.800\hat{j} \times 0.400\hat{i})

    Correct

    F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)=(4.50)(0.400i^×0.800j^)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}) = (4.50)(0.400\hat{i} \times 0.800\hat{j})

    The magnetic force formula is F⃗B=I(L⃗×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}). Reversing the cross product to B⃗×L⃗\vec{B} \times \vec{L} changes the sign because cross products are anticommutative.

  3. Step 3

    F⃗B=−1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = -1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

    Correct

    F⃗B=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

    You accurately evaluated your expression using j^×i^=−k^\hat{j} \times \hat{i} = -\hat{k}, but the sign error from Step 2 carried into this final answer.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that a curved wire in a uniform magnetic field can be analyzed using the equivalent displacement vector L⃗eff\vec{L}_{\text{eff}}.

You calculated the magnitude and direction of L⃗eff=0.400i^ m\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = 0.400\hat{i}\text{ m} accurately.

You correctly evaluated the unit vector cross product j^×i^=−k^\hat{j} \times \hat{i} = -\hat{k} and the numerical arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed cross-product order in magnetic force

You set up the magnetic force equation as F⃗B=I(B⃗×L⃗)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{B} \times \vec{L}) instead of F⃗B=I(L⃗×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the order of operands in the Lorentz force law for current segments. Unlike scalar multiplication, vector cross products are anticommutative: A⃗×B⃗=−(B⃗×A⃗)\vec{A} \times \vec{B} = -(\vec{B} \times \vec{A}). The current path displacement L⃗\vec{L} must always be the first vector, crossed into the magnetic field vector B⃗\vec{B}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Recall the differential force law
  • dF⃗B=I(dl⃗×B⃗)d\vec{F}_B = I(d\vec{l} \times \vec{B}), so F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}).

  • Always write current displacement L⃗\vec{L} first and field B⃗\vec{B} second.

Right-hand rule check
  • Point the fingers of your right hand along current flow L⃗\vec{L}, curl them toward field B⃗\vec{B}, and your thumb points along force F⃗B\vec{F}_B.

  • Check: L⃗\vec{L} is in +x+x (right), B⃗\vec{B} is in +y+y (up), so +x×+y=+z+x \times +y = +z (out of the page, +k^+\hat{k}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B})

  2. F⃗B=(4.50 A)⋅(0.400i^ m×0.800j^ T)\vec{F}_B = (4.50\text{ A}) \cdot (0.400\hat{i}\text{ m} \times 0.800\hat{j}\text{ T})

  3. F⃗B=(4.50)(0.400)(0.800)(i^×j^) N=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = (4.50)(0.400)(0.800)(\hat{i} \times \hat{j})\text{ N} = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

Final answer

F⃗B=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the standard magnetic force relation as I(L⃗×B⃗)I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}) by associating the first term with the moving charges/current and the second with the external field.

  • Practice using the right-hand rule immediately after setting up a cross product to catch sign flips before computing.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses the radius R instead of the diameter 2R for the straight-line displacement between the endpoints.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Leff=Ri^=0.200i^ mL_{\text{eff}} = R\hat{i} = 0.200\hat{i}\text{ m}

    Correct

    L⃗eff=r⃗final−r⃗initial=(R−(−R))i^=2Ri^=0.400i^ m\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = \vec{r}_{\text{final}} - \vec{r}_{\text{initial}} = (R - (-R))\hat{i} = 2R\hat{i} = 0.400\hat{i}\text{ m}

    The effective displacement vector L⃗eff=∫dl⃗\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = \int d\vec{l} goes from the starting point (−R,0)(-R, 0) to the end point (+R,0)(+R, 0). This straight-line distance is the full diameter 2R=0.400 m2R = 0.400\text{ m}, not just the radius RR.

  2. Step 2

    FB=I(Leff×B)=(4.50)(0.200i^×0.800j^)F_B = I(L_{\text{eff}} \times B) = (4.50)(0.200\hat{i} \times 0.800\hat{j})

    Correct

    F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)=(4.50 A)(0.400i^ m×0.800j^ T)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}) = (4.50\text{ A})(0.400\hat{i}\text{ m} \times 0.800\hat{j}\text{ T})

    You correctly set up the force formula and cross product i^×j^\hat{i} \times \hat{j}, but this line inherits the halved displacement value from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    FB=0.720k^ NF_B = 0.720\hat{k}\text{ N}

    Correct

    F⃗B=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

    Evaluating with the correct displacement 2R=0.400 m2R = 0.400\text{ m} gives F⃗B=2(4.50)(0.200)(0.800)k^ N=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = 2(4.50)(0.200)(0.800)\hat{k}\text{ N} = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the equivalent displacement method F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}) for a uniform magnetic field.

You calculated the vector cross product i^×j^=k^\hat{i} \times \hat{j} = \hat{k} accurately to determine the force direction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Radius used instead of diameter for endpoint displacement

You substituted the radius RR for the endpoint separation instead of the diameter 2R2R.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the radius of curvature with the straight-line displacement between endpoints when integrating along a semicircular path.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Displacement Vector Definition
  • For any path from point AA to point BB, L⃗eff=∫ABdl⃗=r⃗B−r⃗A\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = \int_A^B d\vec{l} = \vec{r}_B - \vec{r}_A.

  • Always subtract the initial position vector from the final position vector: (+Ri^)−(−Ri^)=2Ri^(+R\hat{i}) - (-R\hat{i}) = 2R\hat{i}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the endpoint displacement vector: L⃗eff=(Ri^)−(−Ri^)=2Ri^=2(0.200 m)i^=0.400i^ m\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = (R\hat{i}) - (-R\hat{i}) = 2R\hat{i} = 2(0.200\text{ m})\hat{i} = 0.400\hat{i}\text{ m}.

  2. Substitute into the force equation: F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)=(4.50 A)(0.400i^ m×0.800j^ T)\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}) = (4.50\text{ A})(0.400\hat{i}\text{ m} \times 0.800\hat{j}\text{ T}).

  3. Compute the cross product and magnitude: (4.50)(0.400)(0.800)(i^×j^)=1.44k^ N(4.50)(0.400)(0.800)(\hat{i} \times \hat{j}) = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}.

Final answer

F⃗B=1.44k^ N\vec{F}_B = 1.44\hat{k}\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before substituting numerical values, write out r⃗final−r⃗initial\vec{r}_{\text{final}} - \vec{r}_{\text{initial}} explicitly to avoid conflating radius and diameter.

  • Practice computing L⃗eff\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} for different geometric segments such as quarter-circles, triangles, and closed loops.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A wire carrying a current I=2.0 AI = 2.0\text{ A} lies in the xyxy-plane and consists of two straight segments: from (0,0)(0,0) to (0,3.0 m)(0, 3.0\text{ m}), and then from (0,3.0 m)(0, 3.0\text{ m}) to (4.0 m,3.0 m)(4.0\text{ m}, 3.0\text{ m}). A uniform magnetic field B⃗=0.50k^ T\vec{B} = 0.50\hat{k}\text{ T} is present. Find the net magnetic force F⃗B\vec{F}_B on the wire.

Answer

F⃗B=(3.0i^−4.0j^) N\vec{F}_B = (3.0\hat{i} - 4.0\hat{j})\text{ N}. The net displacement is L⃗eff=4.0i^+3.0j^ m\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = 4.0\hat{i} + 3.0\hat{j}\text{ m}. Then F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)=2.0((4.0i^+3.0j^)×0.50k^)=1.0(−4.0j^+3.0i^)=(3.0i^−4.0j^) N\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}) = 2.0\left((4.0\hat{i} + 3.0\hat{j}) \times 0.50\hat{k}\right) = 1.0(-4.0\hat{j} + 3.0\hat{i}) = (3.0\hat{i} - 4.0\hat{j})\text{ N}.

02

A semicircular wire of radius R=0.50 mR = 0.50\text{ m} carrying current I=3.0 AI = 3.0\text{ A} lies in the xzxz-plane with its endpoints at (0,0,−R)(0, 0, -R) and (0,0,+R)(0, 0, +R). Current flows in the direction of increasing zz. A uniform field B⃗=2.0i^ T\vec{B} = 2.0\hat{i}\text{ T} is applied. Calculate the total magnetic force vector F⃗B\vec{F}_B.

Answer

F⃗B=6.0j^ N\vec{F}_B = 6.0\hat{j}\text{ N}. The displacement vector is L⃗eff=2Rk^=1.0k^ m\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} = 2R\hat{k} = 1.0\hat{k}\text{ m}. The force is F⃗B=I(L⃗eff×B⃗)=3.0(1.0k^×2.0i^)=6.0j^ N\vec{F}_B = I(\vec{L}_{\text{eff}} \times \vec{B}) = 3.0(1.0\hat{k} \times 2.0\hat{i}) = 6.0\hat{j}\text{ N}.

03

A closed planar loop consists of a semicircle of radius RR and a straight diameter segment closing it. A steady current II circulates around the loop in a uniform magnetic field B⃗\vec{B}. If the magnetic force on the straight segment is F⃗1\vec{F}_1, what is the magnetic force F⃗2\vec{F}_2 on the curved semicircular segment in terms of F⃗1\vec{F}_1?

Answer

F⃗2=−F⃗1\vec{F}_2 = -\vec{F}_1. The total magnetic force on any closed loop in a uniform magnetic field is zero: F⃗net=F⃗1+F⃗2=0⃗\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{F}_1 + \vec{F}_2 = \vec{0}, which implies F⃗2=−F⃗1\vec{F}_2 = -\vec{F}_1.

Loading workspace…