Resources

A flat mirror of finite length L=45.0 cmL = 45.0\text{ cm} rests horizontally on an optical bench with its left edge at x=0x = 0 and its right edge at x=45.0 cmx = 45.0\text{ cm}. A point laser source is located at coordinates (xs,ys)=(0 cm,30.0 cm)(x_s, y_s) = (0\text{ cm}, 30.0\text{ cm}) and emits rays into the fourth quadrant toward the mirror. Determine the critical threshold range of angles of incidence θi\theta_i (measured relative to the surface normal) such that the reflected ray successfully strikes a vertical detector screen situated at xd=75.0 cmx_d = 75.0\text{ cm} without missing the reflective surface of the mirror.

Answer and steps

Final answer

0∘≤θi≤56.3∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 56.3^\circ

Steps

01

Geometry of the Incident Ray

Let the optical bench lie along the xx-axis (y=0y = 0). The flat mirror occupies the interval: 0 cm≤x≤45.0 cm,y=00\text{ cm} \le x \le 45.0\text{ cm}, \quad y = 0

The laser source is located at: (xs,ys)=(0 cm,30.0 cm)(x_s, y_s) = (0\text{ cm}, 30.0\text{ cm})

The normal to the mirror at any point of incidence (xm,0)(x_m, 0) is directed vertically along the positive yy-axis. Therefore, the angle of incidence θi\theta_i (measured relative to the normal) corresponds to the angle the incoming ray makes with the vertical: tan⁡θi=xm−xsys−0=xm30.0 cm\tan\theta_i = \frac{x_m - x_s}{y_s - 0} = \frac{x_m}{30.0\text{ cm}}

02

Constraint from the Finite Mirror Surface

For the incident ray to strike the reflective surface of the mirror rather than missing it, the point of incidence xmx_m must lie within the physical boundaries of the mirror, [0 cm,45.0 cm][0\text{ cm}, 45.0\text{ cm}]:

  • Minimum point of incidence (left edge, xm=0 cmx_m = 0\text{ cm}): tan⁡θi,min⁡=0 cm30.0 cm=0  ⟹  θi,min⁡=0∘\tan\theta_{i,\min} = \frac{0\text{ cm}}{30.0\text{ cm}} = 0 \implies \theta_{i,\min} = 0^\circ
  • Maximum point of incidence (right edge, xm=45.0 cmx_m = 45.0\text{ cm}): tan⁡θi,max⁡=45.0 cm30.0 cm=1.50\tan\theta_{i,\max} = \frac{45.0\text{ cm}}{30.0\text{ cm}} = 1.50 θi,max⁡=arctan⁡(1.50)≈56.3∘\theta_{i,\max} = \arctan(1.50) \approx 56.3^\circ
03

Trajectory of the Reflected Ray

By the law of reflection, the angle of reflection equals the angle of incidence (θr=θi\theta_r = \theta_i), and the reflected ray travels upward and toward the positive xx-direction for any xm>0x_m > 0.

The line equation for the reflected ray originating at (xm,0)(x_m, 0) is: y(x)=1tan⁡θi(x−xm)=30.0xm(x−xm)y(x) = \frac{1}{\tan\theta_i}(x - x_m) = \frac{30.0}{x_m}(x - x_m)

Since the vertical detector screen is positioned at xd=75.0 cm>45.0 cmx_d = 75.0\text{ cm} > 45.0\text{ cm}, any ray reflected from the mirror surface (xm>0x_m > 0) travels continuously to the right and will intersect the detector plane at: y(xd)=30.0 cmxm(75.0 cm−xm)≥0y(x_d) = \frac{30.0\text{ cm}}{x_m}(75.0\text{ cm} - x_m) \ge 0

At the limiting case xm=45.0 cmx_m = 45.0\text{ cm}, the height on the detector is: y(75.0)=30.045.0(75.0−45.0)=20.0 cmy(75.0) = \frac{30.0}{45.0}(75.0 - 45.0) = 20.0\text{ cm}

Thus, the condition that limits the range of rays striking the mirror and proceeding to the screen is entirely governed by the physical extent of the mirror: 0∘≤θi≤56.3∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 56.3^\circ

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student measures the angle of incidence relative to the horizontal mirror surface instead of the surface normal, using tan(θ) = 30.0 / x.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    tan⁡(θi)=ysx=30.0x\tan(\theta_i) = \frac{y_s}{x} = \frac{30.0}{x}

    Correct

    tan⁡(θi)=xys=x30.0\tan(\theta_i) = \frac{x}{y_s} = \frac{x}{30.0}

    The angle of incidence θi\theta_i is defined relative to the normal to the surface. Since the mirror lies horizontally along the xx-axis, the normal is vertical. In the right triangle formed by (0,ys)(0, y_s), (0,0)(0, 0), and (x,0)(x, 0), the side opposite to θi\theta_i is the horizontal distance xx, and the side adjacent is the vertical distance ys=30.0 cmy_s = 30.0\text{ cm}. Therefore, tan⁡(θi)=x30.0\tan(\theta_i) = \frac{x}{30.0}, not 30.0x\frac{30.0}{x}.

  2. Step 2

    For x=45.0 cm at the right edge:  ⟹  tan⁡(θi)=30.045.0=23  ⟹  θi=arctan⁡(23)≈33.7∘\text{For } x = 45.0\text{ cm} \text{ at the right edge:} \implies \tan(\theta_i) = \frac{30.0}{45.0} = \frac{2}{3} \implies \theta_i = \arctan\left(\frac{2}{3}\right) \approx 33.7^\circ

    Correct

    For x=45.0 cm:  ⟹  tan⁡(θi)=45.030.0=1.50  ⟹  θi=arctan⁡(1.50)≈56.3∘\text{For } x = 45.0\text{ cm:} \implies \tan(\theta_i) = \frac{45.0}{30.0} = 1.50 \implies \theta_i = \arctan(1.50) \approx 56.3^\circ

    Because the tangent formula was inverted in Step 1, evaluating at x=45.0 cmx = 45.0\text{ cm} yielded the complementary glancing angle (33.7∘33.7^\circ) rather than the angle of incidence (56.3∘56.3^\circ).

  3. Step 3

    As x approaches 0,θi approaches 90∘  ⟹  The range of angles is 33.7∘≤θi<90∘\text{As } x \text{ approaches } 0, \theta_i \text{ approaches } 90^\circ \implies \text{The range of angles is } 33.7^\circ \le \theta_i < 90^\circ

    Correct

    At x=0 cm,tan⁡(θi)=030.0=0  ⟹  θi=0∘  ⟹  0∘≤θi≤56.3∘\text{At } x = 0\text{ cm}, \tan(\theta_i) = \frac{0}{30.0} = 0 \implies \theta_i = 0^\circ \implies 0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 56.3^\circ

    At the left edge x=0x = 0, the ray is directed straight down along the normal, so θi=0∘\theta_i = 0^\circ. The resulting range of incident angles is 0∘≤θi≤56.3∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 56.3^\circ.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the critical boundaries are determined by the endpoints of the mirror at x=0x = 0 and x=45.0 cmx = 45.0\text{ cm}.

You correctly applied right-triangle trigonometry to relate the coordinates to an angle.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Angle Measured from Surface Instead of Normal

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined the angle of incidence with respect to the mirror surface (glancing angle) rather than with respect to the surface normal, inverting the opposite and adjacent sides in tan⁡(θi)\tan(\theta_i) as verticalhorizontal\frac{\text{vertical}}{\text{horizontal}} instead of horizontalvertical\frac{\text{horizontal}}{\text{vertical}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Line for Angles in Optics
  • In geometric optics, the angle of incidence θi\theta_i and angle of reflection θr\theta_r are always measured relative to the line perpendicular to the reflective surface (the surface normal), never relative to the surface itself.

  • Draw the normal line perpendicular to the mirror at the point of incidence first, and verify that θi=0∘\theta_i = 0^\circ corresponds to perpendicular (normal) incidence.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Draw the surface normal at the point of incidence (x,0)(x, 0), which points vertically along the yy-axis.

  2. Identify the right triangle with vertices (0,ys)(0, y_s), (0,0)(0, 0), and (x,0)(x, 0). The angle between the incident ray and the vertical normal satisfies tan⁡(θi)=oppositeadjacent=xys=x30.0\tan(\theta_i) = \frac{\text{opposite}}{\text{adjacent}} = \frac{x}{y_s} = \frac{x}{30.0}.

  3. Evaluate at the left boundary of the mirror (x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm}): tan⁡(θi,min⁡)=030.0=0  ⟹  θi,min⁡=0∘\tan(\theta_{i,\min}) = \frac{0}{30.0} = 0 \implies \theta_{i,\min} = 0^\circ.

  4. Evaluate at the right boundary of the mirror (x=45.0 cmx = 45.0\text{ cm}): tan⁡(θi,max⁡)=45.030.0=1.50  ⟹  θi,max⁡=arctan⁡(1.50)≈56.3∘\tan(\theta_{i,\max}) = \frac{45.0}{30.0} = 1.50 \implies \theta_{i,\max} = \arctan(1.50) \approx 56.3^\circ.

Final answer

0∘≤θi≤56.3∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 56.3^\circ

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always sketch and label the dashed normal line perpendicular to the interface before setting up trigonometric ratios.

  • Test the normal incidence limit: check whether your formula gives θi=0∘\theta_i = 0^\circ when a ray strikes perpendicular to the surface.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly requires the reflected ray to hit the screen's base at x_d = 75.0 cm rather than anywhere on the vertical detector, confusing the screen distance with the mirror strike point.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    tan⁡(θi)=x30.0\tan(\theta_i) = \frac{x}{30.0}

  2. Step 2

    The ray must strike the screen at xd=75.0 cmx_d = 75.0\text{ cm}, so the reflection point must be at x=75.0 cmx = 75.0\text{ cm}

    Correct

    0 cm≤xm≤45.0 cm0\text{ cm} \le x_m \le 45.0\text{ cm}

    You assumed that the ray reflects at x=75.0 cmx = 75.0\text{ cm}. However, x=75.0 cmx = 75.0\text{ cm} is the location of the vertical detector screen, while the mirror only extends from x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm} to x=45.0 cmx = 45.0\text{ cm}. Reflection must take place on the mirror surface itself, after which the reflected ray continues toward the screen.

  3. Step 3

    Maximum mirror length is L=45.0 cm  ⟹  tan⁡(θmin⁡)=45.030.0=1.5→θmin⁡=56.3∘  ⟹  tan⁡(θmax⁡)=75.030.0=2.5→θmax⁡=68.2∘L = 45.0\text{ cm} \implies \tan(\theta_{\min}) = \frac{45.0}{30.0} = 1.5 \rightarrow \theta_{\min} = 56.3^\circ \implies \tan(\theta_{\max}) = \frac{75.0}{30.0} = 2.5 \rightarrow \theta_{\max} = 68.2^\circ

    Correct

    tan⁡(θi,min⁡)=0 cm30.0 cm=0  ⟹  θi,min⁡=0∘andtan⁡(θi,max⁡)=45.0 cm30.0 cm=1.50  ⟹  θi,max⁡≈56.3∘\tan(\theta_{i,\min}) = \frac{0\text{ cm}}{30.0\text{ cm}} = 0 \implies \theta_{i,\min} = 0^\circ \quad \text{and} \quad \tan(\theta_{i,\max}) = \frac{45.0\text{ cm}}{30.0\text{ cm}} = 1.50 \implies \theta_{i,\max} \approx 56.3^\circ

    Because you treated x=45.0 cmx = 45.0\text{ cm} and x=75.0 cmx = 75.0\text{ cm} as the minimum and maximum strike points, your resulting angle calculations were shifted away from the true mirror interval [0 cm,45.0 cm][0\text{ cm}, 45.0\text{ cm}].

  4. Step 4

    The range of angles is 56.3∘≤θi≤68.2∘56.3^\circ \le \theta_i \le 68.2^\circ

    Correct

    0∘≤θi≤56.3∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 56.3^\circ

    Your final range inherited the incorrect reflection coordinates from earlier steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the angle of incidence θi\theta_i to the horizontal coordinate of the ray's strike point using tan⁡(θi)=x30.0\tan(\theta_i) = \frac{x}{30.0}.

You accurately computed the arctangent values for your chosen coordinate values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Boundary Condition Confusion

You equated the xx-coordinate of the distant vertical detector screen (xd=75.0 cmx_d = 75.0\text{ cm}) with a reflection point on the mirror surface.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the detector screen's position as a physical point of reflection rather than distinguishing between where the ray reflects (on the horizontal mirror 0≤x≤45.0 cm0 \le x \le 45.0\text{ cm}) and where the reflected ray subsequently intercepts the vertical target (x=75.0 cmx = 75.0\text{ cm}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Physical Boundaries
  • Reflection can only occur where a reflective surface physically exists (xm∈[xleft,xright]x_m \in [x_{\text{left}}, x_{\text{right}}]).

  • Always sketch the optical bench and mark the extent of the mirror independently from the position of any screens or detectors.

Trace Reflected Rays Separately
  • The law of reflection determines the ray's trajectory after it leaves the mirror point (xm,0)(x_m, 0) toward the screen plane at xdx_d.

  • Verify whether rays reflecting from valid points on the mirror actually travel forward (x>xmx > x_m) to hit the detector screen.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the valid reflection points to the physical mirror boundaries: xm∈[0 cm,45.0 cm]x_m \in [0\text{ cm}, 45.0\text{ cm}].

  2. Find the minimum angle of incidence at the left edge (xm=0 cmx_m = 0\text{ cm}): tan⁡(θi,min⁡)=030.0=0  ⟹  θi,min⁡=0∘\tan(\theta_{i,\min}) = \frac{0}{30.0} = 0 \implies \theta_{i,\min} = 0^\circ.

  3. Find the maximum angle of incidence at the right edge (xm=45.0 cmx_m = 45.0\text{ cm}): tan⁡(θi,max⁡)=45.030.0=1.50  ⟹  θi,max⁡=arctan⁡(1.50)≈56.3∘\tan(\theta_{i,\max}) = \frac{45.0}{30.0} = 1.50 \implies \theta_{i,\max} = \arctan(1.50) \approx 56.3^\circ.

  4. Confirm that for all xm>0x_m > 0, the reflected ray travels into the region x>xmx > x_m, intersecting the vertical line x=75.0 cmx = 75.0\text{ cm} at height y=30.0xm(75.0−xm)≥0y = \frac{30.0}{x_m}(75.0 - x_m) \ge 0.

Final answer

0∘≤θi≤56.3∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 56.3^\circ

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a clear ray diagram showing both the mirror segment along the horizontal axis and the vertical detector screen.

  • Distinguish between points where light reflects and points where light is detected.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A point source of light is at (0,40 cm)(0, 40\text{ cm}) and shines rays onto a horizontal flat mirror lying on the xx-axis from x=0x = 0 to x=30 cmx = 30\text{ cm}. Find the range of angles of incidence θi\theta_i of rays that strike the mirror.

Answer

The normal is vertical. For any point of incidence xx, tan⁡θi=xys=x40\tan\theta_i = \frac{x}{y_s} = \frac{x}{40}. At x=0x = 0, θi=0∘\theta_i = 0^\circ. At x=30 cmx = 30\text{ cm}, tan⁡θi=3040=0.75  ⟹  θi=arctan⁡(0.75)≈36.9∘\tan\theta_i = \frac{30}{40} = 0.75 \implies \theta_i = \arctan(0.75) \approx 36.9^\circ. Range: 0∘≤θi≤36.9∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 36.9^\circ.

02

A flat vertical mirror is mounted along the yy-axis between y=0y = 0 and y=50 cmy = 50\text{ cm}. A laser pointer at (25 cm,0)(25\text{ cm}, 0) shines toward the mirror. Determine the range of incident angles θi\theta_i for rays hitting the mirror.

Answer

Since the mirror is vertical along the yy-axis, the normal is horizontal (along the xx-axis). The angle θi\theta_i relative to the normal satisfies tan⁡θi=yxs=y25\tan\theta_i = \frac{y}{x_s} = \frac{y}{25}. At y=0y = 0, θi=0∘\theta_i = 0^\circ. At y=50 cmy = 50\text{ cm}, tan⁡θi=5025=2.0  ⟹  θi=arctan⁡(2.0)≈63.4∘\tan\theta_i = \frac{50}{25} = 2.0 \implies \theta_i = \arctan(2.0) \approx 63.4^\circ. Range: 0∘≤θi≤63.4∘0^\circ \le \theta_i \le 63.4^\circ.

03

A horizontal mirror of length L=60 cmL = 60\text{ cm} lies on the xx-axis from x=20 cmx = 20\text{ cm} to x=80 cmx = 80\text{ cm}. A source at (0,40 cm)(0, 40\text{ cm}) emits rays toward the mirror. Find the angle of incidence range for rays that strike the mirror, and find the position where a ray incident at θi=45∘\theta_i = 45^\circ strikes a screen at x=120 cmx = 120\text{ cm}.

Answer
  1. tan⁡θi=x40\tan\theta_i = \frac{x}{40}. At x=20 cmx = 20\text{ cm}, θi,min⁡=arctan⁡(20/40)=arctan⁡(0.5)≈26.6∘\theta_{i,\min} = \arctan(20/40) = \arctan(0.5) \approx 26.6^\circ. At x=80 cmx = 80\text{ cm}, θi,max⁡=arctan⁡(80/40)=arctan⁡(2)≈63.4∘\theta_{i,\max} = \arctan(80/40) = \arctan(2) \approx 63.4^\circ. Range: 26.6∘≤θi≤63.4∘26.6^\circ \le \theta_i \le 63.4^\circ.
  2. For θi=45∘\theta_i = 45^\circ, xm=40tan⁡(45∘)=40 cmx_m = 40\tan(45^\circ) = 40\text{ cm}. The reflected ray has slope tan⁡(90∘−45∘)=1\tan(90^\circ - 45^\circ) = 1, so y(x)=1⋅(x−40)y(x) = 1 \cdot (x - 40). At x=120 cmx = 120\text{ cm}, y=120−40=80 cmy = 120 - 40 = 80\text{ cm}.
Loading workspace…