Resources
A diver of mass stands on a high-dive platform above the water surface. Student A claims that if the diver leaps upward with an initial speed of , the diver will hit the water with significantly greater kinetic energy than if the diver had jumped downward with the exact same speed , arguing that 'the upward jump allows gravity to accelerate the diver over a greater total vertical distance.' Neglecting air resistance and setting at the water surface: (a) Calculate the total mechanical energy of the diver upon leaving the board for both launch directions. (b) Calculate the kinetic energy and impact speed of the diver at the water surface for both cases. (c) Evaluate Student A's claim from the perspective of work done by a conservative force.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) for both cases; (b) , for both cases; (c) Student A's claim is incorrect because gravity is a conservative force; the net work done by gravity between the board () and the water () depends solely on the net vertical displacement , meaning the extra work done on the way down from the peak exactly cancels the work done against gravity on the way up.
Steps
Part (a): Total Mechanical Energy at Launch
Total mechanical energy is the sum of kinetic energy and gravitational potential energy :
Taking the water surface as the reference level (), the diver's height at the platform is . Using :
- Kinetic Energy: Because kinetic energy depends only on the magnitude of velocity (speed squared, ), the direction of motion (upward or downward) does not affect :
- Gravitational Potential Energy:
- Total Mechanical Energy:
Because both and are scalar quantities independent of the launch angle or direction, the initial mechanical energy is identical for both cases:
Part (b): Kinetic Energy and Speed at Impact
Since air resistance is neglected, gravity is the only force doing work on the diver. Therefore, mechanical energy is conserved throughout the motion:
At the water surface (), the potential energy is zero:
Thus, the entire mechanical energy is converted into kinetic energy:
To find the impact speed :
Substitute the values:
Both the upward and downward jumps result in:
Part (c): Evaluation of Student A's Claim
Student A's claim is incorrect.
- Conservative Force Property: Gravity is a conservative force, which means the total work done by gravity depends exclusively on the initial and final vertical positions ( and ), not on the path taken:
- Cancellation of Extra Work: For the upward jump, the diver travels upward by an extra height , where gravity does negative work (), removing kinetic energy until the diver momentarily stops. As the diver falls back down from the peak to the platform level, gravity does an equal amount of positive work (). The net work done by gravity over the extra portion of the trajectory is zero:
- Consequently, upon passing the platform on the way down, the diver has the exact same downward speed () as if launched downward originally. The net work done from platform to water is identical in both scenarios (), producing identical final kinetic energies.
Typical errors
01 The student treats velocity as a signed vector in the kinetic energy formula and subtracts initial kinetic energy for the downward jump, leading to different mechanical energies.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Upward:
- Step 2
Downward:
CorrectKinetic energy is a scalar quantity defined by and is strictly non-negative. Velocity direction does not make kinetic energy negative, and squaring yields positive .
- Step 3
Upward:
CorrectFor both upward and downward jumps: ,
Your upward calculation is correct, but your downward impact values were affected by the incorrect downward initial energy.
- Step 4
Student A is correct that the upward jump has greater final kinetic energy because the downward jump starts with negative kinetic energy.
CorrectStudent A's claim is incorrect. Gravity is a conservative force, so the work done depends only on initial and final elevation (). For the upward jump, the negative work done on the way up exactly cancels the positive work done falling back to the board level, leaving both divers with identical kinetic energy at impact.
Student A is incorrect. Downward motion does not possess negative kinetic energy, and the conservative nature of gravity ensures both trajectories yield the exact same impact energy.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the formulas for gravitational potential energy and kinetic energy for the upward jump.
You correctly applied the conservation of mechanical energy principle to solve for impact speed from total energy.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated kinetic energy as a vector with a directional sign rather than a scalar quantity based on speed squared ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Scalar Nature of Kinetic Energy
Kinetic energy is a scalar quantity: .
Always square the speed magnitude or negative velocity before multiplying; kinetic energy can never be negative.
- Path Independence of Gravity
Work done by gravity depends solely on vertical displacement : .
Recognize that any extra upward displacement requires negative work against gravity that cancels out on the descent.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate downward initial kinetic energy: .
Add initial potential energy: .
Apply energy conservation at water level (): and for both jumps.
Conclude that Student A is incorrect because gravity is conservative; identical initial mechanical energies at yield identical final kinetic energies at .
(a) for both cases; (b) , for both cases; (c) Student A is incorrect because gravity is conservative and initial mechanical energy is identical.
02 The student misinterprets work done by gravity as depending on total distance traveled along the path rather than net vertical displacement, calculating greater work for the upward jump.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Upward: Downward:
- Step 2
for both cases for both cases
- Step 3
Student A is correct because the upward jump rises an extra height , so gravity acts over a total distance of , doing more total work than falling only .
CorrectStudent A is incorrect because gravity is a conservative force: the work done depends only on the initial and final vertical positions (). The negative work done by gravity while rising () cancels the positive work done while falling back to the board (), so the net work done over the entire dive is identical for both cases.
You treated gravity as doing positive work over the total scalar path length. Because gravity is a conservative vector force, it does negative work on the way up and positive work on the way down, making the work over any closed vertical loop zero.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that kinetic energy depends on speed squared rather than velocity direction.
You applied the law of conservation of mechanical energy accurately to determine impact parameters.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou summed the total path length traveled rather than using net vertical displacement, forgetting that gravity does negative work during the upward portion of the motion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Path Independence of Conservative Work
For a constant downward force of gravity, work depends only on the change in vertical position: .
Always compute work done by gravity using vertical displacement , never total path distance.
- Work Signs on Ascents vs. Descents
When an object moves upward, displacement is opposite to the downward gravitational force, so .
Account for negative work whenever an object moves against the direction of the applied force.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState whether Student A is correct or incorrect: Student A is incorrect.
Write the work-energy definition for gravity as a conservative force: .
Show the cancellation over the extra height: .
Conclude that because the net vertical displacement is in both cases, the net work done by gravity is for both.
Student A is incorrect. Gravity is a conservative force, so the work done depends only on the net vertical displacement , not total path distance. The negative work done on the upward portion exactly cancels the positive work done falling back to the platform level.
Lock it in
Can an object's translational kinetic energy ever be negative?
No. Mass is non-negative and speed squared , making kinetic energy a strictly non-negative scalar regardless of direction.
Similar question
A ball is thrown from a height of with speed . Does throwing it downward at give it less initial mechanical energy than throwing it horizontally at ? Take .
Answer
No, both produce identical total mechanical energy: . Kinetic energy depends only on speed magnitude, not direction.
A skier starts down a frictionless vertical drop. In Run 1, the skier starts straight down a steep slope at . In Run 2, the skier launches over a small upward bump at . Compare their speeds at the bottom.
Answer
The speeds are identical: . Gravity is a conservative force, so the work done depends only on the net vertical change in height, not the launch angle.
A projectile of mass is launched from a cliff of height with speed at an angle above the horizontal. Using conservation of mechanical energy, show that the impact speed at ground level is independent of the launch angle .
Answer
Initial energy is . At ground level (), . Equating gives , which contains no dependence.