Resources

A student standing on a platform measures the sound from a locomotive that is approaching the station at a constant speed of 28.0 m/s28.0\text{ m/s}. The observer measures the shifted pitch to be 865 Hz865\text{ Hz}. If the ambient temperature is such that the speed of sound in air is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, determine the natural source frequency emitted by the locomotive's horn.

Answer and steps

Final answer

794 Hz794\text{ Hz}

Steps

01

Identify the Given Information

  • Speed of sound in air: v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s}
  • Speed of the moving source (locomotive): vs=28.0 m/sv_s = 28.0\text{ m/s}
  • Speed of the stationary observer: vo=0 m/sv_o = 0\text{ m/s}
  • Observed frequency: f′=865 Hzf' = 865\text{ Hz}

02

Apply the Doppler Effect Formula

When a sound source moves toward a stationary observer, each successive wavefront is emitted closer to the previous one in the forward direction. This compresses the observed wavelength and raises the observed frequency.

The relationship between the observed frequency f′f' and the source frequency fsf_s is given by:

f′=fs(vv−vs)f' = f_s \left( \frac{v}{v - v_s} \right)


03

Solve for the Natural Frequency of the Source (fsf_s)

Rearrange the equation to isolate fsf_s:

fs=f′(v−vsv)f_s = f' \left( \frac{v - v_s}{v} \right)

Substitute the known values into the equation:

fs=865 Hz×(340 m/s−28.0 m/s340 m/s)f_s = 865\text{ Hz} \times \left( \frac{340\text{ m/s} - 28.0\text{ m/s}}{340\text{ m/s}} \right)

fs=865×(312340)f_s = 865 \times \left( \frac{312}{340} \right)

fs≈865×0.91765≈793.8 Hzf_s \approx 865 \times 0.91765 \approx 793.8\text{ Hz}

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

fs≈794 Hzf_s \approx 794\text{ Hz}


Common Pitfall

  • Sign convention in the denominator: Be careful when selecting the sign in the Doppler formula. Because the source is moving toward the observer, the waves are compressed, causing the observed pitch to be higher than the emitted pitch (f′>fsf' > f_s). Therefore, the denominator must be (v−vs)(v - v_s) rather than (v+vs)(v + v_s) to yield a fraction greater than 11. Consequently, the original source frequency fsf_s must be lower than the detected 865 Hz865\text{ Hz}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses an addition sign in the denominator instead of a subtraction sign, confusing an approaching source with a receding source.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    fobs=fs⋅vv+vs  ⟹  fs=fobs⋅v+vsvf_{\text{obs}} = f_s \cdot \frac{v}{v + v_s} \implies f_s = f_{\text{obs}} \cdot \frac{v + v_s}{v}

    Correct

    fobs=fs⋅vv−vs  ⟹  fs=fobs⋅v−vsvf_{\text{obs}} = f_s \cdot \frac{v}{v - v_s} \implies f_s = f_{\text{obs}} \cdot \frac{v - v_s}{v}

    You chose a plus sign in the denominator (v+vs)(v + v_s), which describes a source moving away from the observer. When a source approaches, wavefronts bunch together and increase the observed frequency (fobs>fsf_{\text{obs}} > f_s), which requires a smaller denominator: (v−vs)(v - v_s).

  2. Step 2

    fs=865⋅340+28.0340  ⟹  fs=865⋅368340=936.2 Hzf_s = 865 \cdot \frac{340 + 28.0}{340} \implies f_s = 865 \cdot \frac{368}{340} = 936.2\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fs=865⋅340−28.0340  ⟹  fs=865⋅312340≈794 Hzf_s = 865 \cdot \frac{340 - 28.0}{340} \implies f_s = 865 \cdot \frac{312}{340} \approx 794\text{ Hz}

    You substituted your values and calculated correctly according to your formula, but the result was thrown off by the sign error in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the stationary observer means vo=0v_o = 0.

You algebraically rearranged your starting formula cleanly to isolate fsf_s.

You executed the multi-step arithmetic without calculation mistakes.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention error in moving-source Doppler formula

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the sign convention for an approaching source with that of a receding source, overlooking that an approaching source must yield an observed frequency higher than the source frequency.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Reality Check
  • Approaching objects sound higher in pitch (fobs>fsf_{\text{obs}} > f_s), while receding objects sound lower in pitch (fobs<fsf_{\text{obs}} < f_s).

  • Before calculating, check whether your formula makes fobsf_{\text{obs}} larger or smaller than fsf_s.

Denominator Sign Rule for Moving Sources
  • For a stationary observer and moving source: fobs=fs(vv∓vs)f_{\text{obs}} = f_s \left(\frac{v}{v \mp v_s}\right), choosing −- for approaching (smaller denominator, higher frequency) and ++ for receding (larger denominator, lower frequency).

  • Use (v−vs)(v - v_s) whenever the source travels toward the observer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the Doppler formula for an approaching source: fobs=fs(vv−vs)f_{\text{obs}} = f_s \left(\frac{v}{v - v_s}\right).

  2. Isolate the natural frequency: fs=fobs(v−vsv)f_s = f_{\text{obs}} \left(\frac{v - v_s}{v}\right).

  3. Substitute the given values: fs=865 Hz×(340 m/s−28.0 m/s340 m/s)=865×312340≈793.8 Hzf_s = 865\text{ Hz} \times \left(\frac{340\text{ m/s} - 28.0\text{ m/s}}{340\text{ m/s}}\right) = 865 \times \frac{312}{340} \approx 793.8\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

794 Hz794\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always perform a common-sense check: if the source is approaching, the source frequency must be less than the observed frequency (fs<865 Hzf_s < 865\text{ Hz}).

  • Memorize the sign mnemonic: 'Minus in the denominator Makes frequency Mount (approach); Plus in the denominator Pushes frequency down (recede).'

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student swaps the source and observer roles, incorrectly applying the Doppler formula for a moving observer approaching a stationary source.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    fobs=fs∗v+vobsv  ⟹  fs=fobs∗vv+vobsf_{obs} = f_s * \frac{v + v_{obs}}{v} \implies f_s = f_{obs} * \frac{v}{v + v_{obs}}

    Correct

    fobs=fs(vv−vs)  ⟹  fs=fobs(v−vsv)f_{obs} = f_s \left(\frac{v}{v - v_s}\right) \implies f_s = f_{obs} \left(\frac{v - v_s}{v}\right)

    The student on the platform is stationary while the locomotive (the source) is moving. When the source moves, the frequency shift occurs because the emitted wavelength is compressed in the medium, modifying the denominator to (v−vs)(v - v_s), rather than changing the numerator.

  2. Step 2

    fs=865∗340340+28.0f_s = \frac{865 * 340}{340 + 28.0}

    Correct

    fs=865×(340−28.0340)f_s = 865 \times \left(\frac{340 - 28.0}{340}\right)

    You substituted the correct numerical values into the formula you selected, but the expression was affected by the initial formula error.

  3. Step 3

    fs=865∗340368=799.2 Hzf_s = \frac{865 * 340}{368} = 799.2\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fs=865×312340≈794 Hzf_s = 865 \times \frac{312}{340} \approx 794\text{ Hz}

    Your arithmetic was carried out accurately, but propagating the earlier incorrect formula led to 799.2 Hz799.2\text{ Hz} instead of the expected 794 Hz794\text{ Hz}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified all given numerical quantities from the problem statement.

You rearranged your chosen equation algebraically before substituting values.

You performed the arithmetic calculations accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Moving-source vs. moving-observer Doppler confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected the Doppler formula for a moving observer rather than a moving source. In the Doppler effect, observer motion changes the relative speed of wave interception (affecting the numerator: v±vov \pm v_o), whereas source motion physically compresses or stretches the emitted wavefronts in the medium (affecting the denominator: v∓vsv \mp v_s).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Observer vs. Source Motion
  • Observer velocity vov_o appears in the numerator (v±vov \pm v_o), while source velocity vsv_s appears in the denominator (v∓vsv \mp v_s).

  • Always identify which object is in motion before writing the equation: stationary observer means vo=0v_o = 0, and moving source means vs≠0v_s \neq 0 in the denominator.

Approach Sign Convention
  • When objects approach each other, the observed frequency must increase (fobs>fsf_{obs} > f_s).

  • For a moving source approaching, make the denominator smaller than vv by using (v−vs)(v - v_s) so that the ratio vv−vs>1\frac{v}{v - v_s} > 1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the correct formula for a moving source approaching a stationary observer: fobs=fs(vv−vs)f_{obs} = f_s \left(\frac{v}{v - v_s}\right).

  2. Rearrange to solve for the source frequency: fs=fobs(v−vsv)f_s = f_{obs} \left(\frac{v - v_s}{v}\right).

  3. Substitute the given values: fs=865 Hz×(340 m/s−28.0 m/s340 m/s)=865×312340f_s = 865\text{ Hz} \times \left(\frac{340\text{ m/s} - 28.0\text{ m/s}}{340\text{ m/s}}\right) = 865 \times \frac{312}{340}.

Final answer

794 Hz794\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical distinction between wavelength compression (source moving) and relative wave speed (observer moving).

  • Practice setting up the general Doppler equation f′=f(v±vov∓vs)f' = f \left(\frac{v \pm v_o}{v \mp v_s}\right) and crossing out whichever velocity equals zero.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the Doppler frequency ratio when rearranging the formula, multiplying by v / (v - v_s) instead of dividing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    fobs=fs⋅vv−vsf_{\text{obs}} = f_s \cdot \frac{v}{v - v_s}

  2. Step 2

    fs=fobs⋅vv−vsf_s = f_{\text{obs}} \cdot \frac{v}{v - v_s}

    Correct

    fs=fobs⋅v−vsvf_s = f_{\text{obs}} \cdot \frac{v - v_s}{v}

    When isolating fsf_s, you need to divide both sides by vv−vs\frac{v}{v - v_s}, which means multiplying fobsf_{\text{obs}} by the reciprocal v−vsv\frac{v - v_s}{v}.

  3. Step 3

    fs=865⋅340340−28.0  ⟹  fs=865⋅340312=942.6 Hzf_s = 865 \cdot \frac{340}{340 - 28.0} \implies f_s = 865 \cdot \frac{340}{312} = 942.6\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fs=865⋅340−28.0340=865⋅312340≈794 Hzf_s = 865 \cdot \frac{340 - 28.0}{340} = 865 \cdot \frac{312}{340} \approx 794\text{ Hz}

    Your numerical substitution and arithmetic were carried out correctly according to your formula, but the result was altered by the inverted ratio in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the Doppler shift formula appropriate for an approaching source.

You substituted the correct numerical values for the speed of sound, source speed, and observed frequency.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic isolation error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inverting the multiplier incorrectly when isolating a factor: multiplying by the original fraction rather than its reciprocal.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating a variable multiplied by a fraction
  • To solve y=x⋅(ab)y = x \cdot \left(\frac{a}{b}\right) for xx, multiply both sides by the reciprocal: x=y⋅(ba)x = y \cdot \left(\frac{b}{a}\right).

  • Always multiply the other side by the reciprocal of the fraction attached to the variable you are solving for.

Physical reality check
  • When a source moves toward an observer, wave compression makes fobs>fsf_{\text{obs}} > f_s, meaning fsf_s must be less than fobsf_{\text{obs}}.

  • Compare your calculated source frequency with the observed frequency to verify that fs<fobsf_s < f_{\text{obs}} for an approaching source.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. fobs=fs(vv−vs)  ⟹  fs=fobs(v−vsv)f_{\text{obs}} = f_s \left(\frac{v}{v - v_s}\right) \implies f_s = f_{\text{obs}} \left(\frac{v - v_s}{v}\right)

  2. fs=865 Hz×(340 m/s−28.0 m/s340 m/s)=865×(312340)f_s = 865\text{ Hz} \times \left(\frac{340\text{ m/s} - 28.0\text{ m/s}}{340\text{ m/s}}\right) = 865 \times \left(\frac{312}{340}\right)

  3. fs≈793.8 Hz≈794 Hzf_s \approx 793.8\text{ Hz} \approx 794\text{ Hz}

Final answer

794 Hz794\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice rearranging literal equations involving fractional coefficients by multiplying by the reciprocal.

  • Perform a quick physical sense check: if the train is approaching, the perceived pitch is higher, so the true emitted pitch must be lower than 865 Hz865\text{ Hz}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A race car emits an engine tone of 620 Hz620\text{ Hz} while driving directly toward a stationary track worker at 45.0 m/s45.0\text{ m/s}. Taking the speed of sound to be 343 m/s343\text{ m/s}, calculate the frequency heard by the worker.

Answer

714 Hz714\text{ Hz}. Step 1: Use f′=fs(vv−vs)f' = f_s \left(\frac{v}{v - v_s}\right) for an approaching source. Step 2: f′=620(343343−45.0)=620×343298≈713.7 Hz≈714 Hzf' = 620 \left(\frac{343}{343 - 45.0}\right) = 620 \times \frac{343}{298} \approx 713.7\text{ Hz} \approx 714\text{ Hz}.

02

A stationary whistle emits sound at 440 Hz440\text{ Hz}. A cyclist rides directly away from the whistle at 12.0 m/s12.0\text{ m/s} on a day when sound travels at 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}. Find the frequency detected by the cyclist.

Answer

424 Hz424\text{ Hz}. Step 1: For a moving observer traveling away, f′=fs(v−vov)f' = f_s \left(\frac{v - v_o}{v}\right). Step 2: f′=440(340−12.0340)=440×328340≈424.5 Hz≈424 Hzf' = 440 \left(\frac{340 - 12.0}{340}\right) = 440 \times \frac{328}{340} \approx 424.5\text{ Hz} \approx 424\text{ Hz}.

03

A police car with its siren sounding at 900 Hz900\text{ Hz} chases a suspect car. The police car moves at 35.0 m/s35.0\text{ m/s} and the suspect vehicle moves ahead of it at 25.0 m/s25.0\text{ m/s} in the same direction. If the speed of sound is 343 m/s343\text{ m/s}, find the siren frequency detected by the suspect.

Answer

929 Hz929\text{ Hz}. Step 1: Both source and observer are moving in the same direction: f′=fs(v−vov−vs)f' = f_s \left(\frac{v - v_o}{v - v_s}\right), where vo=25.0 m/sv_o = 25.0\text{ m/s} (moving away from source) and vs=35.0 m/sv_s = 35.0\text{ m/s} (moving toward observer). Step 2: f′=900(343−25.0343−35.0)=900×318308≈929.2 Hz≈929 Hzf' = 900 \left(\frac{343 - 25.0}{343 - 35.0}\right) = 900 \times \frac{318}{308} \approx 929.2\text{ Hz} \approx 929\text{ Hz}.

Loading workspace…