Resources

An electric utility customer considers replacing an older electric resistance water heater with an electric air-source heat pump (ASHP) water heater. A student argues: 'Since electric resistance heating converts 100%100\% of electrical energy into thermal energy inside the water tank via Joule heating (P=I2RP = I^2 R), it is physically impossible for an air-source heat pump to deliver an energy efficiency exceeding 100%100\% without violating the First Law of Thermodynamics (conservation of energy).' Deconstruct this conceptual misconception by defining the distinct energy-conversion chain of a heat pump. If the heat pump operates with a coefficient of performance of COPh=3.40\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = 3.40 while absorbing Pelec=750 WP_{\text{elec}} = 750\text{ W} of compressor electrical power, calculate the total heating rate Q˙H\dot{Q}_H delivered to the water tank and the rate of thermal energy Q˙C\dot{Q}_C extracted from the ambient air, reconciling this with conservation of energy.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Conceptual refutation: A resistance heater converts high-grade electrical work directly into thermal internal energy (eta=100%\\eta = 100\% limit), whereas a heat pump does not create heat from electricity alone—it uses mechanical work to pump existing low-temperature thermal energy Q˙C\dot{Q}_C from ambient air into a higher-temperature reservoir Q˙H\dot{Q}_H; Q˙H=COPh×Pelec=2.55×103 W\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \times P_{\text{elec}} = 2.55 \times 10^3\text{ W} (or 2.55 kW2.55\text{ kW}) and Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=1.80×103 W\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 1.80 \times 10^3\text{ W} (or 1.80 kW1.80\text{ kW}), satisfying the First Law Q˙H=Q˙C+Pelec\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}} with an apparent thermal work-to-heat ratio of 340%340\%.

Steps

01

Conceptual Refutation: Energy Conversion vs. Energy Transfer

The student's argument conflates direct energy conversion with heat transfer driven by work:

  • Electric Resistance Heater: Converts high-grade electrical energy directly into thermal energy via Joule heating (P=I2RP = I^2 R). Here, the electrical input is the sole source of the thermal energy, setting a theoretical upper limit of η=QoutWin=100%\eta = \frac{Q_{\text{out}}}{W_{\text{in}}} = 100\%.
  • Air-Source Heat Pump (ASHP): Does not create thermal energy purely from electricity. Instead, it operates a thermodynamic refrigeration cycle (compressor, condenser, expansion valve, evaporator). It uses electrical work (PelecP_{\text{elec}}) to drive a refrigerant that absorbs pre-existing, low-grade thermal energy (Q˙C\dot{Q}_C) from the outdoor ambient air and discharges both that absorbed heat and the compressor work as useful heat (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H) into the water tank.

Because the ambient air provides free energy input, the ratio of useful heat output to electrical work input—known as the Coefficient of Performance (COPh\text{COP}_{\text{h}})—can comfortably exceed 1.01.0 (or 100%100\%) without violating the First Law of Thermodynamics.


02

Total Heating Rate Delivered (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H)

The heating coefficient of performance is defined as the ratio of the useful heating rate delivered to the power consumed:

COPh=Q˙HPelec\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{P_{\text{elec}}}

Rearranging to solve for the heating rate delivered to the water tank, Q˙H\dot{Q}_H:

Q˙H=COPh⋅Pelec\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}}

Substitute the given values (COPh=3.40\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = 3.40 and Pelec=750 WP_{\text{elec}} = 750\text{ W}):

Q˙H=3.40⋅750 W=2550 W=2.55×103 W(2.55 kW)\dot{Q}_H = 3.40 \cdot 750\text{ W} = 2550\text{ W} = 2.55 \times 10^3\text{ W}\quad (2.55\text{ kW})


03

Rate of Heat Extracted from Ambient Air (Q˙C\dot{Q}_C)

Applying the First Law of Thermodynamics (conservation of energy) to the steady-state heat pump cycle:

Total Energy In=Total Energy Out\text{Total Energy In} = \text{Total Energy Out}

Q˙C+Pelec=Q˙H\dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}} = \dot{Q}_H

Solving for the heat extraction rate from the cold reservoir (ambient air), Q˙C\dot{Q}_C:

Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}}

Q˙C=2550 W−750 W=1800 W=1.80×103 W(1.80 kW)\dot{Q}_C = 2550\text{ W} - 750\text{ W} = 1800\text{ W} = 1.80 \times 10^3\text{ W}\quad (1.80\text{ kW})


04

Reconciliation with the First Law

The total energy balance shows:

1.80 kW⏟Heat from air, Q˙C+0.75 kW⏟Electrical work, Pelec=2.55 kW⏟Delivered heat, Q˙H\underbrace{1.80\text{ kW}}_{\text{Heat from air, }\dot{Q}_C} + \underbrace{0.75\text{ kW}}_{\text{Electrical work, }P_{\text{elec}}} = \underbrace{2.55\text{ kW}}_{\text{Delivered heat, }\dot{Q}_H}

Every joule of energy delivered to the water tank is accounted for: 1800 J/s1800\text{ J/s} is drawn from the ambient air and 750 J/s750\text{ J/s} is supplied by the electric grid. The apparent "efficiency" of 340%340\% reflects an energy-movement multiplier rather than energy creation.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the heating coefficient of performance with the cooling coefficient of performance, calculating the extracted heat directly as COP * P_elec.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    A heat pump does not create energy directly from electricity; it uses compressor work to absorb heat from outdoor air and transfer it into the water tank.

  2. Step 2

    Q_dot_C = COPh * P_elec = 3.40 * 750 W = 2550 W

    Correct

    Q˙H=COPh⋅Pelec=3.40⋅750 W=2550 W\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}} = 3.40 \cdot 750\text{ W} = 2550\text{ W}

    By definition, the heating coefficient of performance is the ratio of useful heat delivered to the hot reservoir over the power input, COPh=Q˙HPelec\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{P_{\text{elec}}}. Multiplying COPh\text{COP}_{\text{h}} by PelecP_{\text{elec}} yields Q˙H\dot{Q}_H, not Q˙C\dot{Q}_C.

  3. Step 3

    Q_dot_H = Q_dot_C + P_elec = 2550 W + 750 W = 3300 W

    Correct

    Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=2550 W−750 W=1800 W\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 2550\text{ W} - 750\text{ W} = 1800\text{ W}

    Your First Law energy balance equation Q˙H=Q˙C+Pelec\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}} was set up correctly, but substituting the incorrect value of Q˙C\dot{Q}_C led to an incorrect value for Q˙H\dot{Q}_H.

  4. Step 4

    Delivered heat is 3300 W and extracted heat is 2550 W.

    Correct

    Q˙H=2550 W (or 2.55 kW)\dot{Q}_H = 2550\text{ W}\text{ (or }2.55\text{ kW)} and Q˙C=1800 W (or 1.80 kW)\dot{Q}_C = 1800\text{ W}\text{ (or }1.80\text{ kW)}

    Your stated final values are swapped and numerically affected by the earlier definition error in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately identified that a heat pump transfers thermal energy using mechanical work instead of generating it solely via direct conversion.

You correctly recalled the steady-state First Law energy balance equation relating ambient heat, work input, and delivered heat.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Definition Confusion: COP_h vs COP_c

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the heating coefficient of performance (COPh\text{COP}_{\text{h}}) with the heat extracted from the cold source (Q˙C\dot{Q}_C) instead of the desired useful output delivered to the hot reservoir (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H). In heating mode, the target output is always Q˙H\dot{Q}_H.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define COP by desired output
  • COP=Desired OutputWork Input\text{COP} = \frac{\text{Desired Output}}{\text{Work Input}}. For heating, the desired effect is Q˙H\dot{Q}_H, so COPh=Q˙HWin\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{W_{\text{in}}}.

  • Always pair COPh\text{COP}_{\text{h}} directly with Q˙H\dot{Q}_H, reserving Q˙C\dot{Q}_C for cooling cycles (COPc=Q˙CWin\text{COP}_{\text{c}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_C}{W_{\text{in}}}).

Solve for the remaining thermal rate via the First Law
  • Energy conservation dictates Q˙H=Q˙C+Pelec\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}}, meaning delivered heat must exceed extracted heat: Q˙H>Q˙C\dot{Q}_H > \dot{Q}_C.

  • Calculate Q˙C\dot{Q}_C by subtracting the electrical power from the delivered heat: Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the definition of heating performance: Q˙H=COPh⋅Pelec=3.40⋅750 W=2550 W\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}} = 3.40 \cdot 750\text{ W} = 2550\text{ W}.

  2. Use the conservation of energy to determine the extracted rate: Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=2550 W−750 W=1800 W\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 2550\text{ W} - 750\text{ W} = 1800\text{ W}.

Final answer

Q˙H=2.55 kW\dot{Q}_H = 2.55\text{ kW} and Q˙C=1.80 kW\dot{Q}_C = 1.80\text{ kW}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the formal definitions of COPh\text{COP}_{\text{h}} versus COPc\text{COP}_{\text{c}} based on the user's objective (heating a hot space vs. chilling a cold space).

  • Perform a sanity check: in any heat pump, the delivered heat Q˙H\dot{Q}_H must always be larger than the extracted heat Q˙C\dot{Q}_C because work is added to the fluid.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misapplies conservation of energy by treating COP as a ratio over total delivered heat, adding rather than subtracting electrical work to find the extracted ambient heat.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    A heat pump extracts existing heat from ambient air using electrical work, so energy is transferred rather than converted from scratch.

  2. Step 2

    \dot{Q}H = 3.40 ×\times 750 W\text{ W} = 2550 W\text{ W}

  3. Step 3

    \dot{Q}C = \dot{Q}H + P{elec\text{elec}} = 2550 W\text{ W} + 750 W\text{ W} = 3300 W\text{ W}

    Correct

    \dot{Q}C = \dot{Q}H - P{elec\text{elec}} = 2550 W\text{ W} - 750 W\text{ W} = 1800 W\text{ W}

    By conservation of energy, the total energy entering the heat pump is the sum of ambient heat and electrical power: Q˙C+Pelec=Q˙H\dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}} = \dot{Q}_H. Solving for the heat absorbed from the air gives Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}}, not Q˙H+Pelec\dot{Q}_H + P_{\text{elec}}.

  4. Step 4

    Delivered heat is \text{Delivered heat is } 2550 W\text{ W}  and extracted heat is \text{ and extracted heat is } 3300 W\text{ W}.

    Correct

    \dot{Q}_H = 2550 W\text{ W}\quad (2.55 kW\text{ kW}),\quad \dot{Q}_C = 1800 W\text{ W}\quad (1.80 kW\text{ kW})

    Your final statement for Q˙C\dot{Q}_C carries over the addition error from Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly distinguished heat transfer from direct electrical energy conversion.

You correctly calculated the delivered heat rate using the heating coefficient of performance.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in First Law steady-state energy balance

You accidentally added the input work to the delivered heat rather than setting input power plus absorbed heat equal to delivered heat.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the energy inputs with the energy output of the heat pump cycle. In a heat pump, both electrical work (PelecP_{\text{elec}}) and extracted heat (Q˙C\dot{Q}_C) flow into the system, while only the delivered heat (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H) flows out.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
First Law Control Volume Balance
  • E˙in=E˙out  ⟹  Q˙C+Pelec=Q˙H\dot{E}_{\text{in}} = \dot{E}_{\text{out}} \implies \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}} = \dot{Q}_H

  • Always draw arrows toward the system for inputs (Q˙C,Pelec\dot{Q}_C, P_{\text{elec}}) and away for outputs (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H) before writing the algebraic equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the conservation of energy equation for a steady-state heat pump: Q˙C+Pelec=Q˙H\dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}} = \dot{Q}_H.

  2. Isolate the ambient extraction rate: Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}}.

  3. Substitute the known values: Q˙C=2550 W−750 W=1800 W=1.80 kW\dot{Q}_C = 2550\text{ W} - 750\text{ W} = 1800\text{ W} = 1.80\text{ kW}.

Final answer

Q˙H=2.55 kW\dot{Q}_H = 2.55\text{ kW} and Q˙C=1.80 kW\dot{Q}_C = 1.80\text{ kW}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch an energy flow diagram (Sankey diagram) whenever analyzing a refrigeration or heat pump cycle to clearly see which terms add together.

  • Sanity check: the delivered heat to the tank must always be larger than the heat extracted from the air alone, because compressor work is also converted into thermal discharge.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats COP as a standard fractional efficiency and divides electrical power by COP rather than multiplying.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    A heat pump moves thermal energy from outdoor air to the water tank rather than generating all heat solely from electricity.

  2. Step 2

    Q˙H=PelecCOPh=750 W3.40=220.6 W\dot{Q}_H = \frac{P_{\text{elec}}}{\text{COP}_{\text{h}}} = \frac{750\text{ W}}{3.40} = 220.6\text{ W}

    Correct

    Q˙H=COPh⋅Pelec=3.40⋅750 W=2550 W\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}} = 3.40 \cdot 750\text{ W} = 2550\text{ W}

    The heating coefficient of performance is defined as the benefit divided by the cost: COPh=Q˙HPelec\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{P_{\text{elec}}}. Multiplying both sides by electrical power gives Q˙H=COPh⋅Pelec\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}}, not Pelec/COPhP_{\text{elec}} / \text{COP}_{\text{h}}.

  3. Step 3

    Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=220.6 W−750 W=−529.4 W\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 220.6\text{ W} - 750\text{ W} = -529.4\text{ W}

    Correct

    Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=2550 W−750 W=1800 W\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 2550\text{ W} - 750\text{ W} = 1800\text{ W}

    Your First Law energy balance equation Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} is correct, but substituting the incorrect value of Q˙H\dot{Q}_H produced an erroneous negative heat extraction rate.

  4. Step 4

    Delivered heat is 220.6 W220.6\text{ W} and extracted heat is −529.4 W-529.4\text{ W}.

    Correct

    Delivered heat rate is Q˙H=2550 W\dot{Q}_H = 2550\text{ W} (2.55 kW2.55\text{ kW}) and extracted heat rate is Q˙C=1800 W\dot{Q}_C = 1800\text{ W} (1.80 kW1.80\text{ kW}).

    This conclusion reflects the arithmetic error from Step 2. Extracted heat from the cold reservoir must be positive.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You clearly explained the physical difference between direct energy conversion and work-driven heat pumping.

You correctly stated the energy conservation relationship Q˙H=Q˙C+Pelec\dot{Q}_H = \dot{Q}_C + P_{\text{elec}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula inversion / Misapplied efficiency definition

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the coefficient of performance COPh\text{COP}_{\text{h}} like a standard thermal engine efficiency η<1\eta < 1 where output is less than input, dividing input power by the performance ratio rather than multiplying by it.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define COP from First Principles
  • COPh=Useful Heat DeliveredWork Input=Q˙HPelec\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \frac{\text{Useful Heat Delivered}}{\text{Work Input}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{P_{\text{elec}}}

  • Always write out COPh=Q˙HPelec\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{P_{\text{elec}}} before isolating variables so you multiply by PelecP_{\text{elec}} to find delivered heat.

Sanity Check on Magnitudes
  • For any heat pump operating in heating mode, COPh>1\text{COP}_{\text{h}} > 1, meaning Q˙H>Pelec\dot{Q}_H > P_{\text{elec}} and Q˙C>0\dot{Q}_C > 0.

  • Check that the delivered heating power is greater than the electric power drawn by the compressor.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the definition of heating performance: Q˙H=COPh⋅Pelec=3.40×750 W=2550 W\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}} = 3.40 \times 750\text{ W} = 2550\text{ W}.

  2. Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics: Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=2550 W−750 W=1800 W\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 2550\text{ W} - 750\text{ W} = 1800\text{ W}.

Final answer

Q˙H=2.55 kW\dot{Q}_H = 2.55\text{ kW} and Q˙C=1.80 kW\dot{Q}_C = 1.80\text{ kW}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the definition of heating coefficient of performance as COPh=Q˙H/Win\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \dot{Q}_H / W_{\text{in}} so that Q˙H=COPh⋅Win\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot W_{\text{in}}.

  • Verify that your calculated heat extracted from ambient air Q˙C\dot{Q}_C is strictly positive, as a heat pump must absorb energy from the cold reservoir.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A residential heat pump maintains an indoor temperature by drawing heat from the outside air. It consumes 1.20 kW1.20\text{ kW} of electrical power and operates with a heating coefficient of performance COPh=3.10\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = 3.10. Calculate the rate of heat delivered to the house (Q˙H\dot{Q}_H) and the rate of heat absorbed from the cold outside air (Q˙C\dot{Q}_C).

Answer

Q˙H=COPh⋅Pelec=3.10⋅1.20 kW=3.72 kW\dot{Q}_H = \text{COP}_{\text{h}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}} = 3.10 \cdot 1.20\text{ kW} = 3.72\text{ kW}. Applying conservation of energy, Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=3.72 kW−1.20 kW=2.52 kW\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 3.72\text{ kW} - 1.20\text{ kW} = 2.52\text{ kW}.

02

A geothermal heat pump supplies 12.0 kW12.0\text{ kW} of heat to a building while extracting 9.20 kW9.20\text{ kW} of thermal energy from the ground loop. Assuming steady-state operation, determine the compressor electrical power required (PelecP_{\text{elec}}) and the heating coefficient of performance (COPh\text{COP}_{\text{h}}).

Answer

From energy conservation, Pelec=Q˙H−Q˙C=12.0 kW−9.20 kW=2.80 kWP_{\text{elec}} = \dot{Q}_H - \dot{Q}_C = 12.0\text{ kW} - 9.20\text{ kW} = 2.80\text{ kW}. The heating coefficient of performance is COPh=Q˙HPelec=12.0 kW2.80 kW≈4.29\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{P_{\text{elec}}} = \frac{12.0\text{ kW}}{2.80\text{ kW}} \approx 4.29.

03

An industrial water-heating heat pump provides heat at a rate of Q˙H=45.0 kW\dot{Q}_H = 45.0\text{ kW}. The manufacturer rates its cooling coefficient of performance as COPc=3.80\text{COP}_{\text{c}} = 3.80. Find the electrical power consumption (PelecP_{\text{elec}}) and the rate at which heat is absorbed from the waste stream (Q˙C\dot{Q}_C).

Answer

Using the relation COPh=COPc+1\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = \text{COP}_{\text{c}} + 1, we find COPh=4.80\text{COP}_{\text{h}} = 4.80. The required power is Pelec=Q˙HCOPh=45.0 kW4.80=9.375 kWP_{\text{elec}} = \frac{\dot{Q}_H}{\text{COP}_{\text{h}}} = \frac{45.0\text{ kW}}{4.80} = 9.375\text{ kW}. The rate of heat extracted is Q˙C=Q˙H−Pelec=45.0 kW−9.375 kW=35.625 kW\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}_H - P_{\text{elec}} = 45.0\text{ kW} - 9.375\text{ kW} = 35.625\text{ kW} (or Q˙C=COPc⋅Pelec=3.80⋅9.375 kW=35.625 kW\dot{Q}_C = \text{COP}_{\text{c}} \cdot P_{\text{elec}} = 3.80 \cdot 9.375\text{ kW} = 35.625\text{ kW}).

Loading workspace…