Resources

Two identical test spheres, Sphere AA and Sphere BB, are released from the top edge of a vertical cliff of height H=58.8 mH = 58.8\text{ m}. At time t=0 st = 0\text{ s}, Sphere AA is thrown vertically upward with speed v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s}, while Sphere BB is thrown vertically downward with the exact same initial speed v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 and neglecting air resistance: (a) compare their final speeds vA,impactv_{A,\text{impact}} and vB,impactv_{B,\text{impact}} immediately prior to striking the ground at the cliff base, and (b) determine the time lag Δt=tA−tB\Delta t = t_A - t_B between their ground impact moments.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) vA,impact=vB,impact=39.2 m/sv_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}; (b) Δt=4.00 s\Delta t = 4.00\text{ s}

Steps

Part (a): Comparing the Impact Speeds

To determine the speed of each sphere just before hitting the ground, we apply the work-energy theorem or the kinematic relation connecting speed, acceleration, and displacement:

v2=v02+2gHv^2 = v_0^2 + 2gH

where:

  • v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s} is the initial launch speed,
  • g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 is the acceleration due to gravity,
  • H=58.8 mH = 58.8\text{ m} is the vertical displacement from the top of the cliff to the ground.

Notice that the formula depends on the initial speed squared, v02v_0^2, rather than the direction of the velocity:

  • Sphere BB is launched downward, so its speed increases directly from v0v_0 as it falls through distance HH.
  • Sphere AA travels upward until it momentarily stops, then accelerates downward under gravity. By vertical symmetry, when Sphere AA passes the cliff edge on its way down, its speed is again v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s} directed downward. From that point on, it falls through the exact same vertical distance HH as Sphere BB.

Substituting the given values:

v2=(19.6)2+2(9.80)(58.8)=384.16+1152.48=1536.64 m2/s2v^2 = (19.6)^2 + 2(9.80)(58.8) = 384.16 + 1152.48 = 1536.64\text{ m}^2/\text{s}^2

v=1536.64=39.2 m/sv = \sqrt{1536.64} = 39.2\text{ m/s}

Therefore, both spheres hit the ground with the same speed:

vA,impact=vB,impact=39.2 m/sv_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}


Part (b): Determining the Time Lag Δt=tA−tB\Delta t = t_A - t_B

We can find the time difference by using vertical motion symmetry:

  1. Symmetry of Sphere AA's Round Trip: Sphere AA takes time tup=v0gt_{\text{up}} = \frac{v_0}{g} to reach its highest point, and an equal time tdown=v0gt_{\text{down}} = \frac{v_0}{g} to fall back to the cliff level. The total time to return to the edge of the cliff is:

    treturn=2v0g=2(19.6 m/s)9.80 m/s2=4.00 st_{\text{return}} = \frac{2v_0}{g} = \frac{2(19.6\text{ m/s})}{9.80\text{ m/s}^2} = 4.00\text{ s}

  2. Connecting the Paths: At t=4.00 st = 4.00\text{ s}, Sphere AA is at the cliff edge moving downward at 19.6 m/s19.6\text{ m/s}. This state is identical to Sphere BB's launch state at t=0 st = 0\text{ s}.

    Because Sphere AA follows the exact same descent path as Sphere BB starting 4.00 s4.00\text{ s} later, its flight time from the cliff edge to the ground equals tBt_B:

    tA=treturn+tBt_A = t_{\text{return}} + t_B

    Therefore, the time lag between impacts is simply the round-trip time of Sphere AA:

    Δt=tA−tB=treturn=4.00 s\Delta t = t_A - t_B = t_{\text{return}} = 4.00\text{ s}

(Alternative check) Solving for the descent time of Sphere BB using H=v0tB+12gtB2H = v_0 t_B + \frac{1}{2}gt_B^2: 58.8=19.6tB+4.90tB2  ⟹  tB2+4tB−12=0  ⟹  (tB+6)(tB−2)=058.8 = 19.6 t_B + 4.90 t_B^2 \implies t_B^2 + 4t_B - 12 = 0 \implies (t_B + 6)(t_B - 2) = 0 Since time must be positive, tB=2.00 st_B = 2.00\text{ s}. Hence, tA=2.00 s+4.00 s=6.00 st_A = 2.00\text{ s} + 4.00\text{ s} = 6.00\text{ s}, confirming Δt=6.00 s−2.00 s=4.00 s\Delta t = 6.00\text{ s} - 2.00\text{ s} = 4.00\text{ s}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student believes that throwing Sphere A upward imparts more total kinetic energy or gives gravity more time to accelerate it to a higher final speed than Sphere B.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    hmax⁡=v022g=19.622×9.80=19.6 m  ⟹  Total fall distance for A=58.8+19.6=78.4 m  ⟹  vA,impact=2g×78.4=2×9.80×78.4=39.2 m/sh_{\max} = \frac{v_0^2}{2g} = \frac{19.6^2}{2 \times 9.80} = 19.6\text{ m} \implies \text{Total fall distance for } A = 58.8 + 19.6 = 78.4\text{ m} \implies v_{A,\text{impact}} = \sqrt{2g \times 78.4} = \sqrt{2 \times 9.80 \times 78.4} = 39.2\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    vB,impact=2g×58.8=1152.48=33.9 m/s  ⟹  vA,impact>vB,impactv_{B,\text{impact}} = \sqrt{2g \times 58.8} = \sqrt{1152.48} = 33.9\text{ m/s} \implies v_{A,\text{impact}} > v_{B,\text{impact}}

    Correct

    vB,impact=v02+2gH=19.62+2(9.80)(58.8)=39.2 m/s  ⟹  vA,impact=vB,impactv_{B,\text{impact}} = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gH} = \sqrt{19.6^2 + 2(9.80)(58.8)} = 39.2\text{ m/s} \implies v_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}}

    You calculated Sphere B's impact speed using v=2gHv = \sqrt{2gH}, which assumes the object was released from rest. Because Sphere B was thrown downward with v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s}, its speed squared satisfies v2=v02+2gHv^2 = v_0^2 + 2gH, giving 39.2 m/s39.2\text{ m/s}.

  3. Step 3

    tup=19.69.80=2.0 s  ⟹  tfallA=2×78.49.80=16=4.0 s  ⟹  tA=2.0+4.0=6.0 st_{\text{up}} = \frac{19.6}{9.80} = 2.0\text{ s} \implies t_{\text{fall}_A} = \sqrt{\frac{2 \times 78.4}{9.80}} = \sqrt{16} = 4.0\text{ s} \implies t_A = 2.0 + 4.0 = 6.0\text{ s}

  4. Step 4

    58.8=19.6tB+4.90tB2  ⟹  4.90tB2+19.6tB−58.8=0  ⟹  tB2+4tB−12=0  ⟹  (tB+6)(tB−2)=0 so tB=2.0 s  ⟹  Δt=6.0−2.0=4.0 s58.8 = 19.6 t_B + 4.90 t_B^2 \implies 4.90 t_B^2 + 19.6 t_B - 58.8 = 0 \implies t_B^2 + 4 t_B - 12 = 0 \implies (t_B + 6)(t_B - 2) = 0 \text{ so } t_B = 2.0\text{ s} \implies \Delta t = 6.0 - 2.0 = 4.0\text{ s}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the peak height and impact speed of Sphere A.

You correctly included the initial downward velocity when solving for the flight time of Sphere B.

You correctly calculated the impact time lag Δt=4.0 s\Delta t = 4.0\text{ s}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Initial Velocity in Speed Calculation

You used the dropped-from-rest relation v=2gHv = \sqrt{2gH} for Sphere B instead of incorporating its initial launch speed v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

The formula v=2ghv = \sqrt{2gh} applies only when an object starts from rest (v0=0v_0 = 0). When an object has an initial velocity, mechanical energy conservation or the kinematic equation gives v2=v02+2gΔyv^2 = v_0^2 + 2g\Delta y. Because kinetic energy depends on speed squared and not direction, both spheres launch with the same initial kinetic energy from the same height, so they must strike the ground with identical speeds.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Initial Velocity Term
  • The general third kinematic formula is v2=v02+2gΔyv^2 = v_0^2 + 2g\Delta y, not v=2gΔyv = \sqrt{2g\Delta y}.

  • Always verify whether the initial speed is non-zero before choosing a velocity-displacement equation.

Energy Independence of Launch Direction
  • In the absence of air resistance, final speed v=v02+2gHv = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gH} depends solely on the magnitude of launch speed v0v_0 and vertical displacement HH.

  • Use energy conservation to quickly check speeds: opposite launch directions with equal speed from the same height always yield the same final speed at any common lower elevation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the kinematic relation with the non-zero initial speed for Sphere B: vB,impact2=v02+2gHv_{B,\text{impact}}^2 = v_0^2 + 2gH.

  2. Substitute v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s}, g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, and H=58.8 mH = 58.8\text{ m}: vB,impact=(19.6)2+2(9.80)(58.8)=384.16+1152.48=1536.64=39.2 m/sv_{B,\text{impact}} = \sqrt{(19.6)^2 + 2(9.80)(58.8)} = \sqrt{384.16 + 1152.48} = \sqrt{1536.64} = 39.2\text{ m/s}.

  3. Compare the two impact speeds: since vA,impact=39.2 m/sv_{A,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s} and vB,impact=39.2 m/sv_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}, the two speeds are equal.

Final answer

(a) vA,impact=vB,impact=39.2 m/sv_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}; (b) Δt=4.00 s\Delta t = 4.00\text{ s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review mechanical energy conservation: realize that initial kinetic energy depends on v02v_0^2, so the upward and downward spheres have the exact same total mechanical energy at launch.

  • Practice using the complete form v2=v02+2aΔxv^2 = v_0^2 + 2a\Delta x rather than defaulting to the special free-fall case v=2ghv = \sqrt{2gh}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to account for the downward initial velocity when calculating the time of flight for Sphere B, treating it as dropped from rest.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    vA,impact=v02+2gH=19.62+2×9.80×58.8=39.2 m/s  ⟹  vB,impact=v02+2gH=39.2 m/s  ⟹  vA,impact=vB,impact=39.2 m/sv_{A,\text{impact}} = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gH} = \sqrt{19.6^2 + 2 \times 9.80 \times 58.8} = 39.2\text{ m/s} \implies v_{B,\text{impact}} = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gH} = 39.2\text{ m/s} \implies v_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    −58.8=19.6tA−4.90tA2  ⟹  4.90tA2−19.6tA−58.8=0  ⟹  tA2−4tA−12=0  ⟹  (tA−6)(tA+2)=0 so tA=6.0 s-58.8 = 19.6 t_A - 4.90 t_A^2 \implies 4.90 t_A^2 - 19.6 t_A - 58.8 = 0 \implies t_A^2 - 4t_A - 12 = 0 \implies (t_A - 6)(t_A + 2) = 0 \text{ so } t_A = 6.0\text{ s}

  3. Step 3

    H=(12)gtB2  ⟹  58.8=4.90tB2  ⟹  tB2=12  ⟹  tB=12=3.46 sH = \left(\frac{1}{2}\right) g t_B^2 \implies 58.8 = 4.90 t_B^2 \implies t_B^2 = 12 \implies t_B = \sqrt{12} = 3.46\text{ s}

    Correct

    H=v0tB+12gtB2  ⟹  58.8=19.6tB+4.90tB2  ⟹  tB2+4tB−12=0  ⟹  tB=2.00 sH = v_0 t_B + \frac{1}{2}gt_B^2 \implies 58.8 = 19.6 t_B + 4.90 t_B^2 \implies t_B^2 + 4t_B - 12 = 0 \implies t_B = 2.00\text{ s}

    Sphere BB was thrown downward with an initial speed of v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s}, not dropped from rest. You omitted the initial velocity term v0tBv_0 t_B from the displacement equation.

  4. Step 4

    Δt=6.0−3.46=2.54 s\Delta t = 6.0 - 3.46 = 2.54\text{ s}

    Correct

    Δt=tA−tB=6.00 s−2.00 s=4.00 s\Delta t = t_A - t_B = 6.00\text{ s} - 2.00\text{ s} = 4.00\text{ s}

    Your subtraction was carried out correctly, but the result was affected by the incorrect value of tBt_B.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the conservation of energy / kinematic relation to deduce that both spheres strike the ground at the same speed.

You set up the quadratic displacement equation for Sphere AA with consistent signs and accurately solved for tA=6.0 st_A = 6.0\text{ s}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Initial Velocity

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed Sphere BB was dropped from rest (v0y=0v_{0y} = 0) using H=12gtB2H = \frac{1}{2}gt_B^2, rather than accounting for its downward launch velocity of 19.6 m/s19.6\text{ m/s}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Initial Velocity Condition
  • An object thrown downward has a non-zero downward initial velocity v0yv_{0y}, so its displacement formula must include the term v0ytv_{0y} t.

  • Always check the problem statement carefully: 'thrown downward with speed v0v_0' requires using Δy=v0yt−12gt2\Delta y = v_{0y}t - \frac{1}{2}gt^2 rather than the free-fall from rest formula Δy=−12gt2\Delta y = -\frac{1}{2}gt^2.

Vertical Motion Symmetry Shortcut
  • Sphere AA rises and falls back to cliff level with downward speed v0v_0 in time tround=2v0gt_{\text{round}} = \frac{2v_0}{g}. From the cliff edge down, its motion is identical to Sphere BB.

  • Notice that Δt=tA−tB\Delta t = t_A - t_B is simply the time Sphere AA spends above cliff level: Δt=2v0g=2(19.6)9.80=4.00 s\Delta t = \frac{2v_0}{g} = \frac{2(19.6)}{9.80} = 4.00\text{ s}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the displacement equation for Sphere BB with downward defined as positive: H=v0tB+12gtB2H = v_0 t_B + \frac{1}{2}gt_B^2.

  2. Substitute the values: 58.8=19.6tB+4.90tB258.8 = 19.6 t_B + 4.90 t_B^2.

  3. Divide by 4.904.90: tB2+4tB−12=0t_B^2 + 4t_B - 12 = 0.

  4. Factor the quadratic: (tB+6)(tB−2)=0(t_B + 6)(t_B - 2) = 0, giving the positive root tB=2.00 st_B = 2.00\text{ s}.

  5. Calculate the time lag: Δt=tA−tB=6.00 s−2.00 s=4.00 s\Delta t = t_A - t_B = 6.00\text{ s} - 2.00\text{ s} = 4.00\text{ s}.

Final answer

(a) vA,impact=vB,impact=39.2 m/sv_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}; (b) Δt=4.00 s\Delta t = 4.00\text{ s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When setting up kinematic equations, re-read the launch conditions to ensure you don't default to v0=0v_0 = 0 for downward throws.

  • Practice using trajectory symmetry: whenever two objects are launched from the same height with opposite vertical velocities ±v0\pm v_0, the time difference between their arrivals is purely the round-trip time above that height, Δt=2v0g\Delta t = \frac{2v_0}{g}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student assumes the time lag is simply the time taken for Sphere A to reach its peak rather than the full round-trip time above the cliff.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    12mv02+mgH=12mvimpact2  ⟹  vimpact=v02+2gH=19.62+2(9.80)(58.8)=39.2 m/s  ⟹  vA,impact=vB,impact=39.2 m/s\frac{1}{2}mv_0^2 + mgH = \frac{1}{2}mv_{\text{impact}}^2 \implies v_{\text{impact}} = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gH} = \sqrt{19.6^2 + 2(9.80)(58.8)} = 39.2\text{ m/s} \implies v_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    t_{top\text{top}} = v0g\frac{v_0}{g} = 19.69.80\frac{19.6}{9.80} = 2.0 s\text{ s}_

  3. Step 3

    Δt=ttop=2.0 s\Delta t = t_{\text{top}} = 2.0\text{ s}

    Correct

    Δ\Delta t = t_{round-trip\text{round-trip}} = 2t_{top\text{top}} = 2v0g\frac{2v_0}{g} = 4.00 s\text{ s}

    Sphere AA must both rise to its peak and fall back down to the cliff edge before its state matches Sphere BB's initial launch state. The round-trip time above the cliff is 2ttop=4.00 s2 t_{\text{top}} = 4.00\text{ s}, which represents the full time lag between their impacts.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that kinetic energy depends on speed squared, proving both spheres land with identical speeds.

You correctly applied vertical kinematics to find the time to reach the apex.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Return Trip Time in Vertical Motion Symmetry

You accounted only for the time Sphere AA takes to rise to its peak, omitting the time it takes to fall back to the cliff edge.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the time to reach maximum height (ttop=v0gt_{\text{top}} = \frac{v_0}{g}) with the full round-trip duration back to the original launch level (treturn=2v0gt_{\text{return}} = \frac{2v_0}{g}). Sphere AA only replicates Sphere BB's launch conditions (moving downward at v0v_0 from the cliff) once it completes both the ascent and the descent back to the cliff edge.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Identical Kinematic States
  • When an object is thrown upward at v0v_0, it returns to the original height with velocity −v0-v_0 after a time of t=2v0gt = \frac{2v_0}{g}.

  • Always account for both the ascent and descent phases when using trajectory symmetry to match another object's downward launch.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that Sphere AA takes trise=v0g=2.00 st_{\text{rise}} = \frac{v_0}{g} = 2.00\text{ s} to reach its highest point.

  2. By vertical symmetry under gravity, Sphere AA takes an equal time tfall=2.00 st_{\text{fall}} = 2.00\text{ s} to descend back to the cliff edge.

  3. Upon returning to the cliff edge at t=4.00 st = 4.00\text{ s}, Sphere AA is moving downward with speed v0=19.6 m/sv_0 = 19.6\text{ m/s}, perfectly matching Sphere BB's initial state at t=0 st = 0\text{ s}.

  4. Because both spheres travel the identical downward cliff distance from that point onward, the total difference in impact times is exactly the round-trip time above the cliff: Δt=2(2.00 s)=4.00 s\Delta t = 2(2.00\text{ s}) = 4.00\text{ s}.

Final answer

(a) vA,impact=vB,impact=39.2 m/sv_{A,\text{impact}} = v_{B,\text{impact}} = 39.2\text{ m/s}; (b) Δt=4.00 s\Delta t = 4.00\text{ s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review vertical free-fall symmetry: ascent time equals descent time back to the launch height.

  • When solving relative time delays for objects launched at the same speed in opposite vertical directions, express the delay directly as the round-trip time Δt=2v0g\Delta t = \frac{2v_0}{g}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A stone is thrown vertically downward from a 45 m45\text{ m} high bridge with an initial speed of 10 m/s10\text{ m/s}. Taking g=10 m/s2g = 10\text{ m/s}^2, determine: (a) the speed of the stone just before it hits the water, and (b) the time it takes to reach the water.

Answer

(a) v=v02+2gh=102+2(10)(45)=100+900=1000≈31.6 m/sv = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gh} = \sqrt{10^2 + 2(10)(45)} = \sqrt{100 + 900} = \sqrt{1000} \approx 31.6\text{ m/s} (or 1010 m/s10\sqrt{10}\text{ m/s}). (b) Using v=v0+gtv = v_0 + gt: t=v−v0g=31.62−1010≈2.16 st = \frac{v - v_0}{g} = \frac{31.62 - 10}{10} \approx 2.16\text{ s}.

02

From a tower of height H=40 mH = 40\text{ m}, Ball 1 is thrown vertically upward at 15 m/s15\text{ m/s} and Ball 2 is thrown vertically downward at 15 m/s15\text{ m/s}. Taking g=10 m/s2g = 10\text{ m/s}^2: (a) find the landing speed of each ball, and (b) determine the time difference Δt\Delta t between their landings.

Answer

(a) For both balls, v=v02+2gH=152+2(10)(40)=225+800=1025≈32.0 m/sv = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gH} = \sqrt{15^2 + 2(10)(40)} = \sqrt{225 + 800} = \sqrt{1025} \approx 32.0\text{ m/s}. (b) Ball 1 returns to the tower edge after a round-trip time Δt=2v0g=2(15)10=3.0 s\Delta t = \frac{2v_0}{g} = \frac{2(15)}{10} = 3.0\text{ s}, which is the exact delay between their impacts.

03

A projectile is launched from the edge of a cliff of height hh with initial speed v0v_0 at an angle θ\theta above the horizontal. A second projectile is launched from the same location with the same speed v0v_0 at an angle θ\theta below the horizontal. Neglecting air resistance, prove that both projectiles land with the same speed vimpactv_{\text{impact}}, and express vimpactv_{\text{impact}} in terms of v0v_0, gg, and hh.

Answer

By conservation of mechanical energy, each projectile has initial mechanical energy E=12mv02+mghE = \frac{1}{2}mv_0^2 + mgh and final mechanical energy E=12mvimpact2+0E = \frac{1}{2}mv_{\text{impact}}^2 + 0. Equating the two yields 12mvimpact2=12mv02+mgh  ⟹  vimpact=v02+2gh\frac{1}{2}mv_{\text{impact}}^2 = \frac{1}{2}mv_0^2 + mgh \implies v_{\text{impact}} = \sqrt{v_0^2 + 2gh}. Because this depends only on v0v_0, gg, and hh, the launch angle does not affect the final impact speed.

Loading workspace…