Resources

Two ideal linear polarizers have their transmission axes crossed at 90.0∘90.0^\circ so that no light passes through the system (Ifinal=0I_\text{final} = 0). A student predicts that adding an extra absorbing polarizing filter can only decrease the transmitted intensity further. To test this intuition, a third ideal polarizer is inserted between the two crossed polarizers with its transmission axis oriented at 30.0∘30.0^\circ relative to the first polarizer. If an unpolarized beam with initial intensity I0=500 W/m2I_0 = 500\text{ W/m}^2 is incident on the first polarizer, calculate the new final transmitted intensity IfinalI_\text{final} in W/m2\text{W/m}^2, demonstrating that adding the intermediate polarizer paradoxically increases transmission.

Answer and steps

Final answer

46.9 W/m246.9\text{ W/m}^2

Steps

01

Transmission through the First Polarizer (P1P_1)

To determine the final transmitted intensity after inserting the intermediate polarizer, analyze the beam's polarization state and intensity sequentially through each of the three filters.

The incident beam is unpolarized with an initial intensity of: I0=500 W/m2I_0 = 500\text{ W/m}^2

When completely unpolarized light passes through an ideal linear polarizer, the transmitted light becomes linearly polarized along the polarizer's transmission axis, and its intensity is reduced by half: I1=12I0=12(500 W/m2)=250 W/m2I_1 = \frac{1}{2}I_0 = \frac{1}{2}(500\text{ W/m}^2) = 250\text{ W/m}^2

02

Transmission through the Middle Polarizer (P2P_2)

The light reaching the second polarizer is now linearly polarized along the axis of P1P_1. The transmission axis of P2P_2 is rotated at an angle θ1=30.0∘\theta_1 = 30.0^\circ relative to P1P_1.

According to Malus's Law, the intensity of linearly polarized light after passing through a polarizer oriented at an angle θ\theta relative to its polarization direction is: I=Iincidentcos⁡2θI = I_\text{incident}\cos^2\theta

Applying Malus's Law for the transition from P1P_1 to P2P_2: I2=I1cos⁡2(30.0∘)I_2 = I_1 \cos^2(30.0^\circ)

Since cos⁡(30.0∘)=32\cos(30.0^\circ) = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}: I2=250 W/m2⋅(32)2=250 W/m2⋅34=187.5 W/m2I_2 = 250\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \left(\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\right)^2 = 250\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \frac{3}{4} = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2

The light emerging from P2P_2 is now linearly polarized at 30.0∘30.0^\circ relative to P1P_1.

03

Transmission through the Final Polarizer (P3P_3)

The third polarizer was originally crossed with the first, so its axis is at 90.0∘90.0^\circ relative to P1P_1.

The relative angle θ2\theta_2 between the polarization axis of the beam emerging from P2P_2 and the axis of P3P_3 is: θ2=90.0∘−30.0∘=60.0∘\theta_2 = 90.0^\circ - 30.0^\circ = 60.0^\circ

Applying Malus's Law again: Ifinal=I2cos⁡2(60.0∘)I_\text{final} = I_2 \cos^2(60.0^\circ)

Since cos⁡(60.0∘)=12\cos(60.0^\circ) = \frac{1}{2}: Ifinal=187.5 W/m2⋅(12)2=187.5 W/m2⋅14=46.875 W/m2≈46.9 W/m2I_\text{final} = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^2 = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \frac{1}{4} = 46.875\text{ W/m}^2 \approx 46.9\text{ W/m}^2

Why Transmission Paradoxically Increases

  • Without the middle filter: The electric field vector from P1P_1 is strictly perpendicular (90.0∘90.0^\circ) to the transmission axis of P3P_3, resulting in cos⁡2(90.0∘)=0\cos^2(90.0^\circ) = 0 transmission.
  • With the middle filter: The middle polarizer projects the electric field onto a new axis at 30.0∘30.0^\circ. This creates a non-zero component of the electric field along the direction of P3P_3 (cos⁡(60.0∘)≠0\cos(60.0^\circ) \neq 0), allowing light to pass through the otherwise fully blocked system.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student measures the angle of the third polarizer relative to the first polarizer (90.0°) instead of relative to the preceding polarizer (60.0°), resulting in an intensity of 0 W/m².

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    I1=12⋅I0=250 W/m2I_1 = \frac{1}{2} \cdot I_0 = 250\text{ W/m}^2

  2. Step 2

    I2=I1⋅cos⁡2(30.0∘)=250⋅0.75=187.5 W/m2I_2 = I_1 \cdot \cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 250 \cdot 0.75 = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2

  3. Step 3

    Ifinal=I2⋅cos⁡2(90.0∘)=187.5⋅0=0 W/m2I_\text{final} = I_2 \cdot \cos^2(90.0^\circ) = 187.5 \cdot 0 = 0\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    Ifinal=I2cos⁡2(60.0∘)=187.5⋅(0.5)2=46.9 W/m2I_\text{final} = I_2 \cos^2(60.0^\circ) = 187.5 \cdot (0.5)^2 = 46.9\text{ W/m}^2

    The angle in Malus's Law must be measured between the polarization direction of the incoming light (which is now aligned with P2P_2 at 30.0∘30.0^\circ) and the axis of P3P_3 at 90.0∘90.0^\circ, giving θ=90.0∘−30.0∘=60.0∘\theta = 90.0^\circ - 30.0^\circ = 60.0^\circ, not 90.0∘90.0^\circ.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the half-intensity factor for initially unpolarized incident light.

You correctly calculated the intensity transmitted through the intermediate polarizer using Malus's Law with θ1=30.0∘\theta_1 = 30.0^\circ.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Relative Angle in Malus's Law

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the fixed lab/initial frame angle (90.0∘90.0^\circ) rather than updating the reference frame to the relative angle between consecutive polarizing filters (Δθ=90.0∘−30.0∘=60.0∘\Delta\theta = 90.0^\circ - 30.0^\circ = 60.0^\circ).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Frame for Malus's Law
  • In Malus's Law I=Iincos⁡2θI = I_\text{in}\cos^2\theta, θ\theta is always the relative angle between the polarization direction of the incoming beam and the transmission axis of that specific polarizer: θ=∣θn−θn−1∣\theta = |\theta_n - \theta_{n-1}|.

  • At each consecutive polarizer, subtract the preceding polarizer's orientation angle from the current polarizer's orientation angle before taking the cosine.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the angle between the transmission axis of P2P_2 (30.0∘30.0^\circ) and P3P_3 (90.0∘90.0^\circ): θ2=90.0∘−30.0∘=60.0∘\theta_2 = 90.0^\circ - 30.0^\circ = 60.0^\circ.

  2. Apply Malus's Law at P3P_3: Ifinal=I2cos⁡2(60.0∘)I_\text{final} = I_2 \cos^2(60.0^\circ).

  3. Evaluate using cos⁡(60.0∘)=0.5\cos(60.0^\circ) = 0.5: Ifinal=187.5 W/m2⋅(0.5)2=187.5 W/m2⋅0.25=46.875 W/m2I_\text{final} = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot (0.5)^2 = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot 0.25 = 46.875\text{ W/m}^2.

Final answer

46.9 W/m246.9\text{ W/m}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice tracking how each intermediate polarizer rotates the electric field vector's alignment.

  • Label each relative angle Δθi=θi−θi−1\Delta\theta_i = \theta_i - \theta_{i-1} directly in your setup diagram before calculating.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets that unpolarized light passing through the first polarizer is halved, erroneously applying Malus's law to the full initial intensity I₀.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    I1=I0=500 W/m2I_1 = I_0 = 500\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    I1=12I0=12(500 W/m2)=250 W/m2I_1 = \frac{1}{2}I_0 = \frac{1}{2}(500\text{ W/m}^2) = 250\text{ W/m}^2

    When completely unpolarized light passes through an ideal linear polarizer, the transmitted intensity is cut in half (I1=12I0I_1 = \frac{1}{2}I_0) because the electric field oscillations are uniformly distributed over all transverse directions.

  2. Step 2

    I2=500⋅cos⁡2(30.0∘)=500⋅0.75=375 W/m2I_2 = 500 \cdot \cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 500 \cdot 0.75 = 375\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    I2=250 W/m2⋅cos⁡2(30.0∘)=250⋅0.75=187.5 W/m2I_2 = 250\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 250 \cdot 0.75 = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2

    You correctly applied Malus's Law with θ1=30.0∘\theta_1 = 30.0^\circ, but this calculation inherited the un-halved intensity from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Ifinal=375⋅cos⁡2(60.0∘)=375⋅0.25=93.75 W/m2I_\text{final} = 375 \cdot \cos^2(60.0^\circ) = 375 \cdot 0.25 = 93.75\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    Ifinal=187.5 W/m2⋅cos⁡2(60.0∘)=187.5⋅0.25=46.875 W/m2≈46.9 W/m2I_\text{final} = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \cos^2(60.0^\circ) = 187.5 \cdot 0.25 = 46.875\text{ W/m}^2 \approx 46.9\text{ W/m}^2

    You correctly recognized the relative angle between the second and third polarizers as 90.0∘−30.0∘=60.0∘90.0^\circ - 30.0^\circ = 60.0^\circ, but the final numerical value is doubled due to the initial omission of the one-half factor.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used Malus's Law (I=Iincos⁡2θI = I_\text{in}\cos^2\theta) for successive polarizers.

You correctly evaluated cos⁡2(30.0∘)=0.75\cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 0.75 and cos⁡2(60.0∘)=0.25\cos^2(60.0^\circ) = 0.25.

You correctly calculated the relative angle θ2=90.0∘−30.0∘=60.0∘\theta_2 = 90.0^\circ - 30.0^\circ = 60.0^\circ between the middle and final filters.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
One-Half Rule Omission

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the behavior of unpolarized light entering a polarizer with polarized light entering an aligned polarizer, overlooking the one-half reduction factor for unpolarized light.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Incident Light State
  • Unpolarized light passing through an ideal linear polarizer always emerges with I1=12I0I_1 = \frac{1}{2}I_0, whereas polarized light follows Malus's Law I=Iincos⁡2θI = I_\text{in}\cos^2\theta.

  • Always check whether the incoming beam is unpolarized or already linearly polarized before choosing your intensity formula.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the one-half rule for unpolarized light: I1=12I0=12(500 W/m2)=250 W/m2I_1 = \frac{1}{2} I_0 = \frac{1}{2}(500\text{ W/m}^2) = 250\text{ W/m}^2.

  2. Apply Malus's Law at the middle filter: I2=I1cos⁡2(30.0∘)=250⋅0.75=187.5 W/m2I_2 = I_1 \cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 250 \cdot 0.75 = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2.

  3. Apply Malus's Law at the final filter: Ifinal=I2cos⁡2(60.0∘)=187.5⋅0.25=46.875 W/m2I_\text{final} = I_2 \cos^2(60.0^\circ) = 187.5 \cdot 0.25 = 46.875\text{ W/m}^2.

Final answer

46.9 W/m246.9\text{ W/m}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between unpolarized light (time-averaged projection factor of 12\frac{1}{2}) and linearly polarized light (projection factor of cos⁡2θ\cos^2\theta).

  • Practice multi-filter polarization setups by explicitly labeling the polarization state (unpolarized vs. linearly polarized at angle θ\theta) before each filter.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student forgets to square the cosine in Malus's law, using cos(θ) instead of cos²(θ).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    I1=250 W/m2I_1 = 250\text{ W/m}^2

  2. Step 2

    I2=250⋅cos⁡(30.0∘)=250⋅0.866=216.5 W/m2I_2 = 250 \cdot \cos(30.0^\circ) = 250 \cdot 0.866 = 216.5\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    I2=I1cos⁡2(30.0∘)=250⋅(32)2=187.5 W/m2I_2 = I_1\cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 250 \cdot \left(\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\right)^2 = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2

    Malus's Law states that intensity is proportional to the square of the electric field amplitude, meaning I=Iincidentcos⁡2θI = I_\text{incident}\cos^2\theta, not Iincidentcos⁡θI_\text{incident}\cos\theta.

  3. Step 3

    Ifinal=216.5⋅cos⁡(60.0∘)=216.5⋅0.5=108.25 W/m2I_\text{final} = 216.5 \cdot \cos(60.0^\circ) = 216.5 \cdot 0.5 = 108.25\text{ W/m}^2

    Correct

    Ifinal=I2cos⁡2(60.0∘)=187.5⋅(0.5)2=46.875 W/m2≈46.9 W/m2I_\text{final} = I_2\cos^2(60.0^\circ) = 187.5 \cdot (0.5)^2 = 46.875\text{ W/m}^2 \approx 46.9\text{ W/m}^2

    You correctly identified the relative angle between the second and third filters as 60.0∘60.0^\circ, but this step inherits the incorrect prior intensity and repeats the omission of the square in Malus's Law.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the half-intensity rule for unpolarized light entering the first polarizer.

You correctly identified the relative angle of 60.0∘60.0^\circ between the second and third polarizers.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted square in Malus's law

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated transmitted intensity as scaling linearly with the projection factor cos⁡θ\cos\theta rather than with the square of the electric field projection (cos⁡θ)2(\cos\theta)^2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Amplitude vs. Intensity Relationship
  • The electric field amplitude after a linear polarizer is E=E0cos⁡θE = E_0\cos\theta, but intensity depends on amplitude squared: I∝E2  ⟹  I=I0cos⁡2θI \propto E^2 \implies I = I_0\cos^2\theta.

  • Always write down I=Iincos⁡2θI = I_\text{in}\cos^2\theta explicitly before plugging in numeric values.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Malus's Law to the middle polarizer: I2=250 W/m2⋅cos⁡2(30.0∘)=250⋅34=187.5 W/m2I_2 = 250\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 250 \cdot \frac{3}{4} = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2.

  2. Apply Malus's Law to the final polarizer with θ2=90.0∘−30.0∘=60.0∘\theta_2 = 90.0^\circ - 30.0^\circ = 60.0^\circ: Ifinal=187.5 W/m2⋅cos⁡2(60.0∘)=187.5⋅14=46.875 W/m2I_\text{final} = 187.5\text{ W/m}^2 \cdot \cos^2(60.0^\circ) = 187.5 \cdot \frac{1}{4} = 46.875\text{ W/m}^2.

Final answer

46.9 W/m246.9\text{ W/m}^2

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical derivation of Malus's Law connecting the Poynting vector (S∝E2S \propto E^2) to the electric field component E∥=Ecos⁡θE_\parallel = E\cos\theta.

  • Practice multi-polarizer setups by checking your intermediate values using exact fractions like cos⁡2(30∘)=3/4\cos^2(30^\circ) = 3/4 and cos⁡2(60∘)=1/4\cos^2(60^\circ) = 1/4.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An unpolarized beam of light with initial intensity I0=400 W/m2I_0 = 400\text{ W/m}^2 passes through three linear polarizers. Polarizer 1 has its axis vertical (0∘0^\circ), Polarizer 2 is oriented at 45.0∘45.0^\circ to the vertical, and Polarizer 3 is oriented horizontal (90.0∘90.0^\circ). What is the final transmitted intensity?

Answer

50.0 W/m250.0\text{ W/m}^2. Step 1: I1=12I0=200 W/m2I_1 = \frac{1}{2}I_0 = 200\text{ W/m}^2. Step 2: I2=200cos⁡2(45∘)=200(0.5)=100 W/m2I_2 = 200\cos^2(45^\circ) = 200(0.5) = 100\text{ W/m}^2. Step 3: θ2=90∘−45∘=45∘\theta_2 = 90^\circ - 45^\circ = 45^\circ, so I3=100cos⁡2(45∘)=100(0.5)=50 W/m2I_3 = 100\cos^2(45^\circ) = 100(0.5) = 50\text{ W/m}^2.

02

A beam of light already linearly polarized with intensity Iin=120 W/m2I_\text{in} = 120\text{ W/m}^2 at angle 15.0∘15.0^\circ passes through two additional polarizers: the first oriented at 45.0∘45.0^\circ and the second oriented at 75.0∘75.0^\circ. Calculate the final transmitted intensity.

Answer

67.5 W/m267.5\text{ W/m}^2. Transition 1: Δθ1=45.0∘−15.0∘=30.0∘  ⟹  I1=120cos⁡2(30.0∘)=120⋅0.75=90 W/m2\Delta\theta_1 = 45.0^\circ - 15.0^\circ = 30.0^\circ \implies I_1 = 120\cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 120 \cdot 0.75 = 90\text{ W/m}^2. Transition 2: Δθ2=75.0∘−45.0∘=30.0∘  ⟹  I2=90cos⁡2(30.0∘)=90⋅0.75=67.5 W/m2\Delta\theta_2 = 75.0^\circ - 45.0^\circ = 30.0^\circ \implies I_2 = 90\cos^2(30.0^\circ) = 90 \cdot 0.75 = 67.5\text{ W/m}^2.

03

An unpolarized light beam of intensity I0I_0 passes through a sequence of four polarizers with transmission axes at 0∘0^\circ, 30∘30^\circ, 60∘60^\circ, and 90∘90^\circ respectively. Express the final intensity in terms of I0I_0.

Answer

27128I0≈0.211I0\frac{27}{128}I_0 \approx 0.211 I_0. Step 1: I1=12I0I_1 = \frac{1}{2}I_0. Step 2 to 4: Each step rotates by Δθ=30∘\Delta\theta = 30^\circ, multiplying intensity by cos⁡2(30∘)=34\cos^2(30^\circ) = \frac{3}{4}. Total transmission is Ifinal=12I0⋅(34)3=27128I0I_\text{final} = \frac{1}{2}I_0 \cdot \left(\frac{3}{4}\right)^3 = \frac{27}{128}I_0.

Loading workspace…