Resources

An inventor claims that a newly designed heat engine operating between a hot reservoir at TH=580 KT_H = 580\text{ K} and an exhaust reservoir at TC=290 KT_C = 290\text{ K} delivers 650 J650\text{ J} of work while taking in 1200 J1200\text{ J} of heat. Determine the maximum theoretical Carnot efficiency ηCarnot\eta_{\text{Carnot}} possible for these operating temperatures, evaluate the claimed efficiency ηclaimed\eta_{\text{claimed}}, and state whether this engine violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%, ηclaimed=54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\%; the claim violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics because ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}.

Steps

01

Calculate the Maximum Theoretical Carnot Efficiency

According to Carnot's theorem, the maximum theoretical efficiency ηCarnot\eta_{\text{Carnot}} of any heat engine operating between two thermal reservoirs depends solely on their absolute temperatures (in kelvins):

ηCarnot=1−TCTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H}

Given:

  • Hot reservoir temperature, TH=580 KT_H = 580\text{ K}
  • Cold (exhaust) reservoir temperature, TC=290 KT_C = 290\text{ K}

Substitute the given temperatures:

ηCarnot=1−290 K580 K=1−0.500=0.500 or 50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{290\text{ K}}{580\text{ K}} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500 \text{ or } 50.0\%


02

Calculate the Claimed Thermal Efficiency

The thermal efficiency of any heat engine is the ratio of useful work output (WW) to the heat energy absorbed from the hot reservoir (QHQ_H):

ηclaimed=WQH\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_H}

Given:

  • Work produced, W=650 JW = 650\text{ J}
  • Heat absorbed, QH=1200 JQ_H = 1200\text{ J}

Substitute these values:

ηclaimed=650 J1200 J≈0.5417 or 54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{650\text{ J}}{1200\text{ J}} \approx 0.5417 \text{ or } 54.2\%


03

Evaluate the Inventor's Claim

By the Second Law of Thermodynamics (specifically Carnot's principle), no real or ideal heat engine operating between two given temperatures can have an efficiency greater than a reversible Carnot engine operating between the same two temperatures:

η≤ηCarnot\eta \le \eta_{\text{Carnot}}

Comparing the two efficiencies: ηclaimed=54.2%>ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\% > \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%

Because the claimed efficiency exceeds the Carnot limit, the inventor's claim is physically impossible and violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Common Pitfall: Always verify that reservoir temperatures are in absolute units (kelvins). If temperatures are given in degrees Celsius, converting to kelvins first is essential before evaluating thermal efficiencies.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student inverts the temperature ratio in the Carnot efficiency formula, calculating 1 - T_H / T_C, which yields a negative efficiency and an incorrect comparison.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ηCarnot=1−THTC  ⟹  ηCarnot=1−580290  ⟹  ηCarnot=1−2.0=−1.0\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_H}{T_C} \implies \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{580}{290} \implies \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - 2.0 = -1.0

    Correct

    ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−290 K580 K=0.500 (or 50.0%)\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{290\text{ K}}{580\text{ K}} = 0.500 \text{ (or } 50.0\%)

    The theoretical maximum efficiency is ηCarnot=1−TCTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H}, placing the lower temperature TCT_C in the numerator. Because TH>TCT_H > T_C, inverting the fraction makes THTC>1\frac{T_H}{T_C} > 1, resulting in an unphysical negative efficiency.

  2. Step 2

    ηclaimed=WQH=6501200≈0.542\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{650}{1200} \approx 0.542

  3. Step 3

    The engine does not violate the Second Law because \text{The engine does not violate the Second Law because } 0.542  is greater than \text{ is greater than } -1.0.

    Correct

    The engine violates the Second Law because \text{The engine violates the Second Law because } \eta_{claimed\text{claimed}} = 54.2% > \eta_{Carnot\text{Carnot}} = 50.0%.

    Because your Carnot efficiency from Step 1 was incorrect, your comparison was distorted. Furthermore, the Second Law requires that any real or ideal engine satisfy η≤ηCarnot\eta \le \eta_{\text{Carnot}}; an efficiency greater than the Carnot limit violates the Second Law.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the formula for thermal efficiency η=WQH\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H} to find the claimed efficiency.

You correctly identified that the Second Law involves comparing the operating efficiency with the theoretical Carnot limit.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Carnot Temperature Ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You swapped the hot and cold reservoir temperatures in the Carnot efficiency formula, placing THT_H over TCT_C instead of TCT_C over THT_H, and interpreted an efficiency exceeding the Carnot limit as acceptable rather than a violation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Carnot Efficiency Ratio Check
  • ηCarnot=1−TCTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H}, where TC<THT_C < T_H

  • Always verify that the fraction subtracted from 11 is less than 11 (smaller absolute temperature on top, larger on the bottom) so that 0<ηCarnot<10 < \eta_{\text{Carnot}} < 1.

Second Law Criterion
  • No engine operating between two temperatures can exceed the Carnot limit: η≤ηCarnot\eta \le \eta_{\text{Carnot}}

  • If ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}, the claim is physically impossible and violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the correct Carnot limit: ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−290 K580 K=0.500=50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{290\text{ K}}{580\text{ K}} = 0.500 = 50.0\%.

  2. Recall the claimed efficiency from your Step 2: ηclaimed=650 J1200 J≈54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{650\text{ J}}{1200\text{ J}} \approx 54.2\%.

  3. Compare the two values: since ηclaimed=54.2%>ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\% > \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%, the engine exceeds the maximum theoretical efficiency.

Final answer

ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%, ηclaimed=54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\%; the claim violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics because ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always perform a reality check on thermal efficiency: it must be a positive fraction between 00 and 11. A negative efficiency immediately signals an inverted ratio.

  • Review the physical meaning of Carnot's theorem: ηCarnot\eta_{\text{Carnot}} is an upper ceiling that no engine can exceed without violating the Second Law.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student calculates the claimed efficiency by dividing work done by heat rejected instead of heat input, yielding 650 / 550 ≈ 1.18.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−290580=0.50\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{290}{580} = 0.50

  2. Step 2

    QC=1200−650=550 J  ⟹  ηclaimed=WQC=650550≈1.18Q_C = 1200 - 650 = 550\text{ J} \implies \eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_C} = \frac{650}{550} \approx 1.18

    Correct

    ηclaimed=WQH=650 J1200 J≈0.542 (or 54.2%)\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{650\text{ J}}{1200\text{ J}} \approx 0.542\text{ (or } 54.2\%\text{)}

    Thermal efficiency is defined as the ratio of useful work output to total heat input, η=WQH\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H}. You divided the work by the rejected heat QCQ_C instead of the heat input QH=1200 JQ_H = 1200\text{ J}.

  3. Step 3

    Yes, it violates the Second Law because 1.181.18 is greater than 0.500.50.

    Correct

    Yes, it violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics because ηclaimed=54.2%>ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\% > \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%.

    Your qualitative conclusion is correct, but your reasoning relies on the incorrect efficiency value of 1.181.18 from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the Carnot efficiency formula with absolute temperatures.

You recognized that an engine efficiency exceeding the Carnot efficiency violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect denominator in thermal efficiency formula

You solved for the exhausted heat QCQ_C and placed it in the denominator of the efficiency expression instead of the input heat QHQ_H.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the energy input with energy rejected when defining thermal efficiency. Thermal efficiency measures 'what you get out (WW) divided by what you pay for (QHQ_H)', not the ratio of work to waste heat.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Efficiency Input-Output Definition
  • For any heat engine, thermal efficiency is η=WoutQin=WQH\eta = \frac{W_{\text{out}}}{Q_{\text{in}}} = \frac{W}{Q_H}.

  • Always place total heat absorbed from the hot reservoir (QHQ_H) in the denominator.

Sanity Check on Engine Efficiency
  • By the First Law of Thermodynamics, W=QH−QC<QHW = Q_H - Q_C < Q_H for any engine rejecting heat, so η<1.0\eta < 1.0 (or <100%< 100\%).

  • If your calculated engine efficiency exceeds 1.01.0 (or 100%100\%), check immediately whether you divided by QCQ_C or switched input and output.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the heat input: QH=1200 JQ_H = 1200\text{ J} and work done: W=650 JW = 650\text{ J}.

  2. Compute the claimed thermal efficiency: ηclaimed=WQH=650 J1200 J≈0.5417 or 54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{650\text{ J}}{1200\text{ J}} \approx 0.5417\text{ or } 54.2\%.

  3. Compare the claimed efficiency to the Carnot efficiency: 54.2%>50.0%54.2\% > 50.0\%.

  4. Conclude that because ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}, the claim violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Final answer

ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%, ηclaimed=54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\%; the claim violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics because ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the fundamental definition of thermal efficiency: η=WQH=1−QCQH\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H} = 1 - \frac{Q_C}{Q_H}.

  • Use the quick sanity check that an engine's thermal efficiency must always be strictly less than 11 (100%100\%).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 A student omits subtracting from 1 when finding Carnot efficiency and computes T_C / T_H = 0.50 as the fraction of heat rejected, incorrectly concluding that the claimed efficiency is valid.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ηCarnot=THTC=580290=2.0\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{T_H}{T_C} = \frac{580}{290} = 2.0

    Correct

    ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−290580=0.500 (or 50.0%)\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{290}{580} = 0.500 \text{ (or } 50.0\%\text{)}

    Carnot efficiency is defined as ηCarnot=1−TCTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H}, not THTC\frac{T_H}{T_C}. An efficiency of 2.02.0 (200%200\%) would mean producing twice as much work as the total heat absorbed, which violates energy conservation.

  2. Step 2

    ηclaimed=WQH=6501200≈0.542\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{650}{1200} \approx 0.542

  3. Step 3

    "No, it does not violate the Second Law because 0.542 is less than 2.0."

    Correct

    "Yes, it violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics because ηclaimed=54.2%>ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\% > \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%."

    Because your calculated Carnot efficiency was erroneously set to 2.02.0, your comparison led to an incorrect verdict. Comparing the true values shows ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}, which violates the Second Law.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the definition of actual thermal efficiency as work output divided by heat absorbed: η=WQH\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H}.

You substituted the correct values of W=650 JW = 650\text{ J} and QH=1200 JQ_H = 1200\text{ J} to find ηclaimed≈0.542\eta_{\text{claimed}} \approx 0.542.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion (Carnot efficiency)

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the ratio of hot-to-cold temperatures THTC\frac{T_H}{T_C} instead of the Carnot efficiency relation η=1−TCTH\eta = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H}. Because thermal efficiency represents the fraction of input energy converted to work, any engine efficiency must be less than 11 (or 100%100\%).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Efficiency Upper Bound Sanity Check
  • For any heat engine, efficiency represents WQH=1−QCQH\frac{W}{Q_H} = 1 - \frac{Q_C}{Q_H}. It must always be strictly between 00 and 11 (0%<η<100%0\% < \eta < 100\%).

  • Whenever you compute an efficiency greater than 11 (such as 2.02.0), immediately stop and check your formula.

Carnot Efficiency Formula
  • The maximum theoretical efficiency between two reservoirs at absolute temperatures THT_H and TCT_C is ηCarnot=1−TCTH=TH−TCTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_H}.

  • Place TCT_C in the numerator and THT_H in the denominator, then subtract the fraction from 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate theoretical Carnot efficiency: ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−290 K580 K=1−0.500=0.500=50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{290\text{ K}}{580\text{ K}} = 1 - 0.500 = 0.500 = 50.0\%.

  2. Calculate claimed engine efficiency: ηclaimed=WQH=650 J1200 J≈0.5417=54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{650\text{ J}}{1200\text{ J}} \approx 0.5417 = 54.2\%.

  3. Compare the two efficiencies: ηclaimed=54.2%>ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\% > \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%.

  4. Apply the Second Law of Thermodynamics: No engine can exceed the Carnot limit operating between the same two temperatures.

Final answer

ηCarnot=50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 50.0\%, ηclaimed=54.2%\eta_{\text{claimed}} = 54.2\%; the claim violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics because ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the thermodynamic derivation showing how η=1−QCQH\eta = 1 - \frac{Q_C}{Q_H} leads to ηCarnot=1−TCTH\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} for reversible cycles.

  • Always perform a quick sanity check to ensure calculated efficiencies fall within 0≤η<10 \le \eta < 1 before comparing them.

  • Practice identifying reservoir roles: THT_H is always the larger temperature in the denominator, and TCT_C is the smaller temperature in the numerator.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A heat engine operates between temperatures of TH=800 KT_H = 800\text{ K} and TC=200 KT_C = 200\text{ K}. Calculate its maximum theoretical efficiency ηCarnot\eta_{\text{Carnot}}.

Answer

ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−200 K800 K=1−0.25=0.75 or 75%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{200\text{ K}}{800\text{ K}} = 1 - 0.25 = 0.75 \text{ or } 75\%.

02

An inventor claims an engine absorbs 2000 J2000\text{ J} from a reservoir at 500 K500\text{ K} and produces 900 J900\text{ J} of work while exhausting heat to a reservoir at 300 K300\text{ K}. Does this claim violate the Second Law of Thermodynamics?

Answer

ηCarnot=1−300 K500 K=0.40 (40%)\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{500\text{ K}} = 0.40 \text{ (40\%)}. The claimed efficiency is ηclaimed=WQH=900 J2000 J=0.45 (45%)\eta_{\text{claimed}} = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{900\text{ J}}{2000\text{ J}} = 0.45 \text{ (45\%)}. Since ηclaimed>ηCarnot\eta_{\text{claimed}} > \eta_{\text{Carnot}} (45%>40%45\% > 40\%), the claim violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

03

A geothermal power plant operates with steam at 227∘C227^\circ\text{C} and cooling water at 27∘C27^\circ\text{C}. If the plant achieves 60%60\% of its maximum theoretical Carnot efficiency, what is its actual operating thermal efficiency?

Answer

First convert temperatures to kelvins: TH=227+273=500 KT_H = 227 + 273 = 500\text{ K} and TC=27+273=300 KT_C = 27 + 273 = 300\text{ K}. Maximum efficiency: ηCarnot=1−300 K500 K=0.40 (40%)\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{300\text{ K}}{500\text{ K}} = 0.40 \text{ (40\%)}. Actual efficiency: η=0.60×ηCarnot=0.60×0.40=0.24 or 24%\eta = 0.60 \times \eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 0.60 \times 0.40 = 0.24 \text{ or } 24\%.

Loading workspace…