Resources

An object and a viewing screen are held in fixed positions separated by an axial distance D=72.0 cmD = 72.0\text{ cm}. A thin converging lens of focal length ff is placed between them. According to the thin lens equation, a real, focused image can be formed on the screen only if the focal length does not exceed a critical threshold fmaxf_{\text{max}}. (a) Calculate this theoretical upper bound fmaxf_{\text{max}} for the lens. (b) If a lens with f=16.0 cmf = 16.0\text{ cm} is placed between them, determine the two distinct object distances do,1d_{o,1} and do,2d_{o,2} at which sharp images are formed on the screen.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) fmax=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = 18.0\text{ cm}; (b) do,1=24.0 cmd_{o,1} = 24.0\text{ cm} and do,2=48.0 cmd_{o,2} = 48.0\text{ cm}

Steps

Part (a): Finding the maximum focal length fmaxf_{\text{max}}

  1. Relate the distances using the thin lens equation: For a real image to form on a screen located past the lens, both the object distance dod_o and the image distance did_i must be positive. The total distance between the fixed object and screen is DD: do+di=D  ⟹  di=D−dod_o + d_i = D \implies d_i = D - d_o

    Substituting this into the thin lens formula 1do+1di=1f\frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f}: 1do+1D−do=1f\frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{D - d_o} = \frac{1}{f}

  2. Formulate the quadratic equation for dod_o: Combine the fractions on the left-hand side: (D−do)+dodo(D−do)=1f\frac{(D - d_o) + d_o}{d_o(D - d_o)} = \frac{1}{f} DDdo−do2=1f\frac{D}{D d_o - d_o^2} = \frac{1}{f} Rearranging into standard quadratic form: do2−Ddo+fD=0d_o^2 - D d_o + f D = 0
  3. Apply the condition for real physical solutions: For a real image to be sharply focused on the screen, the quadratic equation must have real solutions for dod_o. Therefore, its discriminant Δ\Delta must be greater than or equal to zero: Δ=(−D)2−4(1)(fD)=D2−4fD≥0\Delta = (-D)^2 - 4(1)(f D) = D^2 - 4f D \ge 0

    Since the physical distance D>0D > 0, dividing both sides by DD yields: D−4f≥0  ⟹  f≤D4D - 4f \ge 0 \implies f \le \frac{D}{4}

    Thus, the theoretical upper limit fmaxf_{\text{max}} is: fmax=D4=72.0 cm4=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{4} = \frac{72.0\text{ cm}}{4} = 18.0\text{ cm}


Part (b): Finding the two lens positions for f=16.0 cmf = 16.0\text{ cm}

  1. Solve the quadratic equation for dod_o: Using the quadratic formula do=−b±Δ2ad_o = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{\Delta}}{2a} with D=72.0 cmD = 72.0\text{ cm} and f=16.0 cmf = 16.0\text{ cm}: do=D±D2−4fD2d_o = \frac{D \pm \sqrt{D^2 - 4f D}}{2}
  2. Compute the discriminant and the two positions: Δ=(72.0)2−4(16.0)(72.0)=5184−4608=576 cm2\Delta = (72.0)^2 - 4(16.0)(72.0) = 5184 - 4608 = 576\text{ cm}^2 Δ=576=24.0 cm\sqrt{\Delta} = \sqrt{576} = 24.0\text{ cm}

    Evaluating the two roots gives: do,1=72.0−24.02=48.02=24.0 cmd_{o,1} = \frac{72.0 - 24.0}{2} = \frac{48.0}{2} = 24.0\text{ cm} do,2=72.0+24.02=96.02=48.0 cmd_{o,2} = \frac{72.0 + 24.0}{2} = \frac{96.0}{2} = 48.0\text{ cm}

Note on symmetry: These two solutions reflect the principle of reversibility of light rays. When do=24.0 cmd_o = 24.0\text{ cm}, the image distance is di=48.0 cmd_i = 48.0\text{ cm} (forming a magnified, real image). When the lens is shifted to do=48.0 cmd_o = 48.0\text{ cm}, the image distance becomes di=24.0 cmd_i = 24.0\text{ cm} (forming a diminished, real image).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the minimum object-screen distance D_min = 4f with the symmetric condition d_o = d_i = D/2 and incorrectly assumes f_max occurs when f = D/2 instead of D/4.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1do+1di=1f\frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} ⟹ For symmetric position, do=di=D2=36.0 cmd_o = d_i = \frac{D}{2} = 36.0\text{ cm} ⟹ 1f=136.0+136.0=236.0\frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{36.0} + \frac{1}{36.0} = \frac{2}{36.0}

  2. Step 2

    fmax=D2=36.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{2} = 36.0\text{ cm}

    Correct

    fmax=36.0 cm2=D4=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = \frac{36.0\text{ cm}}{2} = \frac{D}{4} = 18.0\text{ cm}

    You had correctly calculated 1f=236.0 cm−1\frac{1}{f} = \frac{2}{36.0}\text{ cm}^{-1}, but instead of taking the reciprocal f=36.02=18.0 cmf = \frac{36.0}{2} = 18.0\text{ cm}, you set fmax=D2=36.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{2} = 36.0\text{ cm}.

  3. Step 3

    do2−72.0do+16.0(72.0)=0  ⟹  do2−72.0do+1152=0  ⟹  do=72.0±5184−46082  ⟹  do=72.0±24.02d_o^2 - 72.0 d_o + 16.0(72.0) = 0 \implies d_o^2 - 72.0 d_o + 1152 = 0 \implies d_o = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{5184 - 4608}}{2} \implies d_o = \frac{72.0 \pm 24.0}{2}

  4. Step 4

    do,1=24.0 cm,  do,2=48.0 cmd_{o,1} = 24.0\text{ cm},\; d_{o,2} = 48.0\text{ cm}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the threshold focal length occurs at the symmetric lens position do=di=D2d_o = d_i = \frac{D}{2}.

You correctly formed the quadratic equation for the two object positions in part (b).

You calculated both root values accurately to find the two lens positions.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reciprocal / Formula Confusion

You wrote 1f=236.0\frac{1}{f} = \frac{2}{36.0}, but then wrote fmax=36.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = 36.0\text{ cm} by equating ff with D2\frac{D}{2} instead of solving for f=36.02f = \frac{36.0}{2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the symmetric distance condition do=di=D2d_o = d_i = \frac{D}{2} with the focal length itself, forgetting that substituting do=di=D2d_o = d_i = \frac{D}{2} into the lens equation gives 1f=2D/2=4D\frac{1}{f} = \frac{2}{D/2} = \frac{4}{D}, which implies fmax=D4f_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{4}, not D2\frac{D}{2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Minimum Object-Screen Distance
  • For a thin converging lens to form a real image on a screen separated by distance DD, the condition is D≥4fD \ge 4f, which means fmax=D4f_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{4}.

  • Always verify that your maximum focal length satisfies fmax=D4f_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{4} whenever do=di=D2d_o = d_i = \frac{D}{2}.

Reciprocal Check in Lens Equation
  • When 1f=2x\frac{1}{f} = \frac{2}{x}, solving for ff yields f=x2f = \frac{x}{2}.

  • Take the reciprocal of both the left-hand side and the right-hand side carefully before writing down the final numerical value.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the reciprocal of both sides: f=36.0 cm2f = \frac{36.0\text{ cm}}{2}

  2. Evaluate the quotient: fmax=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = 18.0\text{ cm} (or equivalently, fmax=D4=72.0 cm4=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{4} = \frac{72.0\text{ cm}}{4} = 18.0\text{ cm})

Final answer

(a) fmax=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = 18.0\text{ cm}; (b) do,1=24.0 cmd_{o,1} = 24.0\text{ cm} and do,2=48.0 cmd_{o,2} = 48.0\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember the benchmark optical relation Dmin=4fD_{\text{min}} = 4f for real image formation on a screen.

  • Double-check algebraic inversions whenever working with thin-lens reciprocals 1f\frac{1}{f}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misses the factor of 4 in the quadratic formula discriminant or D² - 4fD, taking the discriminant condition as D² - fD ≥ 0 or D - 4f = 0 erroneously derived as f_max = D.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    \frac{1}{d_o} + rac{1}{D - d_o} = \frac{1}{f} \implies d_o(D - d_o) = fD \implies d_o^2 - D d_o + fD = 0

  2. Step 2

    Discriminant condition: D2−4fD≥0  ⟹  fmax=D4=72.04=18.0 cm\text{Discriminant condition: } D^2 - 4fD \ge 0 \implies f_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{4} = \frac{72.0}{4} = 18.0\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    do2−72.0do+1152=0  ⟹  do=72.0±72.02−11522d_o^2 - 72.0 d_o + 1152 = 0 \implies d_o = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{72.0^2 - 1152}}{2}

    Correct

    do2−72.0do+1152=0  ⟹  do=72.0±72.02−4(1)(1152)2d_o^2 - 72.0 d_o + 1152 = 0 \implies d_o = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{72.0^2 - 4(1)(1152)}}{2}

    In the quadratic formula do=−b±b2−4ac2ad_o = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}, you forgot to multiply the constant term c=1152c = 1152 by 44, writing b2−c\sqrt{b^2 - c} instead of b2−4ac\sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}.

  4. Step 4

    do=72.0±5184−11522=72.0±40322=72.0±63.52  ⟹  do,1=4.25 cm,  do,2=67.8 cmd_o = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{5184 - 1152}}{2} = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{4032}}{2} = \frac{72.0 \pm 63.5}{2} \implies d_{o,1} = 4.25\text{ cm},\; d_{o,2} = 67.8\text{ cm}

    Correct

    do=72.0±5184−46082=72.0±5762=72.0±24.02  ⟹  do,1=24.0 cm,  do,2=48.0 cmd_o = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{5184 - 4608}}{2} = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{576}}{2} = \frac{72.0 \pm 24.0}{2} \implies d_{o,1} = 24.0\text{ cm},\; d_{o,2} = 48.0\text{ cm}

    Your arithmetic followed accurately from the missing factor of 44, but the resulting object distances are incorrect due to the earlier formula error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted di=D−dod_i = D - d_o into the thin lens formula and rearranged it into a quadratic equation.

You accurately identified the discriminant condition Δ≥0\Delta \ge 0 to find the theoretical upper bound fmax=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = 18.0\text{ cm}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of factor 4 in quadratic discriminant

You knew the discriminant was D2−4fDD^2 - 4fD in part (a), but when plugging numerical coefficients into the quadratic formula for part (b), you accidentally omitted the factor of 44 in the 4ac4ac term.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Lapse in applying the full quadratic formula x=−b±b2−4ac2ax = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}, specifically dropping the coefficient 44 when substituting numerical values into the square root.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Quadratic discriminant recall
  • For any quadratic equation ax2+bx+c=0a x^2 + b x + c = 0, the expression inside the radical is always b2−4acb^2 - 4ac.

  • Always explicitly write out the product 4×a×c4 \times a \times c under the radical before calculating the difference.

Symmetry check in optical conjugate positions
  • By the reversibility of light, the two object positions must sum to DD (do,1+do,2=Dd_{o,1} + d_{o,2} = D) and interchange with their image distances (di,1=do,2d_{i,1} = d_{o,2} and di,2=do,1d_{i,2} = d_{o,1}).

  • Check whether your two distances satisfy do,1do,2=fDd_{o,1} d_{o,2} = f D. With your values, 4.25×67.8≈288≠11524.25 \times 67.8 \approx 288 \ne 1152, signaling an algebraic error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the quadratic equation with values: do2−72.0do+1152=0d_o^2 - 72.0 d_o + 1152 = 0.

  2. Apply the full quadratic formula: do=72.0±(−72.0)2−4(1)(1152)2(1)d_o = \frac{72.0 \pm \sqrt{(-72.0)^2 - 4(1)(1152)}}{2(1)}.

  3. Compute the term inside the root: 5184−4608=5765184 - 4608 = 576.

  4. Take the square root: 576=24.0\sqrt{576} = 24.0.

  5. Evaluate the two roots: do,1=72.0−24.02=24.0 cmd_{o,1} = \frac{72.0 - 24.0}{2} = 24.0\text{ cm} and do,2=72.0+24.02=48.0 cmd_{o,2} = \frac{72.0 + 24.0}{2} = 48.0\text{ cm}.

Final answer

(a) fmax=18.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = 18.0\text{ cm}; (b) do,1=24.0 cmd_{o,1} = 24.0\text{ cm} and do,2=48.0 cmd_{o,2} = 48.0\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the quadratic formula components carefully when moving from algebraic forms to numerical substitutions.

  • Practice using optical conjugate symmetry (do,1+do,2=Dd_{o,1} + d_{o,2} = D and do,1do,2=fDd_{o,1} d_{o,2} = fD) to instantly verify solutions in two-position lens problems.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An illuminated slide and a projection screen are separated by D=80.0 cmD = 80.0\text{ cm}. What is the maximum focal length fmaxf_{\text{max}} a converging lens can have to project a sharp image on the screen, and where should the lens be positioned?

Answer

fmax=20.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = 20.0\text{ cm}, positioned midway at do=40.0 cmd_o = 40.0\text{ cm}. Key step: fmax=D4=80.04=20.0 cmf_{\text{max}} = \frac{D}{4} = \frac{80.0}{4} = 20.0\text{ cm}; symmetry requires do=di=D2=40.0 cmd_o = d_i = \frac{D}{2} = 40.0\text{ cm}.

02

A converging lens with f=15.0 cmf = 15.0\text{ cm} is placed between an object and a screen separated by a fixed distance D=80.0 cmD = 80.0\text{ cm}. Find the two object distances do,1d_{o,1} and do,2d_{o,2} that produce focused real images on the screen.

Answer

do,1=20.0 cmd_{o,1} = 20.0\text{ cm} and do,2=60.0 cmd_{o,2} = 60.0\text{ cm}. Key step: Solve do2−80.0do+15.0(80.0)=0  ⟹  do2−80.0do+1200=0d_o^2 - 80.0 d_o + 15.0(80.0) = 0 \implies d_o^2 - 80.0 d_o + 1200 = 0. Roots are do=80.0±6400−48002=80.0±40.02d_o = \frac{80.0 \pm \sqrt{6400 - 4800}}{2} = \frac{80.0 \pm 40.0}{2}, giving 20.0 cm20.0\text{ cm} and 60.0 cm60.0\text{ cm}.

03

In a displacement method (Bessel's method) setup, an object and screen are separated by D=90.0 cmD = 90.0\text{ cm}. Two sharp images are formed when the lens is shifted by a distance d=30.0 cmd = 30.0\text{ cm} between the two positions. Determine the focal length ff of the lens.

Answer

f=20.0 cmf = 20.0\text{ cm}. Key step: In Bessel's method, the two positions are symmetric about the midpoint, so d=do,2−do,1=D2−4fDd = d_{o,2} - d_{o,1} = \sqrt{D^2 - 4fD}. Squaring gives d2=D2−4fD  ⟹  f=D2−d24D=90.02−30.024(90.0)=8100−900360=7200360=20.0 cmd^2 = D^2 - 4fD \implies f = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D} = \frac{90.0^2 - 30.0^2}{4(90.0)} = \frac{8100 - 900}{360} = \frac{7200}{360} = 20.0\text{ cm}.

Loading workspace…