Resources
An electric freight locomotive of mass is coupled to a train car of mass . The locomotive's driving wheels exert a forward horizontal force on the track rails that accelerates the entire train from rest to a speed of over a displacement of along a straight horizontal track. Neglect rolling resistance and air drag. (a) Calculate the constant forward acceleration of the train in and the tension force in the coupling link between the locomotive and the train car in kilonewtons (). (b) Identify the precise Newton's third law reaction partner to the forward propelling force exerted by the locomotive's driving wheels on the track rails, specifying its magnitude in , direction, and the body upon which it acts.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , ; (b) The reaction force is the backward static friction force of magnitude exerted by the locomotive wheels on the track rails, directed horizontally backward opposite the direction of motion, acting on the Earth (via the track).
Steps
Part (a): Determining the Train's Acceleration and Coupler Tension
- Convert the final velocity to SI units:
- Calculate the constant forward acceleration (): Using the kinematic relationship relating displacement , initial velocity , and final velocity :
- Find the tension in the coupler (): Consider the train car of mass as an isolated system. Since resistance forces are neglected, the only horizontal force acting on the car is the forward pull of the coupler:
Part (b): Identifying the Newton's Third Law Reaction Force
- Calculate the total propelling force acting on the train: Treat the locomotive and the train car together as a combined system of total mass : The external horizontal force accelerating the entire train forward is provided by the static friction between the rails and the locomotive's driving wheels:
-
Apply Newton's Third Law: According to Newton's Third Law, if object (the track rails / Earth) exerts a forward force on object (the locomotive driving wheels), then object must exert a force that is equal in magnitude, opposite in direction, and acting on object :
- Magnitude:
- Direction: Horizontally backward (opposite to the train's forward motion)
- Body acted upon: The track rails (and thus the Earth)
- Nature of force: Static friction exerted backward by the locomotive's wheels onto the track rails.
(Common Pitfall: Do not confuse internal tension between the cars with the external driving force, and remember that action-reaction pairs never act on the same object—the reaction to the force propelling the train forward acts on the ground, not on the train.)
Typical errors
01 A student uses the total mass of the train rather than the mass of the trailed car when calculating the coupler tension, obtaining 42.5 kN instead of 11.25 kN.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You used the combined mass of the locomotive and the car instead of isolating the trailing car. The coupler tension only accelerates the trailing car of mass , so .
- Step 3
, Reaction force magnitude: , Direction: backward, Body acted upon: locomotive driving wheels
CorrectMagnitude: ; Direction: horizontally backward; Body acted upon: the track rails (the Earth)
You found the correct magnitude and backward direction, but you named the locomotive driving wheels as the body acted upon. By Newton's third law, the reaction to a force exerted by the wheels onto the rails acts on the track rails (the Earth), not on the wheels.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted the speed from to .
You correctly applied the kinematic equation to calculate the acceleration.
You correctly calculated the total propelling force magnitude as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set the tension equal to the net force on the entire train instead of isolating the trailing train car.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated internal coupler tension as an external force accelerating the entire train system, and you overlooked that Newton's third law reaction pairs must always act on opposite interacting bodies rather than the same body.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define the Free-Body System
An internal connector force (like tension) is found by isolating only the mass that connector directly pulls.
Draw a free-body diagram of the trailing car alone: the only horizontal force acting on it is , so .
- Newton's Third Law Body Swap
If object exerts a force on object (), the reaction partner is exerted by on ().
Switch the agent and the recipient: the reaction partner must act on the track rails/Earth, never on the locomotive itself.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply Newton's second law to the trailing car of mass : .
Identify the interaction pair: the locomotive's driving wheels push backward on the track rails, and the track rails push forward on the driving wheels.
State the reaction partner: magnitude , directed horizontally backward, acting on the track rails (Earth).
(a) , ; (b) Reaction force magnitude is , directed horizontally backward, acting on the track rails (Earth).
02 A student forgets to convert the speed from km/h to m/s, using 72.0 directly in the kinematic equation and producing an incorrect acceleration of 3.24 m/s².
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You used the speed in directly in the kinematic formula without converting it to standard SI units (). Because , the actual acceleration is .
- Step 2Correct
Your isolated free-body equation for the trailing car is correct, but your numerical answer inherits the incorrect acceleration from Step 1.
- Step 3Correct
Newton's third law states that if body exerts a force on body , body exerts an equal and opposite force on body . The forward propelling force on the train is exerted by the track on the locomotive wheels, so its reaction partner is exerted by the locomotive wheels backward onto the track rails (the Earth), not on the wheels.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou selected the correct kinematic equation relating velocity, acceleration, and displacement.
You isolated the trailing car correctly to calculate the coupler tension as .
You correctly combined the locomotive and car masses to find the total propelling force.
You correctly recognized that the reaction force points in the backward direction.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou forgot to convert the speed from to before squaring it in the kinematic relation.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisOverlooking unit consistency across kinematic equations, coupled with confusing which body receives the action force versus the reaction force in an interacting pair.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- SI Unit Check
Kinematic formulas require consistent base units: convert to by dividing by .
Always convert non-standard units (such as ) before substituting them into dynamic or kinematic formulas.
- Newton's Third Law Body Swap
For an action-reaction pair, . The two forces never act on the same body.
Identify the agent and the target of the forward force (track on wheels); swap them to find the target of the reaction force (wheels on track).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert velocity to SI units: .
Calculate acceleration: .
Calculate coupler tension: .
Determine propelling force: .
Identify the reaction partner: By Newton's third law, the reaction force has magnitude , points backward, and acts on the track rails (Earth).
(a) , ; (b) magnitude , directed backward, acting on the track rails (Earth)
03 A student confuses Newton's third law pair with an internal balancing force, incorrectly identifying the tension in the coupler acting backward on the locomotive as the reaction partner.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
Reaction force magnitude: , Direction: backward, Body acted upon: locomotive
CorrectMagnitude: , Direction: backward (opposite to motion), Body acted upon: the track rails (Earth)
You identified the reaction force as the tension in the coupler acting on the locomotive. A Newton's third law pair consists strictly of the mutual forces between two interacting bodies: if the track rails exert a forward force on the locomotive wheels (), the reaction partner is the backward static friction force exerted by the wheels on the track rails (), acting on the track rails.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou converted the speed from kilometers per hour to meters per second accurately.
You used kinematics to calculate the correct constant acceleration of the train.
You correctly applied Newton's second law to the trailing train car to find the tension in the coupler link.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip occurred; this was a conceptual confusion between an internal tension force and an external interaction pair.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou selected another force that points backward (the coupler tension pulling backward on the locomotive) rather than swapping the agent and the recipient of the interaction. For any force , Newton's third law reaction partner must be , meaning it acts on body , not body .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Agent-Recipient Swap Rule
If object exerts force on object , its reaction partner is always with equal magnitude and opposite direction.
Always identify the two interacting objects explicitly. Swap their roles to find the reaction partner, and ensure the reaction acts on the original agent.
- System Propelling Force vs. Subsystem Force
The net propelling force accelerates the total mass , whereas internal tension only accelerates the trailing mass .
Calculate the propelling force from the combined system mass: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the total external horizontal force accelerating the entire train: .
Identify the interaction: The track rails exert a forward static friction force of on the locomotive's driving wheels.
Apply Newton's third law: The reaction partner is the backward force exerted by the locomotive's driving wheels on the track rails.
State the magnitude, direction, and recipient: Magnitude is , direction is horizontally backward (opposite train travel), and the body acted upon is the track rails (Earth).
(a) , ; (b) Magnitude: , Direction: horizontally backward, Body acted upon: the track rails (Earth).
Lock it in
When two connected blocks of masses (pulled) and (trailing) accelerate forward, which mass determines the tension in the link connecting them?
. The connecting link only accelerates the trailing mass , so isolate in your free-body diagram.
Similar question
A tractor of mass pulls a trailer of mass along a level field with an acceleration of . Neglecting friction on the trailer, calculate: (a) the horizontal driving force exerted by the ground on the tractor wheels, and (b) the tension in the hitch connecting the tractor and trailer.
Answer
(a) Total mass . Net driving force . (b) Isolating the trailer gives .
A locomotive of mass pulls two identical rail cars, each of mass , with a constant forward acceleration of . Find the tension in the coupler between the locomotive and the first car, and the tension in the coupler between the first car and the second car.
Answer
For , isolate car 2: . For , isolate cars 1 and 2 together: .
A runner of mass pushes horizontally backward on starting blocks with an average force of . (a) State the magnitude, direction, and recipient of the Newton's third law reaction partner to this force. (b) Determine the runner's initial horizontal acceleration.
Answer
(a) The reaction partner is a forward horizontal force of magnitude exerted by the starting blocks on the runner's feet. (b) Applying Newton's second law to the runner: forward.