Resources

A student forms a closed rigid rectangular wire loop of width w=0.150 mw = 0.150\text{ m} and height h=0.250 mh = 0.250\text{ m} carrying a clockwise current of I=3.50 AI = 3.50\text{ A}. The entire loop is immersed in a uniform horizontal magnetic field B=0.600 TB = 0.600\text{ T} directed in the plane of the loop pointing from left to right (parallel to the top and bottom segments). (a) Calculate the net magnetic force F⃗net\vec{F}_{\text{net}} exerted on the complete closed loop. (b) Calculate the magnetic force F⃗left\vec{F}_{\text{left}} on the left vertical segment alone and explain why a non-zero magnetic torque τ\tau acts on the loop despite F⃗net=0⃗\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{0}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) F⃗net=0 N\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = 0\text{ N}; (b) F⃗left=0.525 N\vec{F}_{\text{left}} = 0.525\text{ N} directed perpendicularly out of the plane; although opposing forces sum to zero vectorially, their separated lines of action produce a non-zero net torque of τ=0.0788 N⋅m\tau = 0.0788\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

Steps

01

Force on the Left Segment

Part (a): Net Magnetic Force on the Closed Loop

The magnetic force exerted on a straight wire segment of length vector L⃗\vec{L} carrying a steady current II in a uniform magnetic field B⃗\vec{B} is given by: F⃗=I(L⃗×B⃗)\vec{F} = I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}) We can analyze the forces acting on each of the four segments of the rectangular loop:

  1. Top segment: The current flows parallel to the magnetic field (θ=0∘\theta = 0^\circ). Ftop=IwBsin⁡(0∘)=0 NF_{\text{top}} = I w B \sin(0^\circ) = 0\text{ N}
  2. Bottom segment: The current flows antiparallel to the magnetic field (θ=180∘\theta = 180^\circ). Fbottom=IwBsin⁡(180∘)=0 NF_{\text{bottom}} = I w B \sin(180^\circ) = 0\text{ N}
  3. Vertical segments (left and right): Both segments are perpendicular to B⃗\vec{B} (θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ) and have equal length hh. Because the current flows in opposite vertical directions on the left and right segments, the cross products yield forces of identical magnitude but directly opposing directions: F⃗right=−F⃗left\vec{F}_{\text{right}} = -\vec{F}_{\text{left}} Summing the forces over all four segments yields: F⃗net=F⃗top+F⃗bottom+F⃗left+F⃗right=0 N\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{F}_{\text{top}} + \vec{F}_{\text{bottom}} + \vec{F}_{\text{left}} + \vec{F}_{\text{right}} = 0\text{ N} (General principle: For any closed current loop of arbitrary geometry placed in a uniform magnetic field, F⃗net=I(∮dl⃗)×B⃗=0⃗\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = I \left(\oint d\vec{l}\right) \times \vec{B} = \vec{0}, because the closed vector path integral ∮dl⃗=0⃗\oint d\vec{l} = \vec{0}.)

Part (b): Magnetic Force on the Left Segment and Origin of Torque

The left segment has length h=0.250 mh = 0.250\text{ m} oriented perpendicular to B⃗=0.600 T\vec{B} = 0.600\text{ T} (θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ). The magnitude of the magnetic force on this segment is: Fleft=IhBsin⁡(90∘)F_{\text{left}} = I h B \sin(90^\circ) Fleft=(3.50 A)⋅(0.250 m)⋅(0.600 T)=0.525 NF_{\text{left}} = (3.50\text{ A}) \cdot (0.250\text{ m}) \cdot (0.600\text{ T}) = 0.525\text{ N}

By the right-hand rule, the force F⃗left\vec{F}_{\text{left}} is directed perpendicularly out of the plane of the loop.

02

Why a Non-Zero Torque Exists Despite F⃗net=0⃗\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{0}

A common pitfall is to assume that zero net force implies zero net torque. While translational equilibrium requires ∑F⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{F} = \vec{0}, rotational equilibrium requires ∑τ⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{\tau} = \vec{0}.

  • The force on the left segment (F⃗left=0.525 N\vec{F}_{\text{left}} = 0.525\text{ N}) acts out of the plane.
  • The force on the right segment (F⃗right=0.525 N\vec{F}_{\text{right}} = 0.525\text{ N}) acts into the plane.
  • Although these two equal-and-opposite forces add to zero translational force, they do not share the same line of action. They are separated by the full width of the loop, w=0.150 mw = 0.150\text{ m}.

This pair of equal, opposite, and non-collinear forces constitutes a couple, which exerts a net torque about the vertical central axis of the loop: τ=Fleft⋅w=(0.525 N)⋅(0.150 m)=0.07875 N⋅m≈0.0788 N⋅m\tau = F_{\text{left}} \cdot w = (0.525\text{ N}) \cdot (0.150\text{ m}) = 0.07875\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} \approx 0.0788\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}

Alternatively, using the magnetic dipole moment μ⃗\vec{\mu} where μ=IA=I(w⋅h)\mu = I A = I(w \cdot h): τ=μBsin⁡(90∘)=I⋅w⋅h⋅B=(3.50 A)⋅(0.150 m)⋅(0.250 m)⋅(0.600 T)=0.0788 N⋅m\tau = \mu B \sin(90^\circ) = I \cdot w \cdot h \cdot B = (3.50\text{ A}) \cdot (0.150\text{ m}) \cdot (0.250\text{ m}) \cdot (0.600\text{ T}) = 0.0788\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}

Because the opposing forces act along separated lines of action, they cause the loop to rotate about its vertical centerline even while the loop experiences no translational acceleration.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies the right-hand rule and reverses the direction of the magnetic force on the left segment to into the page.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ∮dL=0 for a closed loop in uniform B  ⟹  Fnet=0 N\oint dL = 0\text{ for a closed loop in uniform B} \implies F_{\text{net}} = 0\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    Fleft=I⋅h⋅B=(3.50 A)(0.250 m)(0.600 T)=0.525 NF_{\text{left}} = I \cdot h \cdot B = (3.50\text{ A})(0.250\text{ m})(0.600\text{ T}) = 0.525\text{ N}

  3. Step 3

    Direction: into the page\text{Direction: into the page}

    Correct

    Direction: perpendicularly out of the plane (or page)\text{Direction: perpendicularly out of the plane (or page)}

    You determined the force direction as into the page, but applying the standard right-hand rule for the cross product L⃗×B⃗\vec{L} \times \vec{B} on this segment yields a direction perpendicularly out of the plane.

  4. Step 4

    Left and right segments experience opposite forces with separated lines of action, so net torque is non-zero.\text{Left and right segments experience opposite forces with separated lines of action, so net torque is non-zero.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the closed loop integral property to establish that the net magnetic force is zero.

You calculated the magnetic force magnitude on the left wire segment accurately.

You clearly articulated why non-collinear opposing forces produce a non-zero torque.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Right-hand rule sign error

You reversed the direction of the magnetic force vector F⃗=I(L⃗×B⃗)\vec{F} = I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}) on the left vertical segment.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misorienting the vector cross product or confusing the palm/thumb conventions in the right-hand rule when establishing vector directions in three dimensions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Right-Hand Rule for Magnetic Force
  • For F⃗=I(L⃗×B⃗)\vec{F} = I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}), point the fingers of your right hand along current vector L⃗\vec{L} and curl them toward field vector B⃗\vec{B}. Your extended thumb points along F⃗\vec{F}.

  • Always verify that you are using your right hand rather than your left hand, and confirm the orientation of each vector before finding the cross product.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Re-evaluate the orientation for the left segment carrying current in the loop relative to the magnetic field B⃗\vec{B}.

  2. Apply F⃗=I(L⃗×B⃗)\vec{F} = I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}) using the right-hand rule to find that the force points perpendicularly out of the plane.

Final answer

(a) F⃗net=0 N\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = 0\text{ N}; (b) F⃗left=0.525 N\vec{F}_{\text{left}} = 0.525\text{ N} directed perpendicularly out of the plane; non-zero torque exists because the equal and opposite forces act along separated lines of action.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice using the right-hand rule across various coordinate orientations (into/out of page, left/right, up/down).

  • Double-check cross-product directions using unit vectors ( i^, j^, k^\,\hat{i},\,\hat{j},\,\hat{k}) whenever an orientation feels ambiguous.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the dimensions and uses the width instead of the height for the length of the left vertical segment.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Fnet=I(∮dL)×B=0 NF_{\text{net}} = I\left(\oint dL\right) \times B = 0\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    Fleft=I⋅w⋅B  ⟹  Fleft=(3.50 A)(0.150 m)(0.600 T)=0.315 NF_{\text{left}} = I \cdot w \cdot B \implies F_{\text{left}} = (3.50\text{ A})(0.150\text{ m})(0.600\text{ T}) = 0.315\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fleft=IhB=(3.50 A)(0.250 m)(0.600 T)=0.525 NF_{\text{left}} = I h B = (3.50\text{ A})(0.250\text{ m})(0.600\text{ T}) = 0.525\text{ N}

    The left segment is a vertical wire, so its length is the loop height h=0.250 mh = 0.250\text{ m}, not the horizontal width w=0.150 mw = 0.150\text{ m}.

  3. Step 3

    Direction: out of the page\text{Direction: out of the page}

  4. Step 4

    Torque is non-zero because the equal and opposite forces on left and right segments have different lines of action.\text{Torque is non-zero because the equal and opposite forces on left and right segments have different lines of action.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the closed line integral property to conclude that the net magnetic force is zero.

You correctly used the right-hand rule to find the direction of the force on the left wire.

You correctly explained that non-collinear opposing forces create a non-zero torque.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
dimension_mismatch

You substituted the width w=0.150 mw = 0.150\text{ m} rather than the vertical height h=0.250 mh = 0.250\text{ m} for the length of the vertical segment.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Geometric dimension misassignment: overlooking the orientation of the specific wire segment (vertical vs. horizontal) when matching problem labels (ww vs. hh) to the wire length LL.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Segment Dimension Check
  • For a straight wire segment in F⃗=I(L⃗×B⃗)\vec{F} = I(\vec{L} \times \vec{B}), LL is the physical length along that specific segment.

  • Before calculating, label each wire segment on a quick sketch with its specific dimension (hh for vertical segments, ww for horizontal segments).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the length of the left vertical segment as h=0.250 mh = 0.250\text{ m}.

  2. Substitute into the force equation: Fleft=IhB=(3.50 A)(0.250 m)(0.600 T)=0.525 NF_{\text{left}} = I h B = (3.50\text{ A})(0.250\text{ m})(0.600\text{ T}) = 0.525\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) F⃗net=0 N\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = 0\text{ N}; (b) F⃗left=0.525 N\vec{F}_{\text{left}} = 0.525\text{ N} directed perpendicularly out of the plane; net torque is non-zero because the opposing forces act along separated lines of action.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always sketch the rectangular loop and write the specific dimension (hh or ww) directly beside each individual wire segment.

  • Double-check whether the segment you are analyzing is aligned vertically or horizontally before substituting numeric values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly assumes that zero net force always requires zero net torque, concluding the magnetic torque must be zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Closed loop in uniform field: Fnet=0 N\text{Closed loop in uniform field: } F_{\text{net}} = 0\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    Fleft=I⋅h⋅B  ⟹  Fleft=(3.50 A)(0.250 m)(0.600 T)=0.525 N out of the pageF_{\text{left}} = I \cdot h \cdot B \implies F_{\text{left}} = (3.50\text{ A})(0.250\text{ m})(0.600\text{ T}) = 0.525\text{ N}\text{ out of the page}

  3. Step 3

    Because Fnet=0, the system is in complete equilibrium so torque must be zero.\text{Because } F_{\text{net}} = 0\text{, the system is in complete equilibrium so torque must be zero.}

    Correct

    F⃗left\vec{F}_{\text{left}} and F⃗right\vec{F}_{\text{right}} are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction, but separated by width w=0.150 mw = 0.150\text{ m}, forming a couple with non-zero torque τ=Fleft⋅w=(0.525 N)(0.150 m)=0.0788 N⋅m\tau = F_{\text{left}} \cdot w = (0.525\text{ N})(0.150\text{ m}) = 0.0788\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

    Translational equilibrium (∑F⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{F} = \vec{0}) does not guarantee rotational equilibrium (∑τ⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{\tau} = \vec{0}). Because the equal and opposite forces on the left and right segments have different lines of action, they form a force couple that produces a net rotational torque.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the vector sum of magnetic forces over any closed loop in a uniform field vanishes.

You correctly applied F=ILBsin⁡θF = I L B \sin\theta to determine the magnitude and direction of the magnetic force on the left vertical wire.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Translational and Rotational Equilibrium

You equated zero net force with complete static equilibrium, assuming that F⃗net=0⃗\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{0} automatically forces τ⃗net=0⃗\vec{\tau}_{\text{net}} = \vec{0}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated equilibrium as a single condition rather than separating translational equilibrium (∑F⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{F} = \vec{0}) from rotational equilibrium (∑τ⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{\tau} = \vec{0}). When equal and opposite forces do not share a common line of action, their lever arms produce a non-zero couple torque.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Separation of Translational and Rotational Equilibrium
  • An object satisfies translational equilibrium when ∑F⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{F} = \vec{0}, but rotational equilibrium independently requires ∑τ⃗=0⃗\sum \vec{\tau} = \vec{0}.

  • Always evaluate torques about an axis by multiplying each force by its perpendicular moment arm, even when the net force is zero.

Magnetic Couple on a Current Loop
  • Opposite sides of a current loop experience equal and opposite magnetic forces separated by a distance ww, producing a couple torque τ=F⋅w=IABsin⁡θ\tau = F \cdot w = I A B \sin\theta.

  • Check whether opposing magnetic forces share the exact same line of action before claiming that the torque is zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the force on the right segment: F⃗right=0.525 N\vec{F}_{\text{right}} = 0.525\text{ N} directed into the page.

  2. Observe that F⃗left\vec{F}_{\text{left}} and F⃗right\vec{F}_{\text{right}} act along parallel lines separated by the loop width w=0.150 mw = 0.150\text{ m}.

  3. Calculate the couple torque about the vertical centerline: τ=Fleft⋅w=(0.525 N)(0.150 m)=0.0788 N⋅m\tau = F_{\text{left}} \cdot w = (0.525\text{ N})(0.150\text{ m}) = 0.0788\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} (or τ=IAB=(3.50 A)(0.150 m×0.250 m)(0.600 T)=0.0788 N⋅m\tau = I A B = (3.50\text{ A})(0.150\text{ m} \times 0.250\text{ m})(0.600\text{ T}) = 0.0788\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}).

  4. State the conceptual conclusion: while F⃗net=0⃗\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{0} prevents translational acceleration, the non-collinear forces create a non-zero torque that rotates the loop.

Final answer

F⃗net=0 N\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = 0\text{ N}; F⃗left=0.525 N\vec{F}_{\text{left}} = 0.525\text{ N} out of the page; non-zero torque τ=0.0788 N⋅m\tau = 0.0788\text{ N}\cdot\text{m} exists because the opposing forces act along lines of action separated by w=0.150 mw = 0.150\text{ m}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch free-body diagrams showing the point of application and line of action for every force, not just their vector components.

  • Practice calculating torque directly via the magnetic dipole moment formula τ⃗=μ⃗×B⃗\vec{\tau} = \vec{\mu} \times \vec{B} to avoid missing rotational effects.

  • Review the definition of a force couple in rigid-body statics to solidify why equal and opposite forces can induce rotation.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A straight wire segment of length 0.40 m0.40\text{ m} carries a current of 2.0 A2.0\text{ A} directed toward the top of the page. A uniform magnetic field of 0.50 T0.50\text{ T} is directed perpendicularly into the page. Find the magnitude and direction of the magnetic force on the wire.

Answer

F=ILB=(2.0 A)(0.40 m)(0.50 T)=0.40 NF = I L B = (2.0\text{ A})(0.40\text{ m})(0.50\text{ T}) = 0.40\text{ N}. Point fingers up (current) and curl into the page (field); your thumb points to the left. Thus, F⃗=0.40 N\vec{F} = 0.40\text{ N} directed to the left.

02

A square loop of side length s=0.20 ms = 0.20\text{ m} lies in the xyxy-plane and carries a counter-clockwise current I=4.0 AI = 4.0\text{ A}. A uniform magnetic field B⃗=0.80 T i^\vec{B} = 0.80\text{ T}\,\hat{i} is present. Calculate the magnetic force on the bottom edge and the net torque acting on the loop.

Answer

On the bottom edge, current flows in the +x+x direction (parallel to B⃗\vec{B}), so F⃗bottom=0⃗ N\vec{F}_{\text{bottom}} = \vec{0}\text{ N}. The magnetic moment is μ⃗=Is2 k^=(4.0)(0.04) k^=0.16 A⋅m2 k^\vec{\mu} = I s^2\,\hat{k} = (4.0)(0.04)\,\hat{k} = 0.16\text{ A}\cdot\text{m}^2\,\hat{k}. The net torque is τ⃗=μ⃗×B⃗=(0.16 k^)×(0.80 i^)=0.128 N⋅m j^\vec{\tau} = \vec{\mu} \times \vec{B} = (0.16\,\hat{k}) \times (0.80\,\hat{i}) = 0.128\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}\,\hat{j}.

03

A circular wire loop of radius R=0.10 mR = 0.10\text{ m} carrying current I=5.0 AI = 5.0\text{ A} is tilted such that its area normal n^\hat{n} makes an angle of 60∘60^\circ with a uniform magnetic field B=1.2 TB = 1.2\text{ T}. Determine the net translational magnetic force on the loop and the magnitude of the torque tending to rotate it.

Answer

Because the loop is closed and the magnetic field is uniform, the net translational force is F⃗net=0 N\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = 0\text{ N}. The magnetic dipole moment magnitude is μ=I(πR2)=5.0⋅π(0.10)2≈0.1571 A⋅m2\mu = I(\pi R^2) = 5.0 \cdot \pi(0.10)^2 \approx 0.1571\text{ A}\cdot\text{m}^2. The torque magnitude is τ=μBsin⁡(60∘)=(0.1571)(1.2)(32)≈0.163 N⋅m\tau = \mu B \sin(60^\circ) = (0.1571)(1.2)(\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}) \approx 0.163\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

Loading workspace…