Resources

In a university physics laboratory experiment, two laboratory carts are mounted on a level, low-friction air track. Cart 1 has mass m1=0.500 kgm_1 = 0.500\text{ kg} and is equipped with a digital force sensor. Cart 2 has mass m2=1.00 kgm_2 = 1.00\text{ kg} and carries an identical synchronized digital force sensor. Each force sensor features a rubber bumper. Cart 1 is launched toward stationary Cart 2. During the collision, the force sensors record contact force data over time Δt=40.0 ms\Delta t = 40.0\text{ ms}. Sensor 1 records the force exerted by Cart 2 on Cart 1, F21(t)F_{21}(t), and Sensor 2 records the force exerted by Cart 1 on Cart 2, F12(t)F_{12}(t). The peak force recorded by Sensor 1 is measured to be 18.4 N18.4\text{ N}. (a) Predict the theoretical peak force magnitude and the total impulse recorded by Sensor 2 during this collision if the impulse on Cart 1 is measured to be J1=−0.460 N⋅sJ_1 = -0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}. (b) Identify the Newton's third law pair recorded by the laboratory sensors and explain how the digitized force-time profiles F12(t)F_{12}(t) and F21(t)F_{21}(t) must relate at every discrete instant tt throughout the collision.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Peak force magnitude on Sensor 2 is 18.4 N18.4\text{ N}; impulse J2=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}; (b) The pair consists of the contact force exerted by Cart 2 on Cart 1 (F21(t)F_{21}(t)) and the contact force exerted by Cart 1 on Cart 2 (F12(t)F_{12}(t)). By Newton's third law, at every discrete instant tt, F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t), meaning their force-versus-time curves are exact mirror reflections across the time axis with identical peak heights, widths, and integrated impulse areas of opposite sign.

Steps

Part (a): Determining Peak Force and Impulse on Sensor 2

  1. Apply Newton's Third Law to Instantaneous Forces Newton's third law states that whenever two bodies interact, the force exerted by the first body on the second is equal in magnitude and opposite in direction to the force exerted by the second body on the first at every instant of time: F⃗12(t)=−F⃗21(t)\vec{F}_{12}(t) = -\vec{F}_{21}(t) Along the one-dimensional line of motion: F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t)
  2. Peak Force Magnitude Because the magnitudes of the forces are identical at every moment during the contact: ∣F12(t)∣=∣F21(t)∣|F_{12}(t)| = |F_{21}(t)| Therefore, the theoretical peak force magnitude recorded by Sensor 2 must be identical to that recorded by Sensor 1: Peak Force Magnitude=18.4 N\text{Peak Force Magnitude} = 18.4\text{ N}
  3. Total Impulse on Sensor 2 Impulse JJ is defined as the time integral of the force over the collision duration Δt\Delta t: J2=∫0ΔtF12(t) dtJ_2 = \int_{0}^{\Delta t} F_{12}(t)\,dt Substituting F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t): J2=∫0Δt(−F21(t)) dt=−∫0ΔtF21(t) dt=−J1J_2 = \int_{0}^{\Delta t} \big(-F_{21}(t)\big)\,dt = -\int_{0}^{\Delta t} F_{21}(t)\,dt = -J_1 Given that the impulse on Cart 1 is J1=−0.460 N⋅sJ_1 = -0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}: J2=−(−0.460 N⋅s)=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = -(-0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}) = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}

Part (b): Action-Reaction Pair and Profile Comparison

  1. Identifying the Newton's Third Law Pair The interaction pair consists of:

    • F21(t)F_{21}(t): the contact force exerted by Cart 2 on Cart 1.
    • F12(t)F_{12}(t): the contact force exerted by Cart 1 on Cart 2.
  2. Relationship Between the Digitized Force-Time Profiles

    • Instantaneous Equivalence: At every discrete sampling point tit_i across the interval [0,40.0 ms][0, 40.0\text{ ms}], the sensors record equal and opposite values: F12(ti)=−F21(ti)F_{12}(t_i) = -F_{21}(t_i)
    • Graphical Representation: The force-versus-time profile F12(t)F_{12}(t) is an exact inverted reflection (mirror image across the time axis) of F21(t)F_{21}(t). Both profiles share the exact same duration (40.0 ms40.0\text{ ms}), the same symmetric or bell-shaped curve, identical peak magnitudes (18.4 N18.4\text{ N}), and equal area magnitudes under the curve (0.460 N⋅s0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}), with opposite signs.

Common Pitfall: A frequent misconception is that the more massive cart (m2=1.00 kgm_2 = 1.00\text{ kg}) or the stationary cart experiences a different force magnitude than the lighter, moving cart (m1=0.500 kgm_1 = 0.500\text{ kg}). Newton's third law holds strictly regardless of mass differences, motion states, or velocities; unequal masses only result in different accelerations (a=Fma = \frac{F}{m}), not different forces.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes force scales inversely with or depends directly on the cart masses rather than recognizing that contact forces are strictly equal and opposite by Newton's third law.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    m2m1=1.00 kg0.500 kg=2  ⟹  Fpeak,2=18.4 N2=9.20 N\frac{m_2}{m_1} = \frac{1.00\text{ kg}}{0.500\text{ kg}} = 2 \implies F_{\text{peak}, 2} = \frac{18.4\text{ N}}{2} = 9.20\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fpeak,2=Fpeak,1=18.4 NF_{\text{peak}, 2} = F_{\text{peak}, 1} = 18.4\text{ N}

    You divided the peak force by the 2:12:1 mass ratio. By Newton's third law, the force magnitudes exerted between interacting objects are always equal, independent of their masses.

  2. Step 2

    J2=−J12=+0.230 N⋅sJ_2 = \frac{-J_1}{2} = +0.230\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}

    Correct

    J2=−J1=−(−0.460 N⋅s)=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = -J_1 = -(-0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}) = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}

    Because the instantaneous forces are equal and opposite at every instant (F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t)), integrating over time gives equal and opposite total impulses (J2=−J1J_2 = -J_1), with no factor of 22.

  3. Step 3

    Action-reaction pair: F21(t) and F12(t)\text{Action-reaction pair: } F_{21}(t) \text{ and } F_{12}(t)

  4. Step 4

    F12(t)=−0.5F21(t) at each instant due to the 2:1 mass ratio.F_{12}(t) = -0.5 F_{21}(t) \text{ at each instant due to the } 2:1 \text{ mass ratio.}

    Correct

    F12(t)=−F21(t) at every instant tF_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t) \text{ at every instant } t

    You introduced a coefficient of −0.5-0.5 based on mass. Newton's third law requires F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t) strictly, making the profile of F12(t)F_{12}(t) an exact inverted mirror image of F21(t)F_{21}(t) with a 1:11:1 ratio.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified F21(t)F_{21}(t) and F12(t)F_{12}(t) as the Newton's third law action-reaction pair.

You correctly accounted for the opposite directions of the interaction forces by using a negative sign for impulse and force.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass-Dependent Force Misconception in Newton's Third Law

None. This is a conceptual misunderstanding rather than a calculation oversight.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that contact interaction forces scale with or depend on the mass ratio of the colliding objects. While acceleration depends on mass via Newton's second law (a=F/ma = F/m), the contact forces themselves are strictly equal in magnitude and opposite in direction at every instant according to Newton's third law.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equal Magnitude Regardless of Mass
  • Whenever two bodies interact, ∣F⃗A on B(t)∣=∣F⃗B on A(t)∣|\vec{F}_{A \text{ on } B}(t)| = |\vec{F}_{B \text{ on } A}(t)| at all times, no matter how much their masses or speeds differ.

  • Never scale contact interaction forces by mass ratios; set their magnitudes equal before computing kinematic results.

Impulse Conservation Across Pairs
  • Because instantaneous forces are equal and opposite (F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t)), their time integrals satisfy J2=−J1J_2 = -J_1.

  • Set the impulse delivered to one body equal in magnitude and opposite in sign to the impulse delivered to the other.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Newton's third law to the contact force: ∣F12(t)∣=∣F21(t)∣|F_{12}(t)| = |F_{21}(t)| at all instants, so Peak Force Magnitude=18.4 N\text{Peak Force Magnitude} = 18.4\text{ N}.

  2. Integrate both sides over the collision duration Δt\Delta t: J2=∫0ΔtF12(t) dt=−∫0ΔtF21(t) dt=−J1=−(−0.460 N⋅s)=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = \int_0^{\Delta t} F_{12}(t)\,dt = -\int_0^{\Delta t} F_{21}(t)\,dt = -J_1 = -(-0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}) = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}.

  3. Relate the instantaneous profiles: F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t) across the entire collision duration.

Final answer

(a) Peak force magnitude =18.4 N= 18.4\text{ N}; total impulse J2=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}. (b) The pair is F21(t)F_{21}(t) and F12(t)F_{12}(t); at every discrete instant tt, F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Newton's third law to reinforce why interaction force magnitudes never depend on mass.

  • Practice distinguishing between interaction forces (always equal and opposite) and resulting accelerations (which vary inversely with mass).

  • Solve collision problems where masses differ by large factors (such as a truck colliding with a compact car) to build intuition.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the sign of impulse by omitting the opposite direction requirement of Newton's third law and equating impulse directly.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Fpeak,2=18.4 NF_{\text{peak},2} = 18.4\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    J2=J1=−0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = J_1 = -0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}

    Correct

    J2=−J1=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = -J_1 = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}

    Because Newton's third law specifies forces of equal magnitude but opposite direction, the contact force vectors satisfy F⃗12(t)=−F⃗21(t)\vec{F}_{12}(t) = -\vec{F}_{21}(t). Integrating over the collision duration gives J2=−J1J_2 = -J_1, which equals +0.460 N⋅s+0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s} rather than −0.460 N⋅s-0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}.

  3. Step 3

    Action-reaction pair: F21(t)F_{21}(t) and F12(t)F_{12}(t)

  4. Step 4

    F12(t)=F21(t)F_{12}(t) = F_{21}(t) at every instant, so the two sensor profiles are identical in both magnitude and sign.

    Correct

    F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t) at every instant, so the two sensor profiles are reflections across the time axis (equal magnitude, opposite sign).

    Action-reaction forces act in opposite directions along the line of collision. Along a chosen coordinate axis, the instantaneous forces satisfy F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t), meaning the force-time graphs are inverted mirror images across the time axis with opposite algebraic signs.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that Newton's third law guarantees equal force magnitudes regardless of the carts' unequal masses.

You correctly identified the contact forces between the two colliding carts as the action-reaction pair.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error due to ignoring vector opposition in Newton's Third Law

No, this is a conceptual misconception regarding the vector nature and sign relationship of action-reaction pairs.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated Newton's third law as an equality of scalar quantities (F12=F21F_{12} = F_{21}) rather than an equality of vectors with opposite directions (F⃗12=−F⃗21\vec{F}_{12} = -\vec{F}_{21}). Consequently, you preserved the negative sign for the impulse on Cart 2 and concluded that the force profiles share the same algebraic sign.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Vector Nature of Newton's Third Law
  • Newton's third law states F⃗A on B=−F⃗B on A\vec{F}_{A\text{ on }B} = -\vec{F}_{B\text{ on }A}. Along any 1D axis, FA on B(t)=−FB on A(t)F_{A\text{ on }B}(t) = -F_{B\text{ on }A}(t).

  • Always attach an explicit negative sign when equating 1D component forces or impulses of an action-reaction pair.

Impulse Conservation and Action-Reaction Pairs
  • J=∫F(t) dtJ = \int F(t)\,dt, so J⃗2=−J⃗1\vec{J}_2 = -\vec{J}_1.

  • When given the impulse on one colliding body, reverse its sign to find the impulse delivered to the other interacting body.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Newton's third law in one dimension: F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t) for every instant tt.

  2. Integrate both sides with respect to time over the collision duration: J2=∫0ΔtF12(t) dt=−∫0ΔtF21(t) dt=−J1J_2 = \int_0^{\Delta t} F_{12}(t)\,dt = -\int_0^{\Delta t} F_{21}(t)\,dt = -J_1.

  3. Substitute J1=−0.460 N⋅sJ_1 = -0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}: J2=−(−0.460 N⋅s)=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = -(-0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}) = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}.

  4. Describe the graphical profiles: Since F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t), the plots have identical durations and peak magnitudes (18.4 N18.4\text{ N}), but opposite signs, forming mirror images across the horizontal time axis.

Final answer

(a) Theoretical peak force magnitude is 18.4 N18.4\text{ N}; total impulse J2=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}. (b) The pair is F21(t)F_{21}(t) and F12(t)F_{12}(t); they satisfy F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t) at every instant, producing profiles that are equal in magnitude but opposite in sign (inverted reflections across the time axis).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the vector statement of Newton's third law: F⃗12=−F⃗21\vec{F}_{12} = -\vec{F}_{21}.

  • Practice sketching force-versus-time curves for colliding objects on a shared coordinate axis to visualize the opposite-sign reflection.

  • Work through impulse-momentum problems to verify that total system impulse sums to zero: J1+J2=0J_1 + J_2 = 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the peak force by dividing impulse by the total collision duration, confusing average force with peak force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    J2=−J1=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = -J_1 = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}

  2. Step 2

    Fpeak,2=J2Δt=0.460 N⋅s0.0400 s=11.5 NF_{\text{peak}, 2} = \frac{J_2}{\Delta t} = \frac{0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}}{0.0400\text{ s}} = 11.5\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fpeak,2=Fpeak,1=18.4 NF_{\text{peak}, 2} = F_{\text{peak}, 1} = 18.4\text{ N}

    You divided impulse by collision duration, which gives the time-averaged force FavgF_{\text{avg}}, not the peak force. Because Newton's third law requires ∣F12(t)∣=∣F21(t)∣|F_{12}(t)| = |F_{21}(t)| at every discrete instant tt, the maximum force recorded by Sensor 2 must directly equal the maximum force recorded by Sensor 1.

  3. Step 3

    Action-reaction pair: F21(t)F_{21}(t) and F12(t)  ⟹  F_{12}(t) \implies At every instant tt, F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t), meaning equal magnitudes and opposite directions.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly determined that the impulse on Cart 2 is J2=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}.

You correctly identified F21(t)F_{21}(t) and F12(t)F_{12}(t) as the Newton's third law pair.

You correctly stated the instantaneous relation F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing peak force with average force

You substituted the peak force variable into the definition for average force, calculating JΔt\frac{J}{\Delta t}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating collision force profiles as constant rectangles rather than time-varying curves leads to conflating peak force with average force, missing that Newton's third law directly equates the instantaneous extrema of interacting bodies.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Average Force vs. Peak Force
  • Favg=JΔt=1Δt∫0ΔtF(t) dtF_{\text{avg}} = \frac{J}{\Delta t} = \frac{1}{\Delta t}\int_0^{\Delta t} F(t)\,dt, whereas Fpeak=max⁡(∣F(t)∣)F_{\text{peak}} = \max(|F(t)|).

  • For any curved or bell-shaped force-time pulse, recognize that Fpeak>FavgF_{\text{peak}} > F_{\text{avg}} and cannot be found by simply dividing JJ by Δt\Delta t.

Pointwise Newton's Third Law
  • ∣F⃗12(t)∣=∣F⃗21(t)∣|\vec{F}_{12}(t)| = |\vec{F}_{21}(t)| holds identically at every instant tt, including at t=tpeakt = t_{\text{peak}}.

  • To find the peak force on the second object, set it equal to the known peak force magnitude on the first object directly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Newton's third law at the moment of peak contact force: ∣F12(tpeak)∣=∣F21(tpeak)∣|F_{12}(t_{\text{peak}})| = |F_{21}(t_{\text{peak}})|.

  2. Directly read or equate the peak magnitude from Sensor 1: Fpeak,2=Fpeak,1=18.4 NF_{\text{peak}, 2} = F_{\text{peak}, 1} = 18.4\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) Peak force magnitude =18.4 N= 18.4\text{ N}; total impulse J2=+0.460 N⋅sJ_2 = +0.460\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}. (b) The pair consists of F21(t)F_{21}(t) and F12(t)F_{12}(t); at every instant tt, F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the graphical distinction between the height of a force curve (FpeakF_{\text{peak}}) and the height of an equivalent-area rectangle (FavgF_{\text{avg}}).

  • Practice identifying when a question asks for an instantaneous value rather than an interval-averaged value.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.20 kg0.20\text{ kg} billiard ball strikes a rigid 2.0 kg2.0\text{ kg} stationary block. During contact, the ball exerts an average force of 50 N50\text{ N} on the block. What is the magnitude of the average force exerted by the block on the ball?

Answer

50 N50\text{ N}. By Newton's third law, the contact force exerted by the block on the ball has the exact same magnitude as the force exerted by the ball on the block, regardless of the 10:110:1 mass ratio.

02

In a dynamic crash test, Car A (1200 kg1200\text{ kg}) collides with stationary Truck B (3600 kg3600\text{ kg}). Accelerometers record that Car A undergoes an average deceleration magnitude of 18 m/s218\text{ m/s}^2 during the 0.10 s0.10\text{ s} impact. (a) Determine the average force magnitude exerted on Truck B. (b) Find the acceleration magnitude of Truck B during the collision.

Answer

(a) 21,600 N21{,}600\text{ N}; (b) 6.0 m/s26.0\text{ m/s}^2. First, calculate the force on Car A: F=mAaA=(1200 kg)(18 m/s2)=21,600 NF = m_A a_A = (1200\text{ kg})(18\text{ m/s}^2) = 21{,}600\text{ N}. By Newton's third law, the force on Truck B is identical in magnitude (21,600 N21{,}600\text{ N}). Truck B's acceleration is aB=FmB=21,600 N3600 kg=6.0 m/s2a_B = \frac{F}{m_B} = \frac{21{,}600\text{ N}}{3600\text{ kg}} = 6.0\text{ m/s}^2.

03

Two gliders on an air track carry repulsive magnets. Glider 1 (m1=0.300 kgm_1 = 0.300\text{ kg}) and Glider 2 (m2=0.900 kgm_2 = 0.900\text{ kg}) repel each other without touching. If the force-time profile experienced by Glider 1 is described by F21(t)=−F0sin⁡(πt/T)F_{21}(t) = -F_0 \sin(\pi t / T) for 0≤t≤T0 \le t \le T, write the complete expression for F12(t)F_{12}(t) and calculate the ratio of their final speeds ∣Δv1∣∣Δv2∣\frac{|\Delta v_1|}{|\Delta v_2|} after starting from rest.

Answer

F12(t)=+F0sin⁡(πt/T)F_{12}(t) = +F_0 \sin(\pi t / T); speed ratio ∣Δv1∣∣Δv2∣=3\frac{|\Delta v_1|}{|\Delta v_2|} = 3. By Newton's third law, F12(t)=−F21(t)F_{12}(t) = -F_{21}(t) at every instant. The impulses are equal in magnitude: ∣J1∣=∣J2∣=J|J_1| = |J_2| = J. Therefore, m1∣Δv1∣=m2∣Δv2∣m_1 |\Delta v_1| = m_2 |\Delta v_2|, giving ∣Δv1∣∣Δv2∣=m2m1=0.900 kg0.300 kg=3\frac{|\Delta v_1|}{|\Delta v_2|} = \frac{m_2}{m_1} = \frac{0.900\text{ kg}}{0.300\text{ kg}} = 3.

Loading workspace…