Resources
A swimmer can sustain a maximum swimming speed of in calm water. The swimmer stands on the southern bank of a river of width that flows due east with a current speed of . Because , the swimmer cannot prevent downstream drift. (a) Determine the heading angle (measured in degrees west of north) that minimizes the total downstream drift distance upon reaching the opposite bank. (b) Calculate the minimum downstream drift distance accumulated during this crossing.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) west of north; (b)
Steps
Set Up the Coordinate System and Relative Velocity Vectors
Define a Cartesian coordinate system with:
- The -axis pointing downstream (due east).
- The -axis pointing straight across the river from the south bank to the north bank (due north).
Let the swimmer's heading be directed at an angle west of north (upstream).
- The velocity of the river current relative to the ground is:
- The velocity of the swimmer relative to the water is:
- By relative velocity addition, the swimmer's resultant velocity relative to the ground is:
The components of the net velocity are:
Formulate the Total Downstream Drift
The swimmer crosses the river of width under the vertical component . The time required to reach the opposite bank depends only on :
During this time, the swimmer is carried downstream by the horizontal component . The total downstream drift distance upon reaching the opposite bank is:
Find the Heading Angle that Minimizes Drift
To find the angle that minimizes , take the first derivative with respect to and set it to zero:
Setting the factor in parentheses to zero gives the condition for minimum drift:
Substitute the given speeds and :
Thus, the swimmer must head at an angle of west of north.
Geometric Interpretation: In velocity space, the net velocity vector originates at the tail of and terminates on a circle of radius centered at the tip of . To minimize the downstream drift, must make the steepest possible angle with the downstream bank, which occurs precisely when is tangent to this circle. In the resulting right-angled triangle formed by , , and , the angle opposite to satisfies .
Calculate the Minimum Drift Distance
Using the trigonometric identity with :
Substitute and into the expression for drift:
Using the optimal heading angle and river width :
Typical errors
01 The student assumes that minimizing crossing time by aiming straight across also minimizes total downstream drift.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Heading straight across gives the fastest crossing to minimize drift:
CorrectYou equated the condition for minimum crossing time with the condition for minimum downstream drift. Minimizing drift requires balancing the crossing time with the net downstream speed .
- Step 2Correct
Your time calculation followed correctly from your choice of , but the optimal heading of yields a crossing time of approximately .
- Step 3Correct
This downstream drift value was affected by using . The optimal angle reduces downstream drift from down to .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly related crossing time, perpendicular velocity, and river width for perpendicular motion.
You correctly multiplied the net downstream speed by time to compute drift distance.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the strategy minimizing crossing time () also minimizes drift distance (). Because the downstream velocity decreases as you aim upstream, the product is minimized at a non-zero angle where .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Distinguish Objectives
Minimizing crossing time requires maximizing (heading angle ), whereas minimizing drift requires minimizing .
Express drift as an explicit function of heading angle before choosing or optimizing the angle.
- Geometric Tangency for Minimum Drift
When current speed exceeds swimmer speed (), the resultant velocity vector makes the smallest downstream angle when it is tangent to the circle of radius centered at , yielding .
Draw the velocity vector triangle to verify whether the resultant vector can be directed straight across or must be optimized via tangency.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationExpress total downstream drift as a function of heading angle : .
Differentiate with respect to and set : .
Substitute and : .
Compute minimum drift using .
(a) west of north; (b)
02 The student measures the heading angle relative to the riverbank rather than west of north, confusing sine and cosine in the drift minimization condition.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You measured the heading angle from the riverbank instead of west of north. When the angle is defined west of north (relative to the across-river axis), the upstream velocity component is , which leads to the minimization condition and gives .
- Step 2Correct
Your kinematic steps and final drift value are physically consistent with your angle definition, but your intermediate expressions used and because of the complementary angle defined in Step 1.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the minimum drift condition corresponds to the speed ratio .
You correctly calculated the river crossing time, net downstream velocity, and resulting total drift distance.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou solved for the heading angle relative to the riverbank instead of west of north.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisWhen resolving velocity components, an angle measured west of north uses the across-river (north) axis as the reference, making the north component and the upstream component . Setting corresponds to measuring the angle relative to the riverbank (the east-west axis), producing the complementary angle .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Verify the Reference Axis
An angle specified as 'west of north' is measured from the north axis (across the river). The adjacent component along north is , and the opposite component along west is .
Always draw coordinate axes and mark the reference direction before setting up trigonometric ratios for vector components.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDefine the heading angle west of north so that .
Set up the total drift function and differentiate with respect to .
Set , yielding .
Substitute and to get west of north.
(a) west of north; (b) (or with rounded angle)
Lock it in
When crossing a river with current speed , what heading angle (relative to straight across) minimizes total downstream drift?
upstream. Total drift is minimized when the resultant ground velocity vector is tangent to the circle of radius centered at the tip of .
Similar question
A swimmer can swim at in calm water. A river of width flows at . Find the heading angle (upstream from straight across) that minimizes downstream drift, and calculate the resulting minimum drift distance.
Answer
. The minimum drift is .
A motorboat crosses an wide river flowing east at . The boat's top speed relative to water is . Compare the total drift when heading straight north versus heading at the optimal angle to minimize drift.
Answer
For straight north (): , drift . For optimal heading: , drift . Heading at the optimal angle saves of drift.
A river of width flows with speed . A swimmer with speed chooses a heading upstream such that drift distance exactly equals the river width . Find the required ratio if this occurs at the drift-minimizing angle.
Answer
At minimum drift, . Setting gives .