Resources

A point-like light source is placed along the optical axis of a concave spherical mirror with focal length f=+20.0 cmf = +20.0\text{ cm}. Analyze the critical boundary transitions: (a) Evaluate the image distance did_i as the object distance dod_o approaches the focal point from the outside (do→20.0+ cmd_o \to 20.0^+\text{ cm}) versus from the inside (do→20.0− cmd_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm}); (b) Determine the exact object position dod_o at which the image transitions from inverted to upright; and (c) Identify the exact object location where the image is real, inverted, and exactly equal in size to the object (m=−1.00m = -1.00).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) As do→20.0+ cmd_o \to 20.0^+\text{ cm}, di→+∞d_i \to +\infty (real rays emerge parallel); as do→20.0− cmd_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm}, di→−∞d_i \to -\infty (virtual diverging rays emerge); (b) The critical boundary is do=f=20.0 cmd_o = f = 20.0\text{ cm} (the focal plane); (c) do=2f=R=40.0 cmd_o = 2f = R = 40.0\text{ cm}.

Steps

Part (a): Limit Behavior Near the Focal Point

The spherical mirror equation relates the object distance dod_o, image distance did_i, and focal length ff: 1do+1di=1f\frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f}

Solving for did_i: di=f⋅dodo−fd_i = \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f}

Given a concave mirror with f=+20.0 cmf = +20.0\text{ cm}:

  1. Approaching from the outside (do→20.0+ cmd_o \to 20.0^+\text{ cm}):

    • The denominator (do−f)(d_o - f) approaches 00 from positive values: (do−f)→0+(d_o - f) \to 0^+.
    • The numerator approaches (+20.0 cm)(20.0 cm)=+400 cm2>0(+20.0\text{ cm})(20.0\text{ cm}) = +400\text{ cm}^2 > 0.
    • Therefore, the image distance diverges to positive infinity: di→+∞d_i \to +\infty
    • Physical interpretation: The reflected rays become parallel to each other and travel toward infinity on the reflective (real) side of the mirror.
  2. Approaching from the inside (do→20.0− cmd_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm}):

    • The denominator (do−f)(d_o - f) approaches 00 from negative values: (do−f)→0−(d_o - f) \to 0^-.
    • The numerator remains positive.
    • Therefore, the image distance diverges to negative infinity: di→−∞d_i \to -\infty
    • Physical interpretation: The reflected rays diverge, appearing to originate from an infinitely distant virtual point behind the mirror.

Part (b): Transition Between Inverted and Upright Images

The lateral magnification mm of a spherical mirror is given by: m=−didom = -\frac{d_i}{d_o}

Substituting di=f⋅dodo−fd_i = \dfrac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f} into the magnification formula: m=−fdo−f=ff−dom = -\frac{f}{d_o - f} = \frac{f}{f - d_o}

Analyzing the sign of magnification:

  • When do>fd_o > f, f−do<0f - d_o < 0, which gives m<0m < 0. A negative magnification indicates an inverted (and real) image.
  • When do<fd_o < f, f−do>0f - d_o > 0, which gives m>0m > 0. A positive magnification indicates an upright (and virtual) image.

The sign change in magnification occurs precisely at the singularity where do=fd_o = f. Thus, the boundary where the image orientation transitions from inverted to upright is at the focal point: do=f=20.0 cmd_o = f = 20.0\text{ cm}


Part (c): Condition for a Real, Same-Size Inverted Image (m=−1.00m = -1.00)

Using the magnification definition: m=−dido=−1.00  ⟹  di=dom = -\frac{d_i}{d_o} = -1.00 \implies d_i = d_o

Substitute di=dod_i = d_o into the mirror equation: 1do+1do=1f\frac{1}{d_o} + \frac{1}{d_o} = \frac{1}{f} 2do=1f  ⟹  do=2f\frac{2}{d_o} = \frac{1}{f} \implies d_o = 2f

With f=+20.0 cmf = +20.0\text{ cm}: do=2(20.0 cm)=40.0 cmd_o = 2(20.0\text{ cm}) = 40.0\text{ cm}

This object distance corresponds to the mirror's center of curvature (CC), where the radius of curvature is R=2f=40.0 cmR = 2f = 40.0\text{ cm}. At this exact position, the image is formed at the same location (di=40.0 cmd_i = 40.0\text{ cm}), inverted, and identical in size to the object.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the sign of (d_o - f) in the denominator and concludes that the image distance approaches positive infinity from both sides.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1di=1f−1do  ⟹  di=f⋅dodo−f\frac{1}{d_i} = \frac{1}{f} - \frac{1}{d_o} \implies d_i = \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f}

  2. Step 2

    As do→20.0+ cm,  di→+∞\text{As } d_o \to 20.0^+\text{ cm}, \; d_i \to +\infty

  3. Step 3

    As do→20.0− cm,  di→+∞\text{As } d_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm}, \; d_i \to +\infty

    Correct

    lim⁡do→20.0−di=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 20.0^-} d_i = -\infty

    When dod_o approaches 20.0 cm20.0\text{ cm} from the inside (do<20.0 cmd_o < 20.0\text{ cm}), the denominator (do−f)(d_o - f) is negative and approaches 0−0^-. Since the numerator is positive (+400 cm2+400\text{ cm}^2), the quotient approaches −∞-\infty, representing virtual diverging rays behind the mirror.

  4. Step 4

    m=−fdo−f  ⟹  Orientation changes when do=20.0 cmm = \frac{-f}{d_o - f} \implies \text{Orientation changes when } d_o = 20.0\text{ cm}

  5. Step 5

    m=−dido=−1.00  ⟹  di=do  ⟹  120.0=2do  ⟹  do=40.0 cmm = -\frac{d_i}{d_o} = -1.00 \implies d_i = d_o \implies \frac{1}{20.0} = \frac{2}{d_o} \implies d_o = 40.0\text{ cm}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the explicit rational function for image distance di=f⋅dodo−fd_i = \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f}.

You correctly analyzed the right-hand limit as the object approaches the focal point from the outside.

You correctly identified the focal plane as the transition boundary between upright and inverted images.

You correctly computed the object distance for an inverted, equal-sized real image at do=2fd_o = 2f.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in one-sided limit evaluation

You treated the denominator (do−f)(d_o - f) as approaching positive zero from both directions instead of accounting for the negative sign when do<fd_o < f.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the sign of an infinitesimal denominator (do−f)(d_o - f) when taking a left-hand limit (do→f−d_o \to f^-), which leads to missing the transition from a real image on the object side (+∞+\infty) to a virtual image behind the mirror (−∞-\infty).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluate the Sign of the Difference
  • When x→a−x \to a^-, x<ax < a, so (x−a)<0(x - a) < 0 and (x−a)→0−(x - a) \to 0^-.

  • Check whether the object distance is slightly less than or greater than ff before deciding the sign of infinity.

Physical Reality of Virtual Images
  • For a concave mirror, an object inside the focal length (do<fd_o < f) forms a virtual image behind the mirror, meaning di<0d_i < 0.

  • Always cross-check your algebraic limit against ray behavior: rays diverging after reflection appear to come from behind the mirror (di<0d_i < 0).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the denominator sign explicitly: when do→20.0− cmd_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm}, do<20.0 cmd_o < 20.0\text{ cm}, so (do−20.0)→0−(d_o - 20.0) \to 0^-.

  2. Compute the numerator: f⋅do→(20.0)(20.0)=+400>0f \cdot d_o \to (20.0)(20.0) = +400 > 0.

  3. Take the quotient: di=+4000−→−∞d_i = \frac{+400}{0^-} \to -\infty.

Final answer

As do→20.0+ cmd_o \to 20.0^+\text{ cm}, di→+∞d_i \to +\infty; as do→20.0− cmd_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm}, di→−∞d_i \to -\infty.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice tracking one-sided limits (→0+(\to 0^+ vs. →0−)\to 0^-) when evaluating rational expressions in geometric optics.

  • Verify your algebraic signs of did_i against physical ray behavior (real converging rays vs. virtual diverging rays).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the transition boundary between inverted and upright images as occurring where m = 0 rather than where m changes sign across a vertical asymptote at the focal point.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    di=f⋅dodo−f  ⟹  As do→20.0+ cm,di→+∞;  As do→20.0− cm,di→−∞d_i = \frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f} \implies \text{As } d_o \to 20.0^+\text{ cm}, d_i \to +\infty;\; \text{As } d_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm}, d_i \to -\infty

  2. Step 2

    m = -dido\frac{d_i}{d_o} = 0   ⟹  \implies d_i = 0   ⟹  \implies Transition occurs at \text{Transition occurs at } d_o →\to ∞\infty

    Correct

    m = ff−do\frac{f}{f - d_o};; m < 0  for \text{ for } d_o > f  and \text{ and } m > 0  for \text{ for } d_o < f   ⟹  \implies Boundary is \text{Boundary is } d_o = f = 20.0 cm\text{ cm}

    A sign change in lateral magnification does not occur by passing through zero for finite distances; rather, m=ff−dom = \frac{f}{f - d_o} flips sign from negative (inverted) to positive (upright) across the vertical asymptote at the focal point do=f=20.0 cmd_o = f = 20.0\text{ cm}.

  3. Step 3

    m = -dido\frac{d_i}{d_o} = -1.00   ⟹  \implies d_i = d_o   ⟹  \implies 120.0\frac{1}{20.0} = 2do\frac{2}{d_o}   ⟹  \implies d_o = 40.0 cm\text{ cm}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You set up and manipulated the spherical mirror equation correctly.

You evaluated both one-sided directional limits as the object approaches the focal point.

You applied the magnification formula to find the exact location of the inverted, same-size image.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
boundary-transition-misidentification

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that a sign change in orientation requires the magnification function to pass continuously through zero (m=0m = 0), overlooking that lateral magnification changes sign across an infinite discontinuity (vertical asymptote) at do=fd_o = f.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Orientation Boundaries and Asymptotes
  • For a mirror, m=−dido=ff−dom = \frac{-d_i}{d_o} = \frac{f}{f - d_o}. Orientation changes from inverted (m<0m < 0) to upright (m>0m > 0) wherever the denominator changes sign.

  • Check for sign changes across vertical asymptotes (do=fd_o = f) rather than only looking for roots where m=0m = 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express lateral magnification directly as a function of object distance: m=−dido=ff−dom = -\frac{d_i}{d_o} = \frac{f}{f - d_o}.

  2. Analyze the sign of mm: when do>20.0 cmd_o > 20.0\text{ cm}, f−do<0f - d_o < 0, so m<0m < 0 (inverted image). When do<20.0 cmd_o < 20.0\text{ cm}, f−do>0f - d_o > 0, so m>0m > 0 (upright image).

  3. Identify the boundary where the sign flips: this transition occurs at the singularity where do=f=20.0 cmd_o = f = 20.0\text{ cm}.

Final answer

(a) do→20.0+ cm  ⟹  di→+∞d_o \to 20.0^+\text{ cm} \implies d_i \to +\infty; do→20.0− cm  ⟹  di→−∞d_o \to 20.0^-\text{ cm} \implies d_i \to -\infty; (b) do=20.0 cmd_o = 20.0\text{ cm}; (c) do=40.0 cmd_o = 40.0\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how rational functions flip sign across vertical asymptotes versus across zeros.

  • Practice sketching m(do)=ff−dom(d_o) = \frac{f}{f - d_o} for concave (f>0f > 0) and convex (f<0f < 0) mirrors to visualize image orientation transitions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the focal length with the radius of curvature and sets f equal to 20.0 cm / 2 = 10.0 cm, leading to an incorrect position for unit magnification.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    d_i = f⋅dodo−f\frac{f \cdot d_o}{d_o - f}   ⟹  \implies As \text{As } d_o →\to 20.0^+ cm\text{ cm},\ d_i →\to +∞\infty;\ As \text{As } d_o →\to 20.0^- cm\text{ cm},\ d_i →\to -∞\infty

  2. Step 2

    m = −fdo−f\frac{-f}{d_o - f}   ⟹  \implies Orientation changes when \text{Orientation changes when } d_o = 20.0 cm\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    f = 20.02\frac{20.0}{2} = 10.0 cm\text{ cm}

    Correct

    f = +20.0 cm\text{ cm}

    The problem directly specifies the focal length as f=+20.0 cmf = +20.0\text{ cm}. You halved this value, mistaking the given focal length for the mirror's radius of curvature RR.

  4. Step 4

    m = -1.00 means \text{ means } d_i = d_o   ⟹  \implies 1f\frac{1}{f} = 2do\frac{2}{d_o}   ⟹  \implies d_o = 2f = 20.0 cm\text{ cm}

    Correct

    m = -1.00   ⟹  \implies d_i = d_o   ⟹  \implies d_o = 2f = 2(20.0 cm\text{ cm}) = 40.0 cm\text{ cm}

    Your reasoning that m=−1.00m = -1.00 leads to di=dod_i = d_o and do=2fd_o = 2f is completely correct, but substituting your altered value of f=10.0 cmf = 10.0\text{ cm} resulted in an incorrect final position.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the image distance in terms of dod_o and evaluated the one-sided limits approaching the focal length.

You correctly derived lateral magnification to show that the image orientation transitions at the focal plane.

You correctly related unit negative magnification to di=dod_i = d_o and derived the condition do=2fd_o = 2f.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Variable confusion: focal length vs. radius of curvature

You divided the given focal length by 2 instead of using it directly.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the focal length ff with the radius of curvature RR. The relation is f=R2f = \frac{R}{2} (or R=2fR = 2f), meaning you only divide by 2 when given the radius of curvature, not when the problem explicitly gives ff.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Parameter Verification
  • For a spherical mirror, f=R2f = \frac{R}{2} and R=2fR = 2f. If a problem specifies focal length ff, use it directly without dividing by 2.

  • Always read the given parameter carefully: check whether the problem states 'focal length' (ff) or 'radius of curvature' (RR).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the given focal length from the problem: f=+20.0 cmf = +20.0\text{ cm}.

  2. Use the condition derived in your work for m=−1.00m = -1.00: do=2fd_o = 2f.

  3. Substitute f=20.0 cmf = 20.0\text{ cm} directly into the equation: do=2(20.0 cm)=40.0 cmd_o = 2(20.0\text{ cm}) = 40.0\text{ cm}.

Final answer

do=40.0 cmd_o = 40.0\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between focal length ff and radius of curvature R=2fR = 2f.

  • Practice labeling given values with their standard symbols (ff vs. RR) before writing equations.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An object is placed at do=10.0 cmd_o = 10.0\text{ cm} in front of a concave mirror with focal length f=+15.0 cmf = +15.0\text{ cm}. Calculate the image distance did_i and state whether the image is real or virtual.

Answer

di=−30.0 cmd_i = -30.0\text{ cm} (virtual image). Key steps: di=fdodo−f=(15.0)(10.0)10.0−15.0=150−5.0=−30.0 cmd_i = \frac{f d_o}{d_o - f} = \frac{(15.0)(10.0)}{10.0 - 15.0} = \frac{150}{-5.0} = -30.0\text{ cm}. Since di<0d_i < 0, it is virtual.

02

A concave mirror has a radius of curvature R=50.0 cmR = 50.0\text{ cm}. Evaluate lim⁡do→25.0+m\lim_{d_o \to 25.0^+} m and lim⁡do→25.0−m\lim_{d_o \to 25.0^-} m for the lateral magnification mm.

Answer

lim⁡do→25.0+m=−∞\lim_{d_o \to 25.0^+} m = -\infty and lim⁡do→25.0−m=+∞\lim_{d_o \to 25.0^-} m = +\infty. Key steps: f=R/2=25.0 cmf = R/2 = 25.0\text{ cm}. Magnification is m=−fdo−f=ff−dom = -\frac{f}{d_o - f} = \frac{f}{f - d_o}. As do→25.0+d_o \to 25.0^+, do−f→0+  ⟹  m→−∞d_o - f \to 0^+ \implies m \to -\infty (infinitely large, inverted). As do→25.0−d_o \to 25.0^-, do−f→0−  ⟹  m→+∞d_o - f \to 0^- \implies m \to +\infty (infinitely large, upright).

03

A convex spherical mirror has focal length f=−20.0 cmf = -20.0\text{ cm}. As an object approaches the mirror surface from infinity (do→0+d_o \to 0^+), determine whether did_i ever crosses a singularity or changes sign.

Answer

No singularity or sign change occurs; did_i remains strictly negative, increasing from −20.0 cm-20.0\text{ cm} toward 0− cm0^-\text{ cm}. Key steps: di=fdodo−f=−20dodo+20d_i = \frac{f d_o}{d_o - f} = \frac{-20 d_o}{d_o + 20}. Because do>0d_o > 0, the denominator (do+20)(d_o + 20) is always strictly positive, so did_i is continuously negative and never diverges.

Loading workspace…