Resources
A student pushes an eraser of mass vertically upward against a flat, vertical chalkboard. The applied force has a magnitude of directed at an angle of above the horizontal (pushing upward and inward against the board). The coefficients of friction between the eraser and the board are and . Using , establish a standard coordinate system to determine: (a) the normal force exerted by the vertical wall on the eraser, and (b) the magnitude and directional sign of the frictional force acting on the eraser, specifying whether it points upward or downward.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) The eraser accelerates upward because ; therefore, kinetic friction opposes the upward motion: directed downward (in the negative -direction).
Steps
Set up the Coordinate System and Resolve the Applied Force
Let the positive -axis point horizontally into the vertical chalkboard and the positive -axis point vertically upward.
The applied force pushes upward and into the board at an angle above the horizontal:
- Horizontal component:
- Vertical component:
The gravitational force acts vertically downward:
Determine the Normal Force (Part a)
Because the eraser remains in contact with the vertical board without breaking through it or pulling away, there is no acceleration in the horizontal direction ():
Solving for the normal force :
Check for Static Equilibrium or Motion (Part b)
Friction always opposes the tendency of relative motion between contacting surfaces. First, compute the net vertical force that would act on the eraser in the absence of friction:
Since this value is positive, the eraser tends to slide vertically upward.
Next, find the maximum static frictional force that the wall can provide to keep the eraser stationary:
Compare the driving upward force with the maximum static friction:
Because the upward driving force exceeds the threshold of static friction, static equilibrium cannot be maintained. The eraser accelerates upward.
Calculate the Kinetic Frictional Force
Because the eraser is sliding upward, kinetic friction acts on it, directed opposite to the motion (downward, in the negative -direction):
Thus, the frictional force has a magnitude of directed downward.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes static equilibrium holds without comparing the net upward tendency to the maximum static friction, concluding friction is static and equals 6.55 N downward.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
\sum F_y = F_y - mg - f = 0 f = 9.00 - 2.45 = 6.55
Correct. Since , the eraser slips upward, so downward.
You assumed static equilibrium held without testing the maximum static friction threshold. Because the net upward driving force () exceeds (), the eraser is in motion, meaning kinetic friction acts instead.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly established the horizontal force balance to solve for the normal force.
You accurately computed the vertical force component and the weight of the eraser.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeAssuming the object is stationary without evaluating the maximum static friction threshold.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisStatic friction is a self-adjusting constraint force with an upper bound . If the net driving force along the surface exceeds this maximum threshold, static equilibrium cannot be maintained, and kinetic friction opposes the actual sliding motion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Calculate the net driving force
Compute along the surface without friction.
Compare to zero to determine the direction the object tends to slide.
- Check the static friction limit
Static friction can only supply up to .
If , static equilibrium holds and . If , the object slips.
- Apply kinetic friction if slipping
When relative motion occurs, opposing relative velocity.
Use the coefficient of kinetic friction rather than solving for static equilibrium.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the maximum static friction: .
Compare the net upward driving force to the static limit: .
Conclude that the eraser accelerates upward, so kinetic friction acts downward.
Calculate kinetic friction: .
(a) ; (b) downward (-direction)
02 The student assumes the normal force equals the object's weight (N = mg), incorrectly using weight instead of the horizontal force component to evaluate friction.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Because the wall is vertical, the normal force acts horizontally perpendicular to the wall. It balances the horizontal component of the applied force (), not the gravitational force.
- Step 2
, so eraser moves upward
Correct, so the eraser moves upward
Your reasoning to check whether the net upward driving force exceeds maximum static friction is completely correct. However, your calculation of used the incorrect normal force from part (a).
- Step 3Correct
directed downward
You correctly determined that kinetic friction opposes the upward motion and points downward, but substituting the incorrect normal force led to an inaccurate numerical value.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou resolved the vertical component of the pushing force correctly using .
You correctly compared the net driving force () against maximum static friction to determine whether sliding occurs.
You correctly recognized that kinetic friction points downward to oppose upward motion.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou defaulted to setting normal force equal to weight (), overlooking that the surface of contact is vertical.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating as a universal formula rather than deriving from Newton's first law perpendicular to the surface of contact.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define Normal Force Direction
Normal force is always strictly perpendicular to the contact surface.
For a vertical wall, set up to solve for .
- Evaluate Friction Using the True Normal Force
Both static and kinetic friction limits depend directly on the contact normal force: .
Always substitute the perpendicular contact force found from the surface axis, never an unverified .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet horizontal acceleration to zero: .
Compute maximum static friction: .
Compare driving force: , confirming the eraser slips upward.
Compute kinetic friction: pointing downward.
(a) ; (b) directed downward (negative -direction)
03 The student swaps sine and cosine, using F sin θ instead of F cos θ for the normal force, leading to incorrect normal force and friction magnitudes.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
N = F \sin 40.0^ N = 14.0 \sin 40.0^ = 9.00
CorrectN = F \cos 40.0^ = 14.0 \cos 40.0^ 10.7
Because the angle is specified above the horizontal, the horizontal component adjacent to the angle is given by , not .
- Step 2
F_y = F \cos 40.0^ = 10.72 mg = (0.250)(9.80) = 2.45 = F_y - mg = 10.72 - 2.45 = 8.27
CorrectF_y = F \sin 40.0^ = 14.0 \sin 40.0^ 9.00 F_y - mg = 9.00 - 2.45 = 6.55
Your formulation for the vertical driving force is conceptually correct, but it inherits the trigonometric swap from Step 1.
- Step 3
f_{s,\max} = 0.600(9.00) = 5.40 < 8.27,_
Correctf_{s,\max} = _s N = 0.600(10.72) 6.43 < 6.55,
Your comparison logic between the driving force and maximum static friction is completely sound, and your qualitative conclusion that it slips upward is correct.
- Step 4
f_k = k N = 0.450(9.00) = 4.05\text{ N}$$\text{ downward}$$
Correctf_k = k N = 0.450(10.72) 4.83\text{ N}$$\text{ downward}$$
You correctly determined that kinetic friction opposes the upward motion by pointing downward, but the numerical magnitude is affected by the incorrect normal force.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly set up the horizontal equilibrium condition relating the normal force directly to the horizontal push.
You accurately identified that friction must be evaluated by comparing the net driving force against the maximum static friction threshold.
You correctly reasoned that kinetic friction opposes the direction of relative motion and points downward.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou used sine for the horizontal component and cosine for the vertical component, even though the angle was defined relative to the horizontal.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the adjacent and opposite sides of the right triangle when resolving a vector whose angle is given relative to the horizontal axis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Reference Axis
If an angle is measured from the horizontal axis, the horizontal component is adjacent () and the vertical component is opposite ().
Always sketch the right triangle with the vector as the hypotenuse and identify which leg lies along the coordinate axis before writing formulas.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecalculate the horizontal normal force: .
Recalculate the vertical applied force: .
Find the net upward driving force: .
Compute maximum static friction: .
Compare driving force and static friction: Since , the eraser slips upward.
Calculate kinetic friction: directed downward.
(a) ; (b) directed downward (negative -direction)
Lock it in
How do you determine whether an object at rest on a rough surface will begin to slide?
Calculate the net driving force parallel to the surface and compare it to . If , the object slips.
Similar question
A book is pressed against a vertical wall with a horizontal force of . The friction coefficients are and . Taking , does the book slide, and what is the magnitude of the frictional force?
Answer
The book remains stationary, and upward. Key steps: ; downward driving force ; . Since , static friction balances gravity: upward.
A box sits on a horizontal floor with and . A rope pulls the box at an angle of above the horizontal with a tension of . Using , determine the friction force acting on the box.
Answer
directed opposite the pull. Key steps: . Maximum static friction is . Wait: horizontal driving force , so the box slips! Therefore, kinetic friction acts: .
A block is pushed against a vertical wall by an applied force directed at above the horizontal. The coefficients are and . Using , determine the acceleration of the block and the frictional force acting on it.
Answer
downward; (or upward). Key steps: . Net vertical driving force without friction: upward. Maximum static friction is . Since , the block does NOT slide! Thus and static friction is directed downward.