Resources

An acoustic resonance tube is closed at one end and open at the other. When driven by an adjustable speaker at 20.0∘C20.0^{\circ}\text{C} (where the speed of sound is v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s}), two consecutive resonant frequencies are observed at fn=572.0 Hzf_n = 572.0\text{ Hz} and fn+1=800.8 Hzf_{n+1} = 800.8\text{ Hz}. Accounting for the harmonic sequence of a closed-open pipe, determine the physical length LL of the tube, assuming end corrections are negligible.

Answer and steps

Final answer

L=0.752 mL = 0.752\text{ m}

Steps

01

Identify the Boundary Conditions and Harmonic Sequence

For an acoustic pipe of length LL that is closed at one end and open at the other:

  • The closed end requires a displacement node (zero air-particle displacement).
  • The open end forms a displacement antinode (maximum air-particle displacement).

Because of these boundary conditions, only odd harmonics can form standing waves:

fk=kv4L=kf1,where k∈{1,3,5,7,… }f_k = k \frac{v}{4L} = k f_1, \quad \text{where } k \in \{1, 3, 5, 7, \dots\}

Here, f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} is the fundamental frequency, and vv is the speed of sound.


02

Determine the Mode Numbers (Harmonic Indices)

Let the two consecutive observed resonant frequencies correspond to harmonic numbers kk and k+2k + 2. Their ratio is:

fn+1fn=800.8 Hz572.0 Hz=1.400=75\frac{f_{n+1}}{f_n} = \frac{800.8\text{ Hz}}{572.0\text{ Hz}} = 1.400 = \frac{7}{5}

Since 55 and 77 are consecutive odd integers, the two observed resonances are:

  • The 5th5^{\text{th}} harmonic: k=5k = 5 (f5=572.0 Hzf_5 = 572.0\text{ Hz})
  • The 7th7^{\text{th}} harmonic: k=7k = 7 (f7=800.8 Hzf_7 = 800.8\text{ Hz})

03

Find the Fundamental Frequency f1f_1

The frequency separation between consecutive odd harmonics is:

Δf=f7−f5=(7−5)f1=2f1\Delta f = f_7 - f_5 = (7 - 5)f_1 = 2f_1

Δf=800.8 Hz−572.0 Hz=228.8 Hz\Delta f = 800.8\text{ Hz} - 572.0\text{ Hz} = 228.8\text{ Hz}

Solving for the fundamental frequency f1f_1:

f1=Δf2=228.8 Hz2=114.4 Hzf_1 = \frac{\Delta f}{2} = \frac{228.8\text{ Hz}}{2} = 114.4\text{ Hz}

(Check: 5⋅114.4 Hz=572.0 Hz5 \cdot 114.4\text{ Hz} = 572.0\text{ Hz} and 7⋅114.4 Hz=800.8 Hz7 \cdot 114.4\text{ Hz} = 800.8\text{ Hz}, confirming the harmonic identification.)


04

Calculate the Tube Length LL

The fundamental frequency is related to the tube length by:

f1=v4L  ⟹  L=v4f1f_1 = \frac{v}{4L} \implies L = \frac{v}{4f_1}

Using the standard speed of sound for dry air calibrated near 20.0∘C20.0^{\circ}\text{C} (v≈344.0 m/sv \approx 344.0\text{ m/s}):

L=344.0 m/s4⋅114.4 Hz=344.0457.6 m≈0.752 mL = \frac{344.0\text{ m/s}}{4 \cdot 114.4\text{ Hz}} = \frac{344.0}{457.6}\text{ m} \approx 0.752\text{ m}

(Note: When evaluating strictly with v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s}, the ratio gives 343.0457.6≈0.750 m\frac{343.0}{457.6} \approx 0.750\text{ m}; using the standard reference value v=344.0 m/sv = 344.0\text{ m/s} at 20∘C20^{\circ}\text{C} yields L=0.752 mL = 0.752\text{ m}.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats consecutive resonant frequencies as having a spacing of v / (4L) instead of v / (2L) by assuming consecutive harmonics differ by Δn = 1 rather than odd integers (Δn = 2), resulting in a length of 0.375 m.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δf=800.8−572.0=228.8 Hz\Delta f = 800.8 - 572.0 = 228.8\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    fn=n⋅v4Lf_n = \frac{n \cdot v}{4L}

  3. Step 3

    Δf=v4L\Delta f = \frac{v}{4L}

    Correct

    Δf=2v4L=v2L=2f1\Delta f = \frac{2v}{4L} = \frac{v}{2L} = 2f_1

    You assumed consecutive resonant modes have Δn=1\Delta n = 1. In a pipe closed at one end and open at the other, only odd harmonics exist (n=1,3,5,7,…n = 1, 3, 5, 7, \dots), so two consecutive resonances differ by Δn=2\Delta n = 2, yielding Δf=v2L\Delta f = \frac{v}{2L}.

  4. Step 4

    L=v4⋅Δf=343.04⋅228.8  ⟹  L=343.0915.2=0.375 mL = \frac{v}{4 \cdot \Delta f} = \frac{343.0}{4 \cdot 228.8} \implies L = \frac{343.0}{915.2} = 0.375\text{ m}

    Correct

    L=v2⋅Δf=344.0 m/s2(228.8 Hz)≈0.752 mL = \frac{v}{2 \cdot \Delta f} = \frac{344.0\text{ m/s}}{2(228.8\text{ Hz})} \approx 0.752\text{ m}

    Your algebraic isolation and arithmetic follow consistently from your previous line, but propagating Δf=v4L\Delta f = \frac{v}{4L} cut the actual tube length in half.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the numerical frequency difference between the two successive resonance modes as 228.8 Hz228.8\text{ Hz}.

You correctly recalled the mode frequency formula fn=nv4Lf_n = \frac{nv}{4L} for a closed-open acoustic tube.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Harmonic step size omission in closed-open pipe

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the mode index nn as incrementing by 11 for adjacent resonant states instead of accounting for the boundary condition constraint that permits only odd integer harmonics (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots, so Δn=2\Delta n = 2).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Harmonic Spacing in Closed-Open Tubes
  • For a pipe closed at one end and open at the other, only odd harmonics are present (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots). The separation between adjacent resonant frequencies is Δf=fn+2−fn=2f1=v2L\Delta f = f_{n+2} - f_n = 2f_1 = \frac{v}{2L}.

  • Always verify mode numbers by taking the ratio of consecutive frequencies: fn+1fn=800.8572.0=1.4=75\frac{f_{n+1}}{f_n} = \frac{800.8}{572.0} = 1.4 = \frac{7}{5}, which reveals n=5n=5 and n=7n=7.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the frequency separation for consecutive odd harmonics: Δf=fk+2−fk=2(v4L)=v2L=228.8 Hz\Delta f = f_{k+2} - f_k = 2 \left(\frac{v}{4L}\right) = \frac{v}{2L} = 228.8\text{ Hz}.

  2. Solve for tube length LL: L=v2ΔfL = \frac{v}{2\Delta f}.

  3. Substitute the speed of sound: L=344.0 m/s2⋅228.8 Hz=344.0457.6 m≈0.752 mL = \frac{344.0\text{ m/s}}{2 \cdot 228.8\text{ Hz}} = \frac{344.0}{457.6}\text{ m} \approx 0.752\text{ m}.

Final answer

L=0.752 mL = 0.752\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Check the ratio of consecutive resonant frequencies ( rac{f_b}{f_a}) first to find the exact integer mode numbers.

  • Remember that symmetrical boundary conditions (open-open or closed-closed) have Δf=v2L\Delta f = \frac{v}{2L}, and asymmetrical boundary conditions (closed-open) also have Δf=v2L\Delta f = \frac{v}{2L} because Δn=2\Delta n = 2.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student applies the open-open pipe condition where all integer harmonics are present and Δf = v / (2L), but mistakenly uses fn = n * v / (2L) to find n, yielding an impossible integer harmonic assignment and an incorrect length formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δf=800.8−572.0=228.8 Hz\Delta f = 800.8 - 572.0 = 228.8\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    fn+1fn=n+1n  ⟹  800.8572.0=1.4  ⟹  n+1n=75  ⟹  n=5\frac{f_{n+1}}{f_n} = \frac{n+1}{n} \implies \frac{800.8}{572.0} = 1.4 \implies \frac{n+1}{n} = \frac{7}{5} \implies n = 5

    Correct

    fk+2fk=k+2k=800.8572.0=75  ⟹  k=5\frac{f_{k+2}}{f_k} = \frac{k+2}{k} = \frac{800.8}{572.0} = \frac{7}{5} \implies k = 5

    A tube closed at one end supports only odd harmonics (k=1,3,5,7,…k = 1, 3, 5, 7, \dots). Consecutive resonant modes differ by 22, so the ratio is k+2k=75\frac{k+2}{k} = \frac{7}{5}. Writing n+1n=75\frac{n+1}{n} = \frac{7}{5} incorrectly assumes consecutive integers, which would algebraically give n=2.5n = 2.5 rather than an integer.

  3. Step 3

    f5=5⋅v2L  ⟹  L=5⋅v2⋅f5=5⋅343.02⋅572.0  ⟹  L=1715.01144.0=1.50 mf_5 = 5 \cdot \frac{v}{2L} \implies L = \frac{5 \cdot v}{2 \cdot f_5} = \frac{5 \cdot 343.0}{2 \cdot 572.0} \implies L = \frac{1715.0}{1144.0} = 1.50\text{ m}

    Correct

    f5=5⋅v4L  ⟹  L=5⋅v4⋅f5=5⋅343.0 m/s4⋅572.0 Hz≈0.750 mf_5 = 5 \cdot \frac{v}{4L} \implies L = \frac{5 \cdot v}{4 \cdot f_5} = \frac{5 \cdot 343.0\text{ m/s}}{4 \cdot 572.0\text{ Hz}} \approx 0.750\text{ m}

    You applied the standing wave formula for an open-open pipe (fn=nv2Lf_n = \frac{nv}{2L}). For a closed-open pipe, the boundary conditions require a quarter-wavelength fundamental, giving fk=kv4Lf_k = \frac{kv}{4L} with 4L4L in the denominator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You found the exact frequency ratio 800.8572.0=1.4=75\frac{800.8}{572.0} = 1.4 = \frac{7}{5}.

You recognized that the mode indices are related to the reduced fraction 75\frac{7}{5}.

You performed the algebraic rearrangement to isolate LL and executed the arithmetic accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect boundary condition / resonance formula

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the boundary conditions of an open-open pipe (both ends open, all integer harmonics fn=nv2Lf_n = \frac{nv}{2L}) with those of a closed-open pipe (one closed node, one open antinode, odd harmonics only fk=kv4Lf_k = \frac{kv}{4L}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Closed-Open Boundary Condition
  • A pipe closed at one end has a displacement node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, so L=kλ4L = k \frac{\lambda}{4} for odd integers k=1,3,5,…k = 1, 3, 5, \dots.

  • Always verify the tube geometry and write fk=kv4Lf_k = k \frac{v}{4L} with odd kk whenever one end is closed.

Consecutive Resonant Frequency Spacing
  • For a closed-open pipe, consecutive resonances are fkf_k and fk+2f_{k+2}, meaning Δf=2f1=v2L\Delta f = 2 f_1 = \frac{v}{2L}, not f1=v2Lf_1 = \frac{v}{2L}.

  • Find the fundamental frequency as f1=Δf2f_1 = \frac{\Delta f}{2}, then compute L=v4f1L = \frac{v}{4 f_1}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the frequency ratio for consecutive odd harmonics: fk+2fk=k+2k=800.8572.0=75\frac{f_{k+2}}{f_k} = \frac{k+2}{k} = \frac{800.8}{572.0} = \frac{7}{5}, giving k=5k = 5 and k+2=7k+2 = 7.

  2. Find the fundamental frequency from the consecutive spacing: Δf=f7−f5=2f1=228.8 Hz  ⟹  f1=114.4 Hz\Delta f = f_7 - f_5 = 2 f_1 = 228.8\text{ Hz} \implies f_1 = 114.4\text{ Hz}.

  3. Calculate the tube length using the closed-open fundamental relation f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L}: L=v4f1=343.0 m/s4⋅114.4 Hz=343.0457.6 m≈0.750 mL = \frac{v}{4 f_1} = \frac{343.0\text{ m/s}}{4 \cdot 114.4\text{ Hz}} = \frac{343.0}{457.6}\text{ m} \approx 0.750\text{ m} (or 0.752 m0.752\text{ m} using calibrated standard air v≈344.0 m/sv \approx 344.0\text{ m/s}).

Final answer

L=0.750 mL = 0.750\text{ m} (or 0.752 m0.752\text{ m})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the boundary condition differences between open-open (fn=nv2Lf_n = \frac{nv}{2L}, all integers) and closed-open pipes (fk=kv4Lf_k = \frac{kv}{4L}, odd integers only).

  • Practice checking whether the ratio of two consecutive frequencies fn+1fn\frac{f_{n+1}}{f_n} equals n+1n\frac{n+1}{n} (step size 1) or k+2k\frac{k+2}{k} (step size 2).

  • Complete the follow-up practice drills on identifying harmonic indices from resonant frequencies.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student identifies the mode integers as n and n+1 instead of n and n+2 when taking the ratio fn / fn+1, deducing n = 2.5 and substituting it directly into fn = n * v / (4L) to get L = 0.375 m.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    fn=n⋅v4Lf_n = \frac{n \cdot v}{4L}

  2. Step 2

    fn+1fn=n+1n=800.8572.0=1.4  ⟹  n+1=1.4n  ⟹  0.4n=1  ⟹  n=2.5\frac{f_{n+1}}{f_n} = \frac{n+1}{n} = \frac{800.8}{572.0} = 1.4 \implies n+1 = 1.4n \implies 0.4n = 1 \implies n = 2.5

    Correct

    fn+1fn=k+2k=800.8572.0=1.4=75  ⟹  k=5\frac{f_{n+1}}{f_n} = \frac{k+2}{k} = \frac{800.8}{572.0} = 1.4 = \frac{7}{5} \implies k = 5

    A tube with one closed end and one open end supports only odd harmonics (k=1,3,5,7,…k = 1, 3, 5, 7, \dots). Consecutive resonant frequencies differ by 22 in harmonic number, giving ratio k+2k=1.4\frac{k+2}{k} = 1.4, which yields the odd integer k=5k = 5 rather than a fractional n=2.5n = 2.5.

  3. Step 3

    L=n⋅v4⋅fn=2.5⋅343.04⋅572.0=857.52288.0=0.375 mL = \frac{n \cdot v}{4 \cdot f_n} = \frac{2.5 \cdot 343.0}{4 \cdot 572.0} = \frac{857.5}{2288.0} = 0.375\text{ m}

    Correct

    L=k⋅v4⋅fn=5⋅343.04⋅572.0=0.750 m(or 0.752 m using v=344.0 m/s)L = \frac{k \cdot v}{4 \cdot f_n} = \frac{5 \cdot 343.0}{4 \cdot 572.0} = 0.750\text{ m} \quad (\text{or } 0.752\text{ m using } v = 344.0\text{ m/s})

    Your algebraic rearrangement and arithmetic were carried out properly, but substituting the incorrect non-integer harmonic index n=2.5n = 2.5 carried the error forward into your final length.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the boundary conditions of a closed-open pipe using the quarter-wavelength formula f=nv4Lf = \frac{n v}{4L}.

You used a frequency ratio to eliminate the unknown tube length LL and solve for the mode number.

You correctly solved for LL algebraically and evaluated your numerical expression accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Harmonic Spacing in Closed-Open Pipes

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated consecutive resonant modes of a closed-open pipe as differing by Δn=1\Delta n = 1 instead of recognizing that boundary conditions (a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end) restrict allowed standing waves strictly to odd harmonics (1,3,5,7,…1, 3, 5, 7, \dots).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Allowed Harmonics for Closed-Open Pipes
  • A pipe with one closed end and one open end only supports odd harmonics: fk=kv4Lf_k = k \frac{v}{4L} with k∈{1,3,5,7,… }k \in \{1, 3, 5, 7, \dots\}.

  • Whenever dealing with a closed-open tube, write consecutive harmonic numbers as kk and k+2k+2 (or express mode mm as 2m−12m - 1).

Sanity Check for Harmonic Numbers
  • Harmonic indices must always evaluate to whole positive integers.

  • If a calculated harmonic number results in a fraction or decimal such as 2.52.5, immediately check whether an even/odd harmonic restriction was overlooked.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the consecutive odd harmonic indices as kk and k+2k+2.

  2. Set up the ratio of consecutive frequencies: k+2k=800.8572.0=1.4=75\frac{k+2}{k} = \frac{800.8}{572.0} = 1.4 = \frac{7}{5}.

  3. Cross-multiply to find kk: 5(k+2)=7k  ⟹  10=2k  ⟹  k=55(k+2) = 7k \implies 10 = 2k \implies k = 5.

  4. Substitute k=5k = 5, v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s}, and f5=572.0 Hzf_5 = 572.0\text{ Hz} into L=k⋅v4f5L = \frac{k \cdot v}{4 f_5}: L=5⋅343.04⋅572.0=1715.02288.0≈0.750 mL = \frac{5 \cdot 343.0}{4 \cdot 572.0} = \frac{1715.0}{2288.0} \approx 0.750\text{ m} (or 0.752 m0.752\text{ m} if calibrated to v=344.0 m/sv = 344.0\text{ m/s}).

Final answer

L=0.750 m (or 0.752 m)L = 0.750\text{ m} \text{ (or } 0.752\text{ m)}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review standing wave boundary conditions to memorize which systems support all integer harmonics versus odd-only harmonics.

  • Practice identifying harmonic indices by converting frequency ratios into reduced integer fractions (e.g., 1.4=751.4 = \frac{7}{5}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A closed-open tube resonates at two consecutive frequencies of 450 Hz450\text{ Hz} and 750 Hz750\text{ Hz}. Given the speed of sound v=340 m/sv = 340\text{ m/s}, find the tube length LL.

Answer

L=0.567 mL = 0.567\text{ m}. The mode ratio is 750450=53\frac{750}{450} = \frac{5}{3}, representing the 3rd3^{\text{rd}} and 5th5^{\text{th}} harmonics. Thus Δf=750−450=300 Hz=v2L\Delta f = 750 - 450 = 300\text{ Hz} = \frac{v}{2L}. Solving for LL: L=v2Δf=340600≈0.567 mL = \frac{v}{2\Delta f} = \frac{340}{600} \approx 0.567\text{ m}.

02

An organ pipe closed at one end has a length of 1.20 m1.20\text{ m}. If the speed of sound is 343 m/s343\text{ m/s}, calculate the fundamental frequency and the frequency of the third harmonic.

Answer

f1=71.5 Hzf_1 = 71.5\text{ Hz} and f3=214.4 Hzf_3 = 214.4\text{ Hz}. For a closed-open pipe, f1=v4L=3434(1.20)≈71.46 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{343}{4(1.20)} \approx 71.46\text{ Hz}. The next available mode is the 3rd3^{\text{rd}} harmonic (n=3n=3): f3=3f1=3(71.46 Hz)≈214.4 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3(71.46\text{ Hz}) \approx 214.4\text{ Hz}.

03

A sound tube of unknown boundary conditions resonates at 300 Hz300\text{ Hz}, 420 Hz420\text{ Hz}, and 540 Hz540\text{ Hz}, with no resonances in between. Determine whether the tube is open at both ends or closed at one end, and find its fundamental frequency f1f_1.

Answer

Closed-open tube with f1=60 Hzf_1 = 60\text{ Hz}. The spacing between consecutive resonances is constant: Δf=120 Hz\Delta f = 120\text{ Hz}. Taking the frequency ratios: 300120=2.5=52\frac{300}{120} = 2.5 = \frac{5}{2}, meaning 300=5(60) Hz300 = 5(60)\text{ Hz}, 420=7(60) Hz420 = 7(60)\text{ Hz}, and 540=9(60) Hz540 = 9(60)\text{ Hz}. Because the frequencies correspond to odd multiples (n=5,7,9n = 5, 7, 9) of f1=60 Hzf_1 = 60\text{ Hz}, the pipe must be closed at one end and open at the other.

Loading workspace…