Resources

In a university physics laboratory, students determine the center of mass of an irregularly shaped wooden baseball bat of mass M=0.850 kgM = 0.850\text{ kg} and total length L=84.0 cmL = 84.0\text{ cm}. The bat is supported horizontally across two digital laboratory balances placed under its ends: scale A is positioned at the handle end (x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm}) and scale B is positioned at the barrel end (x=84.0 cmx = 84.0\text{ cm}). When the bat rests horizontally at equilibrium, scale A reads a normal force of FA=3.15 NF_A = 3.15\text{ N}, and scale B reads FB=5.18 NF_B = 5.18\text{ N} (taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2). Using rotational and static equilibrium principles, determine the distance xcmx_{\text{cm}} of the center of gravity/mass from the handle end (x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm}).

Answer and steps

Final answer

xcm=52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 52.2\text{ cm}

Steps

01

Identify all forces acting on the bat

Principle of Static Equilibrium

For a rigid body to remain in static equilibrium, two conditions must be satisfied simultaneously:

  1. Translational equilibrium: The net external force acting on the body must be zero: ∑F⃗=0\sum \vec{F} = 0
  2. Rotational equilibrium: The net external torque calculated about any chosen pivot point must be zero: ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0

The horizontal bat is acted upon by three vertical forces:

  • Upward normal force from scale A at the handle end (x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm}): FA=3.15 NF_A = 3.15\text{ N}
  • Upward normal force from scale B at the barrel end (x=L=84.0 cmx = L = 84.0\text{ cm}): FB=5.18 NF_B = 5.18\text{ N}
  • Downward gravitational force (weight WW) acting at the center of mass xcmx_{\text{cm}}: W=Mg=(0.850 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=8.33 NW = M g = (0.850\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 8.33\text{ N}

Checking translational equilibrium in the vertical direction: ∑Fy=FA+FB−W=3.15 N+5.18 N−8.33 N=0 N\sum F_y = F_A + F_B - W = 3.15\text{ N} + 5.18\text{ N} - 8.33\text{ N} = 0\text{ N} This confirms the vertical forces are balanced.


02

Set up the torque equation about the handle end

Choose the pivot point at the handle end (x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm}). This choice is convenient because the lever arm of FAF_A is zero, eliminating FAF_A from the torque equation:

  • Torque due to FAF_A: τA=FA⋅0=0\tau_A = F_A \cdot 0 = 0
  • Torque due to gravity WW (clockwise, acting at xcmx_{\text{cm}}): τW=−W⋅xcm\tau_W = -W \cdot x_{\text{cm}}
  • Torque due to FBF_B (counterclockwise, acting at L=84.0 cmL = 84.0\text{ cm}): τB=+FB⋅L\tau_B = +F_B \cdot L

Setting the sum of torques to zero: ∑τ(x=0)=FB⋅L−W⋅xcm=0\sum \tau_{(x=0)} = F_B \cdot L - W \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0


03

Solve for the center of mass position xcmx_{\text{cm}}

Rearranging the torque equation gives: xcm=FB⋅LWx_{\text{cm}} = \frac{F_B \cdot L}{W}

Substitute the known values: xcm=(5.18 N)(84.0 cm)8.33 N≈52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = \frac{(5.18\text{ N})(84.0\text{ cm})}{8.33\text{ N}} \approx 52.2\text{ cm}

Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is using FAF_A instead of FBF_B in the numerator, or taking the pivot at the midpoint (L/2L/2). Because the baseball bat is thicker at the barrel end, the center of mass is shifted toward the heavier end (xcm>42.0 cmx_{\text{cm}} > 42.0\text{ cm}), which aligns with the larger upward force measured at scale B (5.18 N>3.15 N5.18\text{ N} > 3.15\text{ N}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student associates scale A with the distance from scale A, incorrectly multiplying F_A by the total length L when calculating the torque about the handle.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ∑τ=0 about x=0  ⟹  FA⋅L−Mg⋅xcm=0\sum \tau = 0 \text{ about } x=0 \implies F_A \cdot L - M g \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0

    Correct

    ∑τ(x=0)=FB⋅L−Mg⋅xcm=0\sum \tau_{(x=0)} = F_B \cdot L - M g \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0

    At the pivot x=0x = 0, the upward force FAF_A acts at a distance of 00, so its torque is zero. The upward force acting at the far end x=Lx = L is FBF_B, not FAF_A.

  2. Step 2

    3.15⋅84.0−8.33⋅xcm=0  ⟹  264.6−8.33⋅xcm=03.15 \cdot 84.0 - 8.33 \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0 \implies 264.6 - 8.33 \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0

    Correct

    5.18⋅84.0−8.33⋅xcm=0  ⟹  435.12−8.33⋅xcm=05.18 \cdot 84.0 - 8.33 \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0 \implies 435.12 - 8.33 \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0

    Your arithmetic was carried out accurately, but it inherited the incorrect force value FA=3.15 NF_A = 3.15\text{ N} instead of FB=5.18 NF_B = 5.18\text{ N}.

  3. Step 3

    xcm=31.8 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 31.8\text{ cm}

    Correct

    xcm=52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 52.2\text{ cm}

    This result follows from your earlier substitution error. Notice also that because scale B supports more weight than scale A (5.18 N>3.15 N5.18\text{ N} > 3.15\text{ N}), the center of mass must lie closer to scale B, meaning xcm>42.0 cmx_{\text{cm}} > 42.0\text{ cm}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the system is in rotational equilibrium (∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0).

You strategically selected a convenient pivot point at x=0x = 0 to simplify the torque equation.

You correctly computed the total weight of the bat as W=Mg=8.33 NW = M g = 8.33\text{ N}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wrong Lever Arm / Force Pairing

You accidentally swapped the two balance readings, pairing force FAF_A with distance LL instead of FBF_B.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Failing to explicitly match each force to its specific spatial coordinate relative to the chosen pivot. When taking torques about x=0x = 0, the force at x=0x = 0 (FAF_A) has lever arm r=0r = 0, whereas the force at x=Lx = L (FBF_B) has lever arm r=Lr = L.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Force to Position
  • Torque is τ=F⋅r⊥\tau = F \cdot r_{\perp}, where rr is the vector distance from the pivot to the line of action of that specific force.

  • Always write down the coordinate of each force explicitly before forming each torque term: τA=FA(0)=0\tau_A = F_A(0) = 0 and τB=FB(L)\tau_B = F_B(L).

Sanity Check with Normal Forces
  • The support bearing a larger share of the weight is closer to the center of gravity.

  • Check your answer: since FB=5.18 N>FA=3.15 NF_B = 5.18\text{ N} > F_A = 3.15\text{ N}, the center of mass must be closer to end B (xcm>L/2=42.0 cmx_{\text{cm}} > L/2 = 42.0\text{ cm}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the torque equation about the pivot at the handle (x=0x = 0): ∑τ(x=0)=FB⋅L−Mg⋅xcm=0\sum \tau_{(x=0)} = F_B \cdot L - M g \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0.

  2. Substitute the force at the barrel end (FB=5.18 NF_B = 5.18\text{ N}), the length (L=84.0 cmL = 84.0\text{ cm}), and the weight (Mg=8.33 NM g = 8.33\text{ N}): (5.18)(84.0)−(8.33)xcm=0(5.18)(84.0) - (8.33)x_{\text{cm}} = 0.

  3. Solve for xcmx_{\text{cm}}: xcm=435.128.33≈52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = \frac{435.12}{8.33} \approx 52.2\text{ cm}.

Final answer

xcm=52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 52.2\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Re-solve the same problem by taking torques about the other end (x=Lx = L) to verify that you reach the same position.

  • Practice drawing an annotated free-body diagram showing pivot location and position vectors before writing algebraic torque terms.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses force with mass and divides the torque directly by the bat's mass in kilograms without multiplying by g, resulting in inconsistent units and an erroneous value.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ∑τ=0 about x=0  ⟹  FB⋅L−M⋅xcm=0\sum \tau = 0 \text{ about } x = 0 \implies F_B \cdot L - M \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0

    Correct

    ∑τ=0  ⟹  FB⋅L−Mg⋅xcm=0\sum \tau = 0 \implies F_B \cdot L - Mg \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0

    Torque is defined as force multiplied by lever arm (τ=F⋅d\tau = F \cdot d). The downward force acting at the center of mass is the bat's weight W=MgW = Mg, not its scalar mass MM.

  2. Step 2

    5.18⋅84.0−0.850⋅xcm=0  ⟹  435.12−0.850⋅xcm=0  ⟹  xcm=511.9 cm5.18 \cdot 84.0 - 0.850 \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0 \implies 435.12 - 0.850 \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0 \implies x_{\text{cm}} = 511.9\text{ cm}

    Correct

    5.18⋅84.0−(0.850⋅9.80)⋅xcm=0  ⟹  xcm=435.128.33≈52.2 cm5.18 \cdot 84.0 - (0.850 \cdot 9.80) \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0 \implies x_{\text{cm}} = \frac{435.12}{8.33} \approx 52.2\text{ cm}

    Your algebra was carried out correctly based on your equation, but omitting g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 scaled down the denominator by nearly a factor of ten, producing an answer of 511.9 cm511.9\text{ cm} for an 84.0 cm84.0\text{ cm} bat.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the condition for rotational equilibrium ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0.

You strategically placed the pivot at x=0x = 0 to eliminate the unknown normal force FAF_A from your torque sum.

You correctly identified the lever arm for the barrel scale as the full length LL.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass vs. Weight Confusion

You used the mass M=0.850 kgM = 0.850\text{ kg} directly as a force term in the torque equation without multiplying by the gravitational acceleration gg.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated mass as a force in rotational equilibrium. Torques require quantities with units of force (N\text{N}), so gravitational torque must use weight W=MgW = Mg rather than mass MM.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Unit Homogeneity
  • Every term in a torque equation must have units of N⋅m\text{N}\cdot\text{m} (or N⋅cm\text{N}\cdot\text{cm}).

  • Verify that terms involving mass are converted to weight via W=MgW = Mg before computing torque.

Perform a Physical Bounds Check
  • The center of mass of a rigid object must lie within its geometric boundaries.

  • Check whether your calculated xcmx_{\text{cm}} satisfies 0<xcm<L0 < x_{\text{cm}} < L.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the downward gravitational force as W=Mg=(0.850 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=8.33 NW = Mg = (0.850\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 8.33\text{ N}.

  2. Set the net torque about x=0x = 0 to zero: FB⋅L−W⋅xcm=0F_B \cdot L - W \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0.

  3. Solve for the center of mass: xcm=FB⋅LW=(5.18 N)(84.0 cm)8.33 Nx_{\text{cm}} = \frac{F_B \cdot L}{W} = \frac{(5.18\text{ N})(84.0\text{ cm})}{8.33\text{ N}}.

  4. Calculate the final value: xcm≈52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} \approx 52.2\text{ cm}.

Final answer

xcm=52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 52.2\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between mass (kg\text{kg}) and weight (N\text{N}) when constructing free-body diagrams and torque sums.

  • Always check whether your final answer falls inside the physical length of the object (0 cm≤xcm≤84.0 cm0\text{ cm} \le x_{\text{cm}} \le 84.0\text{ cm}) as a sanity check.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the distance of the center of mass from the barrel end (scale B) using x_cm = (F_A · L) / (M g) and fails to convert it to the required distance from the handle end.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ∑τ=0 about scale B  ⟹  −FA⋅L+Mg⋅d=0\sum \tau = 0 \text{ about scale B} \implies -F_A \cdot L + Mg \cdot d = 0

  2. Step 2

    d=FA⋅LMg  ⟹  d=3.15⋅84.08.33≈31.8 cmd = \frac{F_A \cdot L}{Mg} \implies d = \frac{3.15 \cdot 84.0}{8.33} \approx 31.8\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    xcm=31.8 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 31.8\text{ cm}

    Correct

    xcm=L−d=84.0 cm−31.8 cm=52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = L - d = 84.0\text{ cm} - 31.8\text{ cm} = 52.2\text{ cm}

    Because your pivot was at scale B (x=84.0 cmx = 84.0\text{ cm}), the lever arm dd is the distance from the barrel end. To find the coordinate measured from the handle end (x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm}), you must subtract dd from the total length LL.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the condition for rotational equilibrium (∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0).

You accurately calculated the total weight Mg=8.33 NMg = 8.33\text{ N} and the lever arm from your chosen pivot.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reference frame / pivot coordinate confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You forgot that a torque lever arm is measured relative to your chosen pivot point (scale B at x=84.0 cmx = 84.0\text{ cm}), rather than the coordinate origin at the handle (x=0 cmx = 0\text{ cm}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Track lever-arm reference points
  • In τ=F⋅r\tau = F \cdot r, the lever arm rr is always measured from the chosen pivot, not necessarily from x=0x = 0.

  • Explicitly label your distance variable with its reference point (e.g., dfrom Bd_{\text{from B}}), then use xcm=L−dfrom Bx_{\text{cm}} = L - d_{\text{from B}} to translate back to the required coordinate origin.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. d=31.8 cmd = 31.8\text{ cm} is measured from scale B (x=84.0 cmx = 84.0\text{ cm}).

  2. Convert to the coordinate measured from the handle end: xcm=L−d=84.0 cm−31.76 cm=52.24 cmx_{\text{cm}} = L - d = 84.0\text{ cm} - 31.76\text{ cm} = 52.24\text{ cm}.

Final answer

xcm=52.2 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 52.2\text{ cm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always draw an arrow indicating where your torque distance variable is measured from relative to the chosen pivot.

  • Perform a quick physical sanity check: scale B supports more force (5.18 N>3.15 N5.18\text{ N} > 3.15\text{ N}), so the center of mass must lie closer to the barrel end (xcm>42.0 cmx_{\text{cm}} > 42.0\text{ cm}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A uniform plank of length L=2.0 mL = 2.0\text{ m} and mass 10 kg10\text{ kg} rests horizontally on two supports, one at each end (AA at x=0x = 0, BB at x=2.0 mx = 2.0\text{ m}). A 30 kg30\text{ kg} box is placed on the plank at x=1.5 mx = 1.5\text{ m}. Taking g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\text{ m/s}^2, find the upward normal force exerted by support B.

Answer

FB=270 NF_B = 270\text{ N} (or 269.5 N269.5\text{ N}). Key steps: Choose pivot at support A (x=0x = 0). The torque equation is ∑τA=FB(2.0)−Wplank(1.0)−Wbox(1.5)=0\sum \tau_A = F_B(2.0) - W_{\text{plank}}(1.0) - W_{\text{box}}(1.5) = 0. Substitute Wplank=98 NW_{\text{plank}} = 98\text{ N} and Wbox=294 NW_{\text{box}} = 294\text{ N}: 2.0FB=98(1.0)+294(1.5)=98+441=539 N⋅m2.0 F_B = 98(1.0) + 294(1.5) = 98 + 441 = 539\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}, yielding FB=269.5 NF_B = 269.5\text{ N}.

02

An irregularly shaped metal rod of length L=60.0 cmL = 60.0\text{ cm} is supported horizontally by two force sensors at its ends: sensor 1 is at x=0x = 0 and reads 4.0 N4.0\text{ N}; sensor 2 is at x=60.0 cmx = 60.0\text{ cm} and reads 12.0 N12.0\text{ N}. Determine the distance xcmx_{\text{cm}} of the rod's center of mass from sensor 1.

Answer

xcm=45.0 cmx_{\text{cm}} = 45.0\text{ cm}. Key steps: Total weight is W=F1+F2=4.0+12.0=16.0 NW = F_1 + F_2 = 4.0 + 12.0 = 16.0\text{ N}. Summing torques about x=0x = 0: F2⋅L−W⋅xcm=0F_2 \cdot L - W \cdot x_{\text{cm}} = 0. Thus xcm=F2⋅LW=(12.0 N)(60.0 cm)16.0 N=45.0 cmx_{\text{cm}} = \frac{F_2 \cdot L}{W} = \frac{(12.0\text{ N})(60.0\text{ cm})}{16.0\text{ N}} = 45.0\text{ cm}.

03

A tapered wooden beam of length 3.00 m3.00\text{ m} has its center of mass located at x=1.80 mx = 1.80\text{ m} from its thin end. The beam is supported by two vertical cables: one at the thin end (x=0x = 0) and one placed at a variable position x=dx = d along the beam. If the cable at the thin end can support a maximum tension of only 25%25\% of the beam's total weight WW, what is the minimum value of dd to maintain static equilibrium?

Answer

d=2.40 md = 2.40\text{ m}. Key steps: Let the tension at the thin end be T1≤0.25WT_1 \le 0.25 W, and the tension in the second cable be T2T_2 at distance dd. Sum torques about the second cable (x=dx = d): T1⋅d−W(d−1.80)=0  ⟹  d(W−T1)=1.80WT_1 \cdot d - W(d - 1.80) = 0 \implies d(W - T_1) = 1.80 W. For minimum dd, maximize T1=0.25WT_1 = 0.25 W: d(0.75W)=1.80W  ⟹  d=1.800.75=2.40 md(0.75 W) = 1.80 W \implies d = \frac{1.80}{0.75} = 2.40\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…