Resources

A student examines the discrete emission spectrum of atomic hydrogen and notices that as the principal quantum number nn increases, the energy levels become increasingly crowded together. (a) Calculate the energy difference ΔE2→1=E2−E1\Delta E_{2 \to 1} = E_2 - E_1 and ΔE6→5=E6−E5\Delta E_{6 \to 5} = E_6 - E_5 in eV\text{eV} (with En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{n^2}) to demonstrate that adjacent energy gaps shrink drastically at higher quantum levels. (b) A common misconception claims that the highest-energy photon emitted in the Balmer series (nf=2n_f = 2) must come from the jump between n=3n = 3 and n=2n = 2 because those adjacent states are lowest in energy. Refute this claim by calculating the wavelength λ3→2\lambda_{3 \to 2} versus the series limit wavelength λ∞→2\lambda_{\infty \to 2} in nm\text{nm}, identifying which transition produces the shortest wavelength (highest photon energy).

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ΔE2→1=10.20 eV\Delta E_{2 \to 1} = 10.20 \text{ eV} and ΔE6→5=0.151 eV\Delta E_{6 \to 5} = 0.151 \text{ eV}; (b) λ3→2=656.3 nm\lambda_{3 \to 2} = 656.3 \text{ nm} and λ∞→2=364.6 nm\lambda_{\infty \to 2} = 364.6 \text{ nm}; the highest-energy photon corresponds to the transition from n=∞→2n = \infty \to 2 (3.40 eV3.40 \text{ eV}, λ=364.6 nm\lambda = 364.6 \text{ nm}), not n=3→2n = 3 \to 2 (1.89 eV1.89 \text{ eV}, λ=656.3 nm\lambda = 656.3 \text{ nm}).

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Adjacent Energy Gaps

The energy of the nn-th level in atomic hydrogen is given by the Bohr formula: En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{n^2}

  1. Calculate the transition energy ΔE2→1\Delta E_{2 \to 1}: The energy levels are: E1=−13.60 eV12=−13.60 eVE_1 = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{1^2} = -13.60 \text{ eV} E2=−13.60 eV22=−3.40 eVE_2 = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{2^2} = -3.40 \text{ eV}

    The energy difference is: ΔE2→1=E2−E1=−3.40 eV−(−13.60 eV)=10.20 eV\Delta E_{2 \to 1} = E_2 - E_1 = -3.40 \text{ eV} - (-13.60 \text{ eV}) = 10.20 \text{ eV}

  2. Calculate the transition energy ΔE6→5\Delta E_{6 \to 5}: The energy levels are: E5=−13.60 eV52=−0.544 eVE_5 = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{5^2} = -0.544 \text{ eV} E6=−13.60 eV62≈−0.378 eVE_6 = -\frac{13.60 \text{ eV}}{6^2} \approx -0.378 \text{ eV}

    Evaluating the energy difference between these higher adjacent levels yields: ΔE6→5=E6−E5≈0.151 eV\Delta E_{6 \to 5} = E_6 - E_5 \approx 0.151 \text{ eV}

Comparing ΔE2→1=10.20 eV\Delta E_{2 \to 1} = 10.20 \text{ eV} with ΔE6→5=0.151 eV\Delta E_{6 \to 5} = 0.151 \text{ eV} demonstrates that adjacent energy level separations decrease dramatically as the principal quantum number nn grows, leading to severe spectral line crowding near the ionization threshold.


Part (b): Refuting the Misconception for the Balmer Series

A photon's energy ΔE\Delta E and wavelength λ\lambda are inversely related via the Planck-Einstein relation: ΔE=hcλ  ⟹  λ=hcΔE\Delta E = \frac{hc}{\lambda} \implies \lambda = \frac{hc}{\Delta E} where hc≈1239.8 eV⋅nmhc \approx 1239.8 \text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}. A larger transition energy corresponds to a shorter emitted wavelength.

  1. Transition from n=3n = 3 to n=2n = 2: ΔE3→2=E3−E2=13.60(122−132) eV=13.60(536) eV≈1.89 eV\Delta E_{3 \to 2} = E_3 - E_2 = 13.60 \left(\frac{1}{2^2} - \frac{1}{3^2}\right) \text{ eV} = 13.60 \left(\frac{5}{36}\right) \text{ eV} \approx 1.89 \text{ eV} λ3→2=1239.8 eV⋅nm1.889 eV≈656.3 nm\lambda_{3 \to 2} = \frac{1239.8 \text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{1.889 \text{ eV}} \approx 656.3 \text{ nm}
  2. Series Limit Transition from n=∞n = \infty to n=2n = 2: ΔE∞→2=E∞−E2=0 eV−(−3.40 eV)=3.40 eV\Delta E_{\infty \to 2} = E_\infty - E_2 = 0 \text{ eV} - (-3.40 \text{ eV}) = 3.40 \text{ eV} λ∞→2=1239.8 eV⋅nm3.40 eV≈364.6 nm\lambda_{\infty \to 2} = \frac{1239.8 \text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{3.40 \text{ eV}} \approx 364.6 \text{ nm}

Conclusion:
The misconception confuses the absolute values of the energy levels with the energy difference of the jump. Although n=3n = 3 and n=2n = 2 are among the lowest-lying states in the Balmer series, their difference (ΔE=1.89 eV\Delta E = 1.89 \text{ eV}) is the smallest jump in the series, producing the longest wavelength (λ=656.3 nm\lambda = 656.3 \text{ nm}, red visible light).

The transition from the ionization threshold n=∞→2n = \infty \to 2 represents the maximum possible energy drop (ΔE=3.40 eV\Delta E = 3.40 \text{ eV}), emitting the photon with the highest energy and shortest wavelength (λ=364.6 nm\lambda = 364.6 \text{ nm}, near-ultraviolet).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses photon energy with wavelength, incorrectly concluding that the transition with the larger wavelength has the highest energy.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=−13.60 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV}, E2=−3.40 eV  ⟹  ΔE(2→1)=−3.40−(−13.60)=10.20 eVE_2 = -3.40\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E(2\to 1) = -3.40 - (-13.60) = 10.20\text{ eV} and E5=−0.544 eVE_5 = -0.544\text{ eV}, E6=−0.378 eV  ⟹  ΔE(6→5)=−0.378−(−0.544)=0.166 eVE_6 = -0.378\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E(6\to 5) = -0.378 - (-0.544) = 0.166\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    ΔE(3→2)=−1.51 eV−(−3.40 eV)=1.89 eV  ⟹  λ(3→2)=12401.89=656 nm\Delta E(3\to 2) = -1.51\text{ eV} - (-3.40\text{ eV}) = 1.89\text{ eV} \implies \lambda(3\to 2) = \frac{1240}{1.89} = 656\text{ nm} and ΔE(∞→2)=0−(−3.40 eV)=3.40 eV  ⟹  λ(∞→2)=12403.40=365 nm\Delta E(\infty\to 2) = 0 - (-3.40\text{ eV}) = 3.40\text{ eV} \implies \lambda(\infty\to 2) = \frac{1240}{3.40} = 365\text{ nm}

  3. Step 3

    "Since 656 nm>365 nm656\text{ nm} > 365\text{ nm}, the 3→23\to 2 transition has the highest energy photon."

    Correct

    Since E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}, photon energy is inversely proportional to wavelength. The shorter wavelength (365 nm365\text{ nm}) corresponds to the higher photon energy (3.40 eV>1.89 eV3.40\text{ eV} > 1.89\text{ eV}), so the ∞→2\infty \to 2 transition produces the highest-energy photon.

    Photon energy and wavelength are inversely related (E∝1λE \propto \frac{1}{\lambda}). A larger wavelength corresponds to a smaller photon energy, not a higher one.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately calculated the individual energy levels and the transition energies for both parts.

You correctly used the Planck relation λ=hcΔE\lambda = \frac{hc}{\Delta E} to compute the emission wavelengths.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse relation confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated photon energy as directly proportional to wavelength rather than recognizing their inverse relationship (E=hc/λE = hc/\lambda).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Energy-Wavelength Relationship
  • E=hcλ=hνE = \frac{hc}{\lambda} = h\nu

  • Always recall that higher energy photons have higher frequencies but shorter wavelengths.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. From your previous work, ΔE3→2=1.89 eV\Delta E_{3\to 2} = 1.89\text{ eV} with λ=656 nm\lambda = 656\text{ nm}, and ΔE∞→2=3.40 eV\Delta E_{\infty\to 2} = 3.40\text{ eV} with λ=365 nm\lambda = 365\text{ nm}.

  2. Compare the photon energies directly: 3.40 eV>1.89 eV3.40\text{ eV} > 1.89\text{ eV}.

  3. By E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}, the transition with the greatest energy drop produces the photon with the shortest wavelength.

Final answer

The transition from n=∞→2n = \infty \to 2 produces the highest-energy photon (3.40 eV3.40\text{ eV}), corresponding to the shortest wavelength (365 nm365\text{ nm}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check relationships between wave properties before drawing conclusions: energy scales directly with frequency (E∝νE \propto \nu) and inversely with wavelength (E∝1/λE \propto 1/\lambda).

  • Verify your answer directly with the transition energies you already computed before relying on wavelength numbers alone.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student omits squaring the principal quantum number in the energy formula, using En = -13.60 / n.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    E1=−13.60 eV  ⟹  E2=−13.60/2=−6.80 eV  ⟹  ΔE(2→1)=−6.80−(−13.60)=6.80 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} \implies E_2 = -13.60 / 2 = -6.80\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E(2 \to 1) = -6.80 - (-13.60) = 6.80\text{ eV}

    Correct

    E2=−13.60 eV22=−3.40 eV  ⟹  ΔE2→1=−3.40 eV−(−13.60 eV)=10.20 eVE_2 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{2^2} = -3.40\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E_{2 \to 1} = -3.40\text{ eV} - (-13.60\text{ eV}) = 10.20\text{ eV}

    You divided by n=2n=2 rather than n2=4n^2=4. The Bohr formula requires En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{n^2}, giving E2=−3.40 eVE_2 = -3.40\text{ eV} and ΔE2→1=10.20 eV\Delta E_{2 \to 1} = 10.20\text{ eV}.

  2. Step 2

    E5=−13.60/5=−2.72 eV  ⟹  E6=−13.60/6=−2.27 eV  ⟹  ΔE(6→5)=−2.27−(−2.72)=0.45 eV  ⟹  Adjacent gaps decrease from 6.80 eV to 0.45 eVE_5 = -13.60 / 5 = -2.72\text{ eV} \implies E_6 = -13.60 / 6 = -2.27\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E(6 \to 5) = -2.27 - (-2.72) = 0.45\text{ eV} \implies \text{Adjacent gaps decrease from } 6.80\text{ eV} \text{ to } 0.45\text{ eV}

    Correct

    E5=−13.60 eV52=−0.544 eV  ⟹  E6=−13.60 eV62≈−0.378 eV  ⟹  ΔE6→5≈0.151 eVE_5 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{5^2} = -0.544\text{ eV} \implies E_6 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{6^2} \approx -0.378\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E_{6 \to 5} \approx 0.151\text{ eV}

    Your subtraction method and qualitative deduction that higher level gaps shrink were completely correct, but the numerical values carry forward the omitted square on nn (52=255^2 = 25 and 62=366^2 = 36).

  3. Step 3

    E3=−13.60/3=−4.53 eV  ⟹  ΔE(3→2)=−4.53−(−6.80)=2.27 eV  ⟹  λ(3→2)=1240/2.27=546 nmE_3 = -13.60 / 3 = -4.53\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E(3 \to 2) = -4.53 - (-6.80) = 2.27\text{ eV} \implies \lambda(3 \to 2) = 1240 / 2.27 = 546\text{ nm}

    Correct

    E3=−13.60 eV32=−1.51 eV  ⟹  ΔE3→2=−1.51−(−3.40)=1.89 eV  ⟹  λ3→2=1239.8 eV⋅nm1.89 eV≈656.3 nmE_3 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{3^2} = -1.51\text{ eV} \implies \Delta E_{3 \to 2} = -1.51 - (-3.40) = 1.89\text{ eV} \implies \lambda_{3 \to 2} = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{1.89\text{ eV}} \approx 656.3\text{ nm}

    You applied the Planck-Einstein relation λ=hcΔE\lambda = \frac{hc}{\Delta E} accurately, but the resulting wavelength was affected by the earlier unsquared energy levels.

  4. Step 4

    ΔE(∞→2)=0−(−6.80)=6.80 eV  ⟹  λ(∞→2)=1240/6.80=182 nm\Delta E(\infty \to 2) = 0 - (-6.80) = 6.80\text{ eV} \implies \lambda(\infty \to 2) = 1240 / 6.80 = 182\text{ nm}

    Correct

    ΔE∞→2=0−(−3.40 eV)=3.40 eV  ⟹  λ∞→2=1239.8 eV⋅nm3.40 eV≈364.6 nm\Delta E_{\infty \to 2} = 0 - (-3.40\text{ eV}) = 3.40\text{ eV} \implies \lambda_{\infty \to 2} = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{3.40\text{ eV}} \approx 364.6\text{ nm}

    You correctly set E∞=0 eVE_\infty = 0\text{ eV} and used the photon wavelength formula, but the result inherited your incorrect E2E_2 value.

  5. Step 5

    The ∞→2 transition has the shortest wavelength and highest energy.\text{The } \infty \to 2 \text{ transition has the shortest wavelength and highest energy.}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated transition energies as differences between upper and lower energy levels.

You correctly set the ionization energy level at n=∞n = \infty to 0 eV0\text{ eV}.

You correctly used the inverse relationship between photon energy and wavelength via λ=hcΔE\lambda = \frac{hc}{\Delta E}.

You reached the correct physical conclusion that the transition from n=∞→2n = \infty \to 2 yields the highest photon energy and shortest wavelength in the Balmer series.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted square on quantum number

You wrote En=−13.60 eVnE_n = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{n} instead of En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{n^2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the energy levels as scaling inversely with nn rather than with n2n^2, confusing the linear quantization of angular momentum (L=nℏL = n\hbar) or de Broglie wavelengths with the inverse-square dependence of electrostatic binding energy in the Bohr model.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Bohr Energy Level Dependence
  • Hydrogen energy levels obey an inverse-square law: En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{n^2}.

  • Whenever evaluating hydrogen energy states, explicitly write out n2n^2 in the denominator before dividing (e.g., 22=42^2 = 4, 32=93^2 = 9, 52=255^2 = 25).

Quick Sanity Check on $E_2$
  • The first excited state of hydrogen is E2=−13.604=−3.40 eVE_2 = -\frac{13.60}{4} = -3.40\text{ eV}.

  • Memorize E1=−13.60 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV}, E2=−3.40 eVE_2 = -3.40\text{ eV}, and E3=−1.51 eVE_3 = -1.51\text{ eV} as reference anchor points to catch missing exponent errors immediately.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the full formula En=−13.60 eVn2E_n = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{n^2} to find E1=−13.60 eVE_1 = -13.60\text{ eV} and E2=−13.60 eV4=−3.40 eVE_2 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{4} = -3.40\text{ eV}, giving ΔE2→1=−3.40−(−13.60)=10.20 eV\Delta E_{2 \to 1} = -3.40 - (-13.60) = 10.20\text{ eV}.

  2. Find E5=−13.60 eV25=−0.544 eVE_5 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{25} = -0.544\text{ eV} and E6=−13.60 eV36≈−0.378 eVE_6 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{36} \approx -0.378\text{ eV}, giving ΔE6→5=−0.378−(−0.544)=0.151 eV\Delta E_{6 \to 5} = -0.378 - (-0.544) = 0.151\text{ eV}.

  3. For n=3n=3, E3=−13.60 eV9≈−1.511 eVE_3 = -\frac{13.60\text{ eV}}{9} \approx -1.511\text{ eV}, so ΔE3→2=−1.511−(−3.40)=1.889 eV\Delta E_{3 \to 2} = -1.511 - (-3.40) = 1.889\text{ eV} and λ3→2=1239.8 eV⋅nm1.889 eV≈656.3 nm\lambda_{3 \to 2} = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{1.889\text{ eV}} \approx 656.3\text{ nm}.

  4. For n=∞n=\infty, ΔE∞→2=0−(−3.40)=3.40 eV\Delta E_{\infty \to 2} = 0 - (-3.40) = 3.40\text{ eV} and λ∞→2=1239.8 eV⋅nm3.40 eV≈364.6 nm\lambda_{\infty \to 2} = \frac{1239.8\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{3.40\text{ eV}} \approx 364.6\text{ nm}.

Final answer

(a) ΔE2→1=10.20 eV\Delta E_{2 \to 1} = 10.20\text{ eV} and ΔE6→5=0.151 eV\Delta E_{6 \to 5} = 0.151\text{ eV}; (b) λ3→2=656.3 nm\lambda_{3 \to 2} = 656.3\text{ nm} and λ∞→2=364.6 nm\lambda_{\infty \to 2} = 364.6\text{ nm}; the transition from n=∞→2n = \infty \to 2 produces the shortest wavelength.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how Coulomb's force and orbital radius rn∝n2r_n \propto n^2 combine to produce the 1/n21/n^2 factor in orbital kinetic and potential energy.

  • Practice computing transitions in hydrogen-like ions where Z2Z^2 also appears: En=−(13.60 eV)Z2n2E_n = -(13.60\text{ eV})\frac{Z^2}{n^2}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A photon has an energy of 2.5 eV2.5\text{ eV} and another photon has an energy of 5.0 eV5.0\text{ eV}. Determine the ratio of their wavelengths λ1λ2\frac{\lambda_1}{\lambda_2}.

Answer

Since λ=hcE\lambda = \frac{hc}{E}, λ1λ2=E2E1=5.0 eV2.5 eV=2\frac{\lambda_1}{\lambda_2} = \frac{E_2}{E_1} = \frac{5.0\text{ eV}}{2.5\text{ eV}} = 2.

02

In the Lyman series of atomic hydrogen (nf=1n_f = 1), calculate the wavelength for the first line (2→12 \to 1) and the series limit (∞→1\infty \to 1) given ΔE2→1=10.2 eV\Delta E_{2\to 1} = 10.2\text{ eV} and ΔE∞→1=13.6 eV\Delta E_{\infty\to 1} = 13.6\text{ eV}. State which transition emits the highest-energy photon.

Answer

λ2→1=1240 eV⋅nm10.2 eV≈121.6 nm\lambda_{2\to 1} = \frac{1240\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{10.2\text{ eV}} \approx 121.6\text{ nm} and λ∞→1=1240 eV⋅nm13.6 eV≈91.2 nm\lambda_{\infty\to 1} = \frac{1240\text{ eV}\cdot\text{nm}}{13.6\text{ eV}} \approx 91.2\text{ nm}. The ∞→1\infty \to 1 transition emits the highest-energy photon (13.6 eV13.6\text{ eV}) at the shortest wavelength (91.2 nm91.2\text{ nm}).

03

An electron in a hydrogen-like ion drops between two levels emitting light. If transition A produces light at 450 nm450\text{ nm} and transition B produces light at 150 nm150\text{ nm}, find the ratio of energy emitted ΔEBΔEA\frac{\Delta E_B}{\Delta E_A} and state which transition represents a larger drop on an energy-level diagram.

Answer

ΔEBΔEA=λAλB=450150=3\frac{\Delta E_B}{\Delta E_A} = \frac{\lambda_A}{\lambda_B} = \frac{450}{150} = 3. Transition B represents a vertical drop 3 times larger on the energy-level diagram.

Loading workspace…