Resources

Two straight railway tracks intersect at a right angle at point OO. Train 11 travels eastward toward OO with position x1(t)=−d0+vtx_1(t) = -d_0 + v t along the xx-axis, where d0=1000 md_0 = 1000\text{ m} and v=20.0 m/sv = 20.0\text{ m/s}. Train 22 travels northward away from OO with position y2(t)=vty_2(t) = v t along the yy-axis with the same speed v=20.0 m/sv = 20.0\text{ m/s}, both starting at time t=0t = 0. (a) Derive an expression for the distance S(t)S(t) between the two trains as a function of time. (b) Find the time t∗t^* and the distance of closest approach SminS_{\text{min}} between the two trains. (c) Analyze the asymptotic behavior of the relative velocity vector v⃗2/1\vec{v}_{2/1} and the relative separation rate dSdt\frac{dS}{dt} as t→∞t \to \infty.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) S(t)=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2 mS(t) = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2}\text{ m}; (b) t∗=25.0 st^* = 25.0\text{ s}, with minimum distance Smin=5002 m≈707 mS_{\text{min}} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}; (c) As t→∞t \to \infty, the relative velocity remains constant at v⃗2/1=−20.0i^+20.0j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = -20.0\hat{i} + 20.0\hat{j}\text{ m/s}, and the separation rate approaches the asymptotic limit lim⁡t→∞dSdt=v2=28.3 m/s\lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{dS}{dt} = v\sqrt{2} = 28.3\text{ m/s}.

Steps

Part (a): Distance Between the Trains as a Function of Time

The position vector of Train 11 moving along the xx-axis is: r⃗1(t)=x1(t) i^=(−d0+vt) i^=(−1000+20.0t) i^ m\vec{r}_1(t) = x_1(t)\,\hat{i} = (-d_0 + v t)\,\hat{i} = (-1000 + 20.0t)\,\hat{i}\text{ m}

The position vector of Train 22 moving along the yy-axis is: r⃗2(t)=y2(t) j^=(vt) j^=(20.0t) j^ m\vec{r}_2(t) = y_2(t)\,\hat{j} = (v t)\,\hat{j} = (20.0t)\,\hat{j}\text{ m}

The relative position vector of Train 22 with respect to Train 11 is: r⃗2/1(t)=r⃗2(t)−r⃗1(t)=−(−1000+20.0t) i^+(20.0t) j^ m\vec{r}_{2/1}(t) = \vec{r}_2(t) - \vec{r}_1(t) = -(-1000 + 20.0t)\,\hat{i} + (20.0t)\,\hat{j}\text{ m}

Using the Pythagorean theorem, the distance S(t)=∣r⃗2/1(t)∣S(t) = |\vec{r}_{2/1}(t)| is: S(t)=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2 mS(t) = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2}\text{ m}


Part (b): Time and Distance of Closest Approach

To find the minimum distance, it is simpler to minimize the squared distance f(t)=[S(t)]2f(t) = [S(t)]^2: f(t)=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2f(t) = (-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2 f(t)=1 000 000−40 000t+400t2+400t2=800t2−40 000t+1 000 000f(t) = 1\,000\,000 - 40\,000t + 400t^2 + 400t^2 = 800t^2 - 40\,000t + 1\,000\,000

Take the first derivative with respect to tt and set it to zero: f′(t)=1600t−40 000=0f'(t) = 1600t - 40\,000 = 0 t∗=40 0001600=25.0 st^* = \frac{40\,000}{1600} = 25.0\text{ s}

Since the second derivative f′′(t)=1600>0f''(t) = 1600 > 0, this critical point represents a true minimum.

Substitute t∗=25.0 st^* = 25.0\text{ s} back into the position coordinates: x1(25.0)=−1000+20.0(25.0)=−500 mx_1(25.0) = -1000 + 20.0(25.0) = -500\text{ m} y2(25.0)=20.0(25.0)=500 my_2(25.0) = 20.0(25.0) = 500\text{ m}

The distance of closest approach is: Smin=(−500)2+5002=500 000=5002 m≈707 mS_{\text{min}} = \sqrt{(-500)^2 + 500^2} = \sqrt{500\,000} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}


Part (c): Asymptotic Behavior as t→∞t \to \infty

  1. Relative Velocity Vector v⃗2/1\vec{v}_{2/1}: The velocities of the two trains in the ground frame are: v⃗1=dr⃗1dt=20.0 i^ m/s\vec{v}_1 = \frac{d\vec{r}_1}{dt} = 20.0\,\hat{i}\text{ m/s} v⃗2=dr⃗2dt=20.0 j^ m/s\vec{v}_2 = \frac{d\vec{r}_2}{dt} = 20.0\,\hat{j}\text{ m/s}

    The relative velocity of Train 22 with respect to Train 11 is: v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1=−20.0 i^+20.0 j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1 = -20.0\,\hat{i} + 20.0\,\hat{j}\text{ m/s} Since both individual velocities are constant, v⃗2/1\vec{v}_{2/1} is independent of time and remains constant at all times, including as t→∞t \to \infty: v⃗2/1=−20.0 i^+20.0 j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = -20.0\,\hat{i} + 20.0\,\hat{j}\text{ m/s}

  2. Separation Rate dSdt\frac{dS}{dt}: The rate of change of the distance between them is given by: dSdt=f′(t)2f(t)=1600t−40 0002800t2−40 000t+1 000 000=800t−20 000800t2−40 000t+1 000 000\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{f'(t)}{2\sqrt{f(t)}} = \frac{1600t - 40\,000}{2\sqrt{800t^2 - 40\,000t + 1\,000\,000}} = \frac{800t - 20\,000}{\sqrt{800t^2 - 40\,000t + 1\,000\,000}}

    Dividing the numerator and denominator by tt for t>0t > 0: dSdt=800−20 000t800−40 000t+1 000 000t2\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{800 - \frac{20\,000}{t}}{\sqrt{800 - \frac{40\,000}{t} + \frac{1\,000\,000}{t^2}}}

    Taking the limit as t→∞t \to \infty: lim⁡t→∞dSdt=800800=800=20.02 m/s≈28.3 m/s\lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{800}{\sqrt{800}} = \sqrt{800} = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} \approx 28.3\text{ m/s}

Pitfall Note: The rate of separation dSdt\frac{dS}{dt} is the component of relative velocity along the line connecting the two trains, not the magnitude of the relative velocity vector at all times. Only as t→∞t \to \infty does the direction of the separation vector become purely parallel to v⃗2/1\vec{v}_{2/1}, causing dSdt\frac{dS}{dt} to approach the full relative speed ∣v⃗2/1∣=20.02 m/s|\vec{v}_{2/1}| = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes the trains are closest when Train 1 arrives at the intersection O at t = d₀/v, neglecting that Train 2 is simultaneously moving away.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    x1(t)=−1000+20.0tx_1(t) = -1000 + 20.0t y2(t)=20.0ty_2(t) = 20.0t S(t)=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2S(t) = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2}

  2. Step 2

    Train 1 reaches the origin when x1(t)=0  ⟹  −1000+20.0t=0  ⟹  t∗=50.0 s\text{Train 1 reaches the origin when } x_1(t) = 0 \implies -1000 + 20.0t = 0 \implies t^* = 50.0\text{ s} Smin=y2(50.0)=20.0×50.0=1000 mS_{\text{min}} = y_2(50.0) = 20.0 \times 50.0 = 1000\text{ m}

    Correct

    f(t)=[S(t)]2=800t2−40000t+1000000f(t) = [S(t)]^2 = 800t^2 - 40000t + 1000000 f′(t)=1600t−40000=0  ⟹  t∗=25.0 sf'(t) = 1600t - 40000 = 0 \implies t^* = 25.0\text{ s} Smin=S(25.0)=(−500)2+5002=5002 m≈707 mS_{\text{min}} = S(25.0) = \sqrt{(-500)^2 + 500^2} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}

    You set x1(t)=0x_1(t) = 0 to find the time of closest approach, but while Train 1 approaches the origin, Train 2 is simultaneously moving further away along the yy-axis. The true minimum occurs earlier when the combined rate of separation dSdt=0\frac{dS}{dt} = 0 (or d(S2)dt=0\frac{d(S^2)}{dt} = 0), which yields t∗=25.0 st^* = 25.0\text{ s} and Smin≈707 mS_{\text{min}} \approx 707\text{ m}.

  3. Step 3

    v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1=−20.0i^+20.0j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1 = -20.0\hat{i} + 20.0\hat{j}\text{ m/s} dSdt=1600t−4000021000000−40000t+800t2\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{1600t - 40000}{2\sqrt{1000000 - 40000t + 800t^2}} As t→∞,dSdt→800t800t2=800=28.3 m/s\text{As } t \to \infty, \frac{dS}{dt} \to \frac{800t}{\sqrt{800t^2}} = \sqrt{800} = 28.3\text{ m/s}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly wrote down the position coordinates and used the distance formula to find S(t)S(t).

You correctly computed the relative velocity vector v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1.

You correctly differentiated the distance function and evaluated the limit of dSdt\frac{dS}{dt} as t→∞t \to \infty.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Single-Body Arrival Fallacy in Two-Body Closest Approach

In part (a), you wrote 1000000−4000t+800t21000000 - 4000t + 800t^2 under the radical with a missing zero, though you subsequently fixed it to 40000t40000t in part (c).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the distance between two moving bodies is minimized when one of the bodies reaches a fixed landmark (the intersection OO), neglecting that the other body is continuously moving and that minimum separation depends on the simultaneous motion of both bodies.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Condition for Closest Approach
  • For two moving objects with separation S(t)S(t), the minimum distance occurs when dSdt=0\frac{dS}{dt} = 0 (or equivalently d(S2)dt=0\frac{d(S^2)}{dt} = 0), which geometrically means their relative position vector r⃗2/1\vec{r}_{2/1} is perpendicular to their relative velocity vector v⃗2/1\vec{v}_{2/1} ( r⃗2/1⋅v⃗2/1=0\,\vec{r}_{2/1} \cdot \vec{v}_{2/1} = 0).

  • Always set the derivative of [S(t)]2[S(t)]^2 to zero rather than setting an individual object's coordinate to zero.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Define f(t)=[S(t)]2=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2=800t2−40000t+1000000f(t) = [S(t)]^2 = (-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2 = 800t^2 - 40000t + 1000000.

  2. Set the derivative with respect to time to zero: f′(t)=1600t−40000=0f'(t) = 1600t - 40000 = 0.

  3. Solve for the critical time: t∗=400001600=25.0 st^* = \frac{40000}{1600} = 25.0\text{ s}.

  4. Evaluate S(25.0)=(−1000+20.0(25.0))2+(20.0(25.0))2=(−500)2+5002=5002 m≈707 mS(25.0) = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0(25.0))^2 + (20.0(25.0))^2} = \sqrt{(-500)^2 + 500^2} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}.

Final answer

t∗=25.0 st^* = 25.0\text{ s}, Smin=5002 m≈707 mS_{\text{min}} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Notice in your own derivative in part (c) that the numerator is 1600t−400001600t - 40000; setting that numerator to zero directly gives the true minimum at t=25.0 st = 25.0\text{ s}.

  • Practice solving two-body closest-approach problems both via calculus ( d(S2)dt=0\,\frac{d(S^2)}{dt} = 0) and via the geometric relative-motion method (perpendicular distance to the relative trajectory line).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the relative separation rate dS/dt as the scalar speed difference v₂ - v₁ = 0 rather than the projection of the relative velocity onto the line of sight.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    x1(t)=−1000+20.0tx_1(t) = -1000 + 20.0t, y2(t)=20.0t  ⟹  S(t)=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2=1000000−40000t+800t2y_2(t) = 20.0t \implies S(t) = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2} = \sqrt{1000000 - 40000t + 800t^2}

  2. Step 2

    d(S2)dt=−40000+1600t=0  ⟹  t∗=400001600=25.0 s  ⟹  Smin=500000≈707 m\frac{d(S^2)}{dt} = -40000 + 1600t = 0 \implies t^* = \frac{40000}{1600} = 25.0\text{ s} \implies S_{\text{min}} = \sqrt{500000} \approx 707\text{ m}

  3. Step 3

    v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1=−20.0i^+20.0j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1 = -20.0\hat{i} + 20.0\hat{j}\text{ m/s}

  4. Step 4

    Since both trains move at the same speed v=20.0 m/s,  dSdt=v−v=0 m/s  ⟹  As t→∞,  dSdt→0 m/s\text{Since both trains move at the same speed } v = 20.0\text{ m/s},\; \frac{dS}{dt} = v - v = 0\text{ m/s} \implies \text{As } t \to \infty,\; \frac{dS}{dt} \to 0\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    dSdt=800t−20000800t2−40000t+1000000  ⟹  lim⁡t→∞dSdt=800=20.02 m/s≈28.3 m/s\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{800t - 20000}{\sqrt{800t^2 - 40000t + 1000000}} \implies \lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{dS}{dt} = \sqrt{800} = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} \approx 28.3\text{ m/s}

    You subtracted the two scalar speeds (v−v=0v - v = 0) instead of taking the derivative of the separation distance ddt[S(t)]\frac{d}{dt}[S(t)] or projecting the relative velocity along the line of sight.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the distance S(t)S(t) between the two perpendicular trajectories using the Pythagorean theorem.

You used the squared-distance minimization trick to find t∗t^* and the minimum distance SminS_{\text{min}} cleanly.

You calculated the vector relative velocity v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1 with correct signs and unit vectors.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misidentifying rate of separation as scalar speed difference

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the scalar rate of distance change dSdt\frac{dS}{dt} (which equals v⃗rel⋅r^rel\vec{v}_{\text{rel}} \cdot \hat{r}_{\text{rel}}) with the algebraic difference in absolute speeds ∣v⃗2∣−∣v⃗1∣|\vec{v}_2| - |\vec{v}_1|. Because the two trains move along perpendicular axes, their separation distance increases over time even though both have the same constant speed.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Separation Rate Definition
  • The rate of separation is dSdt=ddt∣r⃗2/1∣=v⃗2/1⋅r^2/1\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{d}{dt}|\vec{r}_{2/1}| = \vec{v}_{2/1} \cdot \hat{r}_{2/1}, not ∣v⃗2∣−∣v⃗1∣|\vec{v}_2| - |\vec{v}_1|.

  • Differentiate S(t)=x(t)2+y(t)2S(t) = \sqrt{x(t)^2 + y(t)^2} with respect to tt, or compute the dot product of relative velocity with the unit separation vector.

Asymptotic Limit of Separation Rate
  • For constant velocity motions, as t→∞t \to \infty, the position vector direction aligns asymptotically with the relative velocity vector, meaning lim⁡t→∞dSdt=∣v⃗rel∣\lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{dS}{dt} = |\vec{v}_{\text{rel}}|.

  • Divide numerator and denominator of dSdt\frac{dS}{dt} by tt to evaluate the limit as t→∞t \to \infty.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Start from the distance formula: S(t)=800t2−40000t+1000000S(t) = \sqrt{800t^2 - 40000t + 1000000}.

  2. Differentiate with respect to tt: dSdt=1600t−400002800t2−40000t+1000000=800t−20000800t2−40000t+1000000\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{1600t - 40000}{2\sqrt{800t^2 - 40000t + 1000000}} = \frac{800t - 20000}{\sqrt{800t^2 - 40000t + 1000000}}.

  3. Factor tt out of the numerator and denominator for t>0t > 0: dSdt=800−20000t800−40000t+1000000t2\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{800 - \frac{20000}{t}}{\sqrt{800 - \frac{40000}{t} + \frac{1000000}{t^2}}}.

  4. Take the limit as t→∞t \to \infty: lim⁡t→∞dSdt=800800=800=20.02 m/s≈28.3 m/s\lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{800}{\sqrt{800}} = \sqrt{800} = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} \approx 28.3\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

As t→∞t \to \infty, v⃗2/1=−20.0i^+20.0j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = -20.0\hat{i} + 20.0\hat{j}\text{ m/s} (constant) and dSdt→20.02 m/s≈28.3 m/s\frac{dS}{dt} \to 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} \approx 28.3\text{ m/s}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between relative velocity magnitude ∣v⃗2/1∣|\vec{v}_{2/1}| and separation rate dSdt\frac{dS}{dt}.

  • Practice finding asymptotic separation rates by differentiating S(t)S(t) directly.

  • Remember that dSdt=0\frac{dS}{dt} = 0 only at the point of closest approach (t=t∗t = t^*), never as t→∞t \to \infty for diverging paths.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly adds coordinates linearly instead of using the Pythagorean theorem for perpendicular axes when determining the distance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    S(t)=y2(t)−x1(t)=20.0t−(−1000+20.0t)  ⟹  S(t)=1000 mS(t) = y_2(t) - x_1(t) = 20.0t - (-1000 + 20.0t) \implies S(t) = 1000\text{ m}

    Correct

    S(t)=[x1(t)]2+[y2(t)]2=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2 mS(t) = \sqrt{[x_1(t)]^2 + [y_2(t)]^2} = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2}\text{ m}

    The two railway tracks intersect at a right angle along the xx-axis and yy-axis. Because the displacements are perpendicular vectors, the distance between them must be calculated using the Euclidean distance formula (the Pythagorean theorem), not by scalar subtraction of coordinates.

  2. Step 2

    t∗ is undefined or any time t≥0,Smin=1000 mt^*\text{ is undefined or any time } t \ge 0, S_{\text{min}} = 1000\text{ m}

    Correct

    t∗=25.0 s,Smin=5002 m≈707 mt^* = 25.0\text{ s}, S_{\text{min}} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}

    Because your distance function was incorrectly found to be constant, your conclusion that the distance never changes follows logically from that earlier mistake, but it gives an incorrect minimum distance and time of closest approach.

  3. Step 3

    v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1=−20.0i^+20.0j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1 = -20.0\hat{i} + 20.0\hat{j}\text{ m/s}

  4. Step 4

    dSdt=d(1000)dt=0 m/s  ⟹  As t→∞,dSdt→0 m/s\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{d(1000)}{dt} = 0\text{ m/s} \implies \text{As } t \to \infty, \frac{dS}{dt} \to 0\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    lim⁡t→∞dSdt=20.02 m/s≈28.3 m/s\lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{dS}{dt} = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} \approx 28.3\text{ m/s}

    Differentiating your constant S(t)=1000 mS(t) = 1000\text{ m} produced zero. With the correct Euclidean distance function, the rate of separation approaches the relative speed ∣v⃗2/1∣=20.02 m/s|\vec{v}_{2/1}| = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} as the position vector aligns with the relative velocity vector at large tt.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the individual coordinate equations x1(t)x_1(t) and y2(t)y_2(t) over time.

You calculated the relative velocity vector v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1 accurately using unit vector notation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Collinear Distance on Orthogonal Axes

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated two perpendicular motion axes as if they were a single straight line, subtracting scalar coordinates across different orthogonal dimensions (y−xy - x) rather than taking the vector magnitude ∣r⃗2−r⃗1∣=Δx2+Δy2|\vec{r}_2 - \vec{r}_1| = \sqrt{\Delta x^2 + \Delta y^2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Verify Axis Orthogonality
  • When objects move along different coordinate axes (xx and yy), their separation vector is Δr⃗=Δx i^+Δy j^\Delta\vec{r} = \Delta x\,\hat{i} + \Delta y\,\hat{j}.

  • Always write the relative position as a vector first, and compute the distance as its magnitude S=(Δx)2+(Δy)2S = \sqrt{(\Delta x)^2 + (\Delta y)^2}.

Distinguish Relative Speed from Rate of Separation
  • Relative speed is ∣v⃗2/1∣|\vec{v}_{2/1}|, whereas the rate of separation is dSdt=r⃗2/1⋅v⃗2/1∣r⃗2/1∣\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{\vec{r}_{2/1} \cdot \vec{v}_{2/1}}{|\vec{r}_{2/1}|}.

  • Compute dSdt\frac{dS}{dt} by taking the time derivative of the Euclidean distance S(t)S(t), or by projecting relative velocity along the line of sight.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the Euclidean distance function: S(t)=x1(t)2+y2(t)2=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2S(t) = \sqrt{x_1(t)^2 + y_2(t)^2} = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2}.

  2. Expand the radicand to find f(t)=[S(t)]2=800t2−40 000t+1 000 000f(t) = [S(t)]^2 = 800t^2 - 40\,000t + 1\,000\,000.

  3. Differentiate f(t)f(t) and set f′(t)=1600t−40 000=0f'(t) = 1600t - 40\,000 = 0 to find t∗=25.0 st^* = 25.0\text{ s}.

  4. Evaluate S(25.0)=(−500)2+5002=5002 m≈707 mS(25.0) = \sqrt{(-500)^2 + 500^2} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}.

  5. Differentiate S(t)S(t) to obtain dSdt=800t−20 000800t2−40 000t+1 000 000\frac{dS}{dt} = \frac{800t - 20\,000}{\sqrt{800t^2 - 40\,000t + 1\,000\,000}} and take the limit as t→∞t \to \infty, which yields 800=20.02 m/s≈28.3 m/s\sqrt{800} = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} \approx 28.3\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

(a) S(t)=(−1000+20.0t)2+(20.0t)2 mS(t) = \sqrt{(-1000 + 20.0t)^2 + (20.0t)^2}\text{ m}; (b) t∗=25.0 st^* = 25.0\text{ s}, Smin=5002 m≈707 mS_{\text{min}} = 500\sqrt{2}\text{ m} \approx 707\text{ m}; (c) v⃗2/1=−20.0i^+20.0j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = -20.0\hat{i} + 20.0\hat{j}\text{ m/s} and lim⁡t→∞dSdt=20.02 m/s≈28.3 m/s\lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{dS}{dt} = 20.0\sqrt{2}\text{ m/s} \approx 28.3\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review calculating distance in 2D using position vectors and the Pythagorean theorem.

  • Practice finding closest-approach distances by minimizing the square of distance [S(t)]2[S(t)]^2 to simplify derivatives.

  • Differentiate between the vector relative velocity v⃗rel\vec{v}_{\text{rel}} and the scalar separation rate dSdt\frac{dS}{dt}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Ship A is at (0,0)(0, 0) moving east at 15 m/s15\text{ m/s}. Ship B is at (0,−600 m)(0, -600\text{ m}) moving north at 20 m/s20\text{ m/s}. Find the time t∗t^* of closest approach.

Answer

The positions are r⃗A=15ti^\vec{r}_A = 15t\hat{i} and r⃗B=(−600+20t)j^\vec{r}_B = (-600 + 20t)\hat{j}. Squared distance is S2=(15t)2+(−600+20t)2=625t2−24000t+360000S^2 = (15t)^2 + (-600 + 20t)^2 = 625t^2 - 24000t + 360000. Setting d(S2)dt=1250t−24000=0\frac{d(S^2)}{dt} = 1250t - 24000 = 0 yields t∗=240001250=19.2 st^* = \frac{24000}{1250} = 19.2\text{ s}.

02

Car 1 moves along the xx-axis with x1(t)=−d0+v1tx_1(t) = -d_0 + v_1 t while Car 2 moves along the yy-axis with y2(t)=v2ty_2(t) = v_2 t. Derive a general formula for the time of closest approach t∗t^* in terms of d0d_0, v1v_1, and v2v_2.

Answer

Squared separation is S2(t)=(−d0+v1t)2+(v2t)2=(v12+v22)t2−2d0v1t+d02S^2(t) = (-d_0 + v_1 t)^2 + (v_2 t)^2 = (v_1^2 + v_2^2)t^2 - 2d_0 v_1 t + d_0^2. Differentiating and setting to zero: 2(v12+v22)t−2d0v1=0  ⟹  t∗=d0v1v12+v222(v_1^2 + v_2^2)t - 2d_0 v_1 = 0 \implies t^* = \frac{d_0 v_1}{v_1^2 + v_2^2}.

03

Two drones fly at the same altitude with constant velocities v⃗1=(6i^+8j^) m/s\vec{v}_1 = (6\hat{i} + 8\hat{j})\text{ m/s} and v⃗2=(−2i^+2j^) m/s\vec{v}_2 = (-2\hat{i} + 2\hat{j})\text{ m/s}. At t=0t = 0, Drone 1 is at (0,0)(0, 0) and Drone 2 is at (100 m,0)(100\text{ m}, 0). Using the geometric relative-velocity condition r⃗rel⋅v⃗rel=0\vec{r}_{\text{rel}} \cdot \vec{v}_{\text{rel}} = 0, find the minimum distance between the drones.

Answer

Relative velocity v⃗2/1=v⃗2−v⃗1=−8i^−6j^ m/s\vec{v}_{2/1} = \vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1 = -8\hat{i} - 6\hat{j}\text{ m/s}, with magnitude vrel=10 m/sv_{\text{rel}} = 10\text{ m/s}. Initial relative position r⃗0=100i^ m\vec{r}_0 = 100\hat{i}\text{ m}. The relative path is a line through (100,0)(100, 0) along (−8,−6)(-8, -6). The distance of closest approach is the perpendicular distance from the origin in the relative frame: Smin=∣r⃗0×v⃗rel∣vrel=∣100(0)−0(−8)−100(−6)∣10=60010=60 mS_{\text{min}} = \frac{|\vec{r}_0 \times \vec{v}_{\text{rel}}|}{v_{\text{rel}}} = \frac{|100(0) - 0(-8) - 100(-6)|}{10} = \frac{600}{10} = 60\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…