Resources

An uncompressed, lightweight vertical spring of force constant k=950 N/mk = 950\text{ N/m} rests on the floor. A steel sphere of mass m=0.850 kgm = 0.850\text{ kg} is dropped from rest from a height H=1.60 mH = 1.60\text{ m} above the top of the spring. Upon striking the spring, the sphere compresses it until instantaneously coming to rest. Assuming mechanical energy is conserved and air resistance is negligible, calculate the maximum downward compression ymaxy_{\text{max}} of the spring in meters. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

ymax=0.177 my_{\text{max}} = 0.177\text{ m}

Steps

01

Define the Reference Levels and Energy States

Principle of Mechanical Energy Conservation

In an isolated system where only conservative forces (gravity and the ideal spring force) do work, total mechanical energy is conserved: Einitial=EfinalE_{\text{initial}} = E_{\text{final}}

Choose the reference point for gravitational potential energy (Ug=0U_g = 0) at the lowest point of the motion, which corresponds to the maximum downward compression ymaxy_{\text{max}} of the spring.

  1. Initial State (at the release point):

    • The sphere is dropped from rest, so its initial kinetic energy is zero: Ki=0K_i = 0.
    • The spring is completely uncompressed, so its elastic potential energy is zero: Us,i=0U_{s,i} = 0.
    • The total height of the sphere above the lowest point is the drop height HH plus the compression distance ymaxy_{\text{max}}: Ug,i=mg(H+ymax)U_{g,i} = mg(H + y_{\text{max}})
    • Total initial mechanical energy: Ei=mg(H+ymax)E_i = mg(H + y_{\text{max}})
  2. Final State (at maximum spring compression):

    • The sphere comes instantaneously to rest before rebounding, so its final kinetic energy is zero: Kf=0K_f = 0.
    • At this lowest level, gravitational potential energy is Ug,f=0U_{g,f} = 0.
    • The spring is compressed by ymaxy_{\text{max}}, storing elastic potential energy: Us,f=12kymax2U_{s,f} = \frac{1}{2}ky_{\text{max}}^2
    • Total final mechanical energy: Ef=12kymax2E_f = \frac{1}{2}ky_{\text{max}}^2

Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is omitting the additional distance ymaxy_{\text{max}} that the sphere falls while compressing the spring, writing the initial gravitational potential energy as only mgHmgH. Because gravity acts throughout the entire descent, the total fall distance is H+ymaxH + y_{\text{max}}.


02

Formulate and Solve the Quadratic Equation

Equating the initial and final mechanical energy:

12kymax2=mg(H+ymax)\frac{1}{2}ky_{\text{max}}^2 = mg(H + y_{\text{max}})

Rearranging into standard quadratic form aymax2+bymax+c=0ay_{\text{max}}^2 + by_{\text{max}} + c = 0:

12kymax2−mgymax−mgH=0\frac{1}{2}ky_{\text{max}}^2 - mgy_{\text{max}} - mgH = 0

Substitute the given numerical values:

  • m=0.850 kgm = 0.850\text{ kg}
  • g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2
  • k=950 N/mk = 950\text{ N/m}
  • H=1.60 mH = 1.60\text{ m}

Calculate the individual terms:

  • 12k=12(950)=475 N/m\frac{1}{2}k = \frac{1}{2}(950) = 475\text{ N/m}
  • mg=(0.850)(9.80)=8.33 Nmg = (0.850)(9.80) = 8.33\text{ N}
  • mgH=(8.33)(1.60)=13.328 JmgH = (8.33)(1.60) = 13.328\text{ J}

The equation becomes:

475ymax2−8.33ymax−13.328=0475 y_{\text{max}}^2 - 8.33 y_{\text{max}} - 13.328 = 0

Apply the quadratic formula, taking the physically meaningful positive root (ymax>0y_{\text{max}} > 0):

ymax=−(−8.33)+(−8.33)2−4(475)(−13.328)2(475)y_{\text{max}} = \frac{-(-8.33) + \sqrt{(-8.33)^2 - 4(475)(-13.328)}}{2(475)}

ymax=8.33+69.3889+25323.2950y_{\text{max}} = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{69.3889 + 25323.2}}{950}

ymax=8.33+25392.5889950=8.33+159.35950≈167.68950≈0.1765 my_{\text{max}} = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{25392.5889}}{950} = \frac{8.33 + 159.35}{950} \approx \frac{167.68}{950} \approx 0.1765\text{ m}

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

ymax=0.177 my_{\text{max}} = 0.177\text{ m}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the additional decrease in gravitational potential energy during the compression of the spring, equating the elastic potential energy only to mgH.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mgH=(12)ky2  ⟹  (0.850)(9.80)(1.60)=(12)(950)y2mgH = \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)ky^2 \implies (0.850)(9.80)(1.60) = \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)(950)y^2

    Correct

    mg(H+y)=12ky2  ⟹  (0.850)(9.80)(1.60+y)=12(950)y2mg(H + y) = \frac{1}{2}ky^2 \implies (0.850)(9.80)(1.60 + y) = \frac{1}{2}(950)y^2

    You set the initial gravitational potential energy to mgHmgH, but the sphere continues falling while compressing the spring downward by yy. Taking the lowest point (maximum compression) as the zero-potential reference level gives an initial height of H+yH + y, so total mechanical energy conservation requires mg(H+y)=12ky2mg(H + y) = \frac{1}{2}ky^2.

  2. Step 2

    13.328=475y2  ⟹  y2=0.0280613.328 = 475y^2 \implies y^2 = 0.02806

    Correct

    475y2−8.33y−13.328=0475y^2 - 8.33y - 13.328 = 0

    Because the missing term mgymgy was omitted in the initial energy balance, this simplified quadratic in y2y^2 propagated from the setup error rather than forming a complete quadratic equation in yy.

  3. Step 3

    y=0.168 my = 0.168\text{ m}

    Correct

    ymax=0.177 my_{\text{max}} = 0.177\text{ m}

    Your calculation from your formula was carried out correctly, but the resulting value is slightly lower than the true maximum compression of 0.177 m0.177\text{ m} because the extra energy from falling through yy was not accounted for.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that total mechanical energy is conserved throughout the motion.

You used the correct formula 12ky2\frac{1}{2}ky^2 for the elastic potential energy stored in the spring.

You performed clean, accurate algebraic simplification and unit handling for your setup.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Gravitational Potential Energy During Spring Compression

You treated the top of the uncompressed spring as the lowest point for gravitational potential energy instead of the lowest point reached by the falling sphere.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the point of initial spring contact with the point of maximum spring compression. When a mass falls onto a vertical spring, gravity continues to do positive work (or gravitational potential energy continues to decrease) over the compression distance yy.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Level Selection
  • Always define the zero level for gravitational potential energy (Ug=0U_g = 0) at the lowest point of interest in the problem (maximum compression).

  • Measure the total vertical displacement from release to the lowest point as Δh=H+ymax\Delta h = H + y_{\text{max}}.

Complete Energy Balance
  • In vertical spring impacts, the total drop height includes the spring deformation: Ei=mg(H+y)E_i = mg(H + y) and Ef=12ky2E_f = \frac{1}{2}ky^2.

  • Set up the equation as a full quadratic ay2+by+c=0ay^2 + by + c = 0 whenever gravity acts along the direction of compression.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the datum Ug=0U_g = 0 at the lowest position where the spring is compressed by yy: Ei=mg(H+y)E_i = mg(H + y) and Ef=12ky2E_f = \frac{1}{2}ky^2.

  2. Equate initial and final mechanical energy: 12ky2=mg(H+y)\frac{1}{2}ky^2 = mg(H + y).

  3. Substitute the values: 475y2=8.33(1.60+y)=13.328+8.33y475y^2 = 8.33(1.60 + y) = 13.328 + 8.33y.

  4. Rearrange into standard quadratic form: 475y2−8.33y−13.328=0475y^2 - 8.33y - 13.328 = 0.

  5. Apply the quadratic formula to find the positive physical root: y=8.33+(−8.33)2−4(475)(−13.328)2(475)=8.33+25392.59950≈0.177 my = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{(-8.33)^2 - 4(475)(-13.328)}}{2(475)} = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{25392.59}}{950} \approx 0.177\text{ m}.

Final answer

ymax=0.177 my_{\text{max}} = 0.177\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When setting up energy conservation for vertical springs, always draw a diagram marking the initial height, the top of the uncompressed spring, and the lowest point reached.

  • Double-check whether gravity acts parallel to the spring's compression; if so, include the term mgymg y in the total drop height.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the condition for maximum compression with static equilibrium, setting the spring force equal to the sphere's weight.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ky=mgky = mg

    Correct

    mg(H+ymax)=12kymax2mg(H + y_{\text{max}}) = \frac{1}{2}ky_{\text{max}}^2

    You set the net force to zero (Fnet=ky−mg=0F_{\text{net}} = ky - mg = 0). This identifies the static equilibrium position where acceleration is zero, not the point of maximum compression where velocity is instantaneously zero. Because the sphere is dropped from a height HH, it carries kinetic energy when it hits the spring and overshoots the equilibrium position until all mechanical energy is converted into elastic potential energy.

  2. Step 2

    950y=(0.850)(9.80)  ⟹  950y=8.33  ⟹  y=8.33950  ⟹  y=0.00877 m950y = (0.850)(9.80) \implies 950y = 8.33 \implies y = \frac{8.33}{950} \implies y = 0.00877\text{ m}

    Correct

    475ymax2−8.33ymax−13.328=0  ⟹  ymax≈0.177 m475y_{\text{max}}^2 - 8.33y_{\text{max}} - 13.328 = 0 \implies y_{\text{max}} \approx 0.177\text{ m}

    You solved your linear equation accurately to obtain 0.00877 m0.00877\text{ m}, but because the governing equation was based on static equilibrium rather than energy conservation, the resulting value represents the equilibrium stretch/compression rather than ymaxy_{\text{max}}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the gravitational weight of the sphere as mg=(0.850)(9.80)=8.33 Nmg = (0.850)(9.80) = 8.33\text{ N}.

You carried out the linear algebraic calculation accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equilibrium vs. Maximum Dynamic Displacement

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the point of static equilibrium (Fnet=0F_{\text{net}} = 0) with the point of maximum dynamic displacement (v=0v = 0). At equilibrium, the sphere moves at maximum speed rather than coming to rest. To find the stopping point, total mechanical energy must be conserved from the release point to the lowest point.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Static Equilibrium vs. Maximum Compression
  • At static equilibrium, Fnet=0F_{\text{net}} = 0 and velocity is maximal during an oscillation; at maximum compression, velocity v=0v = 0 while net upward force is at its maximum.

  • Whenever an object falls onto a spring, use Ei=EfE_i = E_f to determine maximum compression, not ΣF=0\Sigma F = 0.

Total Vertical Descent
  • Gravity does work over the full distance fallen: htotal=H+ymaxh_{\text{total}} = H + y_{\text{max}}.

  • Include both the free-fall height and the spring compression in the gravitational potential energy term: Ug=mg(H+ymax)U_g = mg(H + y_{\text{max}}).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. mg(H+ymax)=12kymax2mg(H + y_{\text{max}}) = \frac{1}{2}ky_{\text{max}}^2

  2. Substitute the given parameters: (0.850)(9.80)(1.60+ymax)=12(950)ymax2(0.850)(9.80)(1.60 + y_{\text{max}}) = \frac{1}{2}(950)y_{\text{max}}^2

  3. 8.33(1.60+ymax)=475ymax28.33(1.60 + y_{\text{max}}) = 475y_{\text{max}}^2

  4. 13.328+8.33ymax=475ymax2  ⟹  475ymax2−8.33ymax−13.328=013.328 + 8.33y_{\text{max}} = 475y_{\text{max}}^2 \implies 475y_{\text{max}}^2 - 8.33y_{\text{max}} - 13.328 = 0

  5. Solve for the positive root using the quadratic formula: ymax=8.33+(−8.33)2−4(475)(−13.328)2(475)y_{\text{max}} = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{(-8.33)^2 - 4(475)(-13.328)}}{2(475)}

  6. ymax=8.33+69.39+25323.2950=8.33+159.35950≈0.1765 my_{\text{max}} = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{69.39 + 25323.2}}{950} = \frac{8.33 + 159.35}{950} \approx 0.1765\text{ m}

Final answer

ymax≈0.177 my_{\text{max}} \approx 0.177\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between equilibrium position (Fnet=0F_{\text{net}} = 0) and turning points (v=0v = 0) in oscillatory systems.

  • Practice setting up energy conservation equations that account for the additional vertical distance traveled while compressing a spring.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student subtracts rather than adds the compression distance in the gravitational potential energy term, writing mg(H - y) instead of mg(H + y).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mg(H−y)=12ky2mg(H - y) = \frac{1}{2}ky^2

    Correct

    mg(H+y)=12ky2mg(H + y) = \frac{1}{2}ky^2

    You subtracted the spring compression yy from the release height HH. Because the sphere falls through both the free-fall height HH and the compression distance yy, the total vertical drop is H+yH + y, giving a change in gravitational potential energy of mg(H+y)mg(H + y).

  2. Step 2

    8.33(1.60−y)=475y2  ⟹  13.328−8.33y=475y2  ⟹  475y2+8.33y−13.328=08.33(1.60 - y) = 475y^2 \implies 13.328 - 8.33y = 475y^2 \implies 475y^2 + 8.33y - 13.328 = 0

    Correct

    8.33(1.60+y)=475y2  ⟹  475y2−8.33y−13.328=08.33(1.60 + y) = 475y^2 \implies 475y^2 - 8.33y - 13.328 = 0

    Your numerical substitutions and algebraic rearrangement were carried out correctly, but the linear coefficient carries a +8.33+8.33 instead of −8.33-8.33 due to the sign error in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    y=−8.33+8.332−4(475)(−13.328)2×475  ⟹  y=−8.33+159.35950y = \frac{-8.33 + \sqrt{8.33^2 - 4(475)(-13.328)}}{2 \times 475} \implies y = \frac{-8.33 + 159.35}{950}

    Correct

    y=8.33+(−8.33)2−4(475)(−13.328)2(475)  ⟹  y=8.33+159.35950y = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{(-8.33)^2 - 4(475)(-13.328)}}{2(475)} \implies y = \frac{8.33 + 159.35}{950}

    You applied the quadratic formula correctly to your equation, but the leading numerator term inherited the incorrect sign from Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    y=0.159 my = 0.159\text{ m}

    Correct

    ymax=0.177 my_{\text{max}} = 0.177\text{ m}

    Your final numerical evaluation matches your quadratic equation, but it differs from the correct value because of the initial sign error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that mechanical energy is conserved between the release point and the point of maximum compression.

You accurately calculated the numerical coefficients mg=8.33 Nmg = 8.33\text{ N}, 12k=475 N/m\frac{1}{2}k = 475\text{ N/m}, and mgH=13.328 JmgH = 13.328\text{ J}.

You executed the quadratic formula and square root calculations with high precision.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Gravitational Potential Energy Distance

You wrote (H−y)(H - y) instead of (H+y)(H + y) when setting up the initial gravitational potential energy relative to the lowest point.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing compression displacement with a reduction in total fall distance. When an object drops onto a vertical spring, gravity continues to pull it downward throughout the entire compression phase yy, so the total downward displacement is the sum H+yH + y, not the difference.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Reference Level Check
  • If the reference level Ug=0U_g = 0 is set at the lowest point of motion (maximum compression), the release height is H+yH + y.

  • Always draw a vertical axis and explicitly mark the initial position (yi=H+yy_i = H + y), the uncompressed spring top (y=yy = y), and the lowest point (yf=0y_f = 0).

Work-Energy Consistency
  • Gravity does positive work over the entire downward journey: Wg=mg⋅dtotal=mg(H+y)W_g = mg \cdot d_{\text{total}} = mg(H + y).

  • Verify that gravity assists the descent during spring compression rather than opposing it.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up energy conservation with the correct total vertical drop: mg(H+y)=12ky2mg(H + y) = \frac{1}{2}ky^2.

  2. Substitute the given values: 8.33(1.60+y)=475y2  ⟹  475y2−8.33y−13.328=08.33(1.60 + y) = 475y^2 \implies 475y^2 - 8.33y - 13.328 = 0.

  3. Apply the quadratic formula for the positive root: y=8.33+(−8.33)2−4(475)(−13.328)950=8.33+159.35950y = \frac{8.33 + \sqrt{(-8.33)^2 - 4(475)(-13.328)}}{950} = \frac{8.33 + 159.35}{950}.

Final answer

ymax≈0.177 my_{\text{max}} \approx 0.177\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the trajectory showing the three key positions: release point, contact with the spring top, and maximum compression.

  • Write the gravitational potential energy relative to the lowest point as Ug=mg×(total height above lowest point)U_g = mg \times (\text{total height above lowest point}).

  • Practice vertical spring drop problems to build the habit of writing H+yH + y for the total vertical displacement.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 2.00 kg2.00\text{ kg} block is dropped from a height of 0.80 m0.80\text{ m} above an uncompressed vertical spring with spring constant k=400 N/mk = 400\text{ N/m}. Calculate the maximum compression of the spring. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

Key steps: Set mg(H+y)=12ky2  ⟹  (2.00)(9.80)(0.80+y)=12(400)y2mg(H + y) = \frac{1}{2}ky^2 \implies (2.00)(9.80)(0.80 + y) = \frac{1}{2}(400)y^2, which simplifies to 200y2−19.6y−15.68=0200y^2 - 19.6y - 15.68 = 0. Solving the quadratic gives y=19.6+19.62−4(200)(−15.68)400=19.6+113.7400≈0.333 my = \frac{19.6 + \sqrt{19.6^2 - 4(200)(-15.68)}}{400} = \frac{19.6 + 113.7}{400} \approx 0.333\text{ m}.

02

A 0.500 kg0.500\text{ kg} package is released from rest on a smooth 30∘30^\circ incline, starting at a distance of 1.20 m1.20\text{ m} along the incline from the top of an uncompressed spring (k=120 N/mk = 120\text{ N/m}). Find the maximum compression xx of the spring along the incline. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

Key steps: The total distance traveled along the incline is d+x=1.20+xd + x = 1.20 + x, so the vertical drop is (1.20+x)sin⁡30∘(1.20 + x)\sin 30^\circ. By energy conservation, mg(1.20+x)sin⁡30∘=12kx2mg(1.20 + x)\sin 30^\circ = \frac{1}{2}kx^2. Substituting values: (0.500)(9.80)(0.5)(1.20+x)=60x2  ⟹  60x2−2.45x−2.94=0(0.500)(9.80)(0.5)(1.20 + x) = 60x^2 \implies 60x^2 - 2.45x - 2.94 = 0. Solving gives x≈0.242 mx \approx 0.242\text{ m}.

03

A vertical spring (k=600 N/mk = 600\text{ N/m}) is compressed by 0.150 m0.150\text{ m} below its equilibrium length by a 0.400 kg0.400\text{ kg} sphere resting on it (not attached). The sphere is released from rest. How high above the uncompressed top of the spring does the sphere rise? Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

Key steps: Let the release position be Ug=0U_g = 0. The sphere leaves the spring when the spring reaches its uncompressed length (having risen by y0=0.150 my_0 = 0.150\text{ m}) and continues upward to a maximum height hh above the uncompressed spring. Total vertical rise from release is y0+hy_0 + h. Energy conservation gives 12ky02=mg(y0+h)\frac{1}{2}ky_0^2 = mg(y_0 + h). Substituting: 12(600)(0.150)2=(0.400)(9.80)(0.150+h)  ⟹  6.75=3.92(0.150+h)  ⟹  0.150+h≈1.722 m\frac{1}{2}(600)(0.150)^2 = (0.400)(9.80)(0.150 + h) \implies 6.75 = 3.92(0.150 + h) \implies 0.150 + h \approx 1.722\text{ m}, so h=1.722−0.150=1.57 mh = 1.722 - 0.150 = 1.57\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…