Resources
A cylindrical glass beaker filled with water to the brim sits on an electronic balance, reading a total system mass of . A solid iron ball of mass and density , suspended from an external rigid stand by a thin thread, is lowered into the water until completely submerged without touching the bottom or walls of the beaker. Water that overflows is collected and removed so the beaker remains filled to the brim. Address the counter-intuitive scenario: (a) calculate the volume of displaced water, (b) calculate the tension in the thread supporting the iron ball, and (c) determine the new reading on the electronic balance while the submerged ball is held suspended.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) ; (c)
Steps
Part (a): Volume of Displaced Water
Because the iron ball is completely submerged, the volume of water displaced, , equals the total volume of the iron ball, :
Substitute the given values:
Part (b): Tension in the Supporting Thread
The submerged iron ball is in static equilibrium under three vertical forces:
- The downward gravitational force:
- The upward tension in the thread:
- The upward buoyant force exerted by the water:
Taking the density of water as , the mass of the displaced water is:
The mass of the iron ball in kilograms is .
Setting the net vertical force to zero:
Using the standard gravitational acceleration :
Part (c): New Reading on the Electronic Balance
An electronic balance measures the normal force exerted on its surface, calibrated to display an equivalent mass .
- Before the ball is lowered:
The scale supports the beaker and the initial water filled to the brim: -
After the ball is submerged and overflow is removed:
- By Archimedes' principle, the water exerts an upward buoyant force on the ball.
- By Newton's third law, the ball exerts an equal and opposite downward reaction force on the water:
- Meanwhile, a volume of water equal to has spilled out and been removed, reducing the water's gravitational weight by .
- Net normal force on the balance:
The loss of weight from the displaced, spilled water is exactly cancelled by the downward reaction force transmitted to the fluid by the suspended ball. Therefore, the balance reading remains unchanged:
(Pitfall to avoid: Do not add the entire mass of the suspended iron ball to the balance. The ball's weight is predominantly supported by the external thread, not the balance. The only force transferred to the fluid is the buoyant reaction force.)
Typical errors
01 The student ignores the downward reaction force of the buoyant force exerted on the liquid by the submerged ball, accounting only for the mass of the lost overflow water.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
While of water overflowed and was removed, the water exerts an upward buoyant force on the ball. By Newton's third law, the ball exerts an equal and opposite downward reaction force on the water. This downward reaction force exactly offsets the weight lost from the spilled water.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the volume of the iron ball and recognized it equals the displaced volume of water.
You correctly set up the equilibrium equation for the suspended ball to find the thread tension.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou omitted the downward reaction force that a submerged object exerts on the surrounding liquid. When fluid exerts an upward buoyant force on a submerged body, Newton's third law requires that the body pushes downward on the fluid with an identical force , which adds directly to the normal force measured by the scale.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Newton's Third Law for Buoyant Force
An upward buoyant force exerted by a fluid on an object is paired with an equal and opposite downward force exerted by the object on the fluid.
When analyzing forces on a container of fluid on a scale, always include a downward force equal to for any partially or fully submerged object.
- Mass-Equivalent Effect on a Scale
An apparent force on the scale changes the reading by .
Sum all mass changes: lost overflow mass () plus the equivalent mass of the downward reaction force () to get .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAccount for the water that overflowed: mass decreased by .
Apply Newton's third law to the fluid system: the submerged ball pushes downward on the water with a force equal to , which adds an equivalent mass of to the scale reading.
Compute the net reading: .
02 The student treats the iron ball as being fully added to the balance system, failing to recognize that the thread supports most of its weight.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
- Step 4Correct
You added the full mass of the iron ball () into the balance reading. Because the ball hangs from an external stand, the thread supports of its weight. By Newton's third law, the only downward force transferred to the beaker system is the reaction to the buoyant force, equal to the weight of the displaced water (). Since of overflow water was removed, the net balance reading remains .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the density and mass to find the volume of the displaced water.
You set up the static equilibrium of the submerged ball properly to calculate the thread tension.
You recognized that water was displaced and removed from the beaker system.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou included the entire gravitational mass of the submerged object in the beaker system's balance reading, failing to account for the fact that the object is supported externally by a thread and transfers only its buoyant reaction force () downward onto the fluid.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify external supports
If an object is suspended by an external thread or stand, its entire weight does not act on the container below.
Always isolate the container-plus-fluid system and only include forces crossing its boundary.
- Apply Newton's third law to buoyancy
A fluid exerts an upward buoyant force on a submerged object, so by Newton's third law, the submerged object pushes down on the fluid with an equal force .
Add an equivalent mass to the balance, never the total mass of the suspended object.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the balance normal force equation: .
Substitute and .
Notice that , so .
03 The student equates the tension in the thread to the full weight of the iron ball, neglecting the upward buoyant force exerted by the displaced water.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You omitted the upward buoyant force acting on the submerged ball. Since the water pushes upward on the ball with buoyant force , the thread only needs to support the apparent weight .
- Step 3
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the volume of the submerged ball using its mass and density.
You accurately identified that the displaced water exerts an upward buoyant force whose reaction pushes down on the fluid.
You correctly balanced the lost water mass against the buoyant reaction force to find the balance reading.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisWhen drawing or formulating the vertical force balance on a suspended submerged object, you equated tension directly to gravitational weight () instead of accounting for the fluid's upward buoyant support ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Free-Body Diagram for Submerged Suspended Object
For a submerged suspended body in static equilibrium, upward forces () must balance the downward gravitational force ().
Always list all upward forces supporting the object; set rather than .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the buoyant force exerted by the water on the ball: .
Set up the equilibrium condition along the vertical axis: .
Solve for the thread tension: .
(a) ; (b) ; (c)
Lock it in
According to Newton's third law, what reaction force corresponds to the upward buoyant force exerted by a fluid on a submerged object?
The object exerts an equal and opposite downward force on the fluid.
Similar question
A beaker containing of water (not filled to the brim) sits on an electronic scale. An aluminum sphere of volume and density is suspended by a string and lowered until completely submerged, without touching the beaker. No water overflows. What is the new reading on the scale? (Take .)
Answer
. Key steps: Because no water spills, the scale supports the original water plus the downward reaction force . The equivalent mass of this reaction force is . Thus, .
A beaker filled to the brim with water sits on a scale reading . A wooden block of mass and density is gently placed on the surface so that it floats freely. The displaced water overflows and is removed. What is the final reading on the scale?
Answer
. Key steps: For a floating object, the buoyant force equals its total weight, so the mass of displaced water equals the object's mass (). The scale loses of overflow water and gains the weight of the block, leaving the balance reading unchanged at .
A beaker filled to the brim with oil (density ) rests on a scale reading . A metal cylinder of mass and volume is suspended from an external spring scale and lowered into the oil until completely submerged. Overflow oil is collected and discarded. Determine (a) the reading on the spring scale supporting the cylinder, and (b) the reading on the bottom electronic scale. (Use .)
Answer
(a) , (b) . Key steps: Displaced oil mass is , giving . (a) Spring scale tension . (b) The bottom scale loses of overflow oil but gains a downward reaction force (), so the bottom scale reading remains .