Resources

Two identical, mutually incoherent motorized air blowers operate simultaneously in a cleanroom. When blower AA operates alone, a monitoring microphone records a sound level of βA=68.0 dB\beta_A = 68.0\text{ dB}. When blower BB operates alone, the sound level is βB=68.0 dB\beta_B = 68.0\text{ dB}. A technician incorrectly predicts that turning both blowers on will double the decibel rating to 136.0 dB136.0\text{ dB}. Determine: (a) the correct total sound level βtotal\beta_{\text{total}} when both blowers run simultaneously, and (b) by how many decibels the sound level changes (Δβ\Delta \beta) if four such identical blowers operate together compared to a single blower.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) βtotal=71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 71.0\text{ dB}; (b) Δβ=+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = +6.02\text{ dB}

Steps

Understanding Sound Intensity and the Decibel Scale

Sound level β\beta measured in decibels (dB\text{dB}) is related to acoustic intensity II by the logarithmic formula:

β=10log⁡10(II0)\beta = 10 \log_{10}\left(\frac{I}{I_0}\right)

where I0=1.0×10−12 W/m2I_0 = 1.0 \times 10^{-12}\text{ W/m}^2 is the standard reference threshold of hearing.

Common Pitfall: Decibel values cannot be added directly (β1+β2≠βtotal\beta_1 + \beta_2 \neq \beta_{\text{total}}). Because decibels represent a logarithmic ratio of intensities, doubling the sound sources does not double the decibel value. Instead, for mutually incoherent sound sources, their physical intensities add linearly:

Itotal=I1+I2+⋯+InI_{\text{total}} = I_1 + I_2 + \dots + I_n


Part (a): Total Sound Level with Two Blowers

  1. Express the total intensity:
    Since the two blowers are identical and incoherent, each produces an intensity I1I_1. Running both gives: Itotal=IA+IB=2I1I_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_B = 2I_1
  2. Compute the resulting sound level βtotal\beta_{\text{total}}:
    Using the logarithmic property log⁡10(x⋅y)=log⁡10(x)+log⁡10(y)\log_{10}(x \cdot y) = \log_{10}(x) + \log_{10}(y): βtotal=10log⁡10(2I1I0)=10log⁡10(I1I0)+10log⁡10(2)\beta_{\text{total}} = 10 \log_{10}\left(\frac{2I_1}{I_0}\right) = 10 \log_{10}\left(\frac{I_1}{I_0}\right) + 10 \log_{10}(2)

    Substitute β1=10log⁡10(I1I0)=68.0 dB\beta_1 = 10 \log_{10}\left(\frac{I_1}{I_0}\right) = 68.0\text{ dB}: βtotal=β1+10log⁡10(2)\beta_{\text{total}} = \beta_1 + 10 \log_{10}(2) βtotal=68.0 dB+10(0.30103) dB=68.0 dB+3.01 dB≈71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 68.0\text{ dB} + 10(0.30103)\text{ dB} = 68.0\text{ dB} + 3.01\text{ dB} \approx 71.0\text{ dB}


Part (b): Change in Sound Level for Four Blowers

  1. Relate four blowers to one blower:
    Operating four identical blowers quadruples the total intensity: I4=4I1I_4 = 4I_1
  2. Calculate the difference Δβ\Delta \beta:
    Δβ=β4−β1=10log⁡10(4I1I0)−10log⁡10(I1I0)\Delta \beta = \beta_4 - \beta_1 = 10 \log_{10}\left(\frac{4I_1}{I_0}\right) - 10 \log_{10}\left(\frac{I_1}{I_0}\right)

    Using the quotient rule of logarithms: Δβ=10log⁡10(4I1I1)=10log⁡10(4)\Delta \beta = 10 \log_{10}\left(\frac{4I_1}{I_1}\right) = 10 \log_{10}(4) Δβ=10(0.60206) dB≈+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = 10(0.60206)\text{ dB} \approx +6.02\text{ dB}

Each doubling of sound intensity adds approximately 3.01 dB3.01\text{ dB}, so quadrupling the intensity adds 2×3.01 dB=+6.02 dB2 \times 3.01\text{ dB} = +6.02\text{ dB}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student directly adds decibel levels together linearly instead of adding sound intensities, leading to a doubled sound level for two blowers and four times the decibels for four blowers.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    βtotal=βA+βB  ⟹  βtotal=68.0 dB+68.0 dB=136.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = \beta_A + \beta_B \implies \beta_{\text{total}} = 68.0\text{ dB} + 68.0\text{ dB} = 136.0\text{ dB}

    Correct

    Itotal=IA+IB=2I1  ⟹  βtotal=β1+10log⁡10(2)=68.0 dB+3.01 dB≈71.0 dBI_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_B = 2I_1 \implies \beta_{\text{total}} = \beta_1 + 10\log_{10}(2) = 68.0\text{ dB} + 3.01\text{ dB} \approx 71.0\text{ dB}

    Decibel levels cannot be added directly because the decibel scale is logarithmic. For mutually incoherent sources, you must add sound intensities linearly (Itotal=IA+IB=2I1I_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_B = 2I_1), which corresponds to adding 10log⁡10(2)≈3.01 dB10\log_{10}(2) \approx 3.01\text{ dB} to the single-blower level.

  2. Step 2

    β4=4⋅68.0 dB=272.0 dB  ⟹  Δβ=β4−β1=272.0 dB−68.0 dB=204.0 dB\beta_4 = 4 \cdot 68.0\text{ dB} = 272.0\text{ dB} \implies \Delta \beta = \beta_4 - \beta_1 = 272.0\text{ dB} - 68.0\text{ dB} = 204.0\text{ dB}

    Correct

    I4=4I1  ⟹  Δβ=10log⁡10(4I1I1)=10log⁡10(4)≈+6.02 dBI_4 = 4I_1 \implies \Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}\left(\frac{4I_1}{I_1}\right) = 10\log_{10}(4) \approx +6.02\text{ dB}

    Operating four identical blowers quadruples the total acoustic intensity (I4=4I1I_4 = 4I_1), not the decibel value. The resulting sound level increase is Δβ=10log⁡10(4)≈+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}(4) \approx +6.02\text{ dB}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that part (b) requires evaluating the difference Δβ=β4−β1\Delta \beta = \beta_4 - \beta_1 between the four-source sound level and the single-source sound level.

You performed arithmetic calculations accurately according to your chosen linear model.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Linear addition of logarithmic quantities

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed sound levels in decibels obey linear superposition, overlooking that decibels represent a logarithmic ratio of intensities where physical intensities sum linearly, resulting in fixed decibel shifts for multiplicative factor increases.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Linear vs. Logarithmic Superposition
  • For nn identical incoherent sound sources of intensity I1I_1, Itotal=nI1I_{\text{total}} = nI_1, and βtotal=β1+10log⁡10(n)\beta_{\text{total}} = \beta_1 + 10\log_{10}(n).

  • Never add or multiply decibels directly; convert to intensity, sum the intensities, and convert back to decibels using logarithmic identities.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express total intensity for two identical sources: Itotal=IA+IB=2I1I_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_B = 2I_1.

  2. Apply the decibel definition: βtotal=10log⁡10(2I1I0)=10log⁡10(I1I0)+10log⁡10(2)=68.0 dB+3.01 dB≈71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 10\log_{10}\left(\frac{2I_1}{I_0}\right) = 10\log_{10}\left(\frac{I_1}{I_0}\right) + 10\log_{10}(2) = 68.0\text{ dB} + 3.01\text{ dB} \approx 71.0\text{ dB}.

  3. Express total intensity for four identical sources: I4=4I1I_4 = 4I_1.

  4. Compute the change in sound level: Δβ=10log⁡10(4I1I1)=10log⁡10(4)=20log⁡10(2)≈+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}\left(\frac{4I_1}{I_1}\right) = 10\log_{10}(4) = 20\log_{10}(2) \approx +6.02\text{ dB}.

Final answer

(a) βtotal=71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 71.0\text{ dB}; (b) Δβ=+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = +6.02\text{ dB}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember the rule of thumb: doubling sound intensity adds approximately +3.0 dB+3.0\text{ dB}, and quadrupling adds +6.0 dB+6.0\text{ dB}.

  • Practice problems combining non-identical incoherent sound sources by converting each source's decibel rating back into absolute intensity II first.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly uses the 20·log10 factor from voltage or sound pressure instead of the 10·log10 factor for sound intensity, resulting in an increase of 6.0 dB for two blowers and 12.0 dB for four blowers.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Itotal=2⋅II_{\text{total}} = 2 \cdot I

  2. Step 2

    βtotal=β+20⋅log⁡10(2)  ⟹  βtotal=68.0 dB+6.0 dB=74.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = \beta + 20 \cdot \log_{10}(2) \implies \beta_{\text{total}} = 68.0\text{ dB} + 6.0\text{ dB} = 74.0\text{ dB}

    Correct

    βtotal=β+10⋅log⁡10(2)=68.0 dB+3.01 dB≈71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = \beta + 10 \cdot \log_{10}(2) = 68.0\text{ dB} + 3.01\text{ dB} \approx 71.0\text{ dB}

    Sound intensity level is defined using a multiplier of 1010, β=10log⁡10(I/I0)\beta = 10\log_{10}(I/I_0), because intensity is a power-like quantity. Using 20log⁡1020\log_{10} applies to root-power field quantities such as sound pressure or voltage, not sound intensity.

  3. Step 3

    Δβ=20⋅log⁡10(4)  ⟹  Δβ=20⋅0.602=12.0 dB\Delta \beta = 20 \cdot \log_{10}(4) \implies \Delta \beta = 20 \cdot 0.602 = 12.0\text{ dB}

    Correct

    Δβ=10⋅log⁡10(4)=10⋅0.602=+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = 10 \cdot \log_{10}(4) = 10 \cdot 0.602 = +6.02\text{ dB}

    Operating four identical blowers quadruples the intensity (I4=4II_4 = 4I), so the change in decibels should be 10log⁡10(4)≈+6.02 dB10\log_{10}(4) \approx +6.02\text{ dB} rather than 20log⁡10(4)20\log_{10}(4).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly realized that decibel values cannot be added directly.

You correctly added the physical intensities linearly for independent incoherent sources.

You set up the logarithmic ratio change correctly using properties of logarithms.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Sound Intensity Level ($10\log$) with Sound Pressure Level ($20\log$)

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You used the 20log⁡1020\log_{10} multiplier (which applies to field or amplitude quantities like sound pressure p/p0p/p_0 or electric voltage V/V0V/V_0) instead of the 10log⁡1010\log_{10} multiplier required for power and intensity quantities (I/I0I/I_0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power vs. Amplitude Logarithmic Multipliers
  • Power and intensity quantities use 10log⁡10(P/P0)10\log_{10}(P/P_0) or 10log⁡10(I/I0)10\log_{10}(I/I_0), whereas field/amplitude quantities (pressure, voltage) use 20log⁡10(A/A0)20\log_{10}(A/A_0) because intensity is proportional to amplitude squared (I∝p2I \propto p^2).

  • Whenever you are dealing directly with sound intensity II or power PP, always write 10log⁡1010\log_{10}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For part (a), doubling the intensity gives Δβ=10log⁡10(2)≈3.01 dB\Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}(2) \approx 3.01\text{ dB}. Adding this to the single-blower level yields βtotal=68.0 dB+3.01 dB≈71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 68.0\text{ dB} + 3.01\text{ dB} \approx 71.0\text{ dB}.

  2. For part (b), quadrupling the intensity gives Δβ=10log⁡10(4)=10(0.602)≈+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}(4) = 10(0.602) \approx +6.02\text{ dB}.

Final answer

(a) βtotal=71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 71.0\text{ dB}; (b) Δβ=+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = +6.02\text{ dB}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize that each doubling of sound intensity adds approximately 3.01 dB3.01\text{ dB}, not 6.02 dB6.02\text{ dB}.

  • Before writing the decibel formula, verify whether your given variable is an intensity/power (10log⁡10\log) or a pressure/amplitude (20log⁡20\log).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the final decibel level for four blowers (74.0 dB) rather than the requested decibel change (Δβ = 6.0 dB).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Itotal=2⋅IA  ⟹  βtotal=68.0 dB+10⋅log⁡10(2)  ⟹  βtotal=68.0 dB+3.0 dB=71.0 dBI_{\text{total}} = 2 \cdot I_A \implies \beta_{\text{total}} = 68.0\text{ dB} + 10 \cdot \log_{10}(2) \implies \beta_{\text{total}} = 68.0\text{ dB} + 3.0\text{ dB} = 71.0\text{ dB}

  2. Step 2

    I4=4⋅IAI_4 = 4 \cdot I_A

  3. Step 3

    Δβ=68.0 dB+10⋅log⁡10(4)=68.0 dB+6.0 dB=74.0 dB\Delta \beta = 68.0\text{ dB} + 10\cdot \log_{10}(4) = 68.0\text{ dB} + 6.0\text{ dB} = 74.0\text{ dB}

    Correct

    Δβ=β4−β1=10log⁡10(4)≈+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = \beta_4 - \beta_1 = 10\log_{10}(4) \approx +6.02\text{ dB}

    The question asks by how many decibels the sound level changes (Δβ\Delta \beta), not for the final decibel rating. You calculated β4=β1+Δβ=74.0 dB\beta_4 = \beta_1 + \Delta \beta = 74.0\text{ dB} instead of stating the difference Δβ=+6.0 dB\Delta \beta = +6.0\text{ dB} (or +6.02 dB+6.02\text{ dB}).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly added incoherent sound intensities linearly rather than adding decibel values directly.

You applied the logarithmic rule β=β1+10log⁡10(N)\beta = \beta_1 + 10\log_{10}(N) accurately for both two and four sound sources.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Target Variable Confusion (Total Level vs. Level Difference)

You calculated the final total sound level β4\beta_4 instead of stopping at the sound level increase Δβ\Delta \beta.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the absolute sound level βN=β1+10log⁡10(N)\beta_N = \beta_1 + 10\log_{10}(N) with the change in sound level Δβ=10log⁡10(N)\Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}(N). When asked for a change (Δβ\Delta \beta), you only need the logarithmic ratio term.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish Level vs. Change
  • Absolute sound level is β=10log⁡10(I/I0)\beta = 10\log_{10}(I/I_0), whereas a change in sound level is Δβ=β2−β1=10log⁡10(I2/I1)\Delta \beta = \beta_2 - \beta_1 = 10\log_{10}(I_2/I_1).

  • Check whether the prompt asks for the new total reading β\beta or the change Δβ\Delta \beta. If it asks for Δβ\Delta \beta, do not add the initial base decibels.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Δβ=β4−βA=10log⁡10(I4IA)\Delta \beta = \beta_4 - \beta_A = 10\log_{10}\left(\frac{I_4}{I_A}\right)

  2. Δβ=10log⁡10(4)=10×0.60206 dB≈+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}(4) = 10 \times 0.60206\text{ dB} \approx +6.02\text{ dB}

Final answer

(a) βtotal=71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 71.0\text{ dB}; (b) Δβ=+6.02 dB\Delta \beta = +6.02\text{ dB} (or +6.0 dB+6.0\text{ dB})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review whether each problem sub-part requests an absolute quantity (XX) or an incremental difference (ΔX\Delta X).

  • Practice computing decibel differences directly using Δβ=10log⁡10(I2/I1)\Delta \beta = 10\log_{10}(I_2/I_1) without computing or adding the baseline decibel value.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A single violin plays at a sound level of 65.0 dB65.0\text{ dB}. If three more identical violins join in, playing at the exact same intensity (so there are 44 violins in total), what is the total sound level?

Answer

71.0 dB71.0\text{ dB}. Key steps: Quadrupling the intensity gives βtotal=β1+10log⁡10(4)=65.0 dB+6.02 dB≈71.0 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = \beta_1 + 10\log_{10}(4) = 65.0\text{ dB} + 6.02\text{ dB} \approx 71.0\text{ dB}.

02

A factory workshop contains 1010 identical machines running simultaneously, producing a total sound level of 85.0 dB85.0\text{ dB}. What was the sound level produced by just one machine running alone?

Answer

75.0 dB75.0\text{ dB}. Key steps: Total intensity is I10=10I1I_{10} = 10 I_1, so β10=β1+10log⁡10(10)=β1+10.0 dB\beta_{10} = \beta_1 + 10\log_{10}(10) = \beta_1 + 10.0\text{ dB}. Thus, β1=85.0 dB−10.0 dB=75.0 dB\beta_1 = 85.0\text{ dB} - 10.0\text{ dB} = 75.0\text{ dB}.

03

Two independent sound sources have sound levels of β1=60.0 dB\beta_1 = 60.0\text{ dB} and β2=63.0 dB\beta_2 = 63.0\text{ dB}. Determine the combined sound level βtotal\beta_{\text{total}} when both operate at the same time.

Answer

64.8 dB64.8\text{ dB}. Key steps: Convert to relative intensities: I1=I0×106.0=1.0×106I0I_1 = I_0 \times 10^{6.0} = 1.0\times 10^6 I_0 and I2=I0×106.3≈1.995×106I0I_2 = I_0 \times 10^{6.3} \approx 1.995\times 10^6 I_0. Sum intensities: Itotal=I1+I2≈2.995×106I0I_{\text{total}} = I_1 + I_2 \approx 2.995\times 10^6 I_0. Convert back: βtotal=10log⁡10(2.995×106)≈64.8 dB\beta_{\text{total}} = 10\log_{10}(2.995\times 10^6) \approx 64.8\text{ dB}.

Loading workspace…