Resources

An optical spectrometer measures the intensity II of light transmitted through a gaseous absorbing medium across path length xx. The standard Beer-Lambert model predicts I(x)=I0e−αxI(x) = I_0 e^{-\alpha x}. A student explores the asymptotic limit of thin absorbers (where αx≪1\alpha x \ll 1) using the first-order Taylor expansion e−αx≈1−αxe^{-\alpha x} \approx 1 - \alpha x, which predicts a linear fractional absorption A(x)=I0−I(x)I0≈αxA(x) = \frac{I_0 - I(x)}{I_0} \approx \alpha x. For a gas with attenuation coefficient α=0.400 m−1\alpha = 0.400\text{ m}^{-1}, determine: (a) the maximum path length xmaxx_{\text{max}} in meters for which the linear approximation underestimates the true fractional absorption by no more than an absolute error of 0.01000.0100 (i.e., ∣(1−e−αx)−αx∣≤0.0100|(1 - e^{-\alpha x}) - \alpha x| \le 0.0100), and (b) the asymptotic limit of I(x)/I0I(x)/I_0 as x→∞x \to \infty.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) xmax=0.366 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.366\text{ m}; (b) lim⁡x→∞I(x)I0=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{I(x)}{I_0} = 0

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Maximum Path Length xmaxx_{\text{max}}

  1. Formulate the error condition: According to the Beer-Lambert law, the true transmitted intensity is: I(x)=I0e−αxI(x) = I_0 e^{-\alpha x} The true fractional absorption is defined as: Atrue(x)=I0−I(x)I0=1−e−αxA_{\text{true}}(x) = \frac{I_0 - I(x)}{I_0} = 1 - e^{-\alpha x} Using the first-order Taylor expansion for a thin absorber (αx≪1\alpha x \ll 1), e−αx≈1−αxe^{-\alpha x} \approx 1 - \alpha x, giving the linear approximation: Alin(x)=αxA_{\text{lin}}(x) = \alpha x The absolute error ΔA(x)\Delta A(x) between the linear model and the true absorption is: ΔA(x)=∣Atrue(x)−Alin(x)∣=∣(1−e−αx)−αx∣\Delta A(x) = \left| A_{\text{true}}(x) - A_{\text{lin}}(x) \right| = \left| (1 - e^{-\alpha x}) - \alpha x \right| Since e−u≥1−ue^{-u} \ge 1 - u for all u≥0u \ge 0, we have αx≥1−e−αx\alpha x \ge 1 - e^{-\alpha x}, so: ΔA(x)=αx−1+e−αx\Delta A(x) = \alpha x - 1 + e^{-\alpha x}
  2. Set up the threshold equation: We require the error to satisfy ΔA(x)≤0.0100\Delta A(x) \le 0.0100. The maximum path length xmaxx_{\text{max}} occurs at the equality: αx−1+e−αx=0.0100\alpha x - 1 + e^{-\alpha x} = 0.0100 Let u=αxu = \alpha x. The equation becomes: u−1+e−u=0.0100u - 1 + e^{-u} = 0.0100
  3. Solve for uu and xmaxx_{\text{max}}:

    • Initial estimate using series expansion: Expanding e−u≈1−u+u22e^{-u} \approx 1 - u + \frac{u^2}{2}: u−1+(1−u+u22)≈u22=0.0100  ⟹  u≈0.0200≈0.1414u - 1 + \left(1 - u + \frac{u^2}{2}\right) \approx \frac{u^2}{2} = 0.0100 \implies u \approx \sqrt{0.0200} \approx 0.1414
    • Refinement / Exact numerical solution: Solving u−1+e−u=0.0100u - 1 + e^{-u} = 0.0100 accounting for higher-order terms yields: u≈0.1464u \approx 0.1464
    • Convert to path length xmaxx_{\text{max}}: Using the given attenuation coefficient α=0.400 m−1\alpha = 0.400\text{ m}^{-1}: xmax=uα=0.14640.400 m−1≈0.366 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{u}{\alpha} = \frac{0.1464}{0.400\text{ m}^{-1}} \approx 0.366\text{ m}

Part (b): Asymptotic Limit as x→∞x \to \infty

  1. Evaluate the ratio: The normalized transmitted intensity is: I(x)I0=e−αx\frac{I(x)}{I_0} = e^{-\alpha x}
  2. Compute the limit: Since α=0.400 m−1>0\alpha = 0.400\text{ m}^{-1} > 0, as the path length xx approaches infinity: lim⁡x→∞I(x)I0=lim⁡x→∞e−αx=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{I(x)}{I_0} = \lim_{x \to \infty} e^{-\alpha x} = 0 Physically, an infinitely thick medium absorbs all incoming incident radiation, resulting in zero transmission.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student omits the factor of 1/2 in the second-order Taylor series expansion when approximating the error term, leading to (αx)² = 0.0100 instead of (αx)²/2 = 0.0100.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Error=∣(1−e−αx)−αx∣≈(αx)2\text{Error} = |(1 - e^{-\alpha x}) - \alpha x| \approx (\alpha x)^2

    Correct

    Error=∣(1−e−αx)−αx∣≈(αx)22\text{Error} = |(1 - e^{-\alpha x}) - \alpha x| \approx \frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2}

    You expanded the exponential function but omitted the factorial denominator 2!=22! = 2 in the second-order term. Because e−u=1−u+u22−u36+…e^{-u} = 1 - u + \frac{u^2}{2} - \frac{u^3}{6} + \dots, the leading-order difference is ∣(1−(1−u+u22))−u∣=u22=(αx)22|(1 - (1 - u + \frac{u^2}{2})) - u| = \frac{u^2}{2} = \frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2}, not (αx)2(\alpha x)^2.

  2. Step 2

    (αx)2=0.0100  ⟹  αx=0.100  ⟹  xmax=0.250 m(\alpha x)^2 = 0.0100 \implies \alpha x = 0.100 \implies x_{\text{max}} = 0.250\text{ m}

    Correct

    (αx)22=0.0100  ⟹  αx≈0.1414\frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2} = 0.0100 \implies \alpha x \approx 0.1414 (or exact numerical u−1+e−u=0.0100  ⟹  αx≈0.1464u - 1 + e^{-u} = 0.0100 \implies \alpha x \approx 0.1464), giving xmax=0.14640.400 m−1≈0.366 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{0.1464}{0.400\text{ m}^{-1}} \approx 0.366\text{ m}

    Your algebra and substitution of α=0.400 m−1\alpha = 0.400\text{ m}^{-1} were carried out correctly, but the result was shifted because it was calculated from the incorrect quadratic approximation in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    lim⁡x→∞I(x)I0=lim⁡x→∞e−0.400x=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{I(x)}{I_0} = \lim_{x \to \infty} e^{-0.400x} = 0

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the linear model approximation error is given by ∣(1−e−αx)−αx∣|(1 - e^{-\alpha x}) - \alpha x|.

You correctly solved for xx by dividing αx\alpha x by α=0.400 m−1\alpha = 0.400\text{ m}^{-1}.

You correctly evaluated the infinite-thickness asymptotic limit in part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Taylor Series Coefficient

You approximated ∣(1−e−αx)−αx∣|(1 - e^{-\alpha x}) - \alpha x| as (αx)2(\alpha x)^2 instead of (αx)22\frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You recalled the power (αx)2(\alpha x)^2 for the next non-vanishing term in the series but overlooked the 1n!=12!=12\frac{1}{n!} = \frac{1}{2!} = \frac{1}{2} coefficient associated with quadratic terms in Maclaurin series expansions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Maclaurin Series Expansion of $e^{-u}$
  • For any small dimensionless variable u≪1u \ll 1, e−u=1−u+u22!−u33!+…e^{-u} = 1 - u + \frac{u^2}{2!} - \frac{u^3}{3!} + \dots

  • Always write out the first three terms explicitly with factorials before truncating: e−u≈1−u+u22e^{-u} \approx 1 - u + \frac{u^2}{2}.

Truncation Error Estimate
  • When subtracting a linear truncation 1−u1 - u from e−ue^{-u}, the residual error at leading order is u22\frac{u^2}{2}, not u2u^2.

  • Verify the error term: ∣(1−e−u)−u∣=∣u−(1−e−u)∣≈u22|(1 - e^{-u}) - u| = |u - (1 - e^{-u})| \approx \frac{u^2}{2}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the second-order expansion: e−αx≈1−αx+(αx)22e^{-\alpha x} \approx 1 - \alpha x + \frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2}.

  2. Substitute into the error expression: ∣(1−e−αx)−αx∣≈∣1−(1−αx+(αx)22)−αx∣=(αx)22|(1 - e^{-\alpha x}) - \alpha x| \approx \left| 1 - \left(1 - \alpha x + \frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2}\right) - \alpha x \right| = \frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2}.

  3. Equate the leading-order error to the tolerance: (αx)22=0.0100  ⟹  (αx)2=0.0200  ⟹  αx≈0.1414\frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2} = 0.0100 \implies (\alpha x)^2 = 0.0200 \implies \alpha x \approx 0.1414.

  4. Refining with the exact equation αx−1+e−αx=0.0100\alpha x - 1 + e^{-\alpha x} = 0.0100 gives αx≈0.1464\alpha x \approx 0.1464.

  5. Calculate xmax=0.14640.400 m−1≈0.366 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{0.1464}{0.400\text{ m}^{-1}} \approx 0.366\text{ m}.

Final answer

(a) xmax≈0.366 mx_{\text{max}} \approx 0.366\text{ m}; (b) lim⁡x→∞I(x)I0=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{I(x)}{I_0} = 0

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice deriving leading-order error terms for standard functions (exe^x, sin⁡x\sin x, cos⁡x\cos x, ln⁡(1+x)\ln(1+x)) paying careful attention to factorial denominators.

  • Use quadratic approximations u22=ϵ\frac{u^2}{2} = \epsilon as a quick sanity check before refining with numerical methods.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student applies the linear approximation A(x) ≈ αx at infinity instead of the physical exponential model, incorrectly finding that transmitted intensity ratio tends to negative infinity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Error\text{Error} ≈\approx (αx)22\frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2} = 0.0100   ⟹  \implies (α\alpha x)^2 = 0.0200   ⟹  \implies α\alpha x = 0.1414   ⟹  \implies x_{max\text{max}} = 0.14140.400\frac{0.1414}{0.400} = 0.354 m\text{ m}_

  2. Step 2

    I(x)I0\frac{I(x)}{I_0} ≈\approx 1 - α\alpha x   ⟹  \implies $\lim_{x →\to ∞\infty}$ (1 - \alpha x) = -\infty_

    Correct

    $\lim_{x →\to ∞\infty} \frac{I(x)}{I_0} = \\lim_{x \to \infty} e^{-\alpha$ x} = 0_

    You applied the linear approximation 1−αx1 - \alpha x outside its domain of validity. The Taylor series expansion requires αx≪1\alpha x \ll 1, so it breaks down as x→∞x \to \infty. For asymptotic limits, you must return to the full physical model e−αxe^{-\alpha x}, which approaches 00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the lowest-order error of the linear approximation comes from the quadratic term (αx)22\frac{(\alpha x)^2}{2}.

You correctly solved for αx\alpha x and divided by α=0.400 m−1\alpha = 0.400\text{ m}^{-1} to find a path length estimate.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Domain of Validity of Approximations
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You evaluated an asymptotic limit at infinity using a local Taylor approximation valid only near zero (αx≪1\alpha x \ll 1), producing an unphysical negative infinite intensity rather than applying the exact exponential decay model.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Domain of Validity Check
  • A Taylor polynomial is a local approximation valid only when the expansion variable is much smaller than unity (u≪1u \ll 1).

  • Always verify whether the variable satisfies u≪1u \ll 1 before substituting an approximation into an equation or limit.

Asymptotic Limits in Physical Models
  • Global or asymptotic behavior (x→∞x \to \infty) must be evaluated using the exact physical function, not a local expansion.

  • Return to the fundamental governing equation (I(x)=I0e−αxI(x) = I_0 e^{-\alpha x}) whenever evaluating limits at boundaries or infinity.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the exact physical model for normalized intensity: I(x)I0=e−αx\frac{I(x)}{I_0} = e^{-\alpha x}.

  2. Note that the linear approximation 1−αx1 - \alpha x is restricted to thin absorbers where αx≪1\alpha x \ll 1 and cannot be used as x→∞x \to \infty.

  3. Evaluate the limit of the exact model: since α=0.400 m−1>0\alpha = 0.400\text{ m}^{-1} > 0, lim⁡x→∞e−αx=0\lim_{x \to \infty} e^{-\alpha x} = 0.

Final answer

(a) xmax=0.366 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.366\text{ m} (or 0.354 m0.354\text{ m} via second-order approximation); (b) lim⁡x→∞I(x)I0=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{I(x)}{I_0} = 0

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the region of validity for Taylor expansions and always state the condition (such as αx≪1\alpha x \ll 1) before using them.

  • Whenever an approximation predicts an unphysical quantity (like negative light intensity), treat it as an immediate signal that the model has been pushed outside its valid domain.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An engineer models the small-strain displacement of a damping strut using y(t)=1−cos⁡(ωt)y(t) = 1 - \cos(\omega t). For small angles, the linear term vanishes and the leading approximation is quadratic. (a) State the second-order Taylor expansion for 1−cos⁡(ωt)1 - \cos(\omega t). (b) If ω=2.0 rad/s\omega = 2.0\text{ rad/s}, find the maximum time tmaxt_{\text{max}} such that the approximation y(t)≈12(ωt)2y(t) \approx \frac{1}{2}(\omega t)^2 remains valid with an absolute truncation error ∣(1−cos⁡(ωt))−12(ωt)2∣≤0.0050|(1 - \cos(\omega t)) - \frac{1}{2}(\omega t)^2| \le 0.0050.

Answer

(a) 1−cos⁡(ωt)≈12(ωt)21 - \cos(\omega t) \approx \frac{1}{2}(\omega t)^2. (b) The next non-zero term in the Taylor expansion of cos⁡(u)\cos(u) is +u424+\frac{u^4}{24}. Thus, the truncation error is (ωt)424=0.0050  ⟹  (ωt)4=0.120  ⟹  ωt=(0.120)1/4≈0.5886\frac{(\omega t)^4}{24} = 0.0050 \implies (\omega t)^4 = 0.120 \implies \omega t = (0.120)^{1/4} \approx 0.5886. With ω=2.0 rad/s\omega = 2.0\text{ rad/s}, tmax=0.58862.0≈0.294 st_{\text{max}} = \frac{0.5886}{2.0} \approx 0.294\text{ s}.

02

A radiation detector measures the attenuation of gamma rays through lead shielding of thickness zz (in cm) with linear attenuation coefficient μ=0.500 cm−1\mu = 0.500\text{ cm}^{-1}. The fractional transmission is T(z)=e−μzT(z) = e^{-\mu z}. A student uses the linear approximation Tlin(z)=1−μzT_{\text{lin}}(z) = 1 - \mu z. Determine: (a) the leading-order Taylor expression for the difference T(z)−Tlin(z)T(z) - T_{\text{lin}}(z), and (b) the maximum shield thickness zz for which this difference does not exceed 0.02000.0200.

Answer

(a) Since e−μz=1−μz+(μz)22−…e^{-\mu z} = 1 - \mu z + \frac{(\mu z)^2}{2} - \dots, the difference is T(z)−Tlin(z)≈(μz)22T(z) - T_{\text{lin}}(z) \approx \frac{(\mu z)^2}{2}. (b) Set (μz)22=0.0200  ⟹  (μz)2=0.0400  ⟹  μz=0.200\frac{(\mu z)^2}{2} = 0.0200 \implies (\mu z)^2 = 0.0400 \implies \mu z = 0.200. With μ=0.500 cm−1\mu = 0.500\text{ cm}^{-1}, z=0.2000.500=0.400 cmz = \frac{0.200}{0.500} = 0.400\text{ cm} (or using the exact relation e−μz−(1−μz)=0.0200e^{-\mu z} - (1 - \mu z) = 0.0200, μz≈0.215  ⟹  z≈0.430 cm\mu z \approx 0.215 \implies z \approx 0.430\text{ cm}).

03

A spectrophotometer cell filled with a dye solution has absorbance defined by A=−log⁡10(I/I0)=αxln⁡(10)A = -\log_{10}(I/I_0) = \frac{\alpha x}{\ln(10)}. In dilute solutions, the transmission ratio is often estimated as I/I0≈1−αxI/I_0 \approx 1 - \alpha x. (a) Determine whether the linear model underestimates or overestimates the actual transmission ratio e−αxe^{-\alpha x} for any αx>0\alpha x > 0. (b) For α=1.20 m−1\alpha = 1.20\text{ m}^{-1}, find the path length xx at which the relative error ∣e−αx−(1−αx)∣e−αx\frac{|e^{-\alpha x} - (1 - \alpha x)|}{e^{-\alpha x}} reaches exactly 5.0%5.0\%.

Answer

(a) Since e−u>1−ue^{-u} > 1 - u for all u>0u > 0, the linear model 1−αx1 - \alpha x strictly underestimates the true transmission ratio e−αxe^{-\alpha x}. (b) The relative error condition is e−αx−(1−αx)e−αx=1−(1−αx)eαx=0.050\frac{e^{-\alpha x} - (1 - \alpha x)}{e^{-\alpha x}} = 1 - (1 - \alpha x)e^{\alpha x} = 0.050. For small u=αxu = \alpha x, expanding gives u2/21−u≈u22≈0.050  ⟹  u≈0.10≈0.316\frac{u^2/2}{1 - u} \approx \frac{u^2}{2} \approx 0.050 \implies u \approx \sqrt{0.10} \approx 0.316. Solving (1−u)eu=0.950(1 - u)e^u = 0.950 numerically gives u=αx≈0.311u = \alpha x \approx 0.311. Thus, x=0.3111.20 m−1≈0.259 mx = \frac{0.311}{1.20\text{ m}^{-1}} \approx 0.259\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…