Resources

A high-speed electric locomotive travels along a level track against an aerodynamic drag force given by Fdrag=bv2F_{\text{drag}} = b v^2, where b=3.60 N⋅s2/m2b = 3.60\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}^2/\text{m}^2. Rolling resistance is negligible. The locomotive operates at a steady initial speed of v1=30.0 m/sv_1 = 30.0\text{ m/s}. A student conjectures that doubling the locomotive's cruising speed to v2=60.0 m/sv_2 = 60.0\text{ m/s} requires doubling the mechanical output power delivered to the wheels (P2=2P1P_2 = 2 P_1). Evaluate this claim by deriving the power dependence on speed, calculate the actual ratio P2/P1P_2 / P_1, and determine the exact mechanical power P2P_2 required at 60.0 m/s60.0\text{ m/s}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

The student's claim is incorrect because mechanical power scales with the cube of speed (P=bv3P = b v^3); P2/P1=8.00P_2 / P_1 = 8.00, and P2=7.78×105 WP_2 = 7.78\times 10^5\text{ W} (or 778 kW778\text{ kW}).

Steps

01

Derive the Power Dependence on Velocity

For an object moving at a constant velocity vv, the net force acting on it is zero according to Newton's first law. Therefore, the driving force FdriveF_{\text{drive}} supplied by the locomotive must exactly balance the opposing aerodynamic drag force FdragF_{\text{drag}}:

Fdrive=Fdrag=bv2F_{\text{drive}} = F_{\text{drag}} = b v^2

Mechanical power PP delivered to overcome a resistance force at a constant velocity is defined as the rate of doing work:

P=Fdrive⋅vP = F_{\text{drive}} \cdot v

Substituting the expression for the drag force:

P=(bv2)⋅v=bv3P = (b v^2) \cdot v = b v^3

Thus, the mechanical power required to overcome aerodynamic drag is directly proportional to the cube of the speed (P∝v3P \propto v^3), not to the speed itself.


02

Evaluate the Student's Claim and Find the Ratio P2/P1P_2 / P_1

The student conjectured that doubling the speed doubles the required power (P2=2P1P_2 = 2P_1).

Using the derived cubic relationship, compare the power at speed v2v_2 to that at speed v1v_1:

P2P1=bv23bv13=(v2v1)3\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \frac{b v_2^3}{b v_1^3} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^3

Given v1=30.0 m/sv_1 = 30.0\text{ m/s} and v2=60.0 m/sv_2 = 60.0\text{ m/s}:

v2v1=60.0 m/s30.0 m/s=2.00\frac{v_2}{v_1} = \frac{60.0\text{ m/s}}{30.0\text{ m/s}} = 2.00

P2P1=(2.00)3=8.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = (2.00)^3 = 8.00

The student's claim is incorrect. Doubling the cruising speed increases the required power by a factor of 8.008.00, not 22.

Common Pitfall: A common mistake is confusing force with power. While the drag force scales with the square of the speed (F∝v2F \propto v^2, so the force quadruples), the engine must apply that quadrupled force over twice the distance each second (P=F⋅vP = F \cdot v), leading to a factor of 22⋅2=82^2 \cdot 2 = 8.


03

Calculate the Mechanical Power P2P_2 at 60.0 m/s60.0\text{ m/s}

Substitute b=3.60 N⋅s2/m2b = 3.60\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}^2/\text{m}^2 and v2=60.0 m/sv_2 = 60.0\text{ m/s} into the power equation:

P2=bv23=(3.60 N⋅s2/m2)⋅(60.0 m/s)3P_2 = b v_2^3 = (3.60\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}^2/\text{m}^2) \cdot (60.0\text{ m/s})^3

P2=3.60⋅216,000 W=777,600 W≈7.78×105 W (or 778 kW)P_2 = 3.60 \cdot 216{,}000\text{ W} = 777{,}600\text{ W} \approx 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W}\text{ (or } 778\text{ kW)}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses force with power by assuming P = F = b v², resulting in a quadratic dependence on speed instead of a cubic one.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    P=bv2P = b v^2

    Correct

    P=F⋅v=(bv2)⋅v=bv3P = F \cdot v = (b v^2) \cdot v = b v^3

    You set power equal to the drag force expression bv2b v^2. Mechanical power delivered to sustain steady speed is defined as work per unit time, which equals force multiplied by velocity (P=FvP = F v).

  2. Step 2

    P∝v2  ⟹  P2P1=(v2v1)2=(60.030.0)2=4.00P \propto v^2 \implies \frac{P_2}{P_1} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{60.0}{30.0}\right)^2 = 4.00

    Correct

    P2P1=(v2v1)3=(2.00)3=8.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^3 = (2.00)^3 = 8.00

    Your ratio calculation followed logically from your quadratic relationship, but because power scales with the cube of speed, doubling the velocity increases the required power by a factor of 23=8.002^3 = 8.00.

  3. Step 3

    P2=bv22=3.60×(60.0)2=12960 WP_2 = b v_2^2 = 3.60 \times (60.0)^2 = 12960\text{ W}

    Correct

    P2=bv23=3.60×(60.0)3=7.78×105 WP_2 = b v_2^3 = 3.60 \times (60.0)^3 = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W} (or 778 kW778\text{ kW})

    Your arithmetic evaluated bv22b v_2^2 accurately, but calculating mechanical power requires bv23b v_2^3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly realized that power does not have a linear relationship with velocity, so the claim that doubling speed doubles power is false.

You correctly set up the scaling ratio using your assumed velocity dependence and evaluated your arithmetic accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing force with power

Writing P=bv2P = b v^2 by treating the resistance force as power.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating force and mechanical power. While overcoming aerodynamic drag requires a driving force that scales as F∝v2F \propto v^2, driving that force at speed vv requires an additional factor of velocity because P=F⋅vP = F \cdot v, yielding a cubic dependence (P∝v3P \propto v^3).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Mechanical Power
  • For an object moving at constant velocity against resistance, P=F⋅vP = F \cdot v.

  • Always multiply the opposing force by velocity when finding instantaneous or steady-state power.

Dimensional Consistency Check
  • Force has units of newtons (N\text{N}), whereas power has units of watts (W=N⋅m/s\text{W} = \text{N}\cdot\text{m/s}).

  • Verify that the units of bv2b v^2 give force (N\text{N}) and multiply by vv (m/s\text{m/s}) to get power.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. P=Fdrive⋅v=(bv2)⋅v=bv3P = F_{\text{drive}} \cdot v = (b v^2) \cdot v = b v^3

  2. P2P1=(v2v1)3=(60.0 m/s30.0 m/s)3=23=8.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{60.0\text{ m/s}}{30.0\text{ m/s}}\right)^3 = 2^3 = 8.00

  3. P2=bv23=3.60 N⋅s2/m2×(60.0 m/s)3=3.60×216,000 W=7.78×105 WP_2 = b v_2^3 = 3.60\text{ N}\cdot\text{s}^2/\text{m}^2 \times (60.0\text{ m/s})^3 = 3.60 \times 216{,}000\text{ W} = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W}

Final answer

The claim is incorrect (P∝v3P \propto v^3); P2/P1=8.00P_2 / P_1 = 8.00, and P2=7.78×105 WP_2 = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W} (or 778 kW778\text{ kW}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the relationship between work, force, and velocity (P=dWdt=Fdxdt=FvP = \frac{dW}{dt} = F \frac{dx}{dt} = F v) to reinforce why power always has an extra factor of vv relative to force.

  • Work through drag and propulsion problems by writing the force balance first, then explicitly applying P=FvP = F v as a separate step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes power is directly proportional to speed, accepting the conjecture that doubling speed doubles the required power.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    P=Fv, and assuming force is constant gives P∝v  ⟹  Doubling speed doubles the power, so the claim is correct.P = F v\text{, and assuming force is constant gives } P \propto v \implies \text{Doubling speed doubles the power, so the claim is correct.}

    Correct

    Fdrive=Fdrag=bv2  ⟹  P=Fdrivev=bv3  ⟹  P∝v3F_{\text{drive}} = F_{\text{drag}} = b v^2 \implies P = F_{\text{drive}} v = b v^3 \implies P \propto v^3

    You treated the opposing force as constant, but the problem specifies aerodynamic drag Fdrag=bv2F_{\text{drag}} = b v^2. At constant velocity, Fdrive=FdragF_{\text{drive}} = F_{\text{drag}}, so substituting FF into P=FvP = F v yields P=bv3P = b v^3. Because PP scales with the cube of velocity, doubling the cruising speed requires 23=82^3 = 8 times the power, so the student's claim is false.

  2. Step 2

    P2P1=v2v1=60.030.0=2.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \frac{v_2}{v_1} = \frac{60.0}{30.0} = 2.00

    Correct

    P2P1=(v2v1)3=(60.030.0)3=2.003=8.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{60.0}{30.0}\right)^3 = 2.00^3 = 8.00

    This ratio followed directly from your assumption that P∝vP \propto v. With the correct cubic relationship P∝v3P \propto v^3, the ratio of mechanical powers is (v2/v1)3=8.00(v_2 / v_1)^3 = 8.00.

  3. Step 3

    P1=bv13=3.60×(30.0)3=97200 W  ⟹  P2=2×P1=2×97200=194400 WP_1 = b v_1^3 = 3.60 \times (30.0)^3 = 97200\text{ W} \implies P_2 = 2 \times P_1 = 2 \times 97200 = 194400\text{ W}

    Correct

    P2=bv23=3.60×(60.0)3=7.78×105 WP_2 = b v_2^3 = 3.60 \times (60.0)^3 = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W}

    Although you used the cubic formula P=bv3P = b v^3 to find P1P_1, you multiplied P1P_1 by 22 instead of 88 to find P2P_2. Evaluating bv23b v_2^3 directly gives 3.60×60.03=777600 W≈7.78×105 W3.60 \times 60.0^3 = 777600\text{ W} \approx 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that mechanical power is related to force and velocity by P=FvP = F v.

You successfully computed the cubic power expression for the initial state, finding P1=97200 WP_1 = 97200\text{ W}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Assuming Constant Force in Velocity-Dependent Drag

You assumed the resistance force was independent of speed when deriving the scaling relation between power and speed.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You evaluated P=FvP = F v by assuming FF is constant instead of substituting the speed-dependent drag force F=bv2F = b v^2. In velocity-dependent resistance problems, both the force required to maintain motion and the distance traveled per second increase with speed, leading to a higher-order power dependence (P=F(v)⋅v=bv3P = F(v) \cdot v = b v^3).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Substitute Variable Force Expressions First
  • In power problems where resistance depends on speed, always substitute F(v)F(v) into P=FvP = F v before deducing scaling relationships.

  • Identify whether force depends on speed; if F=bvnF = b v^n, then power scales as P=bvn+1P = b v^{n+1}.

Verify Scaling Exponents for Ratios
  • If P∝vkP \propto v^k, then scaling the speed by a factor of cc scales the required power by ckc^k, not cc.

  • For P∝v3P \propto v^3, compute (v2/v1)3=23=8(v_2/v_1)^3 = 2^3 = 8 rather than multiplying by 22.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the required driving force at constant cruising speed: Fdrive=Fdrag=bv2F_{\text{drive}} = F_{\text{drag}} = b v^2.

  2. Substitute this into the power formula: P=Fdrivev=(bv2)v=bv3P = F_{\text{drive}} v = (b v^2) v = b v^3.

  3. Determine the power ratio when doubling speed: P2P1=(v2v1)3=(60.030.0)3=8.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{60.0}{30.0}\right)^3 = 8.00.

  4. Calculate P2P_2 at v2=60.0 m/sv_2 = 60.0\text{ m/s}: P2=bv23=3.60×(60.0)3=7.78×105 WP_2 = b v_2^3 = 3.60 \times (60.0)^3 = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W}.

Final answer

The claim is incorrect (P∝v3P \propto v^3); P2/P1=8.00P_2 / P_1 = 8.00, and P2=7.78×105 WP_2 = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how velocity-dependent resistive forces (such as viscous drag F∝vF \propto v and aerodynamic drag F∝v2F \propto v^2) alter the power-velocity scaling laws.

  • Practice deriving power formulas by writing P=F(v)⋅vP = F(v) \cdot v before plugging in numerical values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student evaluates (v₂ / v₁)³ as 2 × 3 = 6 instead of 2³ = 8 when computing the power ratio, propagating this arithmetic miscalculation to P₂.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    F=bv2  ⟹  P=Fv=(bv2)v=bv3  ⟹  P∝v3F = b v^2 \implies P = F v = (b v^2) v = b v^3 \implies P \propto v^3, so doubling speed increases power by more than double, making the claim false.

  2. Step 2

    P2P1=(v2v1)3=(60.030.0)3=23=6.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{60.0}{30.0}\right)^3 = 2^3 = 6.00

    Correct

    P2P1=(v2v1)3=(60.030.0)3=23=8.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = \left(\frac{v_2}{v_1}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{60.0}{30.0}\right)^3 = 2^3 = 8.00

    You correctly set up the ratio using the cubic relationship, but you evaluated 232^3 as 2×3=62 \times 3 = 6 instead of multiplying three factors of 22 (2×2×2=82 \times 2 \times 2 = 8).

  3. Step 3

    P1=3.60×(30.0)3=97200 W  ⟹  P2=6.00×97200=583200 WP_1 = 3.60 \times (30.0)^3 = 97200\text{ W} \implies P_2 = 6.00 \times 97200 = 583200\text{ W}

    Correct

    P2=8.00×97200 W=777600 W=7.78×105 WP_2 = 8.00 \times 97200\text{ W} = 777600\text{ W} = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W}

    Your calculation of P1=97200 WP_1 = 97200\text{ W} is entirely correct, but multiplying it by your erroneous ratio of 6.006.00 rather than 8.008.00 propagated the arithmetic error to P2P_2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed mechanical power as P=FvP = F v and derived the cubic velocity dependence P=bv3P = b v^3.

You correctly determined that power increases by more than double when speed doubles, refuting the claim.

You correctly computed P1=97,200 WP_1 = 97{,}200\text{ W} using the proper parameters.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Exponentiation vs. multiplication confusion

You wrote 23=6.002^3 = 6.00, accidentally multiplying the base by the exponent (2×32 \times 3) instead of evaluating 2×2×22 \times 2 \times 2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating base-exponent evaluation (ana^n) with scalar multiplication (a×na \times n) during mental arithmetic.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Evaluating Integer Powers
  • For any positive integer exponent nn, an=a×a×⋯×a⏟n timesa^n = \underbrace{a \times a \times \dots \times a}_{n\text{ times}}, not a×na \times n.

  • When computing 232^3, write or think out each repeated multiplication explicitly: 2×2×2=82 \times 2 \times 2 = 8.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Evaluate the power ratio: P2P1=23=2×2×2=8.00\frac{P_2}{P_1} = 2^3 = 2 \times 2 \times 2 = 8.00.

  2. Calculate P2P_2 by scaling P1P_1: P2=8.00×97,200 W=777,600 W≈7.78×105 WP_2 = 8.00 \times 97{,}200\text{ W} = 777{,}600\text{ W} \approx 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W} (or directly via P2=3.60×60.03=777,600 WP_2 = 3.60 \times 60.0^3 = 777{,}600\text{ W}).

Final answer

The claim is false; P2/P1=8.00P_2 / P_1 = 8.00, and P2=7.78×105 WP_2 = 7.78 \times 10^5\text{ W} (or 778 kW778\text{ kW}).

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check small integer powers by expanding them into explicit factors before recording the numerical value.

  • Practice distinguishing scaling laws (e.g., F∝v2F \propto v^2 versus P∝v3P \propto v^3) to keep drag force and engine power clearly separated.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cyclist overcomes aerodynamic drag force Fdrag=0.25v2F_{\text{drag}} = 0.25 v^2 (in newtons, with vv in m/s\text{m/s}). Find the mechanical power output required to cycle at a constant speed of 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s}.

Answer

250 W250\text{ W}. Key steps: P=F⋅v=(0.25v2)v=0.25v3=0.25(10.0)3=250 WP = F \cdot v = (0.25 v^2) v = 0.25 v^3 = 0.25 (10.0)^3 = 250\text{ W}.

02

An electric car cruises on a flat highway where rolling resistance is negligible and aerodynamic drag is Fdrag=bv2F_{\text{drag}} = b v^2. By what percentage must the traction motor's power output increase if the driver increases speed from 20.0 m/s20.0\text{ m/s} to 25.0 m/s25.0\text{ m/s}?

Answer

95.3%95.3\% increase. Key steps: The speed ratio is 25.0/20.0=1.2525.0 / 20.0 = 1.25. Since P∝v3P \propto v^3, the power ratio is (1.25)3=1.953125(1.25)^3 = 1.953125. The percentage increase is (1.953125−1)×100%≈95.3%(1.953125 - 1) \times 100\% \approx 95.3\%.

03

A high-speed train experiences two resistance forces: a constant mechanical rolling resistance Froll=1.20×104 NF_{\text{roll}} = 1.20 \times 10^4\text{ N} and an aerodynamic drag Fdrag=4.00v2 NF_{\text{drag}} = 4.00 v^2\text{ N} (where vv is in m/s\text{m/s}). Derive the total power function P(v)P(v), and calculate the total power required to cruise at 50.0 m/s50.0\text{ m/s}.

Answer

P(v)=(1.20×104)v+4.00v3P(v) = (1.20 \times 10^4)v + 4.00 v^3; at 50.0 m/s50.0\text{ m/s}, P=1.10×106 WP = 1.10 \times 10^6\text{ W} (1.10 MW1.10\text{ MW}). Key steps: Total force Ftot=Froll+FdragF_{\text{tot}} = F_{\text{roll}} + F_{\text{drag}}. Power is P=Ftot⋅v=Frollv+bv3P = F_{\text{tot}} \cdot v = F_{\text{roll}} v + b v^3. Evaluating at v=50.0 m/sv = 50.0\text{ m/s}: Proll=(1.20×104)(50.0)=6.00×105 WP_{\text{roll}} = (1.20 \times 10^4)(50.0) = 6.00 \times 10^5\text{ W}; Pdrag=4.00(50.0)3=5.00×105 WP_{\text{drag}} = 4.00 (50.0)^3 = 5.00 \times 10^5\text{ W}; total P=1.10×106 WP = 1.10 \times 10^6\text{ W}.

Loading workspace…