Resources

A dwarf planet travels in an elliptical orbit around the Sun with an eccentricity of e=0.600e = 0.600 and a semi-major axis of a=30.0 AUa = 30.0\text{ AU}. While a student might intuitively assume the planet spends equal amounts of time on both sides of the minor axis, the Sun is located at a focus. Using Kepler's Second Law, determine the ratio of the planet's orbital speed at perihelion (vpv_{\text{p}}) to its orbital speed at aphelion (vav_{\text{a}}), expressed as the exact numerical ratio vpva\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}}. Express the result to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

vpva=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = 4.00

Steps

01

Relate Kepler's Second Law to Conservation of Angular Momentum

Kepler's Second Law states that a line segment joining a planet and the Sun sweeps out equal areas during equal intervals of time. This law is equivalent to the conservation of orbital angular momentum about the Sun, as gravity is a central force producing no net torque:

L=mrv⊥=constantL = m r v_{\perp} = \text{constant}

At the two extreme points of an elliptical orbit—the perihelion (closest approach) and the aphelion (farthest point)—the planet's velocity vector is strictly perpendicular to the position vector (v⊥=vv_{\perp} = v). Therefore:

mrpvp=mravam r_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = m r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}}

Dividing both sides by mrpvam r_{\text{p}} v_{\text{a}} yields the inverse relationship between speed and distance:

vpva=rarp\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}


02

Express Perihelion and Aphelion Distances

In terms of the semi-major axis aa and eccentricity ee:

  • Distance at perihelion: rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e)
  • Distance at aphelion: ra=a(1+e)r_{\text{a}} = a(1 + e)

Substituting these expressions into the speed ratio:

vpva=a(1+e)a(1−e)=1+e1−e\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{a(1 + e)}{a(1 - e)} = \frac{1 + e}{1 - e}

(Note: The semi-major axis a=30.0 AUa = 30.0\text{ AU} cancels out completely, so the speed ratio depends solely on the orbit's eccentricity ee.)


03

Calculate the Numerical Ratio

Substitute the given eccentricity e=0.600e = 0.600:

vpva=1+0.6001−0.600=1.6000.400=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{1 + 0.600}{1 - 0.600} = \frac{1.600}{0.400} = 4.00

Expressed to three significant figures, the ratio is:

vpva=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = 4.00

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the relationship between speed and distance, assuming speed is directly proportional to orbital radius rather than inversely proportional.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    rp=a(1−e)=30.0×(1−0.600)=12.0 AU  ⟹  ra=a(1+e)=30.0×(1+0.600)=48.0 AUr_{\text{p}} = a(1-e) = 30.0 \times (1 - 0.600) = 12.0\text{ AU} \implies r_{\text{a}} = a(1+e) = 30.0 \times (1 + 0.600) = 48.0\text{ AU}

  2. Step 2

    vpva=rpra\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{p}}}{r_{\text{a}}}

    Correct

    vpva=rarp\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}

    By Kepler's Second Law and conservation of angular momentum, rpvp=ravar_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}}, which means orbital speed is inversely proportional to distance at the apsides.

  3. Step 3

    vpva=12.048.0=0.250\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{12.0}{48.0} = 0.250

    Correct

    vpva=48.012.0=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{48.0}{12.0} = 4.00

    Substituting into the inverted relationship propagated the earlier error into your numerical evaluation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the geometric formulas for perihelion and aphelion distances.

You performed accurate arithmetic to find rp=12.0 AUr_{\text{p}} = 12.0\text{ AU} and ra=48.0 AUr_{\text{a}} = 48.0\text{ AU}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted proportionality ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated orbital speed as directly proportional to distance from the Sun rather than applying conservation of angular momentum (rpvp=ravar_{\text{p}}v_{\text{p}} = r_{\text{a}}v_{\text{a}}), which makes orbital speed inversely proportional to distance.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Apsidal Speed-Distance Relationship
  • At perihelion and aphelion, position and velocity are perpendicular, so L=mrvL = m r v is conserved: rpvp=ravar_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}}.

  • Always isolate the ratio carefully: dividing rpvp=ravar_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}} by varpv_{\text{a}} r_{\text{p}} yields vpva=rarp\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}.

Physical Reality Check
  • Kepler's Second Law implies that orbiting bodies move fastest when closest to the central mass and slowest when farthest.

  • Check that vp>vav_{\text{p}} > v_{\text{a}}, meaning the ratio vpva\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} must always be greater than 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply conservation of angular momentum at the apsides: mrpvp=mravam r_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = m r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}}.

  2. Rearrange to solve for the speed ratio: vpva=rarp\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}.

  3. Substitute the distances: vpva=48.0 AU12.0 AU=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{48.0\text{ AU}}{12.0\text{ AU}} = 4.00.

Final answer

vpva=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = 4.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the connection between Kepler's Second Law (equal areas in equal times) and the conservation of orbital angular momentum.

  • Practice rearranging inverse proportions so the ratio of values is paired with the reciprocal ratio of distances.

  • Complete the targeted flashcards and practice problems below to master apsidal speed ratios.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student swaps the geometric formulas for perihelion and aphelion distances, mistakenly setting r_p = a(1 + e) and r_a = a(1 - e).

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    rp=a(1+e)=30.0×1.600=48.0 AU  ⟹  ra=a(1−e)=30.0×0.400=12.0 AUr_{\text{p}} = a(1 + e) = 30.0 \times 1.600 = 48.0\text{ AU} \implies r_{\text{a}} = a(1 - e) = 30.0 \times 0.400 = 12.0\text{ AU}

    Correct

    rp=a(1−e)=30.0×0.400=12.0 AU  ⟹  ra=a(1+e)=30.0×1.600=48.0 AUr_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) = 30.0 \times 0.400 = 12.0\text{ AU} \implies r_{\text{a}} = a(1 + e) = 30.0 \times 1.600 = 48.0\text{ AU}

    Perihelion is the point of closest approach to the Sun, so its distance must be a(1−e)a(1 - e), not a(1+e)a(1 + e). Conversely, aphelion is the farthest point, which corresponds to a(1+e)a(1 + e).

  2. Step 2

    vp⋅rp=va⋅rav_{\text{p}} \cdot r_{\text{p}} = v_{\text{a}} \cdot r_{\text{a}}

  3. Step 3

    vpva=rarp=12.048.0=0.250\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}} = \frac{12.0}{48.0} = 0.250

    Correct

    vpva=rarp=48.012.0=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}} = \frac{48.0}{12.0} = 4.00

    Your algebraic rearrangement was correct, but substituting your swapped orbital distances produced the reciprocal of the correct ratio.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that Kepler's Second Law implies conservation of angular momentum at perihelion and aphelion.

You set up the inverse relationship between orbital speed and distance correctly as vpva=rarp\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Apsidal Distance Formula Inversion

You assigned the larger distance a(1+e)a(1+e) to perihelion and the smaller distance a(1−e)a(1-e) to aphelion.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the Greek prefixes 'peri-' (near/closest) and 'apo-'/'aph-' (away/farthest), leading to an inverted physical assignment of the orbital extrema distances.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Apsidal Prefixes
  • In astronomy, 'peri-' means nearest to the central body and 'ap-' / 'apo-' means farthest from the central body.

  • Always verify that rp<rar_{\text{p}} < r_{\text{a}}, meaning rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) and ra=a(1+e)r_{\text{a}} = a(1 + e) for an ellipse.

Physical Reality Check
  • A planet moves fastest when it is closest to the Sun (perihelion) and slowest when it is farthest (aphelion).

  • Check that the speed ratio vpva\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} is strictly greater than 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the correct perihelion distance: rp=a(1−e)=30.0(1−0.600)=12.0 AUr_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) = 30.0(1 - 0.600) = 12.0\text{ AU}.

  2. Calculate the correct aphelion distance: ra=a(1+e)=30.0(1+0.600)=48.0 AUr_{\text{a}} = a(1 + e) = 30.0(1 + 0.600) = 48.0\text{ AU}.

  3. Substitute these distances into the angular momentum ratio: vpva=rarp=48.0 AU12.0 AU=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}} = \frac{48.0\text{ AU}}{12.0\text{ AU}} = 4.00.

Final answer

vpva=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = 4.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the root meanings: 'peri-' = 'proximity/close' and 'apo-' = 'apart/far'.

  • Perform a sanity check on planetary speeds: planets accelerate as they fall inward toward the Sun, so speed must peak at perihelion (vp>vav_{\text{p}} > v_{\text{a}}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misremembers the orbital distance relation and squares the distance ratio, confusing angular momentum conservation with an inverse-square law.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    rp=a(1−e)=30.0×0.400=12.0 AU  ⟹  ra=a(1+e)=30.0×1.600=48.0 AUr_{\text{p}} = a(1-e) = 30.0 \times 0.400 = 12.0\text{ AU} \implies r_{\text{a}} = a(1+e) = 30.0 \times 1.600 = 48.0\text{ AU}

  2. Step 2

    vpva=(rarp)2\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \left(\frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}\right)^2

    Correct

    vpva=rarp\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}

    At perihelion and aphelion, the velocity vector is perpendicular to the position vector, so conservation of angular momentum gives mrpvp=mravam r_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = m r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}}. This means speed is inversely proportional to distance to the first power, not squared.

  3. Step 3

    vpva=(48.012.0)2=42=16.0\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \left(\frac{48.0}{12.0}\right)^2 = 4^2 = 16.0

    Correct

    vpva=48.012.0=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{48.0}{12.0} = 4.00

    Because of the squared ratio in Step 2, your evaluation yielded 16.016.0 rather than the correct ratio of 4.004.00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the perihelion and aphelion distances from the semi-major axis and eccentricity.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect power in apsidal speed relation

You squared the ratio rarp\frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}} when writing the ratio of orbital speeds.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You likely confused the conservation of angular momentum (L=mrv=constantL = mrv = \text{constant} at apsides) with an inverse-square relationship like Newton's law of universal gravitation, leading you to write v∝1r2v \propto \frac{1}{r^2} instead of v∝1rv \propto \frac{1}{r}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Angular Momentum at Apsides
  • At perihelion and aphelion, the velocity vector is perpendicular to the radial vector: L=mrvL = m r v.

  • Equate rpvp=ravar_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}} to set up a linear inverse ratio: vpva=rarp=1+e1−e\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}} = \frac{1+e}{1-e}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply conservation of angular momentum at the apsides: mrpvp=mravam r_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = m r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}}.

  2. Solve for the ratio of speeds: vpva=rarp\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}.

  3. Substitute the distances: vpva=48.0 AU12.0 AU=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{48.0\text{ AU}}{12.0\text{ AU}} = 4.00.

Final answer

vpva=4.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = 4.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how Kepler's Second Law is fundamentally equivalent to conservation of orbital angular momentum.

  • Remember that gravitational force follows an inverse-square law (F∝1r2F \propto \frac{1}{r^2}), but apsidal speed follows an inverse-linear law (v∝1rv \propto \frac{1}{r}).

  • Practice deriving vpva=1+e1−e\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{1+e}{1-e} directly without calculating intermediate distances.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A comet moves along an elliptical orbit with an eccentricity of e=0.800e = 0.800. Determine the ratio of its speed at perihelion to its speed at aphelion, vpva\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}}.

Answer

vpva=9.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = 9.00. Using the formula vpva=rarp=1+e1−e=1+0.8001−0.800=1.8000.200=9.00\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}} = \frac{1 + e}{1 - e} = \frac{1 + 0.800}{1 - 0.800} = \frac{1.800}{0.200} = 9.00.

02

An asteroid orbits the Sun with perihelion distance rp=1.50 AUr_{\text{p}} = 1.50\text{ AU} and aphelion distance ra=4.50 AUr_{\text{a}} = 4.50\text{ AU}. If its speed at aphelion is 14.0 km/s14.0\text{ km/s}, calculate its orbital speed at perihelion vpv_{\text{p}}.

Answer

vp=42.0 km/sv_{\text{p}} = 42.0\text{ km/s}. By conservation of angular momentum at the apsides, rpvp=ravar_{\text{p}} v_{\text{p}} = r_{\text{a}} v_{\text{a}}. Thus, vp=va(rarp)=14.0×(4.501.50)=14.0×3.00=42.0 km/sv_{\text{p}} = v_{\text{a}} \left(\frac{r_{\text{a}}}{r_{\text{p}}}\right) = 14.0 \times \left(\frac{4.50}{1.50}\right) = 14.0 \times 3.00 = 42.0\text{ km/s}.

03

A spacecraft in an elliptical orbit around Mars has a speed ratio between periapsis and apoapsis of vpva=2.50\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = 2.50. If the semi-major axis of the orbit is a=7000 kma = 7000\text{ km}, find the periapsis distance rpr_{\text{p}} in kilometers.

Answer

rp=4000 kmr_{\text{p}} = 4000\text{ km}. Since vpva=1+e1−e=2.50\frac{v_{\text{p}}}{v_{\text{a}}} = \frac{1+e}{1-e} = 2.50, solving for eccentricity gives 1+e=2.5(1−e)  ⟹  3.5e=1.5  ⟹  e=371 + e = 2.5(1 - e) \implies 3.5e = 1.5 \implies e = \frac{3}{7}. The periapsis distance is rp=a(1−e)=7000(1−37)=7000(47)=4000 kmr_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) = 7000\left(1 - \frac{3}{7}\right) = 7000\left(\frac{4}{7}\right) = 4000\text{ km}.

Loading workspace…