Resources
A student models the work done on a gas versus a solid during compression. A rigid cylinder with a moveable piston contains argon atoms initially occupying a volume of at a constant temperature of . The gas is compressed isothermally and reversibly to . According to the thermodynamic sign convention where represents the work done ON the system: (a) Calculate the work done on the gas in kilojoules (), using . (b) If the same compressive force were applied to an identical volume of solid argon (bulk modulus ), explain why the work done on the solid is virtually zero by calculating the fractional volume change under a pressure change of .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) (negligible compression due to strong repulsive electron cloud overlap in closely-packed solids).
Steps
Part (a): Work Done on the Gas
- State the expression for isothermal reversible work done on an ideal gas: For an ideal gas, the equation of state is: The work done on the gas during a volume change from to is defined as:
- Calculate the thermal energy factor :
- Compute the logarithmic volume ratio:
- Evaluate the total work : Pitfall to avoid: The negative sign in ensures that compressing a system () yields positive work done on the system.
Part (b): Compression of the Solid and Microscopic Model
- Relate bulk modulus to fractional volume change: The bulk modulus measures a substance's resistance to uniform compression:
- Calculate the fractional volume change: Given and :
-
Particle-level interpretation:
- In a gas, atoms are separated by large empty spaces relative to atomic radii. Compressing a gas merely reduces the empty space between particles, which requires overcoming thermal kinetic motion and results in significant displacement (, or an reduction) and measurable mechanical work.
- In a solid, atoms are already densely packed at equilibrium interatomic separations governed by the balance of attractive van der Waals forces and extremely steep repulsive forces from overlapping electron clouds (Pauli exclusion principle). Because atoms strongly resist further interpenetration, the displacement is extremely tiny (). Since mechanical work scales directly with displacement (), the work performed on the solid is virtually zero under comparable pressure changes.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the sign convention for work done on the system with work done by the system, omitting the negative sign in the integral and concluding that work done on the gas is negative.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You omitted the leading negative sign required by the thermodynamic convention for work done on the system. When a gas is compressed (), the natural logarithm is negative, so an explicit negative sign is necessary to make the work done on the gas positive.
- Step 2Correct
Your arithmetic and evaluation of and were accurate, but the sign error from the initial formula carried through to the final value.
- Step 3
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the thermal factor .
You correctly evaluated the logarithmic volume ratio .
You applied the bulk modulus relation correctly to determine the fractional compression of the solid.
You accurately connected the tiny volume displacement of the solid to near-zero mechanical work.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou dropped the initial negative sign from the integral definition , confusing work done on the gas with work done by the gas.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisFailing to verify physical consistency: compressing a system () requires an external agent to push inward, adding energy to the system, which must correspond to positive work done on the gas ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Thermodynamic Sign Convention
For work done ON a system, . For an isothermal ideal gas process, this integrates to .
Always write the integral with its explicit negative sign when the question specifies work done on the system.
- Physical Reality Check for Compression
Compression () means . Therefore, work done on the gas must be positive.
Before writing the final answer, check whether the volume decreased; if it did, ensure .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the standard integral for work done ON the system: .
Substitute the volume ratio: , giving .
Multiply by the thermal factor: .
(a) ; (b) , so .
02 The student inverts the ratio of volumes in the natural logarithm as V_i / V_f, incorrectly finding a negative work value under compression.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Integrating yields . Writing both a leading negative sign and double-inverts the sign.
- Step 2Correct
Your arithmetic and conversion to kilojoules were carried out correctly, but the sign was affected by the formula error in Step 1. Compressing a gas requires positive work done on the system.
- Step 3
- Step 4
The fractional volume change is tiny, so is practically zero and virtually no work is done.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou calculated the thermal factor with exact arithmetic.
You applied the bulk modulus definition correctly to find the fractional volume change of solid argon.
You correctly connected the tiny volume displacement of the solid to the near-zero mechanical work.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou accidentally retained the leading negative sign while flipping the upper and lower integration limits inside the logarithm.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the integral bounds with the log identity , causing a sign error where compression incorrectly produced negative work done on the gas.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Thermodynamic Work Sign Check
When a system is compressed (), external forces push inward, so work done ON the system must be positive ().
Whenever evaluating work done on a system, verify immediately: if , ensure your final calculated is positive.
- Logarithm Negative Sign Absorption
.
Either keep the negative sign outside with the standard ratio , or invert the ratio to and drop the negative sign, but never do both.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationState the integral definition with limits: .
Substitute the given limits: .
Evaluate the logarithm: .
Multiply by the thermal factor: .
03 The student misdefines bulk modulus as B = |ΔV| / (V_i ΔP) by inverting stress and strain, yielding an erroneously large fractional volume change.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You inverted the relation between bulk modulus, stress, and strain. Bulk modulus is defined as volumetric stress over volumetric strain, , which means the fractional volume change is .
- Step 3
Since 5400 is not close to zero, the compression appears large rather than virtually zero.
CorrectBecause (or ) is negligible, atoms in a solid are already tightly packed and strongly resist electron cloud interpenetration, resulting in virtually zero work.
Your conclusion was misled by the inverted ratio of . Once the correct ratio is used, the fractional compression is indeed negligible.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled and applied the thermodynamic integral expression for isothermal work done on an ideal gas.
You tracked the negative sign and logarithmic ratio properly to find the positive work on the gas.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set the dimensionless strain equal to modulus divided by pressure () instead of pressure divided by modulus ().
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the roles of stress (the applied pressure change ) and volumetric strain (the fractional deformation ) in the elastic modulus formula .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Elastic Modulus Structure
Every elastic modulus is defined as .
Always check units: stress has units of pressure (), modulus has units of pressure (), and strain is dimensionless, so .
- Physical Reality Check for Solids
Solids possess high bulk moduli (), so moderate pressures yield fractional changes much smaller than .
If your calculated fractional volume change exceeds , check whether you inverted your stress and modulus terms.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRearrange the bulk modulus definition for fractional volume change: .
Substitute the given numerical values: .
Relate the microscopic model to macroscopic work: in a solid, atoms are closely packed with overlapping electron shells creating steep repulsive forces, so the tiny yields virtually zero boundary displacement and .
(a) ; (b) (virtually zero work because closely packed solid atoms strongly resist further compression).
Lock it in
Under the convention (work done ON the system), what is the sign of during compression ()?
Positive (). Compression requires pushing inward, transferring energy into the gas.
Similar question
An ideal gas containing molecules at is isothermally compressed to one-fourth of its initial volume. Using and the convention , calculate the work done on the gas in joules.
Answer
. Key steps: ; ; .
A cylinder of solid copper (bulk modulus ) has an initial volume of . A uniform external pressure increase of is applied. (a) Find the fractional volume change . (b) Estimate the magnitude of work done on the copper assuming .
Answer
(a) ; (b) . Key steps: ; ; .
A sample of of helium gas at is compressed isothermally from to . Simultaneously, a block of aluminum of the same initial volume (, bulk modulus ) undergoes an identical final pressure change . Using , compare the work done on the gas to the work done on the solid.
Answer
Gas work: ; Solid work: . Key steps: For gas, , , so . . For solid, ; , which is negligible compared to the gas.