Resources

A student performs a resonance air-column experiment using a cylindrical resonance tube partially filled with water. A tuning fork vibrating at f=440.0 Hzf = 440.0\text{ Hz} is held over the top open end of the tube. The water level is gradually lowered from the top rim. The first resonance is detected when the air column length is L1=18.2 cmL_1 = 18.2\text{ cm}, and the second resonance is detected when the air column length is L2=57.1 cmL_2 = 57.1\text{ cm}. Using these scale measurements to eliminate the end correction, determine: (a) the experimental speed of sound vv in m/s\text{m/s}, and (b) the acoustic end correction ee of the tube in millimeters.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) v=342.3 m/sv = 342.3\text{ m/s}; (b) e=12.5 mme = 12.5\text{ mm}

Steps

01

Relate the Resonance Lengths to the Wavelength

Standing Waves in a Tube Closed at One End

In a resonance tube with a water surface at the bottom and an open rim at the top, acoustic resonance occurs when the vibrating air column forms a displacement node at the water surface and a displacement antinode slightly above the open end. Because the air just outside the mouth of the tube also participates in the oscillation, the effective acoustic boundary extends beyond the rim by an end correction ee.

Let λ\lambda be the wavelength of the sound wave and ee be the end correction.

  1. First resonance (fundamental mode, n=1n = 1): L1+e=λ4L_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}
  2. Second resonance (third harmonic, n=3n = 3): L2+e=3λ4L_2 + e = \frac{3\lambda}{4}

02

Determine the Wavelength and Speed of Sound

Subtracting the first resonance equation from the second eliminates the end correction ee: (L2+e)−(L1+e)=3λ4−λ4(L_2 + e) - (L_1 + e) = \frac{3\lambda}{4} - \frac{\lambda}{4} L2−L1=λ2L_2 - L_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2}

Substitute the given lengths L1=18.2 cmL_1 = 18.2\text{ cm} and L2=57.1 cmL_2 = 57.1\text{ cm}: λ2=57.1 cm−18.2 cm=38.9 cm\frac{\lambda}{2} = 57.1\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 38.9\text{ cm} λ=2⋅38.9 cm=77.8 cm=0.778 m\lambda = 2 \cdot 38.9\text{ cm} = 77.8\text{ cm} = 0.778\text{ m}

Using the wave speed equation v=fλv = f\lambda with f=440.0 Hzf = 440.0\text{ Hz}: v=(440.0 Hz)(0.778 m)=342.32 m/s≈342.3 m/sv = (440.0\text{ Hz})(0.778\text{ m}) = 342.32\text{ m/s} \approx 342.3\text{ m/s}


03

Calculate the End Correction

Substitute λ=77.8 cm\lambda = 77.8\text{ cm} back into the first resonance equation: e=λ4−L1e = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 e=77.8 cm4−18.2 cm=19.45 cm−18.2 cm=1.25 cme = \frac{77.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 19.45\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 1.25\text{ cm}

Convert the end correction to millimeters: e=1.25 cm⋅10 mm/cm=12.5 mme = 1.25\text{ cm} \cdot 10\text{ mm/cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}

(Alternative check: e=L2−3L12=57.1−54.62=1.25 cm=12.5 mme = \frac{L_2 - 3L_1}{2} = \frac{57.1 - 54.6}{2} = 1.25\text{ cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}.)


Common Pitfall to Avoid

Assuming the displacement antinode lies exactly at the physical lip of the tube (taking L1=λ/4L_1 = \lambda/4) gives λ=4⋅18.2 cm=72.8 cm\lambda = 4 \cdot 18.2\text{ cm} = 72.8\text{ cm} and v≈320.3 m/sv \approx 320.3\text{ m/s}, which erroneously ignores the mass of air oscillating just outside the tube rim. Always subtract consecutive resonance lengths to cancel out ee first.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that the distance between consecutive resonances in a closed tube is a half-wavelength rather than a quarter-wavelength, calculating λ = L₂ - L₁ and getting half the actual speed of sound.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    ΔL=L2−L1=57.1 cm−18.2 cm=38.9 cm\Delta L = L_2 - L_1 = 57.1\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 38.9\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    λ=ΔL=38.9 cm=0.389 m\lambda = \Delta L = 38.9\text{ cm} = 0.389\text{ m}

    Correct

    ΔL=λ2  ⟹  λ=2ΔL=2(38.9 cm)=77.8 cm=0.778 m\Delta L = \frac{\lambda}{2} \implies \lambda = 2\Delta L = 2(38.9\text{ cm}) = 77.8\text{ cm} = 0.778\text{ m}

    The distance between two consecutive resonance lengths for a fixed frequency in a closed-pipe system corresponds to the distance between consecutive displacement nodes, which is λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}, not λ\lambda.

  3. Step 3

    v=f×λ=440.0×0.389=171.16 m/sv = f \times \lambda = 440.0 \times 0.389 = 171.16\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v=fλ=(440.0 Hz)(0.778 m)≈342.3 m/sv = f\lambda = (440.0\text{ Hz})(0.778\text{ m}) \approx 342.3\text{ m/s}

    Your wave speed formula is correct, but the value is halved because of the incorrect wavelength from Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    λ4=0.389 m4=0.09725 m=9.725 cm  ⟹  e=λ4−L1=9.725 cm−18.2 cm=−8.475 cm=−84.8 mm\frac{\lambda}{4} = \frac{0.389\text{ m}}{4} = 0.09725\text{ m} = 9.725\text{ cm} \implies e = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 = 9.725\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = -8.475\text{ cm} = -84.8\text{ mm}

    Correct

    e=λ4−L1=77.8 cm4−18.2 cm=19.45 cm−18.2 cm=1.25 cm=12.5 mme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 = \frac{77.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 19.45\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 1.25\text{ cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}

    Your relationship L1+e=λ4L_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} is correct, but using the halved wavelength produced an unphysical negative end correction.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly subtracted the two resonant tube lengths to eliminate the acoustic end correction.

You correctly identified the wave speed relationship v=fλv = f\lambda.

You set up the correct fundamental mode equation L1+e=λ4L_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} to solve for the end correction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Wavelength node-spacing confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed the difference between consecutive resonant positions ΔL\Delta L equals a full wavelength λ\lambda instead of a half-wavelength λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}. In any standing wave, the spatial separation between adjacent nodes (or adjacent antinodes) is always λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distance Between Successive Resonances
  • For a resonance tube closed at one end, consecutive resonant air-column lengths satisfy Ln+1−Ln=λ2L_{n+1} - L_n = \frac{\lambda}{2}.

  • Always multiply the distance between consecutive resonances by 2 to determine the wavelength: λ=2(L2−L1)\lambda = 2(L_2 - L_1).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. λ=2(L2−L1)=2(38.9 cm)=77.8 cm=0.778 m\lambda = 2(L_2 - L_1) = 2(38.9\text{ cm}) = 77.8\text{ cm} = 0.778\text{ m}

  2. v=fλ=(440.0 Hz)(0.778 m)=342.32 m/s≈342.3 m/sv = f\lambda = (440.0\text{ Hz})(0.778\text{ m}) = 342.32\text{ m/s} \approx 342.3\text{ m/s}

  3. e=λ4−L1=77.8 cm4−18.2 cm=19.45 cm−18.2 cm=1.25 cm=12.5 mme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 = \frac{77.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 19.45\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 1.25\text{ cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}

Final answer

(a) v=342.3 m/sv = 342.3\text{ m/s}; (b) e=12.5 mme = 12.5\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that adjacent nodes in a standing wave are separated by λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}, so consecutive resonance lengths always differ by half a wavelength.

  • Use the resulting sign of the end correction as a sanity check: an open tube lip requires a positive end correction e>0e > 0 because the antinode sits slightly outside the physical boundary.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student ignores the end correction entirely when finding the speed of sound, assuming the first resonance corresponds simply to L₁ = λ / 4.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    λ=4×L1=4×18.2 cm=72.8 cm=0.728 m\lambda = 4 \times L_1 = 4 \times 18.2\text{ cm} = 72.8\text{ cm} = 0.728\text{ m}

    Correct

    L2−L1=λ2  ⟹  λ=2(57.1 cm−18.2 cm)=77.8 cm=0.778 mL_2 - L_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2} \implies \lambda = 2(57.1\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm}) = 77.8\text{ cm} = 0.778\text{ m}

    Because an acoustic end correction ee exists beyond the open rim, the boundary condition for the fundamental mode is L1+e=λ4L_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}, not simply L1=λ4L_1 = \frac{\lambda}{4}. You need to subtract the two consecutive resonance positions, (L2+e)−(L1+e)=L2−L1=λ2(L_2 + e) - (L_1 + e) = L_2 - L_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2}, to find λ\lambda without assuming e=0e = 0.

  2. Step 2

    v=f×λ=440.0×0.728=320.32 m/sv = f \times \lambda = 440.0 \times 0.728 = 320.32\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v=fλ=440.0 Hz×0.778 m≈342.3 m/sv = f\lambda = 440.0\text{ Hz} \times 0.778\text{ m} \approx 342.3\text{ m/s}

    Your calculation correctly multiplied frequency by your calculated wavelength, but the value was carried over from the incorrect wavelength in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    e=0 mme = 0\text{ mm}

    Correct

    e=λ4−L1=19.45 cm−18.2 cm=1.25 cm=12.5 mme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 = 19.45\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 1.25\text{ cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}

    The problem asks to determine the end correction ee using both resonance lengths. Once λ=77.8 cm\lambda = 77.8\text{ cm} is known, substituting it into L1+e=λ4L_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} gives e=1.25 cm=12.5 mme = 1.25\text{ cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the wave speed relationship v=fλv = f\lambda.

You converted centimeters to meters accurately when evaluating wave speed.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neglected end correction in resonance tube

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed the displacement antinode forms precisely at the physical mouth of the tube (L1=λ/4L_1 = \lambda/4), overlooking that acoustic waves extend slightly outside the tube by an end correction ee, which is eliminated by taking L2−L1=λ/2L_2 - L_1 = \lambda/2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Eliminate end correction with consecutive resonances
  • For a tube closed at one end, consecutive resonant lengths differ by half a wavelength: Ln+1−Ln=λ2L_{n+1} - L_n = \frac{\lambda}{2}.

  • Always subtract adjacent resonance lengths to calculate λ\lambda first, rather than multiplying the single length L1L_1 by 4.

Calculate the end correction explicitly
  • The acoustic boundary satisfies L1+e=λ4L_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}.

  • After finding λ\lambda, substitute it back into e=λ4−L1e = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 to find the acoustic end correction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Relate the two resonance lengths to the wavelength: L1+e=λ4L_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} and L2+e=3λ4L_2 + e = \frac{3\lambda}{4}.

  2. Subtract the two equations to cancel ee: L2−L1=λ2  ⟹  57.1 cm−18.2 cm=38.9 cm=λ2L_2 - L_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2} \implies 57.1\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 38.9\text{ cm} = \frac{\lambda}{2}.

  3. Solve for wavelength: λ=2×38.9 cm=77.8 cm=0.778 m\lambda = 2 \times 38.9\text{ cm} = 77.8\text{ cm} = 0.778\text{ m}.

  4. Compute the speed of sound: v=fλ=440.0 Hz×0.778 m=342.32 m/s≈342.3 m/sv = f\lambda = 440.0\text{ Hz} \times 0.778\text{ m} = 342.32\text{ m/s} \approx 342.3\text{ m/s}.

  5. Compute the end correction: e=λ4−L1=77.8 cm4−18.2 cm=19.45 cm−18.2 cm=1.25 cm=12.5 mme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 = \frac{77.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 19.45\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 1.25\text{ cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}.

Final answer

(a) v=342.3 m/sv = 342.3\text{ m/s}; (b) e=12.5 mme = 12.5\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how boundary conditions create displacement antinodes slightly outside an open tube end.

  • Practice using differences between consecutive resonance positions (L2−L1=λ/2L_2 - L_1 = \lambda/2) to remove systematic end errors.

  • Solve the follow-up exercises below to build fluency with end-correction calculations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the end correction correctly in centimeters but converts to millimeters by dividing by 10 instead of multiplying by 10.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ2=L2−L1=57.1−18.2=38.9 cm  ⟹  λ=2×38.9 cm=77.8 cm=0.778 m\frac{\lambda}{2} = L_2 - L_1 = 57.1 - 18.2 = 38.9\text{ cm} \implies \lambda = 2 \times 38.9\text{ cm} = 77.8\text{ cm} = 0.778\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    v=f×λ=440.0×0.778=342.32 m/sv = f \times \lambda = 440.0 \times 0.778 = 342.32\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    λ4=77.8 cm/4=19.45 cm  ⟹  e=19.45 cm−18.2 cm=1.25 cm\frac{\lambda}{4} = 77.8\text{ cm} / 4 = 19.45\text{ cm} \implies e = 19.45\text{ cm} - 18.2\text{ cm} = 1.25\text{ cm}

  4. Step 4

    e=1.2510=0.125 mme = \frac{1.25}{10} = 0.125\text{ mm}

    Correct

    e=1.25 cm×10 mm/cm=12.5 mme = 1.25\text{ cm} \times 10\text{ mm/cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}

    Because 1 cm=10 mm1\text{ cm} = 10\text{ mm}, converting from centimeters to millimeters requires multiplying by 1010, not dividing by 1010.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You eliminated the unknown end correction by taking the difference between consecutive resonance lengths.

You accurately solved for the wavelength and converted it to meters to find the speed of sound.

You used the fundamental resonance condition to find the correct numerical magnitude of the end correction in centimeters.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted metric prefix conversion factor

You divided by 1010 instead of multiplying by 1010 when converting 1.25 cm1.25\text{ cm} to millimeters.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the direction of metric prefix scaling: millimeters are smaller than centimeters, so a given length contains more millimeters than centimeters (1 cm=10 mm1\text{ cm} = 10\text{ mm}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Unit Scaling Sanity Check
  • Converting from a larger unit (cm\text{cm}) to a smaller unit (mm\text{mm}) must yield a larger numerical value.

  • Always write out the dimensional conversion factor explicitly: 1.25 cm×10 mm1 cm=12.5 mm1.25\text{ cm} \times \frac{10\text{ mm}}{1\text{ cm}} = 12.5\text{ mm}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recall the conversion factor between centimeters and millimeters: 1 cm=10 mm1\text{ cm} = 10\text{ mm}.

  2. Multiply the calculated end correction by 10 mm/cm10\text{ mm/cm}: e=1.25 cm×10 mm/cm=12.5 mme = 1.25\text{ cm} \times 10\text{ mm/cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}.

Final answer

(a) v=342.3 m/sv = 342.3\text{ m/s}; (b) e=12.5 mme = 12.5\text{ mm}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write conversion ratios with explicit units so that units cancel algebraically (e.g., cm×mmcm\text{cm} \times \frac{\text{mm}}{\text{cm}}).

  • Perform a physical reasonableness check: a tube diameter is typically a few centimeters, so an end correction e≈0.6re \approx 0.6r should be around 1 to 2 cm1\text{ to }2\text{ cm} (10 to 20 mm10\text{ to }20\text{ mm}), whereas 0.125 mm0.125\text{ mm} is far too small.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A resonance tube closed at the bottom by water resonates with a 512 Hz512\text{ Hz} tuning fork at lengths L1=15.5 cmL_1 = 15.5\text{ cm} and L2=49.0 cmL_2 = 49.0\text{ cm}. Calculate the speed of sound vv and the end correction ee.

Answer

ΔL=49.0−15.5=33.5 cm  ⟹  λ=2(33.5 cm)=67.0 cm=0.670 m\Delta L = 49.0 - 15.5 = 33.5\text{ cm} \implies \lambda = 2(33.5\text{ cm}) = 67.0\text{ cm} = 0.670\text{ m}. v=fλ=(512 Hz)(0.670 m)=343.0 m/sv = f\lambda = (512\text{ Hz})(0.670\text{ m}) = 343.0\text{ m/s}. e=λ4−L1=16.75 cm−15.5 cm=1.25 cm=12.5 mme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - L_1 = 16.75\text{ cm} - 15.5\text{ cm} = 1.25\text{ cm} = 12.5\text{ mm}.

02

In a resonance tube experiment, resonances occur at air-column lengths of 24.0 cm24.0\text{ cm}, 74.0 cm74.0\text{ cm}, and 124.0 cm124.0\text{ cm}. If the acoustic speed is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, find the frequency ff of the source and determine whether the end correction is zero or non-zero.

Answer

The uniform spacing is ΔL=74.0−24.0=50.0 cm=λ2  ⟹  λ=1.00 m\Delta L = 74.0 - 24.0 = 50.0\text{ cm} = \frac{\lambda}{2} \implies \lambda = 1.00\text{ m}. f=vλ=340 m/s1.00 m=340 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{340\text{ m/s}}{1.00\text{ m}} = 340\text{ Hz}. Since λ4=25.0 cm\frac{\lambda}{4} = 25.0\text{ cm}, the end correction is e=25.0 cm−24.0 cm=1.0 cm=10 mme = 25.0\text{ cm} - 24.0\text{ cm} = 1.0\text{ cm} = 10\text{ mm} (non-zero).

03

An open-closed organ pipe has an unknown effective length. Resonances are observed at consecutive frequencies of 425 Hz425\text{ Hz} and 595 Hz595\text{ Hz}. If the speed of sound is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, determine the fundamental frequency and the physical length of the pipe if its end correction is e=1.5 cme = 1.5\text{ cm}.

Answer

For a closed tube, consecutive harmonic frequencies differ by 2f12f_1: Δf=595−425=170 Hz=2f1  ⟹  f1=85 Hz\Delta f = 595 - 425 = 170\text{ Hz} = 2f_1 \implies f_1 = 85\text{ Hz}. The fundamental wavelength is λ1=vf1=34085=4.0 m\lambda_1 = \frac{v}{f_1} = \frac{340}{85} = 4.0\text{ m}. The effective length is Leff=λ14=1.0 m=100 cmL_{\text{eff}} = \frac{\lambda_1}{4} = 1.0\text{ m} = 100\text{ cm}. Accounting for end correction: L=Leff−e=100 cm−1.5 cm=98.5 cmL = L_{\text{eff}} - e = 100\text{ cm} - 1.5\text{ cm} = 98.5\text{ cm}.

Loading workspace…