Resources

A moving bowling ball of mass m1=6.00 kgm_1 = 6.00\text{ kg} traveling at v1i=+5.00 m/sv_{1i} = +5.00\text{ m/s} strikes a stationary plastic bowling pin of mass m2=1.50 kgm_2 = 1.50\text{ kg} head-on. Many introductory physics students believe that because the heavier bowling ball has vastly greater mass, it must exert a greater magnitude of force on the pin than the pin exerts back on the ball during impact. Address this intuition by evaluating: (a) the ratio of the average contact force magnitude felt by the ball to that felt by the pin during the contact interval Δt\Delta t, ∣Fˉ21∣/∣Fˉ12∣|\bar{F}_{21}| / |\bar{F}_{12}|, and (b) assuming the collision is perfectly elastic, the post-collision velocity v2fv_{2f} of the pin and the ratio of the pin's acceleration magnitude to the ball's acceleration magnitude ∣a2∣/∣a1∣|a_2| / |a_1| during impact.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00 (forces are strictly equal in magnitude per Newton's Third Law); (b) v2f=+8.00 m/sv_{2f} = +8.00\text{ m/s}, and ∣a2∣∣a1∣=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = 4.00 (the pin accelerates 44 times as much as the ball because a=Fma = \frac{F}{m})

Steps

01

Pin's Final Velocity (v2fv_{2f})

Part (a): Ratio of Impact Forces

A common misconception is that a more massive object exerts a larger force on a lighter object than it receives in return. According to Newton's Third Law of Motion, whenever two objects interact, they exert forces on each other that are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction: F⃗12=−F⃗21\vec{F}_{12} = -\vec{F}_{21} Here, F⃗12\vec{F}_{12} is the force exerted on object 11 (ball) by object 22 (pin), and F⃗21\vec{F}_{21} is the force exerted on object 22 by object 11. Because this relation holds at every instant during the collision, it also holds for the time-averaged forces over the contact duration Δt\Delta t: ∣Fˉ21∣=∣Fˉ12∣|\bar{F}_{21}| = |\bar{F}_{12}| Therefore, the ratio of the force magnitudes is: ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00

Part (b): Post-Collision Velocity and Acceleration Ratio

In a one-dimensional, perfectly elastic collision where the target object is initially at rest (v2i=0 m/sv_{2i} = 0\text{ m/s}), both momentum and kinetic energy are conserved. The formula for the final velocity of the second object is:

v2f=(2m1m1+m2)v1iv_{2f} = \left(\frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}\right) v_{1i}

Substitute the given values:

  • m1=6.00 kgm_1 = 6.00\text{ kg}
  • m2=1.50 kgm_2 = 1.50\text{ kg}
  • v1i=+5.00 m/sv_{1i} = +5.00\text{ m/s}

v2f=(2⋅6.00 kg6.00 kg+1.50 kg)(+5.00 m/s)=(12.007.50)(+5.00 m/s)=1.60⋅5.00 m/s=+8.00 m/sv_{2f} = \left(\frac{2 \cdot 6.00\text{ kg}}{6.00\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg}}\right) (+5.00\text{ m/s}) = \left(\frac{12.00}{7.50}\right) (+5.00\text{ m/s}) = 1.60 \cdot 5.00\text{ m/s} = +8.00\text{ m/s}

02

Ratio of Acceleration Magnitudes (∣a2∣/∣a1∣|a_2| / |a_1|)

By Newton's Second Law (F=maF = ma), the acceleration of each object during impact depends inversely on its mass for a given force:

∣a1∣=∣Fˉ12∣m1,∣a2∣=∣Fˉ21∣m2|a_1| = \frac{|\bar{F}_{12}|}{m_1}, \quad |a_2| = \frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{m_2}

Since the force magnitudes are identical (∣Fˉ12∣=∣Fˉ21∣=F|\bar{F}_{12}| = |\bar{F}_{21}| = F):

∣a2∣∣a1∣=F/m2F/m1=m1m2\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{F / m_2}{F / m_1} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}

Substitute the masses:

∣a2∣∣a1∣=6.00 kg1.50 kg=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{6.00\text{ kg}}{1.50\text{ kg}} = 4.00

Key Takeaway: While the impact forces on both objects are strictly equal in magnitude, the lighter pin undergoes an acceleration 44 times greater than that of the heavy bowling ball because of its smaller mass.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes force is proportional to mass, concluding the heavier bowling ball exerts 4 times greater force on the pin than the pin exerts back.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    ∣Fˉ12∣∣Fˉ21∣=m1m2=6.001.50=4.00  ⟹  ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=14.00=0.25\frac{|\bar{F}_{12}|}{|\bar{F}_{21}|} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = \frac{6.00}{1.50} = 4.00 \implies \frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = \frac{1}{4.00} = 0.25

    Correct

    ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00

    According to Newton's Third Law, interacting objects exert forces on each other that are strictly equal in magnitude and opposite in direction (∣Fˉ21∣=∣Fˉ12∣|\bar{F}_{21}| = |\bar{F}_{12}|) at every instant during contact, regardless of their relative masses.

  2. Step 2

    v2f=2(6.00)6.00+1.50⋅5.00=8.00 m/sv_{2f} = \frac{2(6.00)}{6.00 + 1.50} \cdot 5.00 = 8.00\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    ∣a2∣∣a1∣=v2f/Δt∣v1f−v1i∣/Δt  ⟹  v1f=6.00−1.506.00+1.50⋅5.00=3.00 m/s  ⟹  ∣a2∣∣a1∣=8.00∣3.00−5.00∣=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{v_{2f}/\Delta t}{|v_{1f} - v_{1i}|/\Delta t} \implies v_{1f} = \frac{6.00 - 1.50}{6.00 + 1.50} \cdot 5.00 = 3.00\text{ m/s} \implies \frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{8.00}{|3.00 - 5.00|} = 4.00

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the elastic collision formulas for both objects' final velocities.

You correctly evaluated the ratio of acceleration magnitudes from the velocity changes over the collision time.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Force with Acceleration or Mass Dependence

You assumed the contact force between colliding objects scales with mass rather than remaining equal and opposite.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating Newton's Second Law (F=maF = ma) with Newton's Third Law (F12=−F21F_{12} = -F_{21}). A more massive object creates a greater visual effect or causes a lighter object to accelerate much faster, but the mutual interaction forces themselves are always identical in magnitude.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Newton's Third Law for Collisions
  • For any contact interaction between two objects 11 and 22, ∣F⃗12∣=∣F⃗21∣|\vec{F}_{12}| = |\vec{F}_{21}| always holds at every instant.

  • Never scale contact force by mass; set the ratio of mutual forces equal to 1.001.00, then use a=F/ma = F/m to explain differences in acceleration.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the mutual interaction as an action-reaction pair: F⃗21=−F⃗12\vec{F}_{21} = -\vec{F}_{12}.

  2. Take the magnitude of both sides: ∣Fˉ21∣=∣Fˉ12∣|\bar{F}_{21}| = |\bar{F}_{12}|.

  3. Compute the ratio: ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00.

Final answer

(a) ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00; (b) v2f=+8.00 m/sv_{2f} = +8.00\text{ m/s}, and ∣a2∣∣a1∣=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = 4.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Newton's Third Law and note that contact forces are always identical in magnitude regardless of mass or speed.

  • Practice separating the interaction force (which is identical on both bodies) from the resulting acceleration (which is inversely proportional to mass).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the elastic collision velocity formula for the target object with the equal-mass velocity transfer or omits the factor of 2 in the numerator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    By Newton's third law, $|Fˉ\bar{F}{21}| = |Fˉ\bar{F}{12}|   ⟹  \implies ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00

  2. Step 2

    v_{2f} = m1m1+m2\frac{m_1}{m_1 + m_2} ⋅\cdot v_{1i}   ⟹  \implies v_{2f} = 6.006.00+1.50\frac{6.00}{6.00 + 1.50} ⋅\cdot 5.00 = 4.00 m/s\text{ m/s}_

    Correct

    v_{2f} = (2m1m1+m2)\left(\frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}\right) v_{1i} = (2(6.00 kg)6.00 kg+1.50 kg)\left(\frac{2(6.00\text{ kg})}{6.00\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg}}\right)(5.00 m/s\text{ m/s}) = +8.00 m/s\text{ m/s}

    You wrote v2f=m1m1+m2v1iv_{2f} = \frac{m_1}{m_1 + m_2} v_{1i}, omitting the required factor of 22 in the numerator. The expression you used represents the center-of-mass velocity (or the velocity for a completely inelastic collision where the objects stick together), rather than the velocity of the target object in a perfectly elastic collision.

  3. Step 3

    ∣a2∣∣a1∣\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = m1m2\frac{m_1}{m_2} = 6.001.50\frac{6.00}{1.50} = 4.00

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Newton's Third Law to determine that the collision force magnitudes are identical.

You correctly used Newton's Second Law to establish that the acceleration ratio is inversely proportional to the masses.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing factor of 2 in elastic collision formula

You missed the factor of 22 in the numerator when writing down the elastic collision velocity formula for the target object.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You likely confused the elastic collision velocity formula for an initially stationary target, v2f=2m1m1+m2v1iv_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{m_1+m_2}v_{1i}, with the center-of-mass velocity formula, vcm=m1m1+m2v1iv_{\text{cm}} = \frac{m_1}{m_1+m_2}v_{1i} (which describes a completely inelastic collision).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check the Collision Type
  • For a perfectly elastic collision with a stationary target, v2f=2m1m1+m2v1iv_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{m_1+m_2}v_{1i}. If the objects stick together, vf=m1m1+m2v1iv_f = \frac{m_1}{m_1+m_2}v_{1i}.

  • Verify whether kinetic energy is conserved (elastic) before selecting the velocity formula.

Equal-Mass Sanity Check
  • If m1=m2m_1 = m_2, an elastic collision transfers all velocity to the stationary target: v2f=2m12m1v1i=v1iv_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{2m_1}v_{1i} = v_{1i}.

  • Test your formula with m1=m2m_1 = m_2; if it yields 12v1i\frac{1}{2}v_{1i} instead of v1iv_{1i}, the factor of 22 is missing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the standard 1D elastic collision formula for target 22 initially at rest: v2f=(2m1m1+m2)v1iv_{2f} = \left(\frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}\right) v_{1i}.

  2. Substitute the given values: v2f=(2×6.00 kg6.00 kg+1.50 kg)(+5.00 m/s)=(12.007.50)(+5.00 m/s)v_{2f} = \left(\frac{2 \times 6.00\text{ kg}}{6.00\text{ kg} + 1.50\text{ kg}}\right)(+5.00\text{ m/s}) = \left(\frac{12.00}{7.50}\right)(+5.00\text{ m/s}).

  3. Evaluate the result: v2f=1.60×(+5.00 m/s)=+8.00 m/sv_{2f} = 1.60 \times (+5.00\text{ m/s}) = +8.00\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

(a) ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00; (b) v2f=+8.00 m/sv_{2f} = +8.00\text{ m/s} and ∣a2∣∣a1∣=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = 4.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the two standard elastic collision formulas for an initially resting target: v1f=m1−m2m1+m2v1iv_{1f} = \frac{m_1 - m_2}{m_1 + m_2}v_{1i} and v2f=2m1m1+m2v1iv_{2f} = \frac{2m_1}{m_1 + m_2}v_{1i}.

  • Use the equal-mass limiting case (m1=m2m_1 = m_2) as a quick memory check to verify that v2f=v1iv_{2f} = v_{1i}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the acceleration ratio by assuming the heavier object experiences greater acceleration from the impact force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Newton’s third law gives action = reaction  ⟹  ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\text{Newton's third law gives action = reaction} \implies \frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00

  2. Step 2

    v2f=2m1v1im1+m2=2(6.00)(5.00)7.50=8.00 m/sv_{2f} = \frac{2m_1 v_{1i}}{m_1 + m_2} = \frac{2(6.00)(5.00)}{7.50} = 8.00\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    ∣a2∣∣a1∣=m2m1  ⟹  ∣a2∣∣a1∣=1.506.00=0.25\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{m_2}{m_1} \implies \frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{1.50}{6.00} = 0.25

    Correct

    ∣a2∣∣a1∣=F/m2F/m1=m1m2=6.00 kg1.50 kg=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{F / m_2}{F / m_1} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = \frac{6.00\text{ kg}}{1.50\text{ kg}} = 4.00

    By Newton's Second Law, acceleration is inversely proportional to mass for a given force (a=Fma = \frac{F}{m}). Therefore, the ratio of accelerations is ∣a2∣∣a1∣=m1m2\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}, which evaluates to 4.004.00, not 0.250.25.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied Newton's Third Law to establish that the force ratio is 1.001.00.

You selected and evaluated the correct 1D elastic collision velocity formula for the stationary target.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Acceleration-to-Mass Ratio

You set the acceleration ratio equal to m2m1\frac{m_2}{m_1} instead of m1m2\frac{m_1}{m_2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated acceleration as directly proportional to mass rather than inversely proportional (a=Fma = \frac{F}{m}). Under identical net force magnitudes, the lighter object experiences the larger acceleration.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Newton's Second Law Ratio Check
  • For equal contact forces FF, a=Fma = \frac{F}{m}, which implies a2a1=F/m2F/m1=m1m2\frac{a_2}{a_1} = \frac{F/m_2}{F/m_1} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}.

  • Write out the explicit quotient F/m2F/m1\frac{F/m_2}{F/m_1} before simplifying to ensure the mass terms invert correctly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the acceleration of each object during impact using Newton's Second Law: ∣a1∣=Fm1|a_1| = \frac{F}{m_1} and ∣a2∣=Fm2|a_2| = \frac{F}{m_2}, where F=∣Fˉ12∣=∣Fˉ21∣F = |\bar{F}_{12}| = |\bar{F}_{21}|.

  2. Form the ratio: ∣a2∣∣a1∣=F/m2F/m1=m1m2\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{F / m_2}{F / m_1} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}.

  3. Substitute the given masses: ∣a2∣∣a1∣=6.00 kg1.50 kg=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = \frac{6.00\text{ kg}}{1.50\text{ kg}} = 4.00.

Final answer

(a) ∣Fˉ21∣∣Fˉ12∣=1.00\frac{|\bar{F}_{21}|}{|\bar{F}_{12}|} = 1.00; (b) v2f=+8.00 m/sv_{2f} = +8.00\text{ m/s} and ∣a2∣∣a1∣=4.00\frac{|a_2|}{|a_1|} = 4.00

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how reciprocal relationships work when taking ratios of fractions (a=F/ma = F/m).

  • Perform a quick qualitative sanity check after calculating: lighter objects must accelerate more than heavier objects when pushed by equal forces.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 1200 kg1200\text{ kg} car traveling at 15 m/s15\text{ m/s} rear-ends a stationary 3600 kg3600\text{ kg} truck. During the impact, what is the ratio of the average force magnitude exerted by the car on the truck to that exerted by the truck on the car?

Answer

1.001.00. By Newton's Third Law, the force pair between the car and the truck is equal in magnitude and opposite in direction at all times: ∣Fˉcar on truck∣/∣Fˉtruck on car∣=1.00|\bar{F}_{\text{car on truck}}| / |\bar{F}_{\text{truck on car}}| = 1.00.

02

Two ice skaters push off against each other from rest on frictionless ice. Skater 11 has a mass of 40.0 kg40.0\text{ kg} and skater 22 has a mass of 80.0 kg80.0\text{ kg}. If skater 11 accelerates at 3.00 m/s23.00\text{ m/s}^2 during the push, find: (a) the magnitude of force each skater experiences, and (b) the acceleration of skater 22.

Answer

(a) 120 N120\text{ N}; (b) 1.50 m/s21.50\text{ m/s}^2. The force on skater 11 is F=m1a1=(40.0 kg)(3.00 m/s2)=120 NF = m_1 a_1 = (40.0\text{ kg})(3.00\text{ m/s}^2) = 120\text{ N}. By Newton's Third Law, skater 22 feels an equal force of 120 N120\text{ N}, so a2=F/m2=120 N/80.0 kg=1.50 m/s2a_2 = F/m_2 = 120\text{ N} / 80.0\text{ kg} = 1.50\text{ m/s}^2.

03

A spacecraft of mass M=5000 kgM = 5000\text{ kg} catches a space debris fragment of mass m=25 kgm = 25\text{ kg} in a completely inelastic collision. During the collision lasting Δt=0.050 s\Delta t = 0.050\text{ s}, the debris slows down by Δv=200 m/s\Delta v = 200\text{ m/s}. Find: (a) the magnitude of the average force felt by the spacecraft, and (b) the spacecraft's acceleration magnitude during contact.

Answer

(a) 1.0×105 N1.0 \times 10^5\text{ N}; (b) 20 m/s220\text{ m/s}^2. The average force on the debris is ∣Fˉ∣=m∣Δv∣Δt=(25)(200/0.050)=1.0×105 N|\bar{F}| = m \frac{|\Delta v|}{\Delta t} = (25)(200 / 0.050) = 1.0 \times 10^5\text{ N}. By Newton's Third Law, the spacecraft experiences the exact same force magnitude (1.0×105 N1.0 \times 10^5\text{ N}). Its acceleration is ∣aship∣=∣Fˉ∣M=1.0×105 N5000 kg=20 m/s2|a_{\text{ship}}| = \frac{|\bar{F}|}{M} = \frac{1.0 \times 10^5\text{ N}}{5000\text{ kg}} = 20\text{ m/s}^2.

Loading workspace…