Resources
A student predicts that if one end of an open-open organ pipe of fixed length is capped, the fundamental frequency will double because half of the wave cycle is cut off. (a) State the correct relationship between the fundamental frequency of the pipe when open at both ends () versus when one end is closed (). (b) If a pipe open at both ends has a fundamental frequency of , calculate the frequency of its first overtone when one end is capped.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) (the fundamental frequency is halved, not doubled); (b)
Steps
Part (a): Deriving the Relationship Between Fundamental Frequencies
-
Open-Open Pipe (Open at Both Ends):
- Boundary conditions require a displacement antinode (maximum air oscillation) at each open end.
- For the fundamental mode (), the standing wave contains one-half of a wavelength inside the pipe:
- Using the wave speed equation , the fundamental frequency is:
-
Open-Closed Pipe (One End Capped):
- Capping one end forces the air particles against the barrier to be stationary, creating a displacement node at the closed end, while the open end remains an antinode.
- The simplest standing wave fitting these boundaries has a node at one end and an antinode at the other, which spans one-quarter of a wavelength:
- The fundamental frequency is:
- Comparison: Taking the ratio of the two fundamental frequencies:
- Pitfall note: The student assumed capping the pipe "cuts the cycle in half" to increase frequency. In reality, requiring a node at one end and an antinode at the other doubles the required fundamental wavelength from to . Because frequency is inversely proportional to wavelength (), doubling the wavelength halves the fundamental frequency.
Part (b): Calculating the First Overtone of the Capped Pipe
- Find the Fundamental Frequency of the Capped Pipe:
-
Determine the Mode of the First Overtone:
- A pipe with one closed end supports only odd harmonics:
- The fundamental corresponds to .
- The first overtone is the first resonant frequency higher than the fundamental, which corresponds to the third harmonic ().
- Calculate the Frequency:
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the first overtone with the second harmonic (n = 2) for a pipe closed at one end, forgetting that closed pipes support only odd harmonics.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
(the first overtone is the third harmonic)
A pipe with one closed end requires a node at the closed boundary and an antinode at the open boundary, which permits only odd harmonics (). The first frequency above the fundamental is the third harmonic (), not .
- Step 4Correct
Your arithmetic followed directly from assuming , but multiplying by yields the correct first overtone frequency of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly derived the fundamental frequencies from wave boundary conditions and established that .
You accurately computed the fundamental frequency of the capped pipe as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou applied the harmonic progression of an open-open pipe (where all integer multiples exist) to an open-closed pipe, overlooking that boundary conditions at a closed end allow only odd harmonics ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Allowed Harmonics in Open-Closed Pipes
An air column closed at one end and open at the other supports only odd harmonics: with . Even harmonics cannot form because the required displacement node and antinode boundaries cannot be satisfied.
Always list the allowed harmonic series before identifying overtones for a closed-open pipe.
- Overtone vs. Harmonic Number
The fundamental mode is always the first harmonic (). The -th overtone is the -th allowed resonant frequency strictly above the fundamental.
For an open-closed pipe, map the overtones explicitly: fundamental is , 1st overtone is , 2nd overtone is .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecall that a pipe open at one end and closed at the other only supports odd harmonics: for .
Identify the first resonant mode above the fundamental (), which corresponds to .
Multiply the fundamental frequency of the capped pipe by : .
02 The student believes capping one end doubles the fundamental frequency instead of halving it, adopting the misconception stated in the prompt.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Capping one end creates a displacement node at that end and an antinode at the open end, so the fundamental wavelength spans a quarter-wave (). Because the open-open pipe has , the wavelength doubles, which cuts the fundamental frequency in half: .
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Your multiplication was calculated correctly based on your previous result, but the value is incorrect because it carried over the wrong fundamental frequency from Step 1.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that an open-closed pipe only supports odd harmonics and that its first overtone is the third harmonic ().
You correctly multiplied your fundamental frequency by the harmonic number to compute the overtone.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed capping one end doubles the frequency instead of halving it, misinterpreting how closing an end alters the boundary conditions and fundamental standing wavelength.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Fundamental Wavelengths
An open-open pipe requires antinodes at both ends (), whereas an open-closed pipe requires an antinode at the open end and a node at the closed end ().
Compare wavelengths first: since , the fundamental frequency must be halved ().
- Overtone Numbering for Stopped Pipes
A pipe with one end closed produces only odd harmonics: with
Identify the first overtone as and compute using the correct .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the fundamental frequency of the capped pipe: .
Apply the harmonic rule for the first overtone (): .
(a) ; (b)
03 The student correctly calculates the fundamental frequency of the capped pipe but assumes the first overtone is equal to the fundamental frequency itself.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3
n=1 f = 130.0
Correctf_{} = f_3 = 3 f_1 = 3(130.0) = 390.0_
The fundamental mode itself is the lowest resonant frequency (). An overtone is by definition a resonant frequency higher than the fundamental. For a pipe with one closed end, only odd harmonics exist, so the first overtone corresponds to the third harmonic ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly derived the fundamental frequency relationship between open-open and open-closed pipes using standing wave wavelengths.
You calculated the fundamental frequency of the capped pipe accurately.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the fundamental frequency () with the first overtone, overlooking that overtones refer to resonant modes strictly above the fundamental.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Fundamental vs. Overtones
The fundamental frequency is the lowest resonant frequency (). The first overtone is the next higher resonant frequency permitted by the boundary conditions.
Always list the allowed harmonic numbers first ( for a closed-open pipe) and associate the fundamental with and the first overtone with the next term ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify that a pipe open at one end and closed at the other only supports odd harmonics: for .
Set for the first overtone above the fundamental ().
Compute .
f_{} = 390.0_
Lock it in
Why can an air column with one open end and one closed end only resonate at odd harmonics ()?
A closed end must be a displacement node and an open end must be an antinode. Fitting an integral number of quarter-wavelengths with these boundaries requires where is odd.
Similar question
An organ pipe open at both ends has a fundamental frequency of . If one end is securely closed, what is the frequency of its second overtone?
Answer
. Key steps: Fundamental of closed pipe is . The second overtone corresponds to the 5th harmonic (). Thus, .
A student blows across the top of an open cylindrical tube of length , producing its fundamental standing wave. Taking the speed of sound as , calculate the fundamental frequency. If the student then closes the bottom of the tube with a hand, what are the frequencies of the fundamental and the first overtone?
Answer
Open tube fundamental: . Capped tube fundamental: . Capped tube first overtone (): .
A resonance tube closed at one end has successive resonant frequencies measured at and . Determine: (a) the fundamental frequency of the tube, and (b) the harmonic numbers corresponding to these two resonances.
Answer
(a) , (b) and . Key steps: Adjacent harmonics in a closed-open pipe differ by . Here, . Dividing the measured values gives (3rd harmonic, 1st overtone) and (5th harmonic, 2nd overtone).