Resources

A light string of length L=0.800 mL = 0.800\text{ m} and linear mass density μ=3.20×10−3 kg/m\mu = 3.20 \times 10^{-3}\text{ kg/m} has one end attached to a variable-frequency vibrator and the other end passing over a frictionless, massless pulley to support a suspended solid metal sphere of mass M=2.04 kgM = 2.04\text{ kg} (g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2). The string vibrates in its second harmonic mode (n=2n = 2). The metal sphere is then completely submerged in a beaker of water (density ρw=1.00×103 kg/m3\rho_w = 1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3) without touching the bottom or sides, causing the effective tension to decrease due to buoyancy. As a result, the string shifts into resonance at its third harmonic mode (n=3n = 3) at the very same vibrator frequency. Calculate the volume VV of the metal sphere.

Answer and steps

Final answer

V=1.13×10−3 m3V = 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

Steps

01

Relate Resonance Frequency, Harmonic Number, and String Tension

For a string fixed at both ends, the resonance frequencies for the nn-th harmonic mode are given by: fn=n2Lv=n2LTμf_n = \frac{n}{2L} v = \frac{n}{2L} \sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}}

where:

  • nn is the harmonic number (the number of antinodes or loops),
  • LL is the vibrating length of the string,
  • TT is the tension in the string,
  • μ\mu is the linear mass density of the string.
02

Set Up the Frequency Invariance Condition

The frequency of the vibrator remains constant in both scenarios:

  • Initial state (sphere in air): The string is in the second harmonic (n1=2n_1 = 2), and tension is supported solely by the weight of the metal sphere: T1=MgT_1 = M g
  • Final state (sphere submerged in water): The string shifts to the third harmonic (n2=3n_2 = 3). Tension decreases due to the buoyant force B=ρwVgB = \rho_w V g: T2=Mg−B=Mg−ρwVgT_2 = M g - B = M g - \rho_w V g

Equating the frequency for both states: n12LT1μ=n22LT2μ\frac{n_1}{2L} \sqrt{\frac{T_1}{\mu}} = \frac{n_2}{2L} \sqrt{\frac{T_2}{\mu}}

Because the string length LL and linear mass density μ\mu remain unchanged, they cancel out entirely: n1T1=n2T2n_1 \sqrt{T_1} = n_2 \sqrt{T_2}

Squaring both sides gives: n12T1=n22T2n_1^2 T_1 = n_2^2 T_2

Key Pitfall: The parameters L=0.800 mL = 0.800\text{ m} and μ=3.20×10−3 kg/m\mu = 3.20 \times 10^{-3}\text{ kg/m} are extra given information. It is unnecessary to compute the numerical value of ff, as it cancels out directly.

03

Solve for the Sphere's Volume VV

Substitute n1=2n_1 = 2, n2=3n_2 = 3, T1=MgT_1 = M g, and T2=g(M−ρwV)T_2 = g(M - \rho_w V) into the relation: 22(Mg)=32g(M−ρwV)2^2 (M g) = 3^2 g(M - \rho_w V)

Divide both sides by gg: 4M=9(M−ρwV)4M = 9(M - \rho_w V)

Expand and rearrange to isolate VV: 4M=9M−9ρwV4M = 9M - 9\rho_w V 9ρwV=5M9\rho_w V = 5M V=5M9ρwV = \frac{5M}{9\rho_w}

Substitute the given values (M=2.04 kgM = 2.04\text{ kg} and ρw=1.00×103 kg/m3\rho_w = 1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3): V=5⋅2.04 kg9⋅1.00×103 kg/m3=10.209000 m3≈1.13×10−3 m3V = \frac{5 \cdot 2.04\text{ kg}}{9 \cdot 1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3} = \frac{10.20}{9000}\text{ m}^3 \approx 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to square the harmonic numbers when solving the frequency equality for tension, using n₁ * T₁ = n₂ * T₂ instead of squaring the terms.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    f = \frac{n}{2L}$$\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}}   ⟹  \implies 2T1\sqrt{T_1} = 3T2\sqrt{T_2}   ⟹  \implies 2 T_1 = 3 T_2$$

    Correct

    2T1\sqrt{T_1} = 3T2\sqrt{T_2}   ⟹  \implies 2^2 T_1 = 3^2 T_2   ⟹  \implies 4 T_1 = 9 T_2

    When squaring both sides of 2T1=3T22\sqrt{T_1} = 3\sqrt{T_2} to eliminate the radical, both the coefficients and the radicands must be squared: (2T1)2=(3T2)2(2\sqrt{T_1})^2 = (3\sqrt{T_2})^2, which gives 4T1=9T24T_1 = 9T_2 rather than 2T1=3T22T_1 = 3T_2.

  2. Step 2

    2 M g = 3(M g - ρ\rhow g V)

    Correct

    4 M g = 9(M g - ρ\rhow g V)

    You substituted the expressions for tension T1=MgT_1 = Mg and T2=Mg−ρwgVT_2 = Mg - \rho_w g V accurately, but the equation carries over the incorrect coefficients from step 1.

  3. Step 3

    3 ρ\rhow g V = M g   ⟹  \implies V = M3ρw\frac{M}{3\rho_w}

    Correct

    9 ρ\rhow g V = 5 M g   ⟹  \implies V = 5M9ρw\frac{5M}{9\rho_w}

    Your algebraic isolation of VV is mathematically consistent with your equation from step 2, but it inherits the erroneous coefficients.

  4. Step 4

    V = 2.043⋅1.00×103\frac{2.04}{3 \cdot 1.00 \times 10^3} = 6.80 ×\times 10^{-4} m\text{ m}^3

    Correct

    V = 5(2.04)9(1.00×103)\frac{5(2.04)}{9(1.00 \times 10^3)} = 1.13 ×\times 10^{-3} m\text{ m}^3

    Your arithmetic evaluation is consistent with your formula, but the resulting numerical value is incorrect due to the initial algebraic error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the standing-wave frequency formula f=n2LTμf = \frac{n}{2L}\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}}.

You recognized that the driving frequency, length, and mass density remain constant across both states.

You correctly expressed the reduced tension using the buoyant force formula B=ρwgVB = \rho_w g V.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incomplete Squaring of Radical Equation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When eliminating a square root from an equation of the form ax=bya\sqrt{x} = b\sqrt{y}, you squared only the radical terms and left the multiplying coefficients un-squared, using ax=bya x = b y instead of (ax)2=(by)2  ⟹  a2x=b2y(a\sqrt{x})^2 = (b\sqrt{y})^2 \implies a^2 x = b^2 y.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Squaring Multiplied Radicals
  • For any real terms, (cu)2=c2(u)2=c2u(c\sqrt{u})^2 = c^2 (\sqrt{u})^2 = c^2 u.

  • Always place parentheses around the entire side before squaring: write (2T1)2=(3T2)2(2\sqrt{T_1})^2 = (3\sqrt{T_2})^2 before expanding to 4T1=9T24T_1 = 9T_2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Square both sides of the frequency equality: (2T1)2=(3T2)2  ⟹  4T1=9T2(2\sqrt{T_1})^2 = (3\sqrt{T_2})^2 \implies 4T_1 = 9T_2.

  2. Substitute T1=MgT_1 = Mg and T2=Mg−ρwgVT_2 = Mg - \rho_w g V: 4Mg=9(Mg−ρwgV)4Mg = 9(Mg - \rho_w g V).

  3. Divide by gg and expand: 4M=9M−9ρwV  ⟹  9ρwV=5M4M = 9M - 9\rho_w V \implies 9\rho_w V = 5M.

  4. Solve for volume: V=5M9ρw=5(2.04 kg)9(1.00×103 kg/m3)=1.13×10−3 m3V = \frac{5M}{9\rho_w} = \frac{5(2.04\text{ kg})}{9(1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3)} = 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3.

Final answer

V=1.13×10−3 m3V = 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice squaring equations with outside coefficients by explicitly writing parentheses around each side before removing radicals.

  • Solve problems where harmonic number nn and wave speed vv vary inversely under constant frequency.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misremembers the standing wave frequency formula as f = n * v = n * √(T / μ) without the factor of 1 / (2L), but when equating frequencies, assumes frequency is inversely proportional to harmonic number, writing √T₁ / 2 = √T₂ / 3.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    f1=f2  ⟹  T12=T23  ⟹  T14=T29  ⟹  9⋅T1=4⋅T2f_1 = f_2 \implies \frac{\sqrt{T_1}}{2} = \frac{\sqrt{T_2}}{3} \implies \frac{T_1}{4} = \frac{T_2}{9} \implies 9 \cdot T_1 = 4 \cdot T_2

    Correct

    f1=f2  ⟹  n1T1=n2T2  ⟹  2T1=3T2  ⟹  4T1=9T2f_1 = f_2 \implies n_1 \sqrt{T_1} = n_2 \sqrt{T_2} \implies 2\sqrt{T_1} = 3\sqrt{T_2} \implies 4T_1 = 9T_2

    For a string fixed at both ends, the nn-th harmonic frequency is fn=n2LTμf_n = \frac{n}{2L}\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}}. Because ff, LL, and μ\mu are constant, nTn\sqrt{T} is constant, meaning n1T1=n2T2n_1 \sqrt{T_1} = n_2 \sqrt{T_2}. You placed the harmonic number nn in the denominator rather than the numerator.

  2. Step 2

    9⋅M⋅g=4⋅(M⋅g−ρw⋅g⋅V)  ⟹  4⋅ρw⋅g⋅V=−5⋅M⋅g9 \cdot M \cdot g = 4 \cdot (M \cdot g - \rho_w \cdot g \cdot V) \implies 4 \cdot \rho_w \cdot g \cdot V = -5 \cdot M \cdot g

    Correct

    4⋅M⋅g=9⋅(M⋅g−ρw⋅g⋅V)  ⟹  9⋅ρw⋅g⋅V=5⋅M⋅g4 \cdot M \cdot g = 9 \cdot (M \cdot g - \rho_w \cdot g \cdot V) \implies 9 \cdot \rho_w \cdot g \cdot V = 5 \cdot M \cdot g

    Your buoyant force setup T2=Mg−ρwgVT_2 = M g - \rho_w g V is physically sound, but substituting into the inverted ratio 9T1=4T29T_1 = 4T_2 from Step 1 caused the net buoyant term to yield an impossible negative mass balance.

  3. Step 3

    V=−5⋅M4⋅ρw=−2.55×10−3 m3V = \frac{-5 \cdot M}{4 \cdot \rho_w} = -2.55 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

    Correct

    V=5M9ρw=5(2.04 kg)9(1.00×103 kg/m3)≈1.13×10−3 m3V = \frac{5M}{9\rho_w} = \frac{5(2.04\text{ kg})}{9(1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3)} \approx 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

    Your arithmetic follows correctly from your previous equation, but the inherited error produces a negative volume.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly equated the frequencies in both configurations (f1=f2f_1 = f_2).

You correctly modeled the buoyant force using Archimedes' principle to find the reduced tension T2=Mg−ρwgVT_2 = M g - \rho_w g V.

You performed sound algebraic manipulation to isolate the target variable VV.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Harmonic Number in Standing Wave Frequency

No, this is a conceptual misunderstanding of how the harmonic number nn scales with frequency and wave speed on a fixed string.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the harmonic number nn as inversely proportional to the frequency (f∝vnf \propto \frac{v}{n}) rather than directly proportional (f=nv2Lf = \frac{n v}{2L}). When tension drops, wave speed v=T/μv = \sqrt{T/\mu} decreases, so keeping the frequency constant requires more loops (higher nn). Consequently, nTn\sqrt{T} must be constant, giving 2T1=3T22\sqrt{T_1} = 3\sqrt{T_2} rather than T12=T23\frac{\sqrt{T_1}}{2} = \frac{\sqrt{T_2}}{3}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Standing Wave Frequency Formula
  • fn=n2Lv=n2LTμf_n = \frac{n}{2L}v = \frac{n}{2L}\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}} for strings fixed at both ends.

  • Check that each added antinode (higher nn) increases the frequency for a fixed wave speed, so nn sits in the numerator.

Sanity Check on Physical Quantities
  • Physical quantities such as volume, length, and mass density must be positive.

  • If an algebraic solution yields a negative volume (V<0V < 0), recheck the ratio of tensions or forces before finalizing.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the standing wave relation with nn in the numerator: 2T1=3T22\sqrt{T_1} = 3\sqrt{T_2}.

  2. Square both sides: 4T1=9T24T_1 = 9T_2.

  3. Substitute T1=MgT_1 = M g and T2=Mg−ρwgVT_2 = M g - \rho_w g V: 4Mg=9(Mg−ρwgV)4 M g = 9(M g - \rho_w g V).

  4. Divide by gg and expand: 4M=9M−9ρwV  ⟹  9ρwV=5M4M = 9M - 9\rho_w V \implies 9\rho_w V = 5M.

  5. Solve for VV: V=5M9ρw=5(2.04 kg)9(1.00×103 kg/m3)≈1.13×10−3 m3V = \frac{5M}{9\rho_w} = \frac{5(2.04\text{ kg})}{9(1.00 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3)} \approx 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3.

Final answer

V≈1.13×10−3 m3V \approx 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the derivation of standing wave frequencies from L=nλ2L = n\frac{\lambda}{2} and v=fλv = f\lambda.

  • Practice identifying proportional versus inversely proportional relationships before cross-multiplying.

  • Always verify that physical constants and geometric measures (like volume) evaluate to positive values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the buoyant force as an addition to the tension rather than a reduction, using T₂ = M * g + ρ_w * g * V.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    2∗T1=3∗T2  ⟹  4∗T1=9∗T22 * \sqrt{T_1} = 3 * \sqrt{T_2} \implies 4 * T_1 = 9 * T_2

  2. Step 2

    T1=M∗gT_1 = M * g

  3. Step 3

    T2=M∗g+ρw∗g∗VT_2 = M * g + \rho_w * g * V

    Correct

    T2=Mg−ρwgVT_2 = Mg - \rho_w g V

    The buoyant force points upward, supporting part of the sphere's weight. Setting up vertical force balance gives T2+B=MgT_2 + B = Mg, which means the tension decreases to T2=Mg−ρwgVT_2 = Mg - \rho_w g V.

  4. Step 4

    4∗M∗g=9∗(M∗g+ρw∗g∗V)  ⟹  9∗ρw∗g∗V=−5∗M∗g4 * M * g = 9 * (M * g + \rho_w * g * V) \implies 9 * \rho_w * g * V = -5 * M * g

    Correct

    4Mg=9(Mg−ρwgV)  ⟹  9ρwgV=5Mg4Mg = 9(Mg - \rho_w g V) \implies 9\rho_w g V = 5Mg

    Your algebraic manipulation was carried out consistently, but it inherited the sign error from your tension equation.

  5. Step 5

    V=−5∗2.049∗1000=−1.13×10−3 m3V = -\frac{5 * 2.04}{9 * 1000} = -1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

    Correct

    V=5×2.049×1000=1.13×10−3 m3V = \frac{5 \times 2.04}{9 \times 1000} = 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

    The arithmetic matches your intermediate equation, but because of the sign error on buoyancy, your calculated volume is negative.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly derived the relation between harmonic numbers and tensions, n1T1=n2T2n_1\sqrt{T_1} = n_2\sqrt{T_2}.

You correctly recognized that frequency, length, and linear density remain unchanged.

You performed clean algebraic steps when isolating the unknown volume.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in buoyant force balance

You wrote a plus sign instead of a minus sign when incorporating the buoyant force into the string tension.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the direction of the buoyant force in a free-body diagram: buoyancy acts upward against gravity, thereby reducing the net downward pull on the string.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Draw a Free-Body Diagram
  • For a submerged suspended object in static equilibrium: ∑Fy=T+B−Mg=0\sum F_y = T + B - Mg = 0.

  • Always solve for tension as T=Mg−BT = Mg - B. Because B>0B > 0, the tension in the string must be strictly less than the weight in air.

Physical Reality Check on Wave Speed and Harmonics
  • Resonance frequency is f=n2LTμf = \frac{n}{2L}\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}}. For constant ff, n∝1Tn \propto \frac{1}{\sqrt{T}}.

  • Notice that transitioning from n=2n=2 to n=3n=3 requires a smaller wave speed, meaning tension TT must decrease, confirming T2<T1T_2 < T_1.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up vertical equilibrium for the submerged sphere: T2+ρwgV=Mg  ⟹  T2=g(M−ρwV)T_2 + \rho_w g V = Mg \implies T_2 = g(M - \rho_w V).

  2. Substitute T1=MgT_1 = Mg and T2=g(M−ρwV)T_2 = g(M - \rho_w V) into 4T1=9T24T_1 = 9T_2: 4Mg=9g(M−ρwV)4Mg = 9g(M - \rho_w V).

  3. Divide by gg and expand: 4M=9M−9ρwV  ⟹  9ρwV=5M4M = 9M - 9\rho_w V \implies 9\rho_w V = 5M.

  4. Isolate VV: V=5M9ρw=5(2.04 kg)9(1000 kg/m3)V = \frac{5M}{9\rho_w} = \frac{5(2.04\text{ kg})}{9(1000\text{ kg/m}^3)}.

Final answer

V=1.13×10−3 m3V = 1.13 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}^3

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch a quick free-body diagram whenever an object is suspended in a fluid to verify the direction of each force vector before writing equations.

  • Check that computed physical quantities like volume and mass are positive; a negative sign is a clear indicator of a reversed force direction.

  • Verify qualitative trends: an increase in harmonic number at constant excitation frequency always implies a drop in wave speed and string tension.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A string fixed at both ends vibrates in its fundamental mode (n=1n = 1) under tension T1T_1. If the frequency is held constant and the tension is reduced to T2T_2 such that the string vibrates in its second harmonic (n=2n = 2), find the ratio T2T1\frac{T_2}{T_1}.

Answer

T2T1=14\frac{T_2}{T_1} = \frac{1}{4}. Key steps: For fixed frequency and string length, nT=constantn\sqrt{T} = \text{constant}. Thus 1⋅T1=2⋅T21\cdot\sqrt{T_1} = 2\cdot\sqrt{T_2}. Squaring both sides yields 12T1=22T2  ⟹  T1=4T21^2 T_1 = 2^2 T_2 \implies T_1 = 4T_2, giving T2T1=14\frac{T_2}{T_1} = \frac{1}{4}.

02

A suspended mass M=3.00 kgM = 3.00\text{ kg} provides tension to a vibrating string that resonates in its third harmonic (n=3n = 3). When the mass is immersed in an unknown fluid, the string resonates at the fourth harmonic (n=4n = 4) at the same frequency. What is the buoyant force BB acting on the mass?

Answer

B=12.9 NB = 12.9\text{ N}. Key steps: Constant frequency implies 3T1=4T2  ⟹  9T1=16T23\sqrt{T_1} = 4\sqrt{T_2} \implies 9T_1 = 16T_2. Here T1=Mg=3.00×9.80=29.4 NT_1 = Mg = 3.00 \times 9.80 = 29.4\text{ N}, so T2=916T1=16.54 NT_2 = \frac{9}{16} T_1 = 16.54\text{ N}. The buoyant force is B=T1−T2=716Mg=716(29.4 N)≈12.9 NB = T_1 - T_2 = \frac{7}{16}Mg = \frac{7}{16}(29.4\text{ N}) \approx 12.9\text{ N}.

03

A metal block of density ρ=7.80×103 kg/m3\rho = 7.80 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3 hangs from a string resonating in mode n1=3n_1 = 3. When completely submerged in a liquid of density ρL\rho_L, the string resonates in mode n2=5n_2 = 5 at the identical frequency. Calculate the liquid density ρL\rho_L.

Answer

ρL=4.99×103 kg/m3\rho_L = 4.99 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3. Key steps: Frequency invariance gives 3T1=5T2  ⟹  9T1=25T23\sqrt{T_1} = 5\sqrt{T_2} \implies 9T_1 = 25T_2. With T1=ρVgT_1 = \rho V g and T2=(ρ−ρL)VgT_2 = (\rho - \rho_L)Vg, we have 9ρ=25(ρ−ρL)  ⟹  25ρL=16ρ9\rho = 25(\rho - \rho_L) \implies 25\rho_L = 16\rho. Therefore, ρL=1625ρ=1625(7.80×103)=4.99×103 kg/m3\rho_L = \frac{16}{25}\rho = \frac{16}{25}(7.80 \times 10^3) = 4.99 \times 10^3\text{ kg/m}^3.

Loading workspace…